---
title: "The Stem Array"
toh: "Toh 44-45"
sanskrit_title: "Gaṇḍavyūha"
tibetan_title: "sdong pos brgyan pa"
canon_section: "Kangyur › Discourses › A Multitude of Buddhas › Sūtra, “A Multitude of Buddhas”"
url: https://84000.co/translation/toh44-45
published: 2021-11-01
collections: ["Finding Your Path", "Sūtras About Women", "Texts for Recitation", "Texts on Other Buddhas"]
publisher: "84000: Translating the Words of the Buddha"
also_known_as: ["Entry into the Realm of Reality", "Entry into the Realm of Dharma", "The Supreme Array"]
translation_team: "Peter Alan Roberts and team"
translators: ["Peter Alan Roberts"]
license: "CC BY-NC-ND 4.0"
license_url: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
citation: "The Stem Array (Gaṇḍavyūha, Toh 44-45). Translated by Peter Alan Roberts and team. Online publication. 84000: Translating the Words of the Buddha, 2021. https://84000.co/translation/toh44-45."
part: 1
parts: 28
generated: 2026-11-16
---

# The Stem Array

Toh 44-45 · Kangyur › Discourses › A Multitude of Buddhas › Sūtra, “A Multitude of Buddhas” · An 84000 translation · Read online: https://84000.co/translation/toh44-45

> **License:** [CC BY-NC-ND 4.0](https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/). This work is provided under the protection of a Creative Commons CC BY-NC-ND (Attribution - Non-commercial - No-derivatives) 4.0 copyright. It may be copied or printed for fair use, but only with full attribution, and not for commercial advantage or personal compensation. **Cite as:** The Stem Array (Gaṇḍavyūha, Toh 44-45). Translated by Peter Alan Roberts and team. Online publication. 84000: Translating the Words of the Buddha, 2021. https://84000.co/translation/toh44-45.

> This is the plain-text edition of https://84000.co/translation/toh44-45. Passage labels (for example 1.2 or i.3) match the online edition. Each label is followed by the passage's permanent ID in square brackets, and by a Toh number when the passage belongs to one Toh only, for example **1.2** [ID] or **i.3** [ID, toh44-45]. To link to a passage, use https://84000.co/entity/passage/ID?toh=TOH, with TOH = toh44-45 when no Toh is given. Note numbers in square brackets (such as [n.3]) point to the Notes section. When quoting, cite 84000, *The Stem Array* (Toh 44-45), with the passage label and its link. The summary, introduction and notes are by the translators and are not part of the translated text.

## Parts of this text

This text is long, so its plain-text edition is split into 28 parts. Each part keeps 84000's passage labels and ends with the notes its passages refer to. The whole text in one file: https://84000.co/translation/toh44-45/full.md

- [Part 1](https://84000.co/translation/toh44-45.md): Summary, Acknowledgments, Introduction
- [Part 2](https://84000.co/translation/toh44-45/part-2.md): Introduction, The Translation (1.1–1.53)
- [Part 3](https://84000.co/translation/toh44-45/part-3.md): The Translation (1.54–2.55)
- [Part 4](https://84000.co/translation/toh44-45/part-4.md): The Translation (2.56–6.14)
- [Part 5](https://84000.co/translation/toh44-45/part-5.md): The Translation (6.15–9.30)
- [Part 6](https://84000.co/translation/toh44-45/part-6.md): The Translation (9.31–10.37)
- [Part 7](https://84000.co/translation/toh44-45/part-7.md): The Translation (10.38–15.3)
- [Part 8](https://84000.co/translation/toh44-45/part-8.md): The Translation (15.4–17.16)
- [Part 9](https://84000.co/translation/toh44-45/part-9.md): The Translation (17.17–22.6)
- [Part 10](https://84000.co/translation/toh44-45/part-10.md): The Translation (22.7–27.9)
- [Part 11](https://84000.co/translation/toh44-45/part-11.md): The Translation (27.10–34.2)
- [Part 12](https://84000.co/translation/toh44-45/part-12.md): The Translation (34.3–36.33)
- [Part 13](https://84000.co/translation/toh44-45/part-13.md): The Translation (36.34–37.99)
- [Part 14](https://84000.co/translation/toh44-45/part-14.md): The Translation (37.100–39.21)
- [Part 15](https://84000.co/translation/toh44-45/part-15.md): The Translation (39.22–40.114)
- [Part 16](https://84000.co/translation/toh44-45/part-16.md): The Translation (40.115–41.99)
- [Part 17](https://84000.co/translation/toh44-45/part-17.md): The Translation (41.100–43.29)
- [Part 18](https://84000.co/translation/toh44-45/part-18.md): The Translation (43.30–43.246)
- [Part 19](https://84000.co/translation/toh44-45/part-19.md): The Translation (43.247–44.75)
- [Part 20](https://84000.co/translation/toh44-45/part-20.md): The Translation (44.76–54.18)
- [Part 21](https://84000.co/translation/toh44-45/part-21.md): The Translation (54.19–54.236)
- [Part 22](https://84000.co/translation/toh44-45/part-22.md): The Translation (54.237–54.402)
- [Part 23](https://84000.co/translation/toh44-45/part-23.md): The Translation (54.403–56.135)
- [Part 24](https://84000.co/translation/toh44-45/part-24.md): Glossary
- [Part 25](https://84000.co/translation/toh44-45/part-25.md): Glossary
- [Part 26](https://84000.co/translation/toh44-45/part-26.md): Glossary
- [Part 27](https://84000.co/translation/toh44-45/part-27.md): Glossary
- [Part 28](https://84000.co/translation/toh44-45/part-28.md): Glossary

## At a glance

> Machine-generated overview: written by AI from 84000's published summary and introduction, not yet reviewed by an 84000 editor. It is not part of the translation; quote the translation itself.

**In brief:** The Stem Array (Toh 44-45), with the Sanskrit title Gaṇḍavyūha, is the forty-fifth and final chapter of the Buddhāvataṃsaka Sūtra, known in Tibetan as "A Multitude of Buddhas," and belongs to the Discourses section of the Kangyur under the subsection "A Multitude of Buddhas." By far the longest chapter of the Avataṃsaka, it comprises about a third of the entire sūtra. The text follows the journey of the young layman Sudhana, who, guided first by the bodhisattva Mañjuśrī in South India, travels from teacher to teacher — each one called a kalyāṇamitra, or "good friend" — receiving teachings on their extraordinary realizations and miraculous powers. These fifty teachers include men and women, children and adults, humans and deities, monastics and laypeople, among them night goddesses, a courtesan, merchants, and figures not following a recognizably Buddhist path. The final three teachers are the bodhisattvas Maitreya, Mañjuśrī, and Samantabhadra, whose recitation of the Samantabhadracaryāpraṇidhāna, "The Prayer for Completely Good Conduct," closes the sūtra.

**Why read it:** This text offers a sustained narrative exploration of how liberation is encountered through a vast range of teachers — human and divine, orthodox and unexpected — culminating in one of the most widely recited prayers in Tibetan Buddhism.

**Also known as:** Entry into the Realm of Reality, Entry into the Realm of Dharma, The Supreme Array

### Who is Sudhana, and what is the structure of his journey in The Stem Array?

Sudhana is a young layman who, after meeting the bodhisattva Mañjuśrī in South India, is directed to seek out a succession of kalyāṇamitras, or "good friends." Each teacher sends him to the next. In this way he meets fifty teachers of widely varying backgrounds — including deities, children, a courtesan, merchants, and figures not apparently following a Buddhist path — before reaching the bodhisattvas Maitreya, Mañjuśrī, and finally Samantabhadra.

### What is the Samantabhadracaryāpraṇidhāna, and how does it relate to The Stem Array?

The Samantabhadracaryāpraṇidhāna, translated as "The Prayer for Completely Good Conduct," is a sixty-two-verse prayer recited by the bodhisattva Samantabhadra at the conclusion of The Stem Array. It was added to the sūtra in a later stage of its development. The prayer has continued to exist as an independent text and, particularly its first twelve verses, is regularly recited in Tibetan Buddhism.

### How does The Stem Array relate to the larger Buddhāvataṃsaka Sūtra?

The Stem Array is the forty-fifth and final chapter of the Buddhāvataṃsaka Sūtra and by far its longest, comprising about a third of the entire work. While the previous forty-four chapters take place in the presence of the Buddha Śākyamuni — referred to in this sūtra by the name Vairocana — The Stem Array is unique in that most of its narrative unfolds far from the Buddha, in South India, following Sudhana's journey from teacher to teacher.

### What is unusual about the teachers Sudhana meets, and how does the sūtra explain their diversity?

Sudhana's kalyāṇamitras include not only monks and bodhisattvas but also children, women, a courtesan, merchants, night goddesses, non-Buddhist ascetics, and figures such as Mahādeva (also known as Śiva). The sūtra's inclusion of non-Buddhist teachers is connected by the introduction to the view, found in the Satyaka Sūtra, that all religious traditions arise through the blessing of the Buddha and are therefore encompassed within a single path.

### What does the title "The Stem Array" mean, and why is it ambiguous?

The English title follows the Tibetan sdong po bkod pa, itself a translation of the Sanskrit Gaṇḍavyūha. The Sanskrit term gaṇḍa can mean "stem" or "stalk" but also "pieces," "parts," or "sections," and in Pali can refer to the section between the joints of a stem. The title may allude to the successive episodes of Sudhana's journey, like joints along a bamboo stem, though the sūtra's colophon renders it differently as sdong pos rgyan, meaning roughly "an adornment by stems."

### Who translated The Stem Array into English for 84000, and who made the original Tibetan translation?

The 84000 English translation was made by Peter Alan Roberts, first published in 2021. The original Tibetan translation was made by the Indian upādhyāyas Jinamitra and Surendrabodhi together with the chief editor Lotsawa Bandé Yeshé Dé and others, most likely sometime between 800 and 836 CE during the reigns of King Senalek and King Ralpachen.

### What role did The Stem Array play in the construction of Borobudur?

The Stem Array was a major inspiration for the Buddhist monument of Borobudur in Java, built in the ninth century by the Śailendra dynasty. The upper terraces, the third and fourth galleries, are entirely dedicated to the Gaṇḍavyūha, with 460 panels illustrating the sūtra. Of these, 334 panels are dedicated to the conclusion of the sūtra — Maitreya, the brief return to Mañjuśrī, Samantabhadra, and the "Prayer of Good Conduct" — reflecting the particular importance of Maitreya's kūṭāgāra for the builders, who were likewise trying to create an edifice that embodied enlightenment.

## Summary

**s.1** [abc81349-e0ef-492c-b50d-a36647aa1a1d] In this lengthy final chapter of the *Avataṃsaka Sūtra*, while the Buddha Śākyamuni is in meditation in Śrāvastī, Mañjuśrī leaves for South India, where he meets the young layman Sudhana and instructs him to go to a certain *kalyāṇamitra* or “good friend,” who then directs Sudhana to another such friend. In this way, Sudhana successively meets and receives teachings from fifty male and female, child and adult, human and divine, and monastic and lay kalyāṇamitras, including night goddesses surrounding the Buddha and the Buddha’s wife and mother. The final three in the succession of kalyāṇamitras are the three bodhisattvas Maitreya, Mañjuśrī, and Samantabhadra. Samantabhadra’s recitation of the *Samantabhadracaryāpraṇidhāna* (“The Prayer for Completely Good Conduct”) concludes the sūtra.

## Acknowledgments

**ac.1** [2fc6d1c0-fbec-4536-bcb5-f1a3912525a6] Translated by Peter Alan Roberts and edited by Emily Bower, who was also the project manager. Ling Lung Chen was consultant for the Chinese, and Tracy Davis copyedited the final draft. The translator would like to thank Patrick Carré and Douglas Osto, who have both spent decades studying and translating this sūtra, for their advice and help.

The translation was completed under the patronage and supervision of 84000: Translating the Words of the Buddha.

**ac.2** [7002cfb5-dfa6-453d-b227-88d6a51046e4] The generous sponsorship of Richard and Carol Weingarten; of Jamyang Sun, Manju Chandra Sun and Siqi Sun; and of an anonymous donor, which helped make the work on this translation possible, is most gratefully acknowledged.

## Introduction

**i.1** [7a91768d-9f06-43bb-9e83-515aae7b9f43] *The Stem Array* (*Gaṇḍavyūha*) is a unique sūtra in that most of its narrative takes place in South India, far from the presence of the Buddha. It follows the journey of the young Sudhana from teacher to teacher, or *kalyāṇamitra* (literally “good friend”), beginning with his meeting Mañjuśrī when that bodhisattva came to South India. Another unique characteristic is that Sudhana’s teachers include children, non-Buddhists, a courtesan, merchants, and so on, among them a number of women. His teachers are both humans and deities, including eight night goddesses around the Bodhi tree and the forest goddess of Lumbinī, the birthplace of the Buddha. These teachers are often described as having received teachings from numerous other buddhas. For example, the bhikṣu Sāgaramegha describes how he received, from a buddha who appeared out of the ocean, teachings that would take more than a kalpa to write out. The kalyāṇamitras are described as having realizations and miraculous powers that test the limits of the imagination.

**i.2** [050b73ce-74e9-4af1-afd9-e33b19739d92] The *Gaṇḍavyūha* forms the forty-fifth and final chapter of the *Buddhāvataṃsaka* (*A Multitude of Buddhas*) *Sūtra*, where it is called a “chapter” rather than a “sūtra.” According to the Degé colophon, the previous forty-four chapters form six sections, or sūtras, of the *Avataṃsaka*, with the *Gaṇḍavyūha* as the seventh sūtra.[n.1] In his sixteenth-century survey of the major sūtras, Pekar Zangpo (*pad dkar bzang po*) divides the first group of chapters into two, so that the *Gaṇḍavyūha* is the eighth section of the *Buddhāvataṃsaka*.[n.2] The *Gaṇḍavyūha* is one of the four sections that consist of a single sūtra, but it is by far the longest sūtra or chapter, comprising about a third of the *Avataṃsaka Sūtra*.

**i.3** [2b0a6174-b982-4b77-a408-46e92e05cb6e] In the *Buddhāvataṃsaka Sūtra*, the Buddha Śākyamuni never speaks: all the teachings in the forty-five chapters of the *Avataṃsaka* are given by others. In the first forty-four chapters or sūtras this is done in the Buddha’s presence. The *Gaṇḍavyūha* is unique in that most of this lengthy chapter takes place far from his presence, with other buddhas being presented as the sources of teachings received by the kalyāṇamitras whom Sudhana meets. However, the previous chapters of the *Avataṃsaka* have already presented the view that various buddhas are manifestations of the Buddha Vairocana, and it is by the name Vairocana that Śākyamuni is referred to in this sūtra.[n.3]
                      
**i.4** [1c675b59-1ed8-4be6-9d05-1a37b829c27f] The previous forty-four chapters of the *Avataṃsaka Sūtra* take place during the two weeks after the Buddha’s enlightenment, at which time he sits in silence under the Bodhi tree yet is simultaneously present, still in silent meditation, in other locations throughout our universe: the Trāyastriṃśa paradise of Indra on the summit of Sumeru, the Yāma and Tuṣita paradises high above Sumeru, and the highest paradise in the realm of desire—the Paranirmitavaśavartin paradise. Bodhisattvas congregate around him, inspired by his presence to give such teachings as the *Daśabhūmika Sūtra* (*Ten Bhūmi Sūtra*),[n.4] which is taught by the bodhisattva Vajragarbha in the Paranirmitavaśavartin paradise. The *Daśabhūmika Sūtra* had a great influence on the development of Buddhism, eclipsing the previous seven bhūmis of the *Prajñāpāramitā* (*Perfection of Wisdom*) sūtras.

**i.5** [159bdc40-2e97-4433-82d8-c90c9a6e36c0] The *Gaṇḍavyūha*, on the other hand, begins with the Buddha in silent meditation in his Jetavana Monastery in Śrāvastī, where he spent most of his summer retreats. Human pupils are gathered around him along with a multitude of bodhisattvas that his human pupils are not advanced enough to perceive. While the Buddha sits silently in meditation, the bodhisattva Samantabhadra gives a teaching to the assembled bodhisattvas. The bodhisattva Mañjuśrī leaves the assembly for South India, and, rather than continuing to describe events and teachings in the presence of the Buddha, the sūtra follows Mañjuśrī to South India, where he meets Sudhana, and the narrative then follows Sudhana for the rest of the long sūtra. Although the beginning of the sūtra is set at a time later than that of the Buddha’s enlightenment, further on, in the night-goddess chapters, the Buddha is depicted as being present under the Bodhi tree. There are other temporal anomalies: the bodhisattva Maitreya, in the chapter where Sudhana meets him, is portrayed as being on earth and not yet passed away to be reborn in Tuṣita, even though he is said in the Māyādevī chapter, as is generally said in other Buddhist sources, to be already present in Tuṣita. Māyādevī, the Buddha’s mother, appears to Sudhana in Kapilavastu, the Buddha’s hometown, even though she is traditionally said to have passed away shortly after the Buddha’s birth and been reborn as a male deity in the Trāyastriṃśa paradise.

**i.6** [05d1f7f0-80c8-49ee-a916-a425ac039bf2] The sūtra primarily describes (in successive long compounds in Sanskrit) both the inner qualities and the external displays of miraculous powers that have been attained by the various kalyāṇamitras whom Sudhana meets. It concludes with the bodhisattva Samantabhadra composing the *Samantabhadracaryāpraṇidhāna* (“The Prayer for Completely Good Conduct”), which is regularly recited by contemporary Tibetan Buddhists.

### Indian Origins of the Sūtra

**i.7** [602aefb7-f344-4088-b203-a389088a66ed] Mahāyāna sūtras first appeared through the medium of revelations after the tradition of written sūtras had developed. These sūtras appeared in various Buddhist traditions and in various locations.[n.5] Mahāyāna sources show doctrinal similarities to the Mahāsāṃghika tradition.[n.6] The Mahāsāṃghika was especially prevalent in southwest India, and a substantial number of Mahāyāna sūtras have indications of a South Indian provenance, with passing references to South Indian music, or, to take the *Samādhirāja* *Sūtra*[n.7] as just one example, to a prominent South Indian personage, in this case the ṛṣi Ananta. Similarly, much of the *Gaṇḍavyūha Sūtra* takes place in South India, depicting teachers who appear to operate independently of Buddhist communities in the north. Douglas Osto echoes Qobad Afshar in suggesting that the site of Dhanyākara referenced in the *Gaṇḍavyūha* is in fact Dhānyakaṭaka/Dharaṇikoṭa, an ancient city that existed on the banks of the Kṛṣṇa River in the southern region of Andhra. This place, Afshar and Osto believe, was probably where the *Gaṇḍavyūha* was first composed.[n.8]

**i.8** [7f3f0787-8aad-403f-9535-aa1238ac78fe] In terms of its language, the Sanskrit of the *Gaṇḍavyūha Sūtra* has numerous nonclassical Buddhist Hybrid Sanskrit (BHS) features and vocabulary. This is especially true of the verses, which are less prone to revision to Classical Sanskrit than the prose. It is frequently the case that the verses in a sūtra are older than the prose that accompanies them, or they at least retain the original form of the language in which the sūtra was composed. In the *Gaṇḍavyūha*, they favor the *-u* ending for the nominative case, where it would be *-a* in Sanskrit, *-e* in the ancient northeastern dialect, and *-o* in that of the northwest (and its continuation in Pali). The difference between these two kinds of Sanskrit is not evident in the Tibetan or the English translations.

**i.9** [d1d91b47-1a05-4679-987b-93c796e5e803] Concerning the relative chronology of the *Gaṇḍavyūha*, chapter 41 makes a clear reference to the *Satyaka Sūtra* (formally known as *The Teaching of the Miraculous Manifestation of the Range of Methods in the Field of Activity of the Bodhisattvas*),[n.9] which describes a Jain master by the name of Satyaka, who advises a king on the polity of rulership[n.10] and is eventually revealed by the Buddha to be a bodhisattva who takes on various forms in order to benefit beings.[n.11] The *Satyaka Sūtra* briefly presents the single-yāna view that was expounded in *The Lotus Sūtra*,[n.12] but it goes further by stating that all religious traditions in India occur through the blessing of the Buddha and are therefore included within the single yāna.[n.13] This view of the *Satyaka Sūtra* is crucial for understanding one of the surprising elements in the *Gaṇḍavyūha Sūtra*—some of Sudhana’s teachers do not appear to be following a Buddhist path. There is the ṛṣi Bhīṣmottaranirghoṣa, who is teaching young brahmins; and Jayoṣmāyatana, who is following the non-Buddhist ascetic practice of “the five heats” (sitting amid four fires under the noonday sun); and there is even Mahādeva, also known as Śiva. Therefore, in terms of the succession of sūtras, it would appear that the *Gaṇḍavyūha* postdates both *The Lotus Sūtra* (though not necessarily its later chapters) and the *Satyaka Sūtra*.

**i.10** [cea2da31-6fa5-43f5-a5f5-32ab0da79caa] The depiction of the bodhisattva Avalokiteśvara in the *Gaṇḍavyūha* is surprising in that he is presented as an apparently human guru living on the Potalaka Mountain in South India, with no mention of his association with Amitābha’s pure realm of Sukhāvatī, where earlier sūtras locate him. The Potalaka Mountain was an important place of pilgrimage for both the Buddhists and Śaivites of South India, as the abode of both Śiva, who was known as Lokeśvara (Lord of the World), and Avalokiteśvara. This earthly abode of Avalokiteśvara, in Tibet known as the Potala Mountain, would become prominent in Tibetan and Chinese Buddhism, as evidenced by the Potala Palace in Lhasa and Mount Putuo Island in China.

**i.11** [2942a55c-5035-42c5-bb45-11fefed54d42] The *Gaṇḍavyūha Sūtra* first existed in India as an independent sūtra and still exists as an independent sūtra in Sanskrit manuscripts. The successive Chinese translations reveal a gradual growth in the contents of the sūtra, with the addition of more teachers in the Indian version before its eventual translation into Tibetan. Even so, the number of kalyāṇamitras met by Sudhana is still smaller than the number that Maitreya, toward the end of the sūtra, proclaims that Sudhana has met on his journeys—110.

**i.12** [284974ff-75fc-4d0a-b69c-6b862dbc97b5] There was an Indian version longer than the one that was translated into Tibetan, though no Sanskrit manuscript of this version has survived. It is known only from the version sent to China by the king of Orissa, who gave a copy to the Chinese emperor in 795.[n.14] This version was translated by the Kashmiri monk Prajñā in 798, two or three decades before the Tibetan translation was made. The Chinese translations also indicate that the *Gaṇḍavyūha* had a different title in the seventh century, which can be reconstructed from the Chinese *入法界品* (*Ru fa jie pin*) as *Dharmadhātupraveśana* (*Entry into the Realm of the Dharma*).

**i.13** [be7661f8-8ef8-435c-a826-fc7a02c16316] Earlier versions concluded with the Maitreya chapter. The Mañjuśrī and Samantabhadra chapters were added subsequently, and finally the sixty-two-verse “Prayer for Completely Good Conduct,” which has continued to exist as an independent text, was added as the sūtra’s conclusion. This prayer was translated into Chinese in a forty-four-verse version by Buddhabhadra in the early fifth century. Amoghavajra’s (705–74) eighth-century Chinese translation of the prayer has sixty-two verses because of the addition of fifteen verses on Amitābha. This longer version appeared as the conclusion of the *Buddhāvataṃsaka* in the translation into Chinese made in 798 and in the early ninth-century translation into Tibetan. “The Prayer for Completely Good Conduct,” particularly its first twelve verses, is regularly recited in Tibetan Buddhism, and it also exists independently in the Kangyur with an additional concluding verse.[n.15]

**i.14** [743e4d93-276b-4302-b840-55a35916841f] There are no surviving Sanskrit manuscripts of the *Gaṇḍavyūha* from the first millennium, but there is a complete Sanskrit text that dates to 1166 *ᴄᴇ*, three hundred years later than the Tibetan translation. It consists of 289 palm-leaf pages and was sent from Nepal to the Royal Asiatic Society in London by Brian Houghton Hodgson (1800–1894) in the early nineteenth century. Cataloged as Hodgson 2 (A), this is the earliest extant Sanskrit manuscript of the *Gaṇḍavyūha*.[n.16] The Sanskrit Buddhist tradition has continued in Nepal, where the *Gaṇḍavyūha* remains one of the nine central works of Newar Buddhism.[n.17]

### The *Gaṇḍavyūha Sūtra* in China

**i.15** [2a4743c5-b504-4809-88c1-ef695d176b76] The *Gaṇḍavyūha Sūtra* was first translated into Chinese as an independent text by a monk named Shengjian sometime between 388 and 408 *ᴄᴇ*.[n.18] In that translation there are only twenty-five kalyāṇamitras. Compared to the extant Sanskrit version, the first nine kalyāṇamitras after Mañjuśrī and those after the thirty-fourth are not present.[n.19] Therefore, it may represent an unfinished translation or an earlier form of the sūtra, or both.

**i.16** [ca85ffbf-e442-40bf-8d1d-496a88ad6fc1] Not long afterward, in 420, Buddhabhadra (359–429 *ᴄᴇ*), an Indian monk who had migrated to China, translated with his team the entire *Buddhāvataṃsaka Sūtra*, which at that time was composed of thirty-four chapters with the *Gaṇḍavyūha Sūtra* as the final chapter.[n.20] Buddhabhadra’s translation contains not only additional chapters when compared to Shengjian’s translation, but also additional verses and passages within the chapters.

**i.17** [7a84cdef-329b-47e8-83cc-f5b3a9b98da8] Interestingly, the Indian monk Paramārtha (499–569 *ᴄᴇ*), who flourished not long after Buddhabhadra’s time, refers to the *Buddhāvataṃsaka* as a *Bodhisattvapiṭaka* (“basket” or “collected teachings for bodhisattvas”). This is echoed by a copy of this sūtra found in the Mogao Caves at Dunhuang, which bears the title *Bodhisattvapiṭaka Buddhāvataṃsaka*.[n.21] While the presently available Sanskrit does not give the title *Bodhisattvapiṭaka*, the Tibetan colophons feature this designation, though the sense of it shifts depending on the given colophon’s grammar,[n.22] which may suggest that there was some confusion among Tibetan scholars about the term’s significance.

**i.18** [3c55231a-e552-4120-8367-9663cff646a6] The *Buddhāvataṃsaka* had grown even further in size by the time of its translation into Chinese under the direction of the Khotanese Śikṣānanda (*于闐國實叉難陀*, 652–710 *ᴄᴇ*). This was made between 695 and 699 *ᴄᴇ*[n.23] and had an additional five chapters, with the *Gaṇḍavyūha Sūtra* still in final place as the thirty-ninth chapter. The translation of the *Gaṇḍavyūha* in this version varies little from that of Buddhabhadra, with a few exceptions: the final two verses of the Veṣṭhila section have been added, Avalokiteśvara’s mountain is now named Potalaka rather than Prabha, and a short verse greeting appears in the final section.[n.24]

**i.19** [2c5f0485-9118-433c-a0da-ad8803744332] Śikṣānanda’s version of the *Buddhāvataṃsaka* became the basis for the Huayan school of Chinese Buddhism, *huayan* being the Chinese translation of *avataṃsaka* as “flower garland,” and it is Śikṣānanda’s version that was translated by Thomas Cleary into English as *The Flower Ornament Scripture*.[n.25] In Śikṣānanda’s Chinese, the title of the *Gaṇḍavyūha Sūtra* was *入法界品* (*Ru fa jie pin*), which could have come from the Sanskrit *Dharmadhātupraveśanaparivarta* and in English could be translated as *The Chapter on Entering the Realm of the Dharma*. Thomas Cleary translated this as *Entry into the Realm of Reality*, while Douglas Osto translated it as *Entry into the Realm of Dharma*, and Patrick Carré as *l’Entrée dans la dimension absolue* (“*Entry into the Absolute Dimension*”). The term *dharmadhātupraveśana* does occur in the text, as for example in verse 44 of chapter 1.

**i.20** [5cef3193-822b-4605-a4d2-1ac47eeade26] There is a longer version of the *Gaṇḍavyūha Sūtra* that was translated into Chinese as an independent sūtra in 798 by the Kashmiri monk Prajñā. This was the first among the Chinese translations to include “The Prayer for Completely Good Conduct.”[n.26] Prajñā’s translation was based on a Sanskrit manuscript that the king of Orissa sent as a gift to the Chinese emperor, who received it in 795.[n.27] The additions in Prajñā’s version are not found in any surviving Sanskrit edition, nor are they found in the early ninth-century Tibetan translation made just a few decades after Prajñā’s translation. In Prajñā’s translation the *Gaṇḍavyūha Sūtra* is called *The Vow Concerning the Course of Conduct of Samantabhadra and the Entry into the Range of Inconceivable Liberation* (*入不思議解脫境界普賢行願品*, *Ru bu si yi jie tuo jing jie pu xian xing yuan pin*), which could be reconstructed in Sanskrit as *Acintyavimokṣagocarapraveśanasamantabhadracaryāpranidhāna*).

**i.21** [09a46f1f-11df-4ff6-83b1-6e29314bfb06] As mentioned, the *Buddhāvataṃsaka Sūtra* became the basis for the Chinese Huayan school of Buddhism. Li Tongxuan (635–730 *ᴄᴇ*) was particularly influential in the spread of this tradition, and he wrote a commentary (*華嚴論*, *Huayan lun*) on the *Buddhāvataṃsaka Sūtra*, in which he identifies a deeper structure and meaning in the *Gaṇḍavyūha*’s narrative, and that part of Li Tongxuan’s commentary has been translated into French by Patrick Carré. Li also composed a summary of that commentary and a chapter-by-chapter synopsis of the *Buddhāvataṃsaka Sūtra* itself.[n.28] This tradition spread to Korea and Japan, where it became, respectively, the Hwaeom and Kegon schools of Buddhism.

### *Gaṇḍavyūha* and Borobudur

**i.22** [bb0d1eb1-d51f-4e8d-9903-2049e724333a] The *Gaṇḍavyūha Sūtra*, and in particular its Maitreya chapter, was an inspiration for what is arguably the greatest Buddhist monument ever built: Borobudur in Indonesia. This was built in the ninth century by the Buddhist kings of the Śailendra dynasty in Java. The massive structure has a series of encircling terraces that hold 504 statues and 2672 carved panels. The upper terraces, the third and fourth galleries, are entirely dedicated to the *Gaṇḍavyūha*, with 460 panels illustrating the sūtra.[n.29] Of these, it appears that 218 panels are dedicated to the Maitreya chapter, and from among those twenty are dedicated to the description of Maitreya’s kūṭāgāra and thirty-five to the various manifestations of Maitreya.[n.30] In fact, 334 panels are dedicated to the conclusion of the *Gaṇḍavyūha*: Maitreya, the brief return to Mañjuśrī, Samantabhadra, and the “Prayer of Good Conduct.” This reflects the importance of the *Gaṇḍavyūha* and particularly of Maitreya’s kūṭāgāra—an edifice that embodied enlightenment—for the constructors of Borobudur, who were also trying to create an edifice that embodied enlightenment.

**i.23** [9f2d5a1e-1b2b-427a-866c-63e4fd483a60] Although the number of accounts of Sudhana meeting kalyāṇamitras grew in succeeding recensions, they did not reach the number given in the sūtra itself in chapter 54, where Maitreya states that Sudhana, following his initial meeting with Mañjuśrī, has visited 110 kalyāṇamitras. Borobudur, possibly to accord with that statement, does have that number of panels dedicated to the illustration of that part of the *Gaṇḍavyūha*, but even so it does not represent 110 kalyāṇamitras but instead repeats the illustration of certain visits, in addition to portraying Sudhana traveling and depicting incidents in past lives of the kalyāṇamitras.[n.31]

### The *Gaṇḍavyūha Sūtra* in Tibet

**i.24** [faa8f4e4-6689-4283-af6e-4f8f0a807e6a] The *Buddhāvataṃsaka* as translated into Tibetan is composed of forty-five chapters and 115 fascicles, with the *Gaṇḍavyūha Sūtra* still retaining its position as the last of the chapters. According to the Degé Kangyur, the entire *Buddhāvataṃsaka Sūtra*, including the *Gaṇḍavyūha*, was translated into Tibetan by Yeshé Dé, Jinamitra, and Surendrabodhi, which would have been during the reign of King Senalek (r. ca. 800/804–15) or King Ralpachen (r. 815–36). Yeshé Dé and Jinamitra had been working at Samyé Monastery since the reign of King Trisong Detsen (r. 742–98), but Surendrabodhi appears to have come to Tibet after Senalek, Trisong Detsen’s youngest son, became king. Senalek was in turn succeeded by his son Ralpachen, the end of whose reign also saw the end of state-sponsored translation. Therefore, this translation appears to have been made sometime between 800 and 836, but it may incorporate even earlier translation work, particularly in the case of the *Gaṇḍavyūha*.

**i.25** [8a1be16b-ac78-4957-bc02-081db80babb8] By the time of the sūtra’s translation into Tibetan at the beginning of the ninth century, the number of chapters in the *Avataṃsaka Sūtra* had increased from thirty-nine to forty-five. But this is primarily because of the division in Tibetan of what is the Chinese chapter 5 into chapters 5 through 9, with some additional material, and the additional chapters 11 and 32. This Tibetan translation provides the earliest indication of when the forty-fifth chapter was named *Gaṇḍavyūha*.

**i.26** [24593b3d-cb76-43a8-ac2d-912e3a1b5620] According to Tashi Wangchuk, who wrote the colophon to the eighteenth-century Degé edition, and also according to the historian Ngorchen Könchok Lhundrup (1497–1557), the *Buddhāvataṃsaka* is composed of seven sūtras or sections, while Pekar Zangpo divides the first of these into two, making eight sections.

**i.27** [ec1a45a2-5fe9-4b0a-aed5-eed70cff22cc] Whereas the Chinese version of the *Buddhāvataṃsaka* retained the traditional beginning of the *Gaṇḍavyūha Sūtra* as an independent sūtra, commencing with “Thus did I hear…” and so on, the version translated into Tibetan omits it, as do the surviving Sanskrit versions.

**i.28** [41f830a4-f18f-4ef8-805c-3ed9dfa51293] The *Gaṇḍavyūha Sūtra*, which in Tibetan is interpreted to mean, ambiguously, *The Stem Array Sūtra*, is the forty-fifth and last chapter in the Tibetan version of the *Buddhāvataṃsaka Sūtra*, which is made up of four volumes as found in the Degé Kangyur. This chapter is by far the longest, beginning halfway through the third volume and occupying the entire fourth volume of the *Buddhāvataṃsaka*. It is composed of 72 of the 115 fascicles that make up the entire sūtra, beginning with fascicle 44 (the twenty-fourth in volume Ga). Fascicles refer to the bundles of pages in the original Sanskrit manuscripts, usually joined up through two holes in the center of each page. In this translation the beginning of a fascicle is simply marked with the letter B (from the Tibetan for *fascicle*: *bam po*) and a number, for example, [B24].

**i.29** [ac4de0f1-c29c-4e6e-bb31-9bad986ea38e] The quality of the Tibetan translation differs from the rest of the *Buddhāvataṃsaka*, either because of scribal corruption or choices of translation. The Tibetan has peculiarities not shared with all other parts of the *Avataṃsaka*. For example, it retains the archaic spelling of *myi* and *myed* instead of *mi* and *med*. The translation is less reliable than usual, as it contains frequent, possibly inadvertent omissions and misspellings that must have occurred early in the scribal transmission, as some of these errors in the sūtra are found in all Kangyurs.

**i.30** [43dbffd3-15d3-424d-ab47-a429d28ee8f9] It also exhibits a certain idiosyncrasy of translation, in that the terms may not match what was established in the *Mahāvyutpatti* (*bye brag tu rtogs par byed chen po*) and *Madhyavyutpatti* (*sgra sbyor bam po gnyis pa*), the early ninth-century Sanskrit–Tibetan dictionaries produced within the same state-sponsored translation project responsible for the translation of this sūtra. For example, *vyūha* is regularly translated as *rgyan* (“adornment”) instead of *bkod pa* (“array”), even in the title of the sūtra, in spite of its being generally known in Tibetan as *sdong po bkod pa*. These and other variations of the title are touched upon in the *Avataṃsaka*’s editorial colophon in the Degé Kangyur (c.10).

**i.31** [8954bd9c-adc2-4c6f-bca4-34043563c3e5] According to that colophon, this edition of the *Avataṃsaka* was prepared in 1722. This was eight years before the eighth Tai Situpa Chökyi Jungné (1700–1774) began his work as chief editor of the Degé Kangyur. He states in his account of the creation of the Kangyur: “I began in the Iron Dog year,”[n.32] which was 1730, and the carving and printing of the Degé woodblocks did not begin until 1737 and was completed in 1744. It was nevertheless done under the command of the Degé King Tenpa Tsering (1678–1738), as was the entire Degé Kangyur, and therefore may be an earlier edition that Situ incorporated into his edition of the Kangyur. The colophon also states that it was based on the Lithang Kangyur, also known as the Jangsa Tham Kangyur. The creation of this Kangyur took five years, from 1609 until 1614. The Lithang was the second printing of the Kangyur, which otherwise only existed in manuscript form. The first printing was the Yongle in 1411.

**i.32** [d82c7bd4-7d85-456a-9480-303ff20f3f61] The colophons of the Narthang, Lhasa, Stok Palace, and some other Kangyurs ascribe the editing, or perhaps revision, of the *Buddhāvataṃsaka* to a Vairocanarakṣita: “Lotsawa Vairocanarakṣita was the chief editor and established the text.” The great Sakya master Ngorchen Könchok Lhundrup also mentions Vairocanarakṣita’s involvement.

**i.33** [756779f6-f0bd-4a87-8b71-efc8a8b308a5] The long note by the Degé editor after the colophon states, “It is taught that Surendrabodhi and Vairocanarakṣita acted as chief editors for a Chinese translation.”[n.33] As the Indian master Surendrabodhi came to Tibet during the reign of King Senalek (ca. 800/804–15), the identity of this Vairocanarakṣita is a mystery, as he could not be the eleventh-century translator Vairocanarakṣita, nor could he be the eighth-century Vairocana. Tashi Wangchuk adds, “I have not seen any histories or texts that recount translation work done by lotsawas or paṇḍitas other than those listed in the colophon here,” thus apparently rejecting the attribution of Vairocanarakṣita as the editor.

### Translations into Western Languages

**i.34** [d745daca-554a-4b27-b069-aad2857dcfa1] The *Gaṇḍavyūha Sūtra* was translated into German from Buddhabhadra’s Chinese version by Dōi Torakazu as *Das Kegon Sutra, Das Buch vom Eintreten in den Kosmos der Wahrheit* in 1978.

**i.35** [1d4ff179-53c3-42f9-ba90-aea2cf2c4ba1] The entire *Avataṃsaka Sūtra* has been translated from the Chinese by Thomas Cleary and published in 1993 as *The Flower Ornament Scripture*. The *Gaṇḍavyūha Sūtra* is therefore included as the final chapter, chapter 39, under the title “Entry into the Realm of Reality.”

**i.36** [4ba69c18-bc47-4f83-9622-a426fb377619] The Śikṣānanda version has been translated from the Chinese into French by Patrick Carré. There is as yet no translation of the longest Chinese version, which was translated by the Kashmiri Prajñā in 798.

**i.37** [92969083-b0ae-457f-a600-7cd75909a78a] There have been partial unpublished translations from the Sanskrit by Mark Allen Ehman in 1977 and Yuko Ijiri in 2005.

**i.38** [3a457f39-7ba1-4969-9120-41e9df4b9988] Douglas Osto has translated the first part of chapter 1 and chapters 3, 54, and 55 from the Sanskrit of the *Gaṇḍavyūha*, with its title given as *The Supreme Array*. They are available to read on his website.[n.34] He has also included excerpts from other chapters of the sūtra in his book *Power, Wealth and Women in Indian Mahāyāna Buddhism: The Gaṇḍavyūha-sūtra*.

### The Meaning of the Title as Translated into Tibetan

**i.39** [ffb3b881-7da5-4085-843f-07bd13932f82] As mentioned above, the sūtra’s title in Chinese translations differs from that in Tibetan, and it was evidently known by other names in earlier centuries. By the ninth century, however, it was known by this obscure title *Gaṇḍavyūha*. This translation follows the ambiguous meaning assigned to it by the early ninth-century translators into Tibetan.

**i.40** [71c847bc-9ae4-460e-8dc0-4a4565f63b47] There are two versions of the Tibetan title. In the Kangyur, the title is only mentioned in the colophon, where it is given as *sdong pos rgyan*. As stated above, *rgyan* (“adornment”) is used throughout as the translation of *vyūha* instead of the usual *bkod pa* (“array”). Nevertheless, it is usually referred to in Tibetan literature as *sdong po bkod pa*. The Sanskrit compound does not indicate the grammatical connection between the two terms *gaṇḍa* and *vyūha*, but the Kangyur colophon’s *sdong pos rgyan* ascribes an instrumental case to *gaṇḍha*, while its popularly known title *sdong po bkod pa* has no such case. Neither Sanskrit nor Tibetan specifies whether *gaṇḍa* is singular or plural. The title appears to have no connection with the content, unless it is taken to refer to the successive joints in a bamboo stem, as an analogy to the successive episodes in Sudhana’s journey.

**i.41** [282d55d4-d1a3-4221-9b7f-f5097e60e825] *Gaṇḍa* in Buddhist Hybrid Sanskrit can have two meanings: “stem” or “stalk” and “pieces” or “parts” or “sections,” and the Pali specifies that, as a variation of *gaṇṭha*, it can mean the section between the joints of a stem, in addition to such things as a swelling, a boil, an excrescence, and so on. As the sūtra is composed of a series of episodes in which Sudhana meets a succession of teachers, the intended meaning could well have been “an array of parts” or, more freely, “a series of episodes.” The only use of the word *gaṇḍa* in the sūtra itself is within a compound in verse 112 in the Maitreya chapter: *pañcagaṇḍagaticakramohitam*. *Pañcagaṇḍika* is a standard BHS term for the five classes of existence, and therefore that compound could be translated as meaning “the ignorance of the wheel of the five sections of existence,” referring to hells, pretas, animals, humans, and devas. However, because the meanings of *gaṇḍa* can include boil, blister, abscess, goiter, cheek, or bubble (as well as harness, button, joint, bone, and so on), the Tibetan here translates *gaṇḍa* as “blister” (*shu ba*) so that the Tibetan translation of this compound is *shu ba’i lam rgyud lnga yi ’khor lor rmongs* (“the ignorance of the wheels of the blisters of the five existences,” which seems unlikely to have been the original intended meaning).

**i.42** [869d0161-cc35-4960-a390-fa6c5f0341f2] Douglas Osto also points out that *gaṇḍa* has been used as the first element of a compound in Sanskrit to mean “great” or “supreme,” and he therefore has translated *gaṇḍavyūha* as “Supreme Array,” which would have made for a reasonable title.

**i.43** [aa525a70-f4df-4e8e-8643-2e3e8e42c7a8] However, the English translation of the title here, “Stem Array,” follows the better-known version of the Tibetan title, preserving its peculiar ambiguity, while the less familiar title as given in the colophon could have been translated as “An Adornment by Stems.”

### The Meaning of the Title *Buddhāvataṃsaka Sūtr*a

**i.44** [1a59abf4-af6a-4a0e-8de1-962f2836469a] The title of the sūtra in which the *Gaṇḍavyūha* is the final chapter has also been interpreted variously. The word *avataṃsaka* is a substantiate of *avataṃsa*. In Classical Sanskrit, *avataṃsa* describes a garland or any circular ornamentation. For example, *karṇāvataṃsa* (ear *avataṃsa*) means “earring.” One peculiar Tibetan translation of *buddhāvataṃsaka* is “Buddha’s earring” (*snyan gyi gong rgyan*). A *kusumāvataṃsa* (flower *avataṃsa*) is a flower garland that is worn by a person, hence another Tibetan translation of *buddhāvataṃsaka* is “Buddha’s garland,” using an obscure archaic word for garland that has various spellings (*rmad ga chad*, *rma ga chad*, or *rmag chad*). Thomas Cleary, translating into English from the Chinese *Huayan*, calls it *Flower Ornament*. However, in Buddhist Hybrid Sanskrit (BHS), *avataṃsaka* means “a great number,” “a multitude,” or “a collection.” Therefore, we have the Tibetan version of the title as *A Multitude of Buddhas* (*sangs rgyas phal po che*). *phal po che* is used elsewhere in the Kangyur to translate Sanskrit words meaning “multitude,” such as *nicaya*, for “a great assembly of beings” (*skye bo phal po che* for *mahat janakāya*). Although this is the title given in all Kangyurs, some, such as the Urga and Degé have the title *Flower Garland* (*rma ga chad*) at the conclusion of each chapter, a possible indication that this was the earlier translation of the title, which has been left unchanged within the body of the text. However, the *Mahāvyutpatti* dictionary has *phal po che* for *avataṃsaka*, and neither *rma ga chad* nor its variant forms appear anywhere in the dictionary. This contradiction between the chapter colophons and the main title is absent in the Lhasa, Stok Palace, Narthang, Lithang, and Shelkar Kangyurs. This translation follows the example of those latter versions so as to avoid such an evident contradiction.

**i.45** [9b04ba25-04db-4981-a4e7-6cf024a85f64] Whatever the intended meaning of the title, the *Buddhāvataṃsaka Sūtra* does depict a multitude of buddhas, among which are multitudes of the Buddha Śākyamuni, all of whom are emanated by the Buddha Vairocana.

**i.46** [0065b9b9-6022-47a6-bb93-850b0105df9d] During the course of the *Buddhāvataṃsaka Sūtra* we find that the Buddha Śākyamuni is but one of countless manifestations of the Buddha Vairocana. Śākyamuni is even referred to as the Buddha Vairocana. The Buddha Śākyamuni is depicted as being simultaneously present in various locations in our world realm: at the Bodhi tree, in the Trāyastriṃśa paradise of Indra, which is on the summit of Sumeru, in the Yāma and Tuṣita paradises high above Sumeru, and in the highest paradise in the realm of desire—the Paranirmitavaśavartin paradise. Śākyamuni is also depicted as being present in these same locations not only in our world realm but in countless other world realms. The Buddha Vairocana prayed to manifest in this way and to have vast assemblies that his manifestations would teach to, and these buddhas are the result of his prayer. According to the *Buddhāvataṃsaka Sūtra*, not only is Vairocana the source of all buddhas everywhere, but all the bodhisattvas whom those buddhas teach were previously pupils of Buddha Vairocana.
                      
**i.47** [391ecdb9-48e4-4373-8957-ea3ec0326939] This depiction of Śākyamuni as a Vairocana emanation has its precedent in a sūtra that was never translated into Tibetan, the *Brahmajālasūtra*, which introduces the Buddha Vairocana as the buddha who is the source of ten billion Śākyamunis simultaneously existing in various worlds. This sūtra should not be confused with the early Buddhist *Brahmajālasūtra*, which has an identical title but entirely different content. That *Brahmajālasūtra* was translated into Tibetan[n.35] and is included within the Pali canon.

**i.48** [500ec705-0593-42e9-8e79-d9c95b448463] The Buddha Vairocana is therefore portrayed in the *Buddhāvataṃsaka* as the fundamental buddha who is the source of countless manifestations of the Buddha Śākyamuni. The Buddha Vairocana would also later become the central buddha in tantric traditions such as the Shingon tradition of Japan, which is based particularly on the *Mahāvairocanābhisambodhi Tantra* (Toh 494).[n.36] Even in the higher tantras Vairocana still retains his position as the central buddha in the five-buddha-family system.

### Who Is Sudhana and What Is a *Śreṣthin*?

**i.49** [7b87c4a4-73c0-4271-a334-c98627c50d7f] The Borobudur panels portray Sudhana as a prince-like young man with a retinue, whereas there are Chinese and Japanese depictions of him as a chubby child. Many years pass in the course of his wanderings. In chapter 8 it is stated that he spent twelve years searching for the head merchant Muktaka, so even if he were a child at the beginning, he would be an adult by the end. However, the conventional passage of time is not a feature of this sūtra. Sudhana is introduced as being part of one of four groups that come to see Mañjuśrī when he goes to South India. There are laypeople—the male *upāsakas* and female *upāsikās*—and *dārakas* and *dārikas* (“sons and daughters” or “boys and girls”), which, like the compound *strīpuruṣadārakadārikāḥ* much later in the sūtra, appears to imply parents and their children, and this is specifically indicated when Mahāprajña, the first of the eleven named upāsakas, is identified as the father of the first of the daughters. However, the definition of the terms *dāraka* and *dārika* includes unmarried males and females up to the age of twenty, and each of these sons and daughters who come to meet Mañjuśrī is accompanied by a retinue. Therefore, the implication is that Sudhana is not a child but presumably around eighteen or nineteen years old. As Sudhana is the first of the eleven named sons listed, the implication appears to be that, as the most prominent of the sons, he is also the son of Mahāprajña. The only description of his family is the vast, miraculous wealth they obtained upon his birth.

**i.50** [253fa07b-07dd-41a6-a38d-cc162113630b] Throughout the sūtra he is referred to as a *śreṣṭhidāraka*. The word *śreṣṭhin* in Classical Sanskrit can mean “distinguished,” “eminent,” “a person of high position,” and, more specifically, the president of a guild or a head merchant. Edgerton, for the Buddhist Hybrid, gives “guild leader” and “capitalist.” The Pali equivalent *seṭṭhi*, according to the Pali Text Society’s dictionary, can mean “the foreman of a guild,” “a treasurer,” “a banker,” or “a wealthy merchant.” Douglas Osto, in *Power, Wealth and Women in Indian Mahāyāna Buddhism: The Gaṇḍavyūha-sūtra*, used “merchant-banker’s son” to describe Sudhana, but subsequently in his translation of parts of the sūtra he used the simpler “merchant’s son.” Cleary and Carré, translating from the Chinese, have, respectively, “youth” and *jeune* (“young”), omitting a translation of *śreṣṭhin*. Here I follow the Tibetan translation of *śreṣṭhin* as *tshong dpon*, literally “head merchant.”

**i.51** [7fa134cb-46ca-4dc8-83a4-f47e207dd72d] In chapter 8, Muktaka is simply called a *śreṣṭhin*, translated into Tibetan as *tshong dpon* (“head merchant”), and this translation follows the Tibetan, although his work is not described. Cleary translates *śreṣṭhin* as “distinguished man” and also as the adjective “noble”; Carré, translating from the Chinese, has *aîné* (“elder” or “superior”).

**i.52** [278b44df-1d66-4408-83cf-b3c7bddc5614] In chapter 18, Ratnacūḍa is said to be a *dharmaśreṣṭhin*, which was translated into Tibetan as *chos kyi tshong dpon*, literally “head merchant of the Dharma,” presumably meaning that he is a wealthy patron of the Dharma. Cleary translates as both “eminent person” and “religious eminent,” while Carré translates from the Chinese simply as *aîné* (“elder” or “superior”). Ratnacūḍa is twice associated with a market in the narrative and therefore does seem to be an extremely wealthy merchant, and his ten-story house of gold is filled with Dharma activities and even visions of buddhas and bodhisattvas.

**i.53** [8e4153f0-26cd-44ba-8332-d9e1b7e86615] In chapter 19, Samantanetra is said to be a *gāndhikaśreṣṭhin*, translated into Tibetan as *tshong dpon spod tshong* (“head-merchant perfume seller”). Cleary translates this as “eminent perfumer,” which would correspond to the Sanskrit, and Carré has simply *aîné* (“elder” or “superior”), omitting reference to *gāndhika*.

**i.54** [9f1a1a9a-53fc-4cf0-b1cd-01dd23e6ce86] In chapter 24, Utpalabhūti is also called a *gāndhikaśreṣṭhin*, translated into Tibetan slightly differently than in chapter 19 as *spod tshong gi tshong dpon*. Cleary again translates this as “eminent perfumer,” while Carré has simply *parfumeur* (“perfumer” or “perfume seller”), omitting reference to *śreṣṭhin*.

**i.55** [e2769a4d-e8f2-4eb0-9f55-e71649e392d3] In chapter 26, Jayottama is simply called a *śreṣṭhin*, translated into Tibetan as *tshong dpon* (“head merchant”). Cleary translates as “eminent man,” and Carré, translating from the Chinese, has *marchand* (“merchant”). However, in the narrative there is no mention of the work he does, but instead he is said to be advising householders on civic duties, doing so in terms of the Dharma.

### The Numbers

**i.56** [e951113d-f12c-42c4-9dff-2f4145219a10] Chapters 10 and 15 of the *Gaṇḍavyūha* have two long lists of numbers that demonstrate the innumerable beings for whom bodhisattvas seek enlightenment. Any number, no matter how large, does not encapsulate the scope of their salvific agenda. These two lists of numbers should have been identical. As this is a unique list of numbers, they have proved to be very susceptible to corruption or omission. There are differences between the two lists in the surviving Sanskrit and also for the same lists in different Sanskrit editions. Moreover, the same numbers were translated differently into Tibetan in the two chapters even though the translation in chapter 10 of the *Gaṇḍavyūha* is reproduced exactly in chapter 36 or the 36th sūtra in the *Avataṃsaka* as *The Teaching on Using Numbers on Being Questioned by Cittarāja*.[n.37] The *Gaṇḍavyūha* lists were recorded in the *Mahāvyutpatti* Sanskrit–Tibetan dictionary, revealing not only that variations already existed but that they also differed from the Kangyur versions. The Chinese should be the earliest witness to the condition of the lists. However, Buddhabhadra and Śikṣānanda omitted most of the numbers in the *Gaṇḍavyūha* chapter, instead writing “and so on” and jumping to the last number. Therefore, they are not found in Carré’s translations, and Cleary reproduces the version found in the Sanskrit. Meanwhile, Prajñā recorded the list in Chinese phonetics. The phonetics of Chinese ideograms have varied over time and regions, but they are still able to give an indication of the list. However, because of being a long sequence of names for incalculable numbers, it may have suffered from the same defects through successive copying. In addition, Śikṣānanda transliterated the list as it occurs in chapter 36 of the *Avataṃsaka*. In our translation there is an attempt to supplement omissions that have occurred in the two lists and to find the correct Sanskrit spelling for the numbers, with the *Mahāvyutpatti* record of the numbers being particularly important, so as to create a uniformity between the lists. Some of the recorded forms of the numbers in chapter 15 have the nominative case in *-u*, which may well be a remnant of the original Buddhist Hybrid Sanskrit of the sūtra. It may never be possible to ascertain the original condition of the lists, but their purpose was not to create a reliable mathematical tool but to overwhelm the mind with an inconceivable vastness of numbers. Therefore, a disproportionate amount of time has been spent on these pages of numbers, even though a reader may very well skip over them.

**i.57** [c68921b6-c765-4eed-b942-f987cca55df5] The system of enumeration reaches numbers of such enormous value that they exceed even the extensive system of names for large numbers that have been developed in English in modern times, the highest being the googolplex (a 1 followed by a hundred zeros, and the source for the name and verb *Google*). Even such a number is dwarfed by the vastness of the universe of the *Gaṇḍavyūha*, where even within each atom there are as many buddhas as there are atoms in total. Therefore, an attempt to provide equivalent English names foundered, and the inconsistency in the Tibetan has resulted in choosing the Sanskrit names for this translation, though the various Tibetan, Chinese, and Sanskrit equivalents or variants are supplied in the endnotes.

### Challenges in the Translation

**i.58** [3661a5c6-34d1-43a0-8d80-f45339e8faca] Although the translation is based on the Degé edition, and the numbers of the xylograph Degé folios are included within the translation, it is the Comparative Edition of the Degé that has proved invaluable, as it contains detailed annotations of the discrepancies with other editions of the Kangyur, often revealing errors in the Degé. Some of these errors are evidently the result of the copyist mishearing a word being dictated by a reader. The sūtra existed only in handwritten copies for five centuries before the first woodblock printing (the Yongle edition made in China) in 1410. Not included in the Comparative Edition but consulted for this translation is the Stok Palace Kangyur, which belongs to another group of Kangyurs and has occasionally been alone in preserving the correct spelling, for example, *rnyi* (“snare”) translating the Sanskrit *jāla* (“net”) while all other available Kangyurs have *snying* (“essence” or “heart”).

**i.59** [f0778d3e-879e-43a0-a016-488026925aa8] The Sanskrit often provides a witness as to which Kangyur has the correct spelling. Sanskrit manuscripts are themselves just as subject to corruption, and surviving Sanskrit manuscripts date to a later period than the Tibetan translation. At times the Tibetan is evidently translating from a word similar to that in the presently available Sanskrit, and therefore it may have been translated from a manuscript in which particular words were not yet corrupted, or it could be translating from a manuscript that contained an error. The Chinese translations are the earliest witness to the condition of the sūtra in Sanskrit; at times the Chinese agrees with the Tibetan and at times with the available Sanskrit. The work of our Chinese consultant, Ling Lung Chen, has been illuminating in this respect. An example of where the Tibetan and the Chinese are correct and the present Sanskrit is not is where *mukha* (“gateway”) has been misspelled as *sukha* (“bliss”). There are also cases where the Classical Sanskrit meaning of a word has been incorrectly adopted for the Tibetan translation instead of the Buddhist Hybrid Sanskrit meaning. Another problem is inadvertent omission of words, particularly in lists, which may have occurred in the Sanskrit manuscript being used or early in the process of manuscript copying in Tibet. These missing words are included in the translation, even though the meaning would not be affected by their omission.

**i.60** [1cd68ecb-ed05-4632-a24e-b96f334de300] The Sanskrit has also been helpful when the meaning in Tibetan translation is vague and open to interpretation or seems dubious in its accuracy. Another challenge particular to this sūtra is the repetition of long descriptive compounds that are not stock phrases and are meant to be overwhelming, describing qualities beyond the grasp of the ordinary mind. The meaning of words in this context and their interrelationship is open to a wider interpretation than usual; for example, if *sarva* (“all”) begins a compound, it has been open to interpretation as to which part of the compound it refers to. Generally, however, in this translation the Tibetan interpretation is followed unless there appears to be an egregious (and noted) error or an inadvertent omission. Instances of discrepancies among the Tibetan, the Sanskrit, and the Chinese are included in the notes.

**i.61** [1218ac0a-8413-4333-aa36-98da2534efbc] Tibetan does not have the precise cases that Sanskrit has; therefore, the Sanskrit has been invaluable in indicating singular or plural as well as where in long passages the compounds change case, such as from nominative to instrumental in the long passage describing Sudhana at the beginning of chapter 56.

**i.62** [8e03147f-0f71-400a-9f46-746470138ac1] Also, when Sanskrit compounds are translated into Tibetan, it is not always clear where one compound ends and the other begins. This is sometimes indicated by the *shad*, the vertical line in Tibetan orthography, but as the Tibetan editor’s colophon indicates, the placement of the *shad* is at times arbitrary and confusing, the likely result of the process of copying, as some of the errors are evidently transcription errors from listening to the text being read. The Vaidya Sanskrit edition in Roman letters has added punctuation that does not always agree with the Tibetan interpretation of the structure of the sentence. The Suzuki edition of the Sanskrit has also been useful for finding transcription errors in the Vaidya. Tibetan also tends to translate the prefixes of Sanskrit words, while a direct translation from Sanskrit into English would choose a word from the more extensive English vocabulary. This translation tends to follow the latter approach rather than the translation of prefixes. Words can be multivalent in Sanskrit, their meaning altered according to context, and can even be interpreted as having more than one meaning simultaneously. There are Sanskrit poems written with a carefully chosen vocabulary to create verses that can be read as having two different meanings. There are some terms in this sūtra where a choice of translation necessarily means rejecting another possible meaning; for example, *vajra* can refer to a thunderbolt or a diamond, and these two can be seen in that culture as identical. In particular, however, there are two prominent terms in this sūtra that present such a problem: *dharmadhātu* and *samantabhadrabodhisattvacaryā*.

**i.63** [0e13d0fc-5634-4292-aecb-72a259f15bc5] The word *dharmadhātu* is a compound made of two elements: *dharma* and *dhātu*. *Dharma* has a great number of meanings, from “the Buddha’s teachings” to “law,” “justice,” “qualities,” “nature,” “phenomena,” and so on, while *dhātu* can indicate a realm, an element, or a constituent and can be used to mean sensory elements, the relics from an enlightened being’s cremation, and so on. In the term *lokadhātu*, used over and over in this sūtra, *dhātu* can mean “realm,” as in “world realm” or “a realm of worlds.” The term *dharmadhātu* has been used to mean “essence or true nature of phenomena,” such as emptiness, and so the Chinese title, which could be translated as *Entering the Dharmadhātu*, has been translated by Carré as *l’Entrée dans la dimension absolue* (*Entry into the Absolute Dimension*) and by Cleary as *Entry into the Realm of Reality*. Osto has used the more literal “realm of the Dharma,” which has in certain contexts been used in this translation. However, often the meaning appears to be “the realm of phenomena” when something is said to spread everywhere, and occasionally it could mean either, or simultaneously both.
               
**i.64** [84473191-dee3-4500-be7e-52a4e87da1a3] The ambiguity of *samantabhadrabodhisattvacaryā* is reflected in differing translations. It is a compound used repeatedly in the sūtra, and the question is whether *samantabhadra* (“completely good”) is an adjective for *bodhisattvacaryā* (“bodhisattva conduct”) or whether it means the conduct of the bodhisattva Samantabhadra. The sequence of the words in the compound (this is not evident in Tibetan) would appear to signify the former meaning, but its use in the Samantabhadra chapter appears to indicate the latter. At times it could mean both simultaneously.

**i.65** [5e87b9ae-19ac-4a3d-bea1-31171887d62f] Neither the Tibetan nor the Chinese—nor therefore the Sanskrit from which they were translated—had a division of the *Gaṇḍavyūha* into chapters. The later Sanskrit has a division into fifty-six chapters, and because this will make the reading of the sūtra much easier and more accessible for the reader in English, that chapter division has been adopted for this translation.

### Detailed Summary of *The Stem Array Sūtr*a

### Chapter 1: Introduction

**i.66** [fe67ab64-92df-4f2a-854a-0e355a8c7667] The Buddha Śākyamuni is in Jetavana in Śrāvastī with five thousand bodhisattvas and five hundred śrāvakas. In their minds they wish for a teaching, and therefore the Buddha enters samādhi, and countless buddha realms appear there within a vast kūṭāgāra. Bodhisattvas also come from other realms to Śrāvastī. The śrāvakas, lacking in the necessary merit, are unable to see this miraculous display. Then ten bodhisattvas who have come from the ten directions—Vairocanapraṇidhānanābhiraśmiprabha, Duryodhanavīryavegarāja, Samantaśrīsamudgatatejorāja, Asaṅgaśrīgarbharāja, Dharmadhātupraṇidhisunirmitacandrarāja, Dharmārciṣmattejorāja, Sarvamāramaṇḍalavikiraṇajñānadhvajarāja, Vairocanapraṇidhānaketudhvaja, Sarvāvaraṇavikiraṇajñānavikrāntarāja, and Dharmadhātupraṇidhitalanirbheda—recite verses describing what has occurred.

### Chapter 2: Samantabhadra

**i.67** [972c1302-a89d-4828-bbf5-8688406ac423] The bodhisattva Samantabhadra recites verses to the bodhisattvas describing the inconceivable pervasion of phenomena by the buddhas. In addition, the Buddha, still in samādhi, emanates a ray of light from between his eyebrows so that the bodhisattvas can see these countless buddha realms, and in a state of great joy the bodhisattvas emanate countless manifestations. On seeing this, Mañjuśrī recites verses describing this event.

### Chapter 3: Mañjuśrī

**i.68** [b4d33b8a-d06c-4384-a351-d829850b2514] Through the Buddha’s blessing, Śāriputra is enabled to see Mañjuśrī, who is departing for South India. Accompanied by his sixty pupils, he follows Mañjuśrī. He praises Mañjuśrī to his pupil Sāgarabuddhi. They all go to Mañjuśrī and pay homage to him, and Mañjuśrī teaches them ten motivations. Then Mañjuśrī goes to Vicitrasāladhvajavyūha Forest near the city of Dhanyākara. The laypeople of the city, hearing that Mañjuśrī is in the forest, go to see him. Among them is Sudhana, the son of a prominent upāsaka. Mañjuśrī describes the miracles that occurred at Sudhana’s birth, praises Sudhana, and teaches him and the others about the nature of buddhas. Mañjuśrī departs; Sudhana follows him and in verse praises him and requests teaching. Mañjuśrī instructs him to develop bodhisattva conduct by relying on kalyāṇamitras. He tells him to go to the bhikṣu Meghaśrī, who is on Sugrīva Mountain in the southern land of Rāmāvarānta.

### Chapter 4: Meghaśrī

**i.69** [999b947b-ecdd-427c-9cd9-d7d436ed29a3] Sudhana arrives in Rāmāvarānta and finds the bhikṣu Meghaśrī walking on a plateau on the summit of a mountain. Meghaśrī describes how he can see all tathāgatas in every direction. However, he states that his knowledge is limited, and he cannot describe the various accomplishments that enable other bodhisattvas to see all the tathāgatas, and he instructs Sudhana to go to the bhikṣu Sāgaramegha in Sāgaramukha so as to receive instruction on the way of the bodhisattva.

### Chapter 5: Sāgaramegha

**i.70** [e901eaa8-16b0-4c50-8ce2-bc1bd9e34b54] Sudhana meets Sāgaramegha, who describes how by focusing on the ocean and its qualities over twelve years he saw a buddha seated on a giant precious lotus arise from the ocean, with countless deities of various kinds paying homage to that buddha, who gave him a teaching called *All-Seeing Eyes*, which was so vast that even one chapter of it was too long to ever be written out. Sāgaramegha then gave this teaching to the nonhuman beings who came from all directions. However, he states that his knowledge is limited to this teaching and instructs Sudhana to go receive instruction on the way of the bodhisattva from the bhikṣu Supratiṣṭhita in Sāgaratīra.

### Chapter 6: Supratiṣṭhita

**i.71** [12247f37-ac01-498b-9eea-edcbd2991c91] Sudhana searches for Supratiṣṭhita and eventually sees him walking in the sky accompanied by a vast gathering of various kinds of deities, who pay homage to him. Supratiṣṭhita states that he has attained a wisdom called *the unimpeded apex*, so that he knows past lives, all past buddhas, all languages, when to guide beings, and so on, and can perform all kinds of miracles. However, he states that his knowledge is limited to this liberation and instructs Sudhana to go receive instruction on the way of the bodhisattva from a Dravidian named Megha in the town of Vajrapura in the land of Draviḍa.

### Chapter 7: Megha

**i.72** [9de5a410-c0e9-437e-9f9e-52bf0c9e1b19] Sudhana finds Megha teaching on a throne in a courtyard in the town of Vajrapura. Megha comes down from his throne and makes many offerings to Sudhana. He praises the bodhisattvas through various analogies, and light rays shine from his mouth, spreading throughout the universe. Many deities of various kinds come to listen. Then Megha sits back on his throne and states that he has attained Sarasvatī’s power of retention, so that he knows the languages of all the different kinds of deities and other beings throughout all worlds. However, he states that his knowledge is limited to this Sarasvatī power of retention, and he instructs Sudhana to go receive instruction on the way of the bodhisattva from a head merchant named Muktaka in the land of Vanavāsī.

### Chapter 8: Muktaka

**i.73** [44199ea2-161a-473f-a33e-dc2ec63d5b3e] After twelve years Sudhana reaches Vanavāsī and finds Muktaka. Muktaka enters a state of meditation through the power of retention called *the assembly of all the buddha realms*, and countless buddhas, their deeds, their realms, and their pupils become visible within his body. He comes out of his meditation and states that through the liberation called *the unimpeded display*, he can see any buddha in any realm or time that he wishes to, and he is aware that his mind’s perceptions are the mind’s own illusions and that all attainment is the attainment of the mind. However, he states that his knowledge is limited to this liberation called *the unimpeded display*, and he instructs Sudhana to go receive instruction on the way of the bodhisattva from a bhikṣu named Sāgaradhvaja in the land of Milaspharaṇa at the southern tip of India.

### Chapter 9: Sāgaradhvaja

**i.74** [11da0b18-1727-4108-8aee-37b38dee92dd] Sudhana arrives at Milaspharaṇa and finds the bhikṣu Sāgaradhvaja sitting in meditation at the end of a meditation walkway. He is emanating various kinds of beings, bodhisattvas, and buddhas from different parts of his body, and these emanations are spreading throughout all the buddha realms, accomplishing various kinds of activities. Sudhana sits before him for six months and six days, until Sāgaradhvaja rises from his samādhi. He describes to Sudhana the nature of the samādhi he has attained, but he states that his knowledge is limited to that and instructs him to go to request teaching from the upāsikā Āśā in a park outside the town of Mahāprabhasa.

### Chapter 10: Āśā

**i.75** [054f04be-b7da-4f02-8e32-b43879f1c272] Sudhana arrives at Samantavyūha Park, which is miraculously beautiful and made of precious substances. The upāsikā Āśā is seated on a throne inside a magnificent palace, with vast numbers of beings of various kinds paying homage to her. She tells Sudhana she has attained the bodhisattva liberation called *the banner of bliss without sorrow* and recounts her past as a pupil of innumerable buddhas. She emphasizes how bodhisattvas are dedicated to the welfare of all beings. However, as her knowledge is limited to her bodhisattva liberation, she instructs him to go to the ṛṣi Bhīṣmottaranirghoṣa in the land named Nālayu.

### Chapter 11: Bhīṣmottaranirghoṣa

**i.76** [7e3496bd-6a9e-4d27-a80c-562f97daf2f5] Sudhana arrives in Nālayu and finds the ṛṣi Bhīṣmottaranirghoṣa, along with ten thousand young brahmin pupils, in an ashram in a miraculously beautiful forest. Bhīṣmottaranirghoṣa tells his pupils of Sudhana’s greatness, and they make offerings to him. Bhīṣmottaranirghoṣa tells Sudhana that he has attained the bodhisattva liberation called *the banner of being invincible to others*. He places his hand on Sudhana’s head, and Sudhana sees innumerable buddha realms and hears the teachings of those buddhas for innumerable kalpas. When Bhīṣmottaranirghoṣa removes his hand, Sudhana is back in the forest at that same time. Bhīṣmottaranirghoṣa says his knowledge is limited to this bodhisattva liberation and instructs him to go to the brahmin Jayoṣmāyatana in the land of Īṣāṇa.

### Chapter 12: Jayoṣmāyatana

**i.77** [eb6903c0-9881-4892-a92a-3433ea804ac4] Sudhana finds the brahmin Jayoṣmāyatana undertaking the ascetic practice of sitting beneath a cliff surrounded by four fires and under the noonday sun. He tells Sudhana that if he climbs to the top of the precipice above him and jumps into a fire, he will have pure conduct. On hearing this, Sudhana has doubts about Jayoṣmāyatana, but deities appear in the sky describing how Jayoṣmāyatana’s asceticism has benefited them on the path to buddhahood. Sudhana then obeys the brahmin’s instructions, and leaping into the fire, he is unharmed and attains samādhi. Jayoṣmāyatana then tells Sudhana that his own knowledge is limited to this bodhisattva liberation called *the unceasing domain* and therefore he should go to Princess Maitrayaṇī in the city of Siṃhavijṛmbhita.

### Chapter 13: Maitrayaṇī

**i.78** [36d4e5aa-e4ef-4b5a-87ed-540d16112c5a] Sudhana finds Princess Maitrayaṇī with an entourage of five hundred maidens in a miraculous palace. She instructs Sudhana to look around the palace, and he sees innumerable buddhas in every object. She tells Sudhana that she has attained the gateway to the perfection of wisdom called *the complete display of memory*, but as her knowledge is limited to that, he should go to the bhikṣu Sudarśana in the land called Trinayana.

### Chapter 14: Sudarśana

**i.79** [036fbe20-3c80-44ce-880b-46f82d5be4dc] After a long search, Sudhana finds the bhikṣu Sudarśana attended by devas while practicing walking meditation in a forest. He tells Sudhana that within his lifetime, he has been the pupil of innumerable buddhas for vast lengths of time and perceives countless buddhas as he practices his walking meditation. However, his knowledge is limited to this bodhisattva liberation called *the never-extinguished lamp of wisdom*. Therefore, he instructs Sudhana to go to a boy named Indriyeśvara in the city of Sumukha.

### Chapter 15: Indriyeśvara

**i.80** [c79573ff-71d3-4b2b-8548-011a10859311] Sudhana finds Indriyeśvara playing in the sand with ten thousand other children. Indriyeśvara tells Sudhana that he has been the pupil of Mañjuśrī and has mastered all kinds of branches of knowledge. In particular he relates at length the system of enumeration that bodhisattvas use. However, his knowledge is limited to this gateway called *the wisdom that possesses clairvoyance in all crafts*. Therefore, he instructs Sudhana to go to the upāsikā Prabhūtā in the town of Samudrapratiṣṭhāna.

### Chapter 16: Prabhūtā

**i.81** [7bb902f8-24b6-4ea7-83c2-4705c7fa0a52] Sudhana finds the young girl Prabhūtā in a marvelous house, wearing a simple white robe and no jewelry, with just a small pot before her and no other provisions in her house. Ten thousand beautiful maidens are present as her attendants. She tells Sudhana that she has attained the bodhisattva liberation called *the unceasing display of the treasure of merit*. Through this she is able to provide countless beings in all directions with whatever they wish out of her small pot. With the food from her pot, she aids śrāvakas, pratyekabuddhas, and bodhisattvas in countless realms in attaining their enlightenments. Sudhana witnesses countless beings arriving at her home and receiving whatever they wish from the pot. Prabhūtā then says that as her knowledge is limited to this bodhisattva liberation, he should go to the householder Vidvān in the town of Mahāsaṃbhava.

### Chapter 17: Vidvān

**i.82** [967f40bb-c901-430f-890a-b0fef9ce1454] Sudhana finds Vidvān upon a throne on a platform at the crossroads in the center of the town. Vidvān tells Sudhana that he has attained the bodhisattva liberation called *the merit that arises from the treasury of the mind*. Therefore, he is able to provide beings with whatever they wish, and he has brought his entourage of ten thousand musicians onto the path to enlightenment. Sudhana sees countless beings arrive. When Vidvān looks up into the sky, all that the beings wish for comes down into Vidvān’s hands, and he gives it to them. However, Vidvān says his knowledge is limited to this bodhisattva liberation and instructs Sudhana to go to see the head merchant and Dharma patron named Ratnacūḍa in the town of Siṃhapota.

### Chapter 18: Ratnacūḍa

**i.83** [e2b9c587-96d2-49d3-ba90-284ebe82c0ef] Sudhana finds Ratnacūḍa in the town’s market. Ratnacūḍa takes him to his ten-story home made of gold. On the first four floors he witnesses bodhisattva activity of generosity, and on the fifth floor and upward he sees bodhisattvas discussing the Dharma. On the tenth floor all the bodhisattvas are in their last life. Ratnacūḍa tells Sudhana how in the past he made an offering of incense to a buddha and the aroma covered the entire world for a week. This resulted in his attaining the bodhisattva liberation called *the unimpeded display of the field of prayer*, through which he can see all buddhas and bodhisattvas. However, as his knowledge is limited to this bodhisattva liberation, he instructs Sudhana to go to a perfume seller by the name of Samantanetra in the town of Samantamukha.

### Chapter 19: Samantanetra

**i.84** [36617498-8fca-433e-8f78-a34b4dd435ab] Sudhana finds Samantanetra in a perfume shop in the middle of the town. Samantanetra describes how he can cure all illnesses, heal beings, and set them on the path to enlightenment. He is also able to make an offering of perfume to all buddha realms. However, his knowledge is limited to this gateway called *the forms of perfume that satisfy all beings and through which in every way one sees, makes offerings to, and honors the buddhas*. Therefore, he instructs him to go to King Anala in the town of Tāladhvaja.

### Chapter 20: Anala

**i.85** [99f656d1-3c41-4f38-a584-e4e2ae7f9a01] Sudhana finds King Anala sitting on the throne in judgment on hundreds of thousands of criminals as a horde of terrifying executioners punish them in various ways, creating a lake of blood and a mountain of body parts. Sudhana has doubts as to whether King Anala is a bodhisattva, but deities appear in the sky and tell him not to doubt. King Anala takes Sudhana into his palace and explains that what he has seen is an illusion the king creates to inspire beings to avoid bad actions. He states that his knowledge is limited to this bodhisattva liberation called *the attainment of illusions* and therefore instructs Sudhana to go to King Mahāprabha in the city called Suprabha.

### Chapter 21: Mahāprabha

**i.86** [886f2dee-c10f-44d9-b465-e835d4dd87aa] After a long search, Sudhana finds the city of Suprabha, which appears to be miraculously made of precious materials. He finds King Mahāprabha seated on a throne in the city along with vast amounts of goods, animals, and women arranged as gifts. King Mahāprabha tells Sudhana that he has attained the bodhisattva conduct called *the banner of great love* from countless buddhas. He provides everyone in his kingdom with whatever they wish. He states that some beings see the city as ordinary, while others see it as made of precious materials, and this is according to their realization. The king demonstrates entering a samādhi that causes the entire country to shake. Beings, deities, and even mountains and plants bow in his direction. In the same way he brings happiness and serenity to beings in countless realms. King Mahāprabha states that his knowledge is limited to *the banner of great love* and instructs him to go see the upāsikā Acalā in the city called Sthirā.

### Chapter 22: Acalā

**i.87** [2b6a5d7b-c43e-4d9c-a773-756954f250f0] Sudhana reaches the city of Sthirā and finds the upāsikā Acalā at home with her parents in a house shining with a golden light that causes Sudhana to enter states of samādhi. She is extremely beautiful, shining with light, and has an exceptional aroma. Acalā describes her past life as a princess during the time of the Buddha Pralambabāhu. One night she saw him shining in the sky, and since that time she has followed his instructions for many kalpas. She demonstrates her miraculous power of revealing to him a vision of countless buddha realms made of beryl. She states that her attainment is limited to a certain conduct, samādhi, and the liberation called *the essence of the wisdom that is difficult to attain*, and she instructs Sudhana to go see the parivrājaka Sarvagamin.

### Chapter 23: Sarvagamin

**i.88** [b09cfc70-afae-4d93-8379-8eabfe2119da] After a long journey, Sudhana reaches the town of Tosala in the land called Amitatosala. Having searched through the town, he goes to a shining hill called Sulabha to the north of the town. At its summit he finds Sarvagamin being honored by ten thousand brahmins. Sarvagamin describes how through the samādhi called *the light of the practice of all gateways* he can benefit beings in many ways throughout many worlds. He instructs Sudhana to go to the perfume merchant Utpalabhūti.

### Chapter 24: Utpalabhūti

**i.89** [ca9502f0-864b-44d7-86d1-bc6465f73a16] Sudhana arrives in the land called Pṛthurāṣṭra and finds the perfume merchant Utpalabhūti, who tells Sudhana of his mastery of perfumes that have magical and spiritual effects. He tells Sudhana to go to a mariner by the name of Vaira.

### Chapter 25: Vaira

**i.90** [49c1166f-4fad-4a20-b6c5-4e5f361064bb] Sudhana goes to the city of Kūṭāgāra and finds the mariner Vaira at the city’s gate on the shore of the ocean, where he is telling tales of the sea to a hundred thousand merchants and many hundreds of thousands of other people and describing the qualities of the Buddha. He tells Sudhana that he practices the bodhisattva conduct called *the banner of great compassion*, aids beings in various ways, knows the locations of islands and treasures and the ways of sailing on the ocean, and sets beings toward enlightenment through his teaching. However, his attainment is limited to the bodhisattva liberation called *remembering to abide with the fruitful hearing and seeing of the banner of great compassion*, and therefore he instructs Sudhana to go to see the head merchant Jayottama.

### Chapter 26: Jayottama

**i.91** [e46ac6f9-6e06-4d47-8ecc-0e3dff47c75e] Sudhana reaches the town called Nandihāra and finds Jayottama in a forest on the eastern side of the town, speaking about civic duties to many thousands of householders. He tells Sudhana how in many worlds he teaches the Dharma, pacifies disputes and wars, guides people away from bad behavior, and sets them on the path to enlightenment. He tells Sudhana to go see a bhikṣuṇī by the name of Siṃhavijṛmbhitā.

### Chapter 27: Siṃhavijṛmbhitā

**i.92** [e3a97b5c-9a63-4dca-9bd0-051d2c637d72] Sudhana arrives in the town of Kaliṅgavana in the land of Śroṇāparānta and finds Siṃhavijṛmbhitā in a park named Sūryaprabha that, because of her miraculous power, is covered with jewels and other miraculous manifestations. There are thrones at the foot of jewel trees, on all of which sit Siṃhavijṛmbhitā teaching the Dharma to various kinds of beings and bodhisattvas. She tells Sudhana that she has attained the bodhisattva liberation called *the eradication of all conceit*, which enables her to go in various forms to various worlds to make offerings to buddhas and bodhisattvas. Stating that her realization is limited, she instructs him to go see a courtesan named Vasumitrā.

### Chapter 28: Vasumitrā

**i.93** [83ebdff4-0d7c-4c50-8004-38a12d952ea6] Sudhana arrives in the city of Ratnavyūha in the land of Durga and searches for the courtesan Vasumitrā. The people who do not know her qualities wonder why a practitioner like Sudhana would want to see her. Those who do know her qualities tell him where her home is. It is vast, comprising many buildings made of precious materials and divine in appearance. She is beautiful and skilled in languages and all arts and treatises. Her body illuminates her residence. She tells Sudhana that she takes on a beautiful form among various kinds of beings who are under the power of desire and teaches them the Dharma to free them from desire, and that they also become free from desire on seeing her, touching her, kissing her, and so on. She describes that in a past life she was a head merchant’s wife who offered a bell to the Buddha Atyuccagāmin, who had entered their city accompanied by miraculous events. Mañjuśrī was an attendant of that buddha and set her on the path to enlightenment. She states that her attainment is limited to the bodhisattva liberation called *the complete attainment of freedom from desire* and instructs him to go see the householder Veṣṭhila.

### Chapter 29: Veṣṭhila

**i.94** [ec03458f-471b-46ae-96bb-8823a1fb5e58] Sudhana goes to the town of Śubhapāraṃgama, where he meets the householder Veṣṭhila, who attained the samādhi called *the display of the unceasing family of the buddhas* when he opened the door of a shrine. Through this samādhi he sees countless buddhas of the past, present, and future. He instructs Sudhana to meet the bodhisattva Avalokiteśvara.

### Chapter 30: Avalokiteśvara

**i.95** [48f07e69-074b-4ff1-8af0-ea1807364ac3] Sudhana goes to the Potalaka Mountain and on its western side finds Avalokiteśvara teaching within a forest grove. Avalokiteśvara places his radiant hand on Sudhana’s head and tells him that he has the bodhisattva activity called *the unimpeded gateway to great compassion*. He describes how he benefits beings through various manifestations and emanations, freeing them from various kinds of fear. However, being limited to that activity, he instructs Sudhana to go to the Cakravāla mountain range to see the bodhisattva Ananyagāmin, who has just come from another world realm in the east.

### Chapter 31: Ananyagāmin

**i.96** [b9327b39-f92d-4a74-9093-a493d9e27b7a] Sudhana goes to see the bodhisattva Ananyagāmin, who says that in the eastern realm of Śrīgarbhavatī he has attained the bodhisattva liberation called *the arising of every gateway* at the feet of the Buddha Samantaśrīsaṃbhava, and that it has taken him countless kalpas to reach this world, even though he passed countless realms with each step. He also made offerings to all the buddhas in those realms and manifested bodies to benefit the beings there, and he did this while approaching this world from all other directions simultaneously. He tells Sudhana that his attainment is limited to the bodhisattva liberation called *the arising of every gateway* and instructs him to go see the deity Mahādeva.

### Chapter 32: Mahādeva

**i.97** [43b912bc-5253-4417-8e4f-b7b05d09f116] Sudhana reaches the city named Dvāravatī and finds the deity Mahādeva in a temple in the center of the city. When Sudhana asks him for instruction, he extends his four arms to the four great oceans and brings back water to rinse out his mouth. He praises bodhisattvas, who are so difficult to meet, and states that he has attained the bodhisattva liberation called *the net of clouds*. Through that liberation he manifests heaps of jewels and precious objects in front of Sudhana for him to use as offerings to the buddhas in order to gain merit. In that way he establishes countless beings in the practice of generosity. He manifests ugliness to those with desire, terrifying manifestations to the proud, and dangers to the lazy, so that they will follow the Dharma. As he is limited to this bodhisattva liberation, he instructs Sudhana to go from South India to Magadha in North India, to the site of the Buddha’s enlightenment, and see the earth goddess Sthāvarā there.

### Chapter 33: Sthāvarā

**i.98** [2d62e98d-1fb6-4fdd-8fae-f64d3ab7916f] Sudhana leaves South India and reaches the bodhimaṇḍa in Magadha. As he approaches the earth goddess Sthāvarā, another million earth goddesses declare that a great realized being is approaching. They manifest an array of miraculous appearances. Sthāvarā states that Sudhana has accumulated merit in this place in past lives and demonstrates its result by stamping on the ground so that there appear millions of treasures that Sudhana will always be able to use. She states that she has attained the bodhisattva liberation called *the essence of invincible wisdom*, as a result of which she has practiced the Dharma and protected bodhisattvas since the time of the Buddha Dīpaṅkara. She received this liberation from the Buddha Sunetra many kalpas previously and since then has always been in the presence of buddhas. As she is limited to this bodhisattva liberation, she instructs Sudhana to go to Kapilavastu, the hometown of the Buddha Śākyamuni, to see the night goddess Vāsantī.

### Chapter 34: Vāsantī

**i.99** [b30249a0-b8ff-42da-afda-b598ed0373bc] Sudhana reaches Kapilavastu, and after sunset he sees the night goddess Vāsantī in the sky above the town. She has a golden body, and he sees in her pores the realms of beings she has liberated and her various emanations, and he also hears from her pores the Dharma teachings she has given. She tells Sudhana that she has attained the bodhisattva liberation called *the gateway to guiding beings through the radiance of the Dharma that eliminates the darkness of all beings*. She describes how she helps various beings who are distressed in various ways in darkness, and how she liberates beings from the darkness of saṃsāra and protects and saves beings from physical and spiritual dangers. Then she describes these activities in verse. She then explains that many kalpas previously, she had been a queen who was awoken one night by a night goddess named Suviśuddhacandrābhā, who told her that the Buddha Sarvadharmanigarjitarāja had just attained buddhahood in a nearby forest and had manifested a miraculous light. She went to that buddha, entered the Dharma, and in every lifetime that followed had a fortunate rebirth and accumulated merit. After countless kalpas, she became the beautiful daughter of a head merchant, and the night goddess Suviśuddhacandrābhā had become a night goddess named Viśuddhanetrābhā. One night the night goddess revealed herself to the merchant’s daughter and told her of the Buddha Sumerudhvajāyatanaśāntanetraśrī, who had attained buddhahood seven days previously and was the first of five hundred buddhas who would appear in that kalpa. The merchant’s daughter went to that buddha and on seeing his face remembered her previous lives. It was from that buddha that she received the bodhisattva liberation called *the gateway to guiding beings through the radiance of the Dharma that eliminates the darkness of all beings*. As a result, she could be in countless realms before many buddhas simultaneously, knew the languages of beings in countless realms, and manifested to them in various ways. However, she says that she is limited to this attainment and instructs Sudhana to go back to the bodhimaṇḍa to see the night goddess Samantagambhīraśrīvimalaprabhā.

### Chapter 35: Samantagambhīraśrīvimalaprabhā

**i.100** [3d692979-673f-4807-911e-a1053731b8fd] Sudhana returns to the bodhimaṇḍa and sees the night goddess Samantagambhīraśrīvimalaprabhā. She instructs him in ten qualities that bodhisattvas need to attain. She states that she has attained the bodhisattva liberation called *complete subjugation through the bliss of the peace of śamatha*, through which she can see all the buddhas in the three times, receive all their teachings, and ripen beings in various ways. Stating that she is limited to this liberation, she instructs Sudhana to go see the night goddess Pramuditanayanajagadvirocanā, who is nearby.

### Chapter 36: Pramuditanayanajagadvirocanā

**i.101** [be4c4701-dec5-44fe-957b-a4c7909573b6] Sudhana goes to the southern side of the bodhimaṇḍa, where he sees the night goddess Pramuditanayanajagadvirocanā. Sudhana sees emanated bodies, as numerous as all beings, coming from all her pores, teaching the path of the bodhisattva to beings in different languages and forms. Sudhana praises her in verse and then asks her when she attained her bodhisattva liberation called *the banner of the power of vast, stainless, completely good joy*. Pramuditanayanajagadvirocanā replies in verse, describing how in a previous world in the distant past she was the queen of a cakravartin. She was awoken by night goddesses on the night that a buddha named Śrisamudra attained buddhahood and shone with a miraculous light. She woke the king, the court, and the other queens, and with a great mass of people they went to the Buddha. That was when she first developed the aspiration to attain buddhahood, and she particularly prayed to become like those night goddesses. She lists the numerous buddhas whom she offered to and received teachings from throughout a number of worlds and kalpas. Finally she received and attained her bodhisattva liberation from the Buddha Ratnaśrīpradīpaguṇaketu and then, out of compassion for beings, took on her present form as a night goddess. However, she states that she is limited to that attainment and instructs Sudhana to go to the night goddess Samantasattvatrāṇojaḥśrī, who is nearby among the assembly at the bodhimaṇḍa.

### Chapter 37: Samantasattvatrāṇojaḥśrī

**i.102** [045070a7-ac07-4e40-9bd7-ce2d0cddd772] As Sudhana walks the short distance to see the night goddess Samantasattvatrāṇojaḥśrī, she radiates onto him a light ray that causes him to enter a samādhi and see worlds in the atoms of the ground, and to see her appearing in them all to guide and help beings through the power of her bodhisattva liberation called *the manifestations that guide beings that appear in all worlds*. Sudhana recites verses to her, describing this vision, and asks her when she attained that liberation. She describes how countless kalpas in the past, in a world called Vairocanatejaḥśrī, she was a princess named Padmabhadrābhirāmanetraśrīcandrā, the daughter of a cakravartin who ruled all four continents. North of the capital there was a Bodhi tree, before which was a lake with a magical lotus in its center, upon which was the Buddha Samantajñānaratnārciśrīguṇaketurāja, the first of countless buddhas to appear in that kalpa. Over a period of ten thousand years, he radiated light rays to the beings in that world, informing them and preparing them for his eventual appearance as a buddha. At the moment of his attainment of buddhahood in that world, there were miraculous omens everywhere. The bodhisattva Samantabhadra appeared above the cakravartin’s palace, his radiance outshining all other lights. He informed the king that a buddha had appeared at the Bodhi tree. On seeing Samantabhadra, the princess wished to be with him always, in all her lives. The king manifested miraculously throughout the world, encouraging everyone to come and see the Buddha. On seeing the Buddha, the princess cast her jewels toward him, and they formed a miraculous display in the air. She had a vision of Samantabhadra’s presence throughout countless worlds and attained various samādhis. The buddha told her that in a past life Samantabhadra had instructed her to repair the statue of the buddha of that time and that this had been the cause of her good rebirths and connection with buddhas and Samantabhadra in all her lives. The night goddess Samantasattvatrāṇojaḥśrī then explains to Sudhana that she had been the princess, Maitreya was the king, and his queen, the mother of the princess, was the night goddess Praśantarutasāgaravatī. Samantasattvatrāṇojaḥśrī describes how she attended and made offerings to a succession of buddhas through the kalpas, and she describes the teachings she received from some of them. She lists a number of buddhas in verse, and finally says that her attainment is limited to the bodhisattva liberation called *the manifestations that guide beings that appear in all worlds* and that Sudhana should go to see the nearby night goddess Praśantarutasāgaravatī.

### Chapter 38: Praśantarutasāgaravatī

**i.103** [b320ad19-8829-432d-ad08-98dec268f030] Sudhana goes directly to the night goddess Praśantarutasāgaravatī, who tells him she has attained the bodhisattva liberation called *the display in each instant of mind of the arising of the power of vast delight*. She explains that she teaches the Dharma everywhere in various ways to beings and that she can see all bodhisattvas wherever they are and whatever are they doing. In particular she sees how the Buddha, whom she calls Vairocana, in every instant radiates light rays everywhere that take on various forms to guide beings, and seeing this gives her great delight. She describes the vast qualities of her liberation, and when Sudhana asks her about her past, she states that in a world realm called Kanakavimalaprabhāvyūha, beyond many worlds to the east, there was a buddha named Avivartyadharmadhātunirghoṣa, and she was a goddess at the bodhimaṇḍa of that world. On seeing him she first developed the aspiration to enlightenment, and subsequently in various lifetimes she attended every buddha that appeared in an innumerable succession in that world, thereby attaining various samādhis. Then she was reborn in this Sahā world, where she has attended the first four buddhas and will attend all those who will come. On seeing the present buddha, Vairocana, she attained her bodhisattva liberation. After that she could see as many realms and buddhas as there are atoms within each atom and was able to receive all their teachings in each instant of mind. However, as she is limited to this liberation, she instructs Sudhana to go to the nearby night goddess Sarvanagararakṣāsaṃbhavatejaḥśrī, who is there in Vairocana’s assembly.

### Chapter 39: Sarvanagararakṣāsaṃbhavatejaḥśrī

**i.104** [04880ce0-43ab-495e-a042-c15fe70d768f] Sudhana sees the night goddess Sarvanagararakṣāsaṃbhavatejaḥśrī seated on a lotus throne and having a body that can appear to and communicate with all beings. She tells him she has attained a bodhisattva liberation called *the entry into beautiful sounds and profound manifestations*. She describes how she guides beings, teaching the Dharma in various ways, and how she sees the realm of phenomena in ten ways and teaches through thousands of powers of mental retention, ten of which she lists. She describes how in the distant past there was a kalpa in one world where countless buddhas appeared, the first of which was Sarvadharmasāgaranirghoṣaprabharāja. At that time there was a cakravartin king who after the buddha’s passing used his miraculous powers to create a display to revive the declining teachings. His daughter, who was a bhikṣuṇī, on seeing that miracle attained the bodhisattva liberation called *the entry into beautiful sounds and profound manifestations*. The night goddess reveals that she was the bhikṣuṇī and the king was the bodhisattva Samantabhadra. She then lists the names of just over a hundred of the countless buddhas of that kalpa, all of whom she was a pupil of, and for countless kalpas since, she has been attending buddhas. She says she is limited to this bodhisattva liberation and instructs Sudhana to go to the night goddess Sarvavṛkṣpraphullanasukhasaṃvāsā, who is nearby at the feet of the Buddha Vairocana, the name she uses for Śākyamuni.

### Chapter 40: Sarvavṛkṣpraphullanasukhasaṃvāsā

## Notes for this part

**n.1** See colophon, c.3.

**n.2** Pekar Zangpo, *mdo sde spy’i rnam bzhag* (2006), 18.

**n.3** This depiction of Śākyamuni as a Vairocana emanation has its precedent in a sūtra that was never translated into Tibetan but exists in Chinese translation: the *Brahmajālasūtra*. This sūtra introduces the Buddha Vairocana as the primordial buddha who is the source of ten billion Śākyamunis who exist simultaneously in ten billion different worlds. This sūtra should not be confused with the *Brahmajālasūtra* that exists both in the Pali canon and in the Tibetan Kangyur (Toh 352).

**n.4** See Peter Alan Roberts, trans., The Ten Bhūmis, Toh 44-31.

**n.5** There is evidence for Mahāyāna sūtras originating in northern India. In his *Genealogies of Mahāyāna Buddhism*, Joseph Walser argues that the “core portion” of *The Perfection of Wisdom in Eight Thousand Lines* (Toh 12, *Aṣṭasāhasrikāprajñāpāramitā*) was most probably written in the second half of the first century in Mathura, which is located in present-day Uttar Pradesh. He also offers the tentative conclusion that it was written by “a Sarvāstivādin monk residing at Buddhadeva’s Guhavihāra outside of Maṭ.” See Walser (2018), 242.

**n.6** Osto notes that Etienne Lamotte, Edward Conze, and Nalinaksha Dutt all regard the Mahāsāṃghika as the source of the Mahāyāna tradition. See Osto (2008), 157, n. 5. Paul Williams argues that at least some Mahāyāna sūtras emerged from the Mahāsāṃghika: “There can be no doubt that at least some early Mahāyāna sūtras originated in Mahāsāṃghika circles. In the *lokottaravāda* supramundane teachings we are getting very close to a teaching well-known in Mahāyāna that the Buddha’s death was also a mere appearance; in reality he remains out of his compassion, helping suffering humanity, and thence the suggestion that for those who are capable of it the highest religious goal should be not to become an Arhat but to take the Bodhisattva vows, embarking themselves on the long path to a supreme and totally superior Buddhahood.” See Williams (2009), 21. This view has been contested by a number of scholars, however, including Paul Harrison, who maintains in his “Searching for the Origins of the Mahāyāna: What Are We Looking For?” that it is impossible to draw a clear connection between the Mahāyāna and a single sect, maintaining instead that the Mahāyāna was a loose set of related movements that cut across Buddhist India. For a fine summary of scholarship concerning the origins of the Mahāyāna, see Osto (2008), 105–16.

**n.7** Toh 127. See translation in Peter Alan Roberts, trans., The King of Samādhis Sūtra, 84000: Translating the Words of the Buddha, 2018.

**n.8** Osto (2008), 108–9.

**n.9** *Bodhisattvagocaraupāyaviṣayavikurvāṇanirdeśa*, Toh 146. See English translation in Jamspal 2010.

**n.10** See *Satyaka Sūtra*, folios 98.b–130.a.

**n.11** See *Satyaka Sūtra*, folios 132.b–133.a.

**n.12** *Saddharmapuṇḍarīkanāmamahāyānasūtra*, Toh 113. See translation in Peter Alan Roberts, trans., The White Lotus of the Good Dharma, 84000: Translating the Words of the Buddha, 2018.

**n.13** This is found in chapter 4 of the *Satyaka Sūtra*, titled “The Teaching as a Single Yāna” (*theg pa gcig tu bstan pa’i le’u*). See *Satyaka Sūtra*, folios 94.b–98.b.

**n.14** Osto (2008), 5.

**n.15** The Prayer of Good Conduct (*Āryabhadracaryāpraṇidhānarāja*, Toh 1095).

**n.16** Osto (2008), 6, 113.

**n.17** Termed the *Navadharma* (“Nine Dharmas”) or *Navagrantha* (“Nine Texts”), these works are (1) *Prajñāpāramitā*, (2) *Gaṇḍavyūha*, (3) Daśabhūmi, (4) Samādhirāja, (5) *Laṅkāvatāra*, (6) Saddharmapuṇḍarīka, (7) Lalitavistara, (8) Suvarṇaprabhāsa, and (9) *Tathāgatagūhya*. See Lewis (1993), 327, n. 15.

**n.18** Osto (2008), 4.

**n.19** Osto (2008), 129.

**n.20** Osto (2008), 4.

**n.21** Ōtake (2007), 93–94.

**n.22** The Stok Palace (vol. 34, folio 310.a), Lhasa (vol. 46, folio 341.b), Choné (vol. 94, folio 284.a), and Narthang (vol. 40, folio 340.a) editions read *shin tu rgyas pa chen po’i mdo sangs rgyas phal po che zhes bya ba/ byang chub sems dpa’i sde snod kyi nang nas sdong pos brgyan pa zhes bya ba chos kyi rnam grangs chen po las*. This could be translated, “the great Dharma discourse called the *Gaṇḍavyūha* from within the *Bodhisattvapiṭaka* called the vast *Buddhāvataṃsaka Sūtra*,” which suggests that the *Buddhāvataṃsaka* is a type of text known as a *Bodhisattvapiṭaka*. Urga (vol. 38, folio 362.a) has *sangs rgyas phal po che zhes bya ba/ shin tu rgyas pa chen po’i mdo las/ byang chub sems dpa’i sde snod cing / sdong pos rgyan pa zhes bya ba*, which could be translated as “the *Bodhisattvapiṭaka* and *Gaṇḍavyūha* from the Mahāvaipulya sūtra called the *Buddhāvatamska*,” although *cing* grammatically should follow a verb, not a noun, and it could well be an error for *kyi nang* when that is pronounced “chi nang.” This, like the aforementioned colophon from Dunhuang, suggests that both *Bodhisattvapiṭaka* and *Gaṇḍavyūha* are titles for one and the same work. By contrast, the Degé (vol. 38, folio 362.a) and Kangxi (vol. 60, folio 263.a) read *shin tu rgyas pa chen po’i mdo/ sangs rgyas phal po che zhes bya ba las/ byang chub sems dpa’i sde snod kyi nang / sdong pos brgyan pa zhes bya ba chos kyi rnam grangs chen po las*. This could be rendered, “From the Mahāvaipulya sūtra called the *Buddhāvataṃsaka*, from within the *Bodhisattvapiṭaka*, the great Dharma discourse called the *Gaṇḍavyūha*,” meaning that the *Gaṇḍavyūha* is from the *Bodhisattvapiṭaka*, a collection of bodhisattva teachings, and has been included in the *Buddhāvataṃsaka*. In other words, the *Gaṇḍavyūha* is contained in the *Bodhisattvapiṭaka* that is contained in the *Buddhāvataṃsaka*—a statement that would not seem to make much sense.

**n.23** Osto (2008), 4.

**n.24** Osto (2008), 130.

**n.25** Osto (2008), 11.

**n.26** Osto (2008), 5.

**n.27** Osto (2008).

**n.28** Van Norden (2019).

**n.29** Fontein (1967), 117. Fontein (2012), 1. See also Revianur (2018), 577.

**n.30** Fontein (1967), 118.

**n.31** Fontein (1967), 120–21.

**n.32** *si tu chos kyi ’byung gnas*, folio 205.a.

**n.33** See c.5 and particularly n.2244.

**n.34** D. E. Osto, “The Supreme Array Scripture,” accessed July 6, 2021.

**n.35** Toh 352 in the Kangyur.

**n.36** *rnam par snang mdzad chen po mngon par rdzogs par byang chub pa rnam par sprul pa byin gyis rlob pa shin tu rgyas pa mdo sde’i dbang po’i rgyal po*.

**n.37** *sems kyi rgyal pos dris nas grangs la ’jug pa bstan pa*, folios 348.b–393.b.

Continued in part 2: https://84000.co/translation/toh44-45/part-2.md
