---
title: "The Exposition of Karma"
toh: "Toh 338"
sanskrit_title: "Karmavibhaṅga"
tibetan_title: "las rnam pa ’byed pa"
canon_section: "Kangyur › Discourses › General Sūtra Section"
url: https://84000.co/translation/toh338
published: 2023-04-17
collections: ["Sūtras about Karma", "Sūtras for Beginners"]
publisher: "84000: Translating the Words of the Buddha"
translation_team: "Bruno Galasek-Hul and team"
translators: ["Bruno Galasek-Hul"]
license: "CC BY-NC-ND 4.0"
license_url: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
citation: "The Exposition of Karma (Karmavibhaṅga, Toh 338). Translated by Bruno Galasek-Hul and team. Online publication. 84000: Translating the Words of the Buddha, 2023. https://84000.co/translation/toh338."
part: 1
parts: 4
generated: 2026-11-21
---

# The Exposition of Karma

Toh 338 · Kangyur › Discourses › General Sūtra Section · An 84000 translation · Read online: https://84000.co/translation/toh338

> **License:** [CC BY-NC-ND 4.0](https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/). This work is provided under the protection of a Creative Commons CC BY-NC-ND (Attribution - Non-commercial - No-derivatives) 4.0 copyright. It may be copied or printed for fair use, but only with full attribution, and not for commercial advantage or personal compensation. **Cite as:** The Exposition of Karma (Karmavibhaṅga, Toh 338). Translated by Bruno Galasek-Hul and team. Online publication. 84000: Translating the Words of the Buddha, 2023. https://84000.co/translation/toh338.

> This is the plain-text edition of https://84000.co/translation/toh338. Passage labels (for example 1.2 or i.3) match the online edition. Each label is followed by the passage's permanent ID in square brackets, and by a Toh number when the passage belongs to one Toh only, for example **1.2** [ID] or **i.3** [ID, toh338]. To link to a passage, use https://84000.co/entity/passage/ID?toh=TOH, where TOH is the Toh number shown after the ID, or toh338 if none is shown. Note numbers in square brackets (such as [n.3]) point to the Notes section. When quoting, cite 84000, *The Exposition of Karma* (Toh 338), with the passage label and its link. The summary, introduction and notes are by the translators and are not part of the translated text.

## Parts of this text

This text is long, so its plain-text edition is split into 4 parts. Each part keeps 84000's passage labels and ends with the notes its passages refer to. The whole text in one file: https://84000.co/translation/toh338/full.md

- [Part 1](https://84000.co/translation/toh338.md): Summary, Acknowledgments, Introduction, The Translation (1.1–1.43)
- [Part 2](https://84000.co/translation/toh338/part-2.md): The Translation (1.44–1.132)
- [Part 3](https://84000.co/translation/toh338/part-3.md): The Translation, Abbreviations (1.133–1.186)
- [Part 4](https://84000.co/translation/toh338/part-4.md): Glossary

## At a glance

> Machine-generated overview: written by AI from 84000's published summary and introduction, not yet reviewed by an 84000 editor. It is not part of the translation; quote the translation itself.

**In brief:** The Exposition of Karma (Toh 338), whose Sanskrit title is Karmavibhaṅga, is a discourse found in the General Sūtra Section of the Kangyur's Discourses. The Buddha, staying in Prince Jeta's grove in Śrāvastī, addresses the brahmin youth Śuka Taudeyaputra with a systematic analysis of how deeds generate their corresponding results. The text moves through five broad sections, examining how differences in longevity, health, happiness, and appearance arise from past actions, how specific deeds determine rebirth in various realms, and how the presence or absence of certain factors modifies the outcomes of virtuous and nonvirtuous conduct. Central to the teaching is the role of moral intention in shaping karmic fruition. Throughout, the exposition is illustrated by morality tales and examples drawn from Buddhist narrative literature, including a retelling of the Maitrakanyaka sea-voyage story and an account involving the elder Mahāmaudgalyāyana. The text circulated widely across Asia, with versions surviving in Sanskrit, Pāli, Khotanese, Kuchean, Sogdian, Chinese, and Tibetan.

**Why read it:** This text offers a structured account of how specific actions of body, speech, and mind lead to specific consequences, anchored in narrative examples that make the abstract workings of karma concrete and memorable.

### Who is the audience for the Buddha's teaching in The Exposition of Karma, and where does the discourse take place?

The Buddha delivers the exposition to the brahmin youth Śuka Taudeyaputra while staying in Prince Jeta's grove at Anāthapiṇḍada's Park in Śrāvastī. The text opens with the Buddha announcing that he will teach Śuka the exposition on karma, and Śuka assents before the full teaching unfolds.

### How is the teaching organized and what topics does it cover?

The Exposition of Karma is structured in five main sections. The first examines how differences in life circumstances such as longevity, happiness, illness, and appearance result from past deeds. A second addresses causes for rebirth in various worlds. A third covers specific outcomes when certain factors are present or absent. Two final sections deal more broadly with virtuous and nonvirtuous deeds and their consequences.

### What role does intention play in the karma described in this text?

The Exposition of Karma places particular emphasis on mental intention as the key factor in morally relevant action. The text reflects the Buddhist understanding that karma designates actions of body, speech, and mind, and that once performed these deeds ripen into pleasant or unpleasant results. The centrality of intention distinguishes the Buddhist formulation of karma from other Indian accounts of karmic causation.

### What narrative stories and literary references appear in the text?

The text's longest illustrative story follows a sea merchant's son called Maitrāyajña, who mistreats his mother and suffers torments in a personal hell as a result. Another story features the elder Mahāmaudgalyāyana, who is refused alms and reveals the karmic relationship between himself and a family. Many other stories and sūtra citations are woven throughout, including four quotations from the Cakravartisūtra and a passage from the Kālikasūtra.

### What is the significance of the Borobudur monument in relation to this text?

The Borobudur on the island of Java in Indonesia is thought to include pictorial representations drawn from The Exposition of Karma. Its lowest or most basic level, known as the hidden base, features reliefs depicting stories from the text that illustrate the law of karma, representing the foundation of religious merit that must be accomplished before ascending to higher levels of the Buddhist path.

### In how many languages does The Exposition of Karma survive, and what does this indicate?

Versions or fragments of The Exposition of Karma survive in Sanskrit, Pāli, Khotanese, Kuchean, Sogdian, Chinese, and Tibetan. It was translated into Chinese six times across several centuries. This wide distribution, from Java to Central Asia and China, reflects the text's broad influence as a source for the Buddhist doctrine that humans are responsible for the consequences of their actions.

### Who translated The Exposition of Karma into English for 84000, and what source text did they use?

The English translation was prepared by Bruno Galasek-Hul and first published by 84000 in 2023. The translators based their work primarily on the Tibetan text of the Degé Kangyur (Toh 338) and the Comparative Edition, while also consulting the Sanskrit editions prepared by Sylvain Lévi and Kudo Noriyuki to resolve ambiguities in the Tibetan.

## Summary

**s.1** [4eb5261d-4d0b-47cb-9472-1e85aede7b49] In *The Exposition of Karma*, the Buddha presents to the brahmin youth Śuka Taudeyaputra a discourse on the workings of karma. This is enlivened by many examples drawn from the rich heritage of Buddhist narrative literature, providing a detailed analysis of how deeds lead to specific consequences in the future. For the Buddhist, this treatise answers many questions pertaining to moral causation, examining specific life situations and their underlying karmic causes and emphasizing the key role that intention plays in the Buddhist ethic of responsibility.

## Acknowledgments

**ac.1** [6b440f00-ff70-47a5-94c9-cf8d421f108b] This sūtra was translated into English from the Tibetan and the Sanskrit by Bruno Galasek-Hul with Lama Kunga Thartse Rinpoche (Evam Choden Buddhist Center, Kensington, Berkeley, California) as the consulting Lama.

The translation was completed under the patronage and supervision of 84000: Translating the Words of the Buddha.

**ac.2** [ba624951-2e73-463a-90a9-90b030855fb1] We gratefully acknowledge the generous sponsorship of Late Ng Ah Chon, Late Lee Tiang Chuan, Lee Cheng Watt and family, Late Lee Cheng Boon and family, Lee Boon Tee and family, Lee Pheck Tiang and family, Lee Pheck Choo and family, Lee Siang Choo and family. Their support has helped make the work on this translation possible.

## Introduction

**i.1** [76ac9d42-3be5-4d2c-b7aa-510c2a2aa319] *The Exposition of Karma* (*Karmavibhaṅga*) opens in Prince Jeta’s grove, where the Buddha announces to the brahmin youth Śuka Taudeyaputra[n.1] that he will deliver this exposition on karma. The ensuing teaching provides a detailed analysis of the complex workings of karma. This is enlivened by many examples drawn from the rich store of Buddhist narrative literature, especially the Buddha’s past-life stories. It begins with a section in which the Buddha poses and answers a series of questions about how conspicuous differences in life circumstances such as longevity, happiness, illness, and appearance have been determined by past deeds. A second section follows, in which questions relating to specific causes for rebirth in various worlds are answered. A third section contains a series of miscellaneous questions and answers that examine the specific outcomes of deeds when certain factors are either present or absent in their performance. Two final sections focus more broadly on virtuous and nonvirtuous deeds and their respective positive and negative consequences. In each of these contexts, the relationship between actions and their results is illustrated by examples and morality tales from Buddhist narrative literature.

### Karma

**i.2** [fa130976-742c-4290-a27e-42e1f8251111] The central theme of the *Karmavibhaṅga* is the concept of cause and effect, the complex system of positive and negative results that, in Indian religious thought, are attributed to karma (“action”) itself. In the Buddhist context, the term karma designates both morally good (kuśala) and bad (akuśala) actions of body, speech, and mind. Once committed, all such deeds “ripen” (vipāka) into their corresponding pleasant and unpleasant (or neutral) results, called “karmic fruition” (karma-phala).[n.2] From this standpoint, the entire universe and everything in it is the result of individuals’ actions.[n.3] According to the *Karmavibhaṅga*, certain unpleasant features of one’s environment are the direct outcome of the ten nonvirtuous courses of action.[n.4] The botanical or agricultural metaphor employed in the Buddhist description of the karmic process of the individual is perhaps noteworthy: through the *ripening* of karma one *reaps* or *harvests* the *fruits* of one’s actions. Although the historical Buddha was not the first teacher in ancient India to teach the concept of karmic cause and effect, it has been argued that he advanced and redefined the existing notions of karmically relevant actions as consisting primarily in mental intention (Skt. cetanā; Tib. sems pa).[n.5] This is summarized in the frequently cited passage from the Aṅguttara Nikāya of the Pāli canon: “By action I mean intention, monks. Having formed a (moral) intention, one carries out an action with body, speech, or mind.”[n.6]

### The textual references in the *Karmavibhaṅg*a

**i.3** [05b956b7-f04c-4440-be6b-4f7e13de14cd] The *Karmavibhaṅga* is rich in references to sūtras and citations from Buddhist literature. Its longest illustrative story is a version of the popular narrative from the *Maitrakanyakāvadāna* (*Divyāvadāna* no. 38) of the voyage of the sea merchant’s son Maitrakanyaka (called Maitrāyajña in the *Karmavibhaṅga*), who undertakes a sea voyage to make his fortune, disregarding his mother’s pleas for him to remain on shore and instead physically mistreating her. Because of his disobedience and abuse, he is shipwrecked on the shores of a foreign country and ends up suffering the torments of his personal hell. Another popular story is that of the sthavira Mahāmaudgalyāyana, who is refused alms by a family and subsequently reveals to a stranger their karmic relationship. Both stories are widely known among Tibetan Buddhists from orally transmitted anecdotes of Tibetan lamas. However, many of the other stories and text titles referenced in the *Karmavibhaṅga* are either completely unknown to us or differ from their better-known versions and other extant texts that bear identical or similar titles.[n.7]

### The *Karmavibhaṅga’s* Significance and Geographical Distribution in the Buddhist World

**i.4** [de4106fa-2e90-4670-88f2-0d76dc407d3a] Lokesh Chandra, writing about the Javanese Buddhist monument the Borobudur, notes the wide-ranging influence of the *Karmavibhaṅga*: “It was a popular text from the island of Java to the sands of Central Asia and as far as the sprawling land of China, that is, wherever the doctrine of Buddha held sway.”

**i.5** [e5e52911-5433-49d3-b886-665355650187] A further measure of the work’s widespread popularity is the diverse range of languages in which we find extant versions or fragments of the work: Sanskrit, Pāli, Khotanese, Kuchean, Sogdian, and Chinese.[n.8] Indeed, it was translated into Chinese five times over eight centuries. Thus, in a variety of cultural contexts, the work served as an important source for the central Buddhist doctrine that humans are responsible for the consequences of their actions.[n.9]

**i.6** [5a8d4e0d-34c3-4663-affe-1bd0b4970054] The design of the Borobudur on the island of Java in Indonesia is thought to include pictorial representations drawn from the *Karmavibhaṅga*.[n.10] According to Lokesh Chandra, the monument is a physical model of the Buddhist path to awakening in terms of the four sambhāras or accumulations of merit (puṇya), wisdom (jñāna), tranquility (śamatha), and special insight (vidarśanā) according to the *Lalitavistara*,[n.11] while skillfully integrating and harmonizing other textual traditions. The lowest or most basic level of religious merit (puṇya), which must be accomplished before one can ascend to the higher levels of the path, is represented by Borobudur’s so-called hidden base, which features reliefs depicting stories from the *Karmavibhaṅga* that illustrate the law of karma.

### The title of the text

**i.7** [ebeb80fe-df22-488a-8261-bf140cc0bb05] The exact original title of Toh 338 cannot be established beyond a doubt. Sylvain Lévi, the first to edit and translate the text, referred to it as the *Mahākarmavibhaṅga* (MKV).[n.12] However, the adjective mahā- (“great”) only occurs in the title given to one of the two surviving nearly complete manuscripts (called MS[A] by Kudo Noriyuki),[n.13] and only in an appendix to the text.[n.14] The second of the two nearly complete manuscripts (called MS[B] in Kudo’s edition) bears the title *Karmavibhaṅgasūtraṃ*.[n.15] There are similar variants in the Tibetan translations of the text preserved in the different Kangyur collections.[n.16]
                                           
**i.8** [415c090c-c9cd-4a30-a2e3-ade8b9da989a] For the sake of simplicity, we here follow Kudo and use the title Karmavibhaṅga instead of Mahākarmavibhaṅga or Karmavibhaṅgasūtra to refer to the text translated here (Toh 338), with the caveat that different versions of this text with either the same or a different title are extant.[n.17] The *Karmavibhaṅga* belongs to a group of texts which has been labeled the Karmavibhaṅga- or Śukasūtra class.[n.18]

### Genre

**i.9** [840386e5-a40d-42e5-a75c-28963c3da93c] Although one manuscript (MS[B]) contains the word sūtra in its title, there is insufficient evidence from the extant Sanskrit manuscripts to determine whether the Karmavibhaṅga actually belonged to the scriptural category of sūtra or not.[n.19] As indicated by the example of the Cakravartisūtra—a text the Karmavibhaṅga quotes four times—texts that were designated as sūtras may nevertheless have belonged to the Abhidharma Piṭaka of one of the early Buddhist schools.[n.20] Indeed, from the point of view of style, the actual “sūtra-portion” of the Sanskrit version as edited by Lévi seemingly ends after presenting a mere list of eighty karmic categories.[n.21] Subsequently, something more akin to a commentary on those categories is inserted, bracketed by the list and the title (*Karmavibhaṅgasūtraṃ samāptam*; given in the colophon of MS[B]) that formally marks the end of the text. But there is no “classical” sūtra ending such as a statement that the assembled audience was delighted and rejoiced in the Blessed One’s words.[n.22] Indeed, the *Karmavibhaṅga*’s diction is rather characteristic of a treatise or commentary (Sanskrit śāstra): the different actions and their karmic results are presented in the form of a (hypothetical) dialogue in which replies are given to questions about the expected outcomes of specific types of action. This seamless inclusion of what reads like a commentary as well as the diction of the sūtra, which appears to be more in line with a commentarial treatise, is unusual for the sūtra genre. Equally unusual is the absence of a formulaic, sūtra-typical closure in the Sanskrit version of both MS[A] and MS[B].[n.23]

**i.10** [8c15aa7f-5e08-4276-94f2-2a55d3753cd5] The Tibetan tradition on the other hand regarded the *Karmavibhaṅga* as belonging to the sūtra category (mdo sde), and the Tibetan version possesses the characteristic sūtra frame. All the editions of the Tibetan Kangyur available through the website *Resources for Kanjur and Tanjur Studies* classify it under the sūtra category.[n.24] The Degé Kangyur contains the *Karmavibhaṅga* in a subsection called Collection of Sūtras Belonging to the Hīnayāna (theg dman gyi mdo mang), in the vicinity of such celebrated Buddhist classics as the *Udānavarga* and the *Karmaśataka*.[n.25]

### Extant versions of the text

**i.11** [fb960016-101a-42e6-b2ba-7f9b5ba85165] A good deal of excellent scholarly work has been done on the *Karmavibhaṅga* and its related texts. In what follows we collate and summarize some general information about the extant versions of the *Karmavibhaṅga* and the existing scholarship.

#### Sanskrit versions

**i.12** [49e5fa1b-c00d-48be-a001-0a46385d90bb] The Sanskrit text of the *Karmavibhaṅga* was first edited and published together with a French translation by Sylvain Lévi (1932). Lévi used handwritten copies of the original manuscripts. His edition and translation of the text remains the most comprehensive study, bringing together in one place most of the extant versions and fragments of this important text. Kudo Noriyuki (2004) has published a transliteration of the original manuscripts together with extensive annotations on the quotations of the *Karmavibhaṅga*.

#### Pāli versions

**i.13** [40d17e2c-2f78-43f1-b5e8-2f5185517a3a] As is the case with so many sūtras, we have little concrete information about the origin, the circumstances, or the age of the text of the *Karmavibhaṅga*.[n.26] Perhaps one of the oldest canonical versions of a more detailed discussion of the Buddhist formulation of the doctrine of karmic cause and effect—if one accepts that parts of the Pāli canon are among the oldest representatives of Indian Buddhism, that is—can be found in two texts (Pāli sutta) of the Majjhima Nikāya of the Pāli canon: the *Cūḷakammavibhaṅgasutta* (MN 135) and the *Mahākammavibhaṅgasutta* (MN 136).[n.27] The phraseology and the “cast of characters” of the *Cūḷakammavibhaṅgasutta*, which contains altogether fourteen karmic categories that partly overlap with those of the *Karmavibhaṅga*, bear some resemblance to the *Karmavibhaṅga*. The Pāli version of the brahmin youth’s name, Śuka, is Subha.[n.28]

#### Chinese translations

**i.14** [0a0813e4-7478-4719-96b9-f427cbedc3f7] According to Lokesh Chandra, the *Karmavibhaṅga* was popular in China. Different recensions of the text were translated into Chinese altogether six times—some of them probably from versions transmitted via Central Asia, where the text was equally well known. The earliest translation dates to the third century *ᴄᴇ*.[n.29] All the different translations bearing various related titles, and possibly representing different recensions of the text, have been collectively called the Śukasūtra-class after Śuka Taudeyaputra,[n.30] the protagonist of the frame story. The Chinese translations, in the order of their dates of translation, are as follows:

- Taishō 78: *Doutiao jing* 兜調經 (**Taudeyasūtra*?), the earliest translation, was prepared under the Western Jin, 265–316 *ᴄᴇ*. The name of the translator is unknown (Lévi: Cha).
-

Taishō 26: *Yingwu jing* 鸚鵡經 (*Śukasūtra*), the 170th sūtra of the Madhyamāgama, was translated 397–98 *ᴄᴇ* by Saṅghadeva (Lévi: Chs).

- Taishō 79: *Yingwu jing* 鸚鵡經 (*Śukasūtra*), translated 435–43 *ᴄᴇ* by Guṇabhadra (Lévi: Chb).

- Taishō 80: *Fo wei Shoujia zhangzhe shuo yebao chabie jing* 佛爲首迦長者說業報差別經, translated 582 *ᴄᴇ* by Fazhi 法智 Gautama Dharmaprājña (Lévi: Chg).[n.31]

- Taishō 81: *Fenbie shan e baoying jing* 分別善惡報應經, translated 984 *ᴄᴇ* by Tian Xizai (Lévi: Cht).

- Taishō 755: *Jingyi youpose suowen jing* 淨意優婆塞所問經, translated 982–1017 *ᴄᴇ* by Shihu (Lévi: Chc).

**i.15** [a3606403-5ed7-4cbc-beb6-1dac6f93cadd] Of these, Taishō 80 is given as the Chinese translation equivalent of the Tibetan text translated here, the *las rnam par ’byed pa* (Toh 338).[n.32]

#### Central Asian versions

**i.16** [d12cf3e6-4b0d-4b2f-bf22-182408f72ff2] We can infer from the large number of surviving fragments of versions of the *Karmavibhaṅgasūtra* from the Buddhist centers of the Central Asian oasis towns along the ancient Silk Road that this text and its cognate versions must also have been very popular among Central Asian Buddhists. We know of an old Khotanese version,[n.33] a Central Asian fragment in Sanskrit,[n.34] several fragments of a Kuchean version,[n.35] and a Sogdian version.[n.36]

#### Tibetan translations

**i.17** [5bac1855-d78b-4c1c-87c4-1b23918ea6ae] Apart from the Sanskrit and the Central Asian recensions of the *Karmavibhaṅga*, three different Tibetan versions are preserved in different Kangyurs. While the Kangyurs of the Tshalpa (tshal pa) line mainly contain the versions of the text as preserved in Toh 338 and Toh 339, the Kangyurs belonging to the Thempangma (them spangs ma) line contain the Toh 339 version and, instead of the Toh 338 version, another version of the text. The mixed-lineage Lhasa Kangyur includes all three.[n.37]

**i.18** [e9f8384e-f474-446f-96d0-b7b1ce466c96] A text bearing the title *las rnam par ’byed pa zhes bya ba* (*Karmavibhaṅganāma*) in the Tengyur (Toh 3959) is an independent work attributed to the authorship of Atiśa Dīpaṅkaraśrījñāna (982–1054) and has no direct or explicit relation to the *Karmavibhaṅga* or the Tibetan versions. Apart from the Nepalese Sanskrit commentary contained in Lévi’s 1932 edition of the *Karmavibhaṅga*, we are aware of only one (combined) commentary on the *las rnam par ’byed pa* (Toh 338) and the (here so called) *las rnam par ’gyur ba’i mdo* (Toh 339) by Choné Lama Drakpa Shedrup (co ne bla ma grags pa bshad sgrub, 1675–1748).[n.38] No canonical commentary on the *Karmavibhaṅga* is known to us.

**i.19** [aa88a3a8-7ceb-4639-a970-1cca1192e2e7] None of the other known versions is an exact match of Toh 338. In other words, we do not possess, and do not know whether there ever existed, a complete Indic source text of the *las rnam par ’byed pa*. The relationships of the different Tibetan versions of the *Karmavibhaṅga* as well as their relationships to the other extent versions in other languages await further research.

### Notes on the English translation

**i.20** [56938e3c-9fc6-400e-8457-99a75432a6d7] We have based our English translation on the Tibetan text (Toh 338) of the Degé Kangyur as well as the Comparative Edition (*dpe bsdur ma*) and prioritized the diction and register of the Tibetan translation. However, we have also perused the Sanskrit editions made by Lévi and Kudo in parallel with the Tibetan text and have chosen to translate the corresponding Sanskrit passage instead of the Tibetan in cases where the Tibetan translation was ambiguous or unintelligible. Our preferences are recorded in the notes.

## The Translation

**The Exposition of Karma**

**1.1** [e783d704-d098-466c-9773-d96c9c7f46ff] Homage to all the buddhas and bodhisattvas!

Thus did I hear at one time. The Bhagavān was staying in Śrāvastī, in Prince Jeta’s grove, Anāthapiṇḍada’s Park.[n.39]

There the Bhagavān addressed the brahmin youth Śuka[n.40] thus: “Son,[n.41] I will teach you *The Exposition of Karma*.[n.42] Listen carefully and remember it well, and I will teach!”

“Please do so, Bhagavān!”

**1.2** [860da169-b783-48df-910f-c0372b90ae73] The brahmin youth Śuka having thus assented, the Bhagavān said to him, “Son, I say that beings are owners of their own actions,[n.43] they originate from their actions,[n.44] they are heirs of their actions,[n.45] and they take action as their refuge.[n.46] In this way, son, beings are divided into high, middle, and low in terms of their actions.

“In this regard, there are, for instance, the actions that lead to a short life.[n.47]

**1.3** [34143b38-42d3-4337-aea7-2952077ea9e4] “What kind of action leads to a short life? Killing, rejoicing in killing, celebrating killing,[n.48] instigating the death of an enemy, praising the death of an enemy, causing death in the womb,[n.49] praising the causing of death in the womb, and preparing the sacrificial ground where buffalo, cows, pigs, birds, and so on are to be killed. The children and grandchildren of the originator of this sacrifice, as well as other people hoping for a positive result or acting out of fear, will kill many beings as they continue to carry out this initial sacrifice.[n.50]

**1.4** [9f5b8f1d-fed3-4b82-9cce-f65e3ff9091c] “For example, in a certain city in Kāśmīr, a certain mendicant who was an arhat was sitting at the door of a house. On a road leading straight to this house, a miserably mooing cow was being led along on a lead. The mendicant, having seen the cow, exclaimed, ‘Alas! What a misery!’

**1.5** [ab0f9f04-953d-40f6-bf23-41e525a14d03] “The people then asked the mendicant, ‘Ācārya, why did you say, “Alas! What a misery”?’

**1.6** [de44f61e-9e0f-4fc5-8234-e306193513a5] “He replied, ‘Although I usually do not speak to those without faith, in this particular case I will speak.’[n.51] Then he said, ‘That cow being led along there, mooing, was in a former existence a rich merchant. He had prepared a piece of land for the yearly sacrifice and killed a great many cows there. When the time of his death drew near, he called his sons and said to them, “Sons, if you love me, you will also execute this yearly cattle sacrifice after I am dead!” So instructed, the sons agreed and said, “We will.” Then this man died and, because he had killed out of confusion, was reborn as a cow in his own house. After having been reborn there again and again, and having been killed time and again, this is now the sixth time he is being led to the sacrificial ground.’

**1.7** [86d6c58e-f0b3-4746-8829-670fe726af83] “The mendicant then said to the cow with pity, ‘You yourself have prepared this very sacrificial ground. You yourself have performed this very sacrifice and killed many cows. Your mooing is to no avail! What is it good for?’ So it was said.

**1.8** [1866e8eb-854f-4f18-88fd-69288e58819c] “Seeing the preparation of a sacrificial ground such as this is like witnessing a battle[n.52] during which many beings such as humans and horses are killed,[n.53] or like being thrilled about the accoutrements of war.[n.54]

**1.9** [0d1af360-7683-4a81-82e6-e30f2eddd4fa] “As the Buddha has said in the *Kālikasūtra*:[n.55]

>

“ ‘Ānanda, resorting to killing and having grown accustomed to it and practiced it often becomes the cause for rebirth in the hells, in the animal realm, or as a ghost.’

**1.10** [a7e352f9-07f9-4f7b-9e0e-9bffff940140] “When killing is done few times and on a small scale, it leads to having a short lifespan.[n.56]

**1.11** [bdf1597d-90d2-4043-97f9-92a51685c56e] “What kind of action leads to a long life? Abstaining from killing; speaking praise of abstaining from killing and encouraging others to do so; freeing people and cattle, pigs, birds, and so forth that are to be killed; giving protection to those stricken with fear; arousing thoughts of kindness toward those who are without protection; arousing thoughts of love toward those who are sick, children, and the elderly; giving food to and arousing thoughts of love toward those who are in need; and rejecting all those things referred to above concerning war and so forth,[n.57] and instead practicing virtue such as renovating and restoring stūpas and monasteries[n.58] that have fallen into disrepair.

**1.12** [07e925f4-81a3-4a74-9a51-5366e14e177c] “It is said in that same sūtra:

>
“ ‘For he who restores what has fallen into ruin,[n.59]
Untimely death will not occur.’[n.60]

“This kind of action leads to a long life.

**1.13** [00f91d40-c7b5-4540-bbce-1b64fd8a79e2] “What kind of action leads to having many illnesses? Anger and hitting someone with the fist or the palm of the hand;[n.61] enjoying hitting somebody with the fist or the palm of the hand; speaking praise of the merit of hitting someone with the fist or the palm of the hand and encouraging it; causing one’s parents mental or physical distress; causing monks who possess moral discipline mental distress; feeling glad when one’s enemies are stricken by illness; feeling unhappy when one’s enemies recover from an illness; and not giving medicine and giving indigestible foods—this kind of action leads to having many illnesses.

**1.14** [a4e2952a-b093-4613-a684-85e0ed37b0ac] “What kind of action leads to having few illnesses? Not hitting someone with the palm of the hand or with the fist;[n.62] encouraging others to abstain from hitting with the palm of the hand or the fist and praising the merits of abstaining from hitting; rejoicing in not hitting; serving one’s ill parents, householders, and monks, regardless of whether they are senior or junior monks; caring for the sick; not feeling happy or glad when one’s enemies fall ill; rejoicing in their recovery; and giving medicine and digestible food[n.63]—this kind of action leads to having few illnesses.

**1.15** [7f5c9d6c-cf9a-49cc-b21d-fc0e31658a24] “What kind of action leads to having an ugly appearance?[n.64] Anger, enmity, resentment, spite,[n.65] speaking ill of one’s parents, speaking ill of householders and of senior or junior monks, soiling stūpas and monasteries and the site of a stūpa, extinguishing offering lamps at stūpas and images, deriding ugly people, and having little sense of cleanliness—this kind of action leads to ugliness.

**1.16** [9dafeb00-393d-4829-9278-a6444f988ee5] “What kind of action leads to beauty? The opposites of anger, enmity, resentment, and spite; donating clothing; plastering[n.66] stūpas and monasteries with white lime;[n.67] donating beautiful[n.68] bowls; making an offering of incense, scented ointment, cloth, and ornaments; praising one’s parents; praising noble ones and those who possess moral discipline; cleaning and sweeping the court around a stūpa, a monastery, and one’s house; not deriding ugly people; not deriding others in general, whether old or young; and being very cleanly—this kind of action leads to beauty.

**1.17** [62303e42-ae29-4660-8975-e9785b43c0a6] “What kind of action leads to having little power?[n.69] Avarice; envy; being unhappy about others’ successes; being unhappy when others are praised; despising one’s parents; despising noble ones and those who possess moral discipline; despising the sick, the old, and the young; praising what is vile, what is lacking Dharma,[n.70] and the roots of nonvirtue; and turning away from the mind of awakening—this kind of action leads to having little power.

**1.18** [c5e782b3-f1a4-4549-bab4-8bb9524e807b] “What kind of action leads to being powerful? Not being avaricious; not being envious; rejoicing in others’ successes; not rejoicing in others’ failures; rejoicing in hearing about others’ glory, renown, and good reputation;[n.71] being happy when others are praised; building stūpas and monasteries in commemoration of the Bhagavān;[n.72] turning away from what is vile, from what is lacking Dharma, and from the roots of demerit; encouraging others to engage in the roots of merit that lead to distinction; aspiring to reach awakening; and aspiring to attain distinction through the dedication of all roots of merit[n.73]—this kind of action leads to being powerful.

**1.19** [7af63f9d-da08-4e85-9390-0bb355bcc525] “What kind of action leads to being born into a low social status? Vanity; conceit; not honoring one’s father and mother, śramaṇas, and brāhmaṇas; not respecting the head of a family; not attending to[n.74] one’s parents; not attending to noble ones, to those who possess moral discipline, and to others occupying a position of authority, such as one’s preceptor and one’s teacher; and despising people of low class—this kind of action leads to being born into a low social status.

**1.20** [eeef84df-28e8-42d5-b97d-e7eb836e8b78] “What kind of action leads to being born into a family of high social status? Having little vanity; having no conceit; honoring one’s father and mother, śramaṇas, and brāhmaṇas; honoring the head of the family; attending to one’s parents; attending to noble ones, to those who possess moral discipline, and to others occupying a position of authority, such one’s preceptor and teacher; and not despising people of low class.

**1.21** [e0d3f63a-3056-4b6d-8833-a34240f01900] “For example, the Buddha has said in a sūtra:[n.75]

>

“ ‘Monks, you should know that a community[n.76] that is approached by monks who possess moral discipline, are celibate, and possess the quality of virtue can expect five benefits. What are the five? It develops faith in the ones possessing moral discipline who have approached them. Furthermore, monks, at that time, that community enters the path leading to rebirth in heaven. And what is more, monks, the moment the community greets and welcomes those approaching who possess moral discipline, the community has already entered the path leading to rebirth in heaven.’

“This kind of action leads to being reborn in a family of high social status.

**1.22** [96b069d9-11a7-412a-90f2-02e3bde97704] “What kind of action leads to poverty?[n.77] Stealing;[n.78] encouraging others to commit theft; speaking praise of stealing; taking pleasure in stealing and in having stolen;[n.79] depriving one’s parents of their livelihood; depriving noble ones and those who possess moral discipline of their livelihood and stealing the livelihood of monks, children, the elderly, the poor, and the sick; rejoicing when others fail to gain wealth; preventing others from gaining wealth; and rejoicing in a bad harvest—this kind of action leads to poverty.

**1.23** [7a717327-48a4-4dfa-9e56-3ef35a0f6948] “What kind of action leads to wealth? Abstaining from stealing; rejoicing when someone abstains from taking what was not freely given to them by others; providing one’s parents with a livelihood; providing noble ones and those who possess moral discipline with a livelihood; offering sustenance to the sick, children, the elderly, the poor, and others; rejoicing in the gain of others; and rejoicing in a good harvest.

**1.24** [e7b333b7-1298-43ea-af7a-55d2a77cb184] “In the same sūtra it is said:

>

“ ‘What is more, monks, when the merit-collecting communities make offerings to those approaching them who possesses moral discipline they enter the path leading to prosperity.’

“This kind of action leads to great wealth.

**1.25** [5e5b56da-d4d6-4607-9c20-ca7387d8d5b4] “What kind of action leads to low intelligence?[n.80] Here, one does not ask the learned[n.81] śramaṇas or brāhmaṇas or others, ‘What is the Dharma? What is not the Dharma?[n.82] What, when done by me, is conducive to happiness?’[n.83] One associates with[n.84] people who lack intelligence and abandons wise people. One teaches what is not the true Dharma, and even though one knows that a reciter of the Buddhist scriptures has spoken well, due to one’s being opinionated[n.85] one does not say ‘well done!’ But when a reciter has spoken what does not correspond with the Dharma, one says ‘well done!’ One praises wrong views and criticizes right views. One denigrates writers and reciters of manuscripts[n.86] and deprives them of their livelihood. This kind of action leads to low intelligence.

**1.26** [157ac061-37a6-4cea-8e6b-011bc5519cc1] “What kind of action leads to great intelligence? Here, one has a disposition that dares to inquire[n.87] and asks the learned śramaṇas and brāhmaṇas questions; one completely shuns those lacking wisdom; one extols the true Dharma and elucidates it; one criticizes what is not the true Dharma; and one praises the confidence of the Dharma reciters[n.88] and says ‘well done!’ One acclaims those who speak coherently and steers clear of those who speak what is unacceptable;[n.89] one praises right view and criticizes[n.90] wrong view; one makes offerings of paper, ink, and reed pens;[n.91] and, as explained in the *Nandikasūtra*,[n.92] one does not drink alcohol. The thirty-five[n.93] faults of drinking alcohol that are taught in that sūtra will be discussed later in the section on the nonvirtuous actions.[n.94] This kind of action leads to great intelligence.

**1.27** [5b60bbac-23dc-4db2-8630-44697966a523] “What kind of action leads to rebirth as a hell being? Carrying out gravely negative actions of body, speech, and mind with intensely angry thoughts; entertaining the wrong view of annihilation, the wrong view of eternalism, and the wrong view of nihilism;[n.95] speaking with hostility;[n.96] ingratitude; performing the evil actions that bring immediate retribution; and flinging false accusations at noble ones and those who possess moral discipline—this kind of action leads to rebirth in the hell realms.

**1.28** [5ad3540e-6a13-438e-b6d5-6667bfb9c6bc] “What kind of action leads to rebirth in the animal realm?[n.97] Carrying out moderately bad actions with body, speech, and mind and the varied actions stemming from desire, hatred, and confusion; presenting improper gifts[n.98] to one’s parents or Buddhist monks; ridiculing[n.99] beings who are reborn in the animal realm; and making the aspiration to be reborn there as, for example, when someone practices the ox vow or the dog vow,[n.100] thinking, ‘May I be reborn like that!’[n.101]

**1.29** [7cbc74b2-09d9-4edb-9f87-3d67ee155aa3] “As an example, one may here relate the Heroic Past Deeds[n.102] of the Bodhisattva from the *Siṃhajātaka*, or the story of the brahmin Varṣākāra’s rebirth as a monkey.[n.103]

**1.30** [0f7eec37-9c90-476a-ac02-5a5bd50cd794] “The brahmin Varṣākāra saw the sthavira Mahākāśyapa on Vulture Peak, flying in the sky above the city of Rājagṛha.[n.104] Because of his close association with Devadatta and Prince Ajātaśatru, he harbored hostile thoughts in his mind and made this insulting comment:[n.105] ‘This monk flies through the air from mountain peak to mountain peak just as a monkey swings from tree to tree.’

**1.31** [6e7e4e36-bf91-42bf-b622-bf839deda08d] “When the brahmin Varṣākāra, his mind filled with hatred, had made this insulting comment, the Buddha was asked, ‘Venerable Bhagavān, what will be the karmic result of this?’

**1.32** [9e886086-05ac-4ac9-b23d-341e478e4c1c] “The Bhagavān replied, ‘By the karmic ripening of these abusive words, the brahmin Varṣākāra will be reborn as a monkey during five hundred future lives.’[n.106]

**1.33** [2444257c-d315-41fa-b422-72e29b1c72e3] “Varṣākāra then became frightened and developed faith in the Buddha. He asked the Bhagavān at the time of his parinirvāṇa,[n.107] ‘Where[n.108] will this deed become exhausted?’[n.109]

**1.34** [c2e50c21-c970-4268-9787-93545b70ca8d] “The Bhagavān said, ‘During these five hundred lives you will be reborn in Rājagṛha in the Jambu continent, the Rose-Apple continent, which derives its name from the fruits called jambu that are the size of large earthen pots and delicious like the pure honey of bees.[n.110] From there, leaving this incarnation, you will reach heaven.’[n.111]

**1.35** [170c0c87-dc87-4d8c-baae-78fe74acaed8] “To give another example, having been reborn among lions by virtue of a thought of hatred, the Bhagavān spoke the following stanza in reference to this topic:[n.112]

**1.36** [77d29b9e-3cc1-4f37-8449-390aefe60f37] > “ ‘Long is the night for the one who lies awake;
Long is a yojana for the one who is exhausted.
Saṃsāra is long for the foolish,
Even if they are acquainted with the holy Dharma.’[n.113]

“This kind of action leads to rebirth in the animal realm.

**1.37** [9b95d806-d69c-4559-aa1e-1b0eccdb02dd] “What kind of action leads to rebirth in the realm of ghosts?[n.114] Here, someone adopts a negative course of conduct[n.115] of body, speech, and mind with a mind full of anger and hatred or craving; pursues a wrong way of making a living[n.116] due to improper desire; dies while being angry, hungry, or thirsty; or dies while having thoughts of attachment to material things.

**1.38** [ec754005-bae3-47ca-878d-a577162ff16e] “An illustration [818] from the *Śatavarga-āgama Karmavibhaṅgasūtra*:[n.117]

> “ ‘The Bhagavān said to Ānanda, “Ānanda, either an action done by a person in a previous lifetime resurfaces and becomes present, or it becomes the force that leads to wrong views at the time of death.” ’[n.118]

“This kind of action leads to rebirth in the realm of ghosts.

**1.39** [32368fa3-0817-4e5b-8596-44a0ba0a744d] “What kind of action leads to rebirth in the realm of the asuras? Someone’s committing only small or minor misdeeds with body, speech, and mind; pride; arrogance;[n.119] the pride of identification with a self;[n.120] the pride of inferiority;[n.121] dedicating the roots of virtue of one’s positive actions to rebirth in the world of the asuras;[n.122] and following an immoral course of conduct yet in an intelligent manner that springs from refined desire—this kind of action leads to rebirth in the realm of the asuras.

**1.40** [2d0cce23-9d81-4557-b7ec-6d31d905d1c8] “What kind of action leads to rebirth as a human? Here, one cultivates the ten virtuous courses of action. What are the ten? One abandons the ten nonvirtuous actions: the three physical actions of killing, stealing,[n.123] and sexual misconduct; the four verbal actions of lying, slander, harsh speech, and idle talk; and, furthermore, the three mental actions of covetousness,[n.124] malice, and wrong views.[n.125] This kind of action leads to rebirth as a human.

**1.41** [9805c53e-c2e4-4acf-afef-786449c95ab0] “What kind of action leads to rebirth as a deva belonging to the realm of sensuous desire?[n.126] Here, someone practices well, and brings to perfection, the ten virtuous courses of action—this kind of action leads to rebirth as a deva belonging to the realm of sensuous desire.

**1.42** [af885ae0-b6be-4bb8-abdd-e942fe375000] “What kind of action leads to rebirth as a deva belonging to the realm of form? Someone practices well the ten virtuous courses of action, accomplishes them, and brings them to perfection to an especially superior degree—this kind of action leads to rebirth as a deva belonging to the realm of form.

**1.43** [b36e1565-89b5-4b8a-b95f-d8d7aa15d794] “What kind of action leads to rebirth as a deva belonging to the formless realm? One enters the four attainments of the formless states and, having entirely and completely transcended all notions of form, and the notion of materiality having vanished, through disengaging the mind from the notion of distinctness, thinking, ‘Space is infinite,’[n.127] one has perfected the sphere of infinity of space and abides in it.[n.128] Having entirely and completely transcended the sphere of infinity of space, thinking, ‘Consciousness is infinite,’ one has perfected the sphere of infinity of consciousness and abides in it.[n.129] Having entirely and completely transcended the sphere of infinity of consciousness, thinking, ‘Nothing at all exists,’ one has perfected the sphere of nothingness and abides in it.[n.130] Having entirely and completely transcended the sphere of nothingness, one has perfected the sphere of neither perception nor nonperception and abides in it.[n.131] This kind of action leads to rebirth as a deva belonging to the formless realm.

## Notes for this part

**n.1** In the Pāli sources he is named Subha Todeyyaputta, “Subha, son of Todeyya.” His full name in the extant Sanskrit version of the sūtra is Śuka Taudeyaputra (*śuko māṇavas taudeyaputro* “The brahmin youth Śuka, son of Taudeya”). The Tibetan version has *bram ze’i khye’u shu ka* (equivalent to Sanskrit *śuko māṇava*) throughout but mentions that he is the son of the brahmin Taudeya (*bram ze to’u de ya*) at the end of the sūtra.

**n.2** In many presentations, “mixed” actions (i.e., partially good and partially bad actions) and “neutral” (Skt. *avyākṛta*) actions complement the pair of opposites of good and bad actions, but the *Karmavibhaṅga* does not contain an explicit discussion of these categories.

**n.3** For a canonical account of the relationship between karma, the different rebirth destinies, and Buddhist cosmology, see, for example Bruno Galasek-Hul and Lama Kunga Thartse Rinpoche, trans., The Limits of Life, Toh 307 (84000: Translating the Words of the Buddha, 2021). See also Dharmachakra Translation Committee, trans., The Application of Mindfulness of the Sacred Dharma, Toh 287 (84000: Translating the Words of the Buddha, 2021), which provides an extensive magisterial overview of the workings of moral causation in all the realms of existence.

**n.4** Although the *Karmavibhaṅga* does not make use of technical terms such as *retributive*, *outflowing*, and *predominating results*, as the *Abhidharmakośa* does (see AKK 87a,b; La Vallée Poussin/Pruden 1988–90, p. 672), the three categories of “outflowing result” (*niṣyandaphala*), “retributive result” (*vipāka*), and “predominating result” (*adhipattiphala*) are tacitly employed by way of example. At 1.145-1.154, the predominating and outflowing results are illustrated, while in most of the paragraphs up to 1.132 the retributive result is illustrated. The retributive result is produced when a virtuous or nonvirtuous action is accumulated (*upacita*), i.e., carried out repeatedly and with intent, i.e., full awareness, and results in rebirth in a state of suffering in one of the lower rebirth destinations; the outflowing result is produced when the person who has performed the action is—due to other karmic forces—reborn as a human being, and it results in an experience equivalent to the action; finally, the predominating result is produced through intensively and/or repeatedly engaging in the ten virtuous actions or the ten nonvirtuous actions and results in a suitable or unsuitable environment.

**n.5** See Gombrich 2009, pp. 13, 127–28, and, specifically, 123: “Among the five *khandha*, the fourth group, volitions, includes *cetanā*, intention. This the Buddha declared to be what constitutes karma and therefore lends an action its ethical quality, whether good or bad.”

**n.6** AN III, 415,7–8: *Cetanāhaṃ bhikkhave kammaṃ vadāmi; cetayitvā kammaṃ karoti kāyena vācāya manasā*. Readers who are interested in more specialized descriptions and a more comprehensive treatment of the topic of karma and rebirth in ancient India and in Buddhism may consult the H-Buddhism Buddhist Studies Bibliography project on Zotero (filter tag “karma”), accessed April 9, 2020. In particular, two excellent in-depth studies are recommended: Halbfass 2000 (in German) and Timme Kragh 2006.

**n.7** In the extensive appendix to his edition of the *Karmavibhaṅga*, Kudo (2004, pp. 229–323) catalogs and comments on the known parallels of the cited texts and stories in the order of their appearance.

**n.8** For an excellent, exhaustive overview of the extant versions of the *Karmavibhaṅga*, see Maggi 1995, pp. 19–20.

**n.9** Lokesh Chandra 2010, p. 29.

**n.10** For photographs of the reliefs of the hidden base of the Borobudur accompanied by English translations from the Sanskrit of individual paragraphs of the *Karmavibhaṅga*, see Ānandajoti Bhikkhu, “Karma-vibhanga, Deeds and their Results,” *Photo Dharma*, last accessed July 24, 2020.

**n.11** See Dharmachakra Translation Committee, trans., *The Play in Full*, Toh 95 (84000: Translating the Words of the Buddha, 2013), 4.30.

**n.12** See, e.g., pw, s.v. “vibhaṅga”; BHSD, s.v. “vibhaṅga”: (1) “classification”; (2) “explanation, commentary.” For the word *vibhaṅga* as part of titles of Indic Buddhist works, see the introduction to Bruno Galasek-Hul and Lama Kunga Thartse Rinpoche, trans., *Transformation of Karma*, Toh 339 (84000: Translating the Words of the Buddha, 2021), i.5–i.6. Sylvain Lévi in his 1932 edition of the Sanskrit text translated the title as *La grande classification des actes* (*Mahākarmavibhaṅga*, *The Great Classification of Acts*).

**n.13** Lévi has identified this appendix, which was included in the manuscript bundle of MS[A], as constituting a commentary on the *Karmavibhaṅga* and appositely labeled it *Karmavibhaṅga-upadeśa*. Lévi 1932, pp. 2, 167.

**n.14** Vasubandhu’s *Abhidharmakośabhāṣya* refers to a work titled *Mahākarmavibhāgasūtra*, but it is doubtful that this sūtra is identical with the *Karmavibhaṅga* as we have it. See Abhidh-k-bh(P) 281,11 ad AKK V.6. The context of this passage in the Abhidh-k-bh is a discussion of different early Buddhist schools’ views on the removal of latent dispositions (Skt. *anuśayas*) through the realization of the four noble truths. No such passage, concerning neither the wording nor the doctrinal content, can be identified in the *Karmavibhaṅga*.

**n.15** Kudo 2004, p. 215.

**n.16** Looking at the first pages of several Kangyur editions, we find the following variations from the transliteration of the Sanskrit title in the Kangyurs of the Tshalpa group, *karma bi b+hang ga* (= *karmavibhaṅga*). The London manuscript Kangyur; Stok Palace manuscript Kangyur; and Shey Palace manuscript Kangyurs reads *karmA bi b+hang ka* (= *karmavibhaṅga*), and the Phukdrak manuscript Kangyur reads *karma bi b+ha ga* (= *karmavibhāga*). Complicating matters further, the Phukdrak manuscript Kangyur contains two versions of the *las rnam par ’byed pa*, both seemingly containing the same text, of which the second, F404 (vol. 97 [mdo sde, na], folios 333.b–356.a) has the transliterated Sanskrit title *kar ma b+ha ba ka* (= *karma-bhavaka* or *karma-bhāvaka*, “[the sūtra that explains] existence through actions”). One may want to readily dismiss this last variant of the title as a mere scribal error or the result of ignorance of the Sanskrit language. However, the Shelkar Kangyur records as the Tibetan title of the related sūtra Toh 339 (see Bruno Galasek-Hul and Lama Kunga Thartse Rinpoche, trans., Transformation of Karma, 2021) *las kyis rnam par ’gyur ba zhes bya ba’i chos kyi gzhung* (“The Dharma Scripture called Transformation through Karma”). It is, of course, possible that the latter is a scribal error (in Tibetan prints and manuscripts the case markers -*kyis* and -*kyi* are frequently mixed up), but both variant titles point to the central theme of the *Karmavibhaṅga*-group of texts: the coming to be or the transformation of existence through actions.

**n.17** For instance, the Degé version of the *Karmavibhaṅga* translated here differs from the extant Sanskrit versions of the *Karmavibhaṅga*—MS[A] and MS[B], respectively (Kudo 2004). These, although sufficiently different themselves, rather correspond with the version called S1 by Mauro Maggi (Maggi 1995, p. 19) and with Kudo’s “Tib–3” which is the same as the Tibetan version of the Berlin manuscript Kangyur studied by Walter Simon (1970) as well as the extensive Dunhuang fragment Pelliot tibétain 944 (see n.31 for the latter).

**n.18** See also Bruno Galasek-Hul and Lama Kunga Thartse Rinpoche, trans., Transformation of Karma (84000: Translating the Words of the Buddha, 2021), i.2.

**n.19** See Kudo 2004, p. xi: “However, we have no evidence for deciding whether or not this text is a sūtra.” See also p. ix, where Kudo summarizes the works on the *Karmavibhaṅga* done by other scholars. Namikawa Takayoshi, for example, by comparing the citations in the *Karmavibhaṅga* from the *Cakravartisūtra* with other parallel texts, supposes that the *Karmavibhaṅga* belonged to the canon of the Sāṃmatīya school of Buddhism. Given Namikawa’s hypothesis that the *Cakravartisūtra* belonged to the Abhidharma Piṭaka of a school that also possessed the *Karmavibhaṅga*, one might even further speculate that the *Karmavibhaṅga*, too, originally belonged to the Abhidharma Piṭaka of the Sāṃmatīya school. We have not been able to independently verify this hypothesis but rely solely on the excellent scholarship of these Japanese scholars. See also n.19.

**n.20** See Kudo 2004, p. ix and pp. 262–63, n. 37. This sūtra is titled differently in MS[A] and MS[B]: *Cakravartisūtra* and *Cakravartisūtravibhaṅga*, respectively, and only MS[A] has the addition of *Abhidharma* before the text’s title. (We have normalized the Sanskrit spellings of the texts’ titles, following Lévi, and left out variants; for a transcription of the original spellings in the manuscripts, see Kudo 2004, pp. 262–63). For an obscure remark in the *Karmavibhaṅga-upadeśa* that “other schools” classified the *Karmavibhaṅga* as belonging to an otherwise unknown collection called *Abhidharmasaṁyukta*, see Lévi 1932, p. 12 (“un passage obscur qui semble indiquer que le Karmavibhaṅga était classé par d’autres écoles dans les Abhidharmasaṁyuktas, genre de division dont nous ne savons rien non plus”) and p. 167 (*gotrāntarīyāṇāṃ Abhidharmasaṁyukteṣu*).

**n.21** This is indicated by the phrase *uddeśaḥ Karmavibhaṅgasya dharmaparyāyasya*, “[Now follows] the exposition/ exemplification of the Dharma-discourse *Karmavibhaṅga* (Lévi 1932, p. 32). Cf. also Kudo 2004, p. 34 for MS[A] and p. 35 for MS[B]*.*

**n.22** Lévi 1932, p. 2.

**n.23** Yet, the *Karmavibhaṅga* certainly does not exhibit the level of formality and scholasticism that one finds, for example, in Vasubandhu’s *Abhidharmakośabhāṣya*. On the other hand, MS[B] contains not only the title *Karmavibhaṅgasūtra* but also the expression “Dharma discourse” (*dharmaparyāya*), omitted by MS[A], which usually designates a sūtra-style way of teaching. See Lévi 1932, p. 32; Kudo 2004, p. 35.

**n.24** *Resources for Kangyur and Tanjur Studies*, Universität Wien, accessed October 21, 2019.

**n.25** Lozang Jamspal and Kaia Fischer, trans., The Hundred Deeds, Toh 340 (84000: Translating the Words of the Buddha, 2020).

**n.26** The manuscript that Sylvain Lévi examined and on which he based his edition has, according to the colophon, been dated between 1410 and 1411 *ᴄᴇ* (Lévi 1932, p. 1).

**n.27** For English translations of these texts, see Bhikkhu Ñāṇamoli and Bhikkhu Bodhi 2009.

**n.28** For details on the name, see Lévi 1932, p. 21, n. 3, where he suggests as the common origin to both variants of the name the Ardhamāgadhī *Sua* and furthermore references Śuka, son of Vyāsa, of the *Mahābhārata*.

**n.29** Maggi (1995, pp. 19–20) lists altogether six Chinese translations, which is correct. The information given in Lokesh Chandra is thus incomplete; see Lokesh Chandra 2010, pp. 27–28. We were unable to assess for this translation how the Chinese translations relate to the Tibetan or the Sanskrit versions of the *Karmavibhaṅga*.

**n.30** See Kudo 2004, p. viii; see Lokesh Chandra 2010, p. 90.

**n.31** According to Maggi 1995, p. 20, n. 2, a manuscript fragment of this Chinese translation was discovered at Dunhuang. It would perhaps be worthwhile to compare this Chinese Dunhuang fragment with Pelliot tibétain 944, the Tibetan fragment of the *las rnam par ’byed pa* found at Dunhuang.

**n.32** See Lewis R. Lancaster, *The Korean Buddhist Canon: A Descriptive Catalogue*, accessed November 4, 2019, K 805. This catalog furthermore states that Taishō 78, 79, and 81 are the Chinese equivalents of Toh 339, *las kyi rnam par ’gyur ba zhes bya ba chos kyi gzhung* (Bruno Galasek-Hul and Lama Kunga Thartse Rinpoche, trans., Transformation of Karma, 2021). A comparison of these Chinese works with the Tibetan translation Toh 339, as well as the Central Asian fragment in the Hoernle collection (reproduced in Lévi 1932, pp. 235–36) is so far lacking.

**n.33** Maggi 1995.

**n.34** Hoernle 1916.

**n.35** Lévi 1932, pp. 243–57; reprinted in a separate publication in Lévi 1933, pp. 84–107, with a French translation.

**n.36** Oldenburg 1920.

**n.37** The third version of the text, not included in the Degé Kangyur, is represented by the Tibetan translation H343 in the Lhasa Kangyur (despite the misleading entries in the *dkar chag*), S287 in the Stok Palace manuscript Kangyur, B346 in the Berlin manuscript Kangyur, and N784 in the Narthang’s supplementary (*kha skong*) volume, as well as by a Dunhuang version (PT944). For details of its content, see Simon 1970. 84000 hopes to add an English translation to this collection in future.

**n.38** For detailed information on Drakpa Shedrup, see s.v. at *The Treasury of Lives*, accessed September 12, 2022. This short work by Drakpa Shedrup is strictly speaking not a commentary as it merely summarizes the sūtra’s main points in a concise way (*don bsdus*) and largely follows the structure of Toh 339. The second part of Drakpa Shedrup’s text contains a concise summary of the *tshe’i mtha’i mdo* (*Āyuḥparyanta*, Toh 307). He first gives a summary of the different karmic categories, which is then followed by a short explication of the categories and the specific actions that lead to their respective result. While Drakpa Shedrup’s commentary does not add any new information that is not available from the sūtras themselves, it stands out for its conciseness and very clear language.

**n.39** MS[A] reads *anāthapiṇḍa*.

**n.40** The Sanskrit adds the patronymic Taudeyaputra to Śuka’s name (Lévi 1932, p. 29).

**n.41** D: *bram ze’i bu*; H *bram ze’i khye’u*. The Tibetan *bram ze’i bu* corresponds to the Sanskrit *māṇavaka* (see Kudo 2004, pp. 8 and 26; Mvy [Sakaki 3846]). Bhikkhu Bodhi translates the Pāli *māṇava* as “student” (see Bhikkhu Ñāṇamoli and Bhikkhu Bodhi 2009, p. 1053).

**n.42** According to the Tibetan (*las rnam par ’byed pa bstan gyis*). The Sanskrit reads *Karmavibhaṅgaṃ te Māṇavaka dharmaparyāyaṃ deśayiṣyāmi* (“Son, I will teach you the discourse on Dharma [called] *The Exposition of Karma*”). (Lévi 1932, p. 29; Kudo 2004, p. 27: MS[B] only, MS[A] omits.)

**n.43** The terms translated here are well-known Buddhist terms in the context of the teachings on karma, and our translation follows the Sanskrit and Bhikkhu Bodhi’s translation of the Pāli *Cūḷakammavibhaṅgasutta* (see Bhikkhu Ñāṇamoli and Bhikkhu Bodhi 2009, pp. 1053–54). Here the Tibetan seems to be literally saying “[beings] exist as their own actions” or “[beings] become their own actions” (*sems can rnams bdag gi las las su gyur ba*). The terms given in the Tibetan translation do not follow the standard translation equivalents given in Mvy (Sakaki 2313): *las bdag gyir byed pa* for *karmasvakaḥ*.

**n.44** The Tibetan text deviates from the standard translation of *karmayoniḥ*, *las kyi skye gnas pa* (see Mvy [Sakaki 2315]). Also, the order in which the terms are presented differs from the Sanskrit editions, where *karmadāyāda* (see n.45) stands before *karmayoni* (Lévi 1932, p. 30; Kudo 2004, pp. 26 and 27).

**n.45** Again, the Tibetan differs from the standard terminology of Mvy (Sakaki 2314), which gives *las kyi bgo skal la spyod pa* for *karmadāyādaḥ*.

**n.46** Here, the expression “they take action as their refuge” means that action is the basis for beings’ destiny in the sense that actions determine who one is or who one will become. The Sanskrit reads *karmapratiśaraṇa* (Lévi 1932, p. 30; Kudo 2004, p. 26, MS[A]; p. 27, MS[B], has a lacuna here). See Mvy (Sakaki 2316): *karmapratisaraṇam* = *las brten par bya ba*. According to Edgerton, this is a *bahuvṛhi* compound (BHSD, s.v. “pratisaraṇa”). The entire phrase is well known from the Pāli Canon (MN III, 203,4–6): *Kammassakā, māṇava, sattā kammadāyādā kammayonī kammabandhū kammapaṭisaraṇā. Kammaṃ satte vibhajati yad idaṃ hīnappaṇītatāyāti*. See Bhikkhu Ñāṇamoli and Bhikkhu Bodhi 2009, p. 1053: “Student, beings are owners of their actions, heirs of their actions; they originate from their actions, are bound to their actions, have their actions as their refuge. It is action that distinguishes beings as inferior and superior.”

**n.47** The Sanskrit text first gives a list of all the categories that are to be analyzed and presented in detail in the main body of the text; see Lévi 1932, pp. 30–32. This list is absent in the Tibetan translation.

**n.48** The Sanskrit additionally reads “welcoming the death of an enemy” (*amitramaraṇābhinandanaṃ*) here.

**n.49** This very likely refers to the practice of abortion (Sanskrit *garbhaśātana*). However, we have opted for a more literal translation of the Tibetan.

**n.50** Our translation of this sentence largely follows the Sanskrit. The commentarial gloss on the Sanskrit reads as follows: “The children [lit. sons] and grandchildren of the originator of this sacrifice, as well as other people, hoping for a [positive, i.e., desired] result [of the ritual action of sacrifice] or filled with fear [i.e., of potential negative consequences of not performing the sacrifice], [will] kill many beings as they continue [this initial sacrifice]” (*tasya yajñapravartakasya putrāḥ pautrāś cānye ca janāḥ phalārthino bhayabhītāś cānuvṛttiṃ kurvāṇāḥ sattvān nirghātayanti*, Lévi 1932, p. 32; see Kudo 2004, pp. 36 and 37, with slightly different reading in MS[B] without, however, altering the meaning). The sense of repetition and thus establishing an act as a custom or tradition (*anuvṛttiṃ* √*kṛ*) is borne out by the illustrative story that follows.

**n.51** Following the reading of D: *sgos kyis* (see Jäschke 1972, s.vv. “sgos” and “phyir”). Y and K read *dgos kyis*?

**n.52** According to the Sanskrit, all editions of which read *yuddhadarśanaṃ* (Lévi 1932, p. 33; Kudo 2004, pp. 40 and 41). Tibetan reads *dmag* (“army” or “host”), the expected translation equivalent of which, according to Mvy, is the Sanskrit *senā*, etc.

**n.53** C reads *mang por dog pa*. If *dog pa* could be read as synonymous with *nyam nga* (“fear, despair; harm”), C should be read and the Degé reading corrected: “[Seeing] a sacrificial ground such as this is like a battle, seeing the fear and despair in the many beings, humans and horses, and so forth [that are going to be killed].”

**n.54** Lévi translates, “and furthermore congratulating the men engaged in battle on their equipment” (et aussi les félicitations à propos des armes, adressées à des gens en train de se batter; Lévi 1932, p. 112).

**n.55** See Kudo 2004, pp. 229–30, n. 2.

**n.56** The Sanskrit editions (Lévi 1932, p. 33; Kudo 2004, pp. 40 and 41) contain an additional passage that mentions ten evil consequences (“disadvantages”) of killing living beings (without listing them) and refer to the Nandikasūtra for the full list; for the complete passage in a surviving Skt. witness of a version of the *Nandikasūtra*, the *Āryanandikaparipṛcchāsūtra*, see Vinīta 2010, pp. 109–11.

**n.57** Translated according to Lévi’s conjecture of the Tibetan, which makes good sense; see Lévi 1932, p. 34, n. 2: *dmag la sogs par sngar smos pa thams cad bzlog pa ste* (“and having rejected/done the opposite of all that was said above regarding armies and so forth”). However, his conjecture (*smon pa* to *smos pa*) seems not to be backed by any edition of the Kangyur that we have consulted, i.e., Narthang (in Lévi 1932, p. 185), K, D, and the critical apparatus of the Comparative Edition.

**n.58** The Tibetan here, and throughout, has only two terms, *mchod rten* and *gtsug lag khang*, where the Sanskrit specifies three objects: *stūpa*, *caitya*, and *vihāra*. According to Mvy (Sakaki 6999, 7000), the Tibetan *mchod rten* should be used to translate both the Sanskrit *stūpa* and *caitya*. The Sanskrit word *caitya* can refer to a *stūpa*, but also to a shrine, a sacred place, or any sacred object. Thus, in addition to the place where the Buddha Śākyamuni attained awakening (the *bodhimaṇḍa*) and other sacred sites associated with the life of the Buddha, it can also designate non-Buddhist shrines or sacred sites (see Drewes 2007, p. 103).

**n.59** Tibetan *zhig cing ral ba* literally means “that which has dilapidated and/or was torn down.”

**n.60** A, D: *tshe ’phrog bdud* (literally, perhaps, “life-stealing demon”). This seems to be a gloss of the variations in Y, K, J, and N: *ye ’grog* and C: *ye ’brog*. According to Rolf A. Stein (see McKeown 2010, pp. 21, 34, 267, and specifically, 61–62), *ye ’brog*/*ye ’drog*/*yen ’brog* (the latter seemingly a phonetically influenced variant spelling) is Chinese vocabulary for *’dre gdon*, a kind of evil spirit, demon, or demonic force that causes premature death and misery. (For the translations “contagious disease,” “injury inflicted on the soul,” and “harm done to the mind,” see Jäschke [1972, s.v. “ye ’brog”], who gives Milarepa’s songs and oral explanation as his sources.) The Sanskrit reads *akālamṛtyur*, “premature death” (Lévi 1932, p. 34; Kudo 2004, pp. 42 and 43). Thus it seems likely that the explanatory gloss *tshe ’phrog bdud* refers to more or less specific demonic forces (the *’dre*) traditionally believed to steal the life force and cause sudden accidents and untimely death.

**n.61** According to the Tibetan. The Sanskrit does not mention anger.

**n.62** Reading Y and K: *de ni thal mo dang khu tshur gyis mi rteg pa dang*; D and other versions omit *mi*.

**n.63** This translation follows Lévi (1932, p. 37: “donner des remèdes et aussi des aliments digestibles”) and the Sanskrit *parijīrṇabhojanaṃ*. The Tibetan *kha zas zhu nas stobs pa* (literally “Having digested food, [they regain their] strength”) is not clear.

**n.64** The core meaning of the Sanskrit term *varṇa* (Tibetan *kha dog*) is “color.” In a particular sense (from as early as the *Ṛgveda*), it can mean the color of skin or complexion, thus the derived meanings of “species,” “class of people,” and “caste” (Mayrhofer 1976, p. 154, s.v. “várṇaḥ”). It seems that it can also refer to the general appearance or figure of a person, and it is this latter sense that is probably intended here. Lévi interprets the Sanskrit *durvarṇa* (Kudo 2004, p. 52) as “disgracieux” (Lévi 1932, p. 115). The following paragraph makes it clear that the Tibetan *mdzes* (“beautiful,” for *suvarṇa*) refers to a general physical feature or appearance. See also Lévi 1932, p. 37, n. 2, where he refers to plate 21 of Borobudur’s hidden base, which is inscribed with *virūpa* and shows representations of people with deformations.

**n.65** According to Mvy (Sakaki 1964), the translation equivalent of the Tibetan *’tshig pa* should be the Sanskrit *pradāsa*. Lévi prints the variant *pradāśaḥ* (Lévi 1932, pp. 37–38 and n. 2), but MS[A] has *paridādya*, which according to Kudo should be read as *paridāgha* (Kudo 2004, p. 52, n. 5). Edgerton prefers the reading *paridāgha* over *pradāsa* (see BHSD, s.v. “pradāsa”). Other Abhidharma lists of the *upakleśas* read *pradāśa*/*pradāsa* (see, e.g., Abhidh-k-bh 57,4 [= AKK II.27b] and 313,12 [= AKK V.50a]). *Pradāśa* (and its variants *pradāsa*/*paridāgha*) is a Buddhist Sanskrit word. Perhaps its etymological meaning, as reflected in the Tibetan translation *’tshig pa*, is “burnt” or “smolder(ing),” which may hint at an underlying feeling of suppressed or concealed anger. Kenjiu Kasawara’s translation of the *Dharmasaṃgraha* has “contentiousness” for *pradāśa* (see Müller and Wenzel 1885, no. 69: Sanskrit p. 14 [*pradāśa*]; English translation p. 50). Someone whose anger is “smoldering” beneath the surface may consequently be more quarrelsome, i.e., more easily given to animosity, malice, and spite. The word “contentiousness,” however, does not seem to hit the appropriate linguistic register.

**n.66** This translates the (lexicalized) variant reading *skyang nul* in Y and H (D: *rkyang nul*). See Jäschke 1972, s.v. “skyang nul.” The Sanskrit text reads *sudhādānaṃ*, “donating” (Kudo 2004, p. 52; Lévi 1932, p. 38; see also n.67).

**n.67** Tibetan *rdo thal* (“limestone,” “chalk,” or “ashes”). Sanskrit reads *stūpacaityagṛheṣu ca sudhādānaṃ*, which may suggest chalk or lime (*sudhā*). Lévi (1932, p. 115) translated, “donner du plâtre pour les stūpas, les maisons à caitya.” This sentence may refer to the practice of whitewashing a stūpa, a ceremony that can still be witnessed today in the Kathmandu valley at the stūpas of Svayambhūnāth and Bodhanāth.

**n.68** The Tibetan *sdug gu* here translates the Sanskrit *suvarṇa*, which can also mean “golden.”

**n.69** Tibetan *mthu chung ba*, Sanskrit *alpeśākhya*, Pāli *appesakkha* (*ttaṃ*). See Bhikkhu Bodhi’s translation “uninfluential” (Bhikkhu Ñāṇamoli and Bhikkhu Bodhi 2009, p. 1056). The Buddhist Sanskrit *alpeśākhya* (Pāli *appesakkha*) (see CPD, s.v. “appesakkha”; BHSD, s.v. “alpeśākhya”) originally means “unrespected, insignificant, of little esteem.” The scholarly consensus is that the Middle Indic form of the term is derived from an original Sanskrit form *alpa-*/*mahā-yaśas-ka*. Two forms are attested in the early Buddhist Sanskrit texts: *alpa-*/*mahāśakya* and *alpe-*/*maheśākhya*. The occurrence of either term can serve as an indicator of a text’s affiliation with the Sarvāstivādin or the Mūlasarvāstivādin school. The form *alpa-*/*mahāśakya* is surmised by Edgerton to have originated as a folk-etymological alteration of *alpe-*/*maheśākhya* (see BHSD, s.v. “mahāśakya”). The traditional analysis of the term, however, is *alpa-īśa-ākhya* (*maheśākhya* being an analogous formation), literally perhaps “named after an insignificant chief or master, of low origin” (Apte, s.v. “alpa-”). This meaning is reflected in the standardized Tibetan translation given in Mvy (Sakaki 6412): *dbang chung bar grags pa*.

**n.70** Sanskrit *dharmahīne*, Tibetan *chos ngan pa*. The Tibetan expression is usually translated as “inferior doctrines.” Here, the Sanskrit equivalent seems rather to imply that something or someone *outside* of Dharma is referred to (see pw, s.vv, “a-dharma,” “dharma-hīna”).

**n.71** The Sanskrit (Kudo 2004, p. 56) reads *parasya yaśovarṇṇaśabdaślokaśravanena* [*sic*] *tuṣṭiḥ* (“being gratified when hearing about others’ glory, praise, renown, and good reputation”). The Tibetan *gzhan gyi grags dang sgra dang tshig su bcad pa snyan pa thos na* seems not to have translated Sanskrit *varṇa* (“praise, renown, glory”; Tibetan *brjod pa*) here, while in later paragraphs we find the list extended by *brjod pa* (“praise”). See 1.165 (*grags pa dang brjod pa dang sgra dang tshigs su bcad pa*), 1.172 (*brjod pa dang / sgra dang tshigs su bcad pa*), and 1.173 (*grags pa dang / brjod pa dang / sgra dang tshigs su bcad pa*). This variation in translating a stock phrase supports the assumption that the extant text of the *Karmavibhaṅga* is a text that grew over time, i.e., passages and paragraphs were added on at different times. Nonetheless, *grags pa* can translate both the Sanskrit *yaśas* and *varṇa*, which indeed share the same sense (“praise, renown, glory”) in Sanskrit.

**n.72** We have supplied the word “commemoration” here to form an intelligible English sentence. The Tibetan reads, “Erecting a stūpa of/for the Bhagavān” (*bcom ldan ’das kyi mchod rten … brtsigs pa*). The Sanskrit expresses a causative sense (-*kārāpaṇa*, “causing to be built”): “commissioning the building of shrines and stūpas [in commemoration] of the Bhagavān” (*bhagavānaś caityastūpakārāpaṇaṃ*).

**n.73** According to the Tibetan reading of D. Neither the Tibetan (*dge ba’i rtsa ba thams cad kyis mthu chen por sems bskyed pa ste*) nor the corresponding Sanskrit (*sarvamaheśākhyakuśalamūlaṃ bodhicittotpādanaṃ*; Kudo 2004, p. 56—we have normalized Kudo’s transcription of the Sanskrit manuscript MS[A]) are clear. The Tibetan has only *sems bskyed pa* (*cittotpāda*), instead of *byang chub kyi sems bskyed pa* for *bodhicittotpādana*, and the syntax is parallel to the immediately preceding sentence (i.e., *mthu chen po* + *la-don* followed by *sems bskyed pa*). The Tibetan of D here seems to have preserved the better reading. The Sanskrit *bodhicittotpādana* does not make much sense in this context, and we think that *bodhi*- is a later addition. Lévi (1932, p. 39) edited the Sanskrit to read *sarvamaheśākhyakuśalamūle bodhicittotpādanaṃ* (Lévi’s copy seems to have read *sarvamaheśākhyakuśalamūle* instead of -*mūlaṃ*) and translated as “produire la Pensée de toutes les Racines-de-bien qui font les grands personnages” (to produce the thought [of awakening] from all the roots of good which make (the) great persons). However, Lévi (1932, p. 39, n. 4) refers to bas-relief 43 of the hidden base of the Borobudur, which bears the inscription *maheśākhya* (“distinguished, exalted, eminent, powerful”) and portrays a life of luxury. For a similar idea, see verse 18, chapter 31 of the *Prajñāpāramitāratnaguṇasaṃcayagāthā* (Yuyama 1976, p. 128: *tatu vardhate kuśala–mūla mahānubhāvo candro v’ an-abhru prabha-maṇḍala śukla-pakṣo*, and the Tibetan translation of it in the Dunhuang recension: *de-las dge-ba’i rtsa-ba mthu-chen ’phel ’gyur-te/ /sprin med zla ba yar ngo’i ’od kyi dkyil ’khor bzhin* (Yuyama 1976, p. 190) (“From that his wholesome root grows into something of great might; As the moon, in the absence of cloud, is a circle of radiant light in the bright half of the lunar month”; translation Conze 1975, p. 70). Z reads *dge ba’i rtsa ba chung ngu rgyun mi gcod pa dang / dge ba’i rtsa ba chen po yang dag par ’dzin du ’jug pa’o* (“Not interrupting the continuous accumulation of lesser (or small? *chung ngu*) roots of merit; causing [someone] to take up/engage in the [accumulation of the] greater roots of merit”). It is not clear to us, however, what the lesser and greater roots of merit would be. See the extant Central Asian Sanskrit fragment from Eastern Turkestan (the *Śukasūtra*; Lévi 1932, pp. 235–36): [*mahā-*]*śakyāt kuśalamūlād vicchandanam alpaśakyānāṁ pudgalānāṁ paribhavaḥ* (“discouraging [*vicchandana*; for this Buddhist Sanskrit word, see Wogihara 1971, p. 37 and Mvy (Sakaki 6527): *vicchandyati*] [someone] from [accumulating] powerful roots of merit; having contempt for persons with little power”). In any case, the passage seems to point to the idea of dedicating one’s accumulated merit to the attainment of worldly happiness, wealth, and greatness with which comes worldly power and authority.

**n.74** Tibetan *rim gro* is generally translated as “respect” or “honor.” Here, however, the meaning “to serve” or “to attend on” can be confirmed by the corresponding Sanskrit (*a-*)*pratyupaṣṭhānaṃ* in MS[A] (Kudo 2004, p. 58), used here in its meaning as found in the Pāli suttas: *paccupaṭṭhāna* (“tending to”). See PED, s.v.; BHSD, s.v. “pratyupasthāna (2).”

**n.75** This sūtra has not been identified. A similar passage, however, can be found in the Pāli Aṅguttara Nikāya of the Sutta Piṭaka (AN III, 244–45). See Kudo 2004, p. 240, n. 10; Lévi 1932, p. 40, n. 3.

**n.76** According to the Tibetan, which uses *grong* (“village”) in the first sentence and *rigs* (= Sanskrit *kula*) in the following sentences. The Sanskrit (Lévi 1932, p. 40; Kudo 2004, p. 60) reads *kula* (“family, household, house community”). In Old and Classical Sanskrit, the term refers to all the people with whom one shares meals (German *Speisegemeinschaft*), which in traditional societies may exceed the modern, so-called (nuclear) family; thus we have opted for “community.”

**n.77** The Tibetan longs spyod chung ba literally means “(having) few possessions/little wealth.”

**n.78** The Tibetan ma byin par len pa (Sanskrit adattādāna) literally means “taking what was not given.”

**n.79** The Sanskrit has only tadabhyanumodanam, “taking pleasure in stealing” (Kudo 2004, p. 60). An alternative translation of the Tibetan may be “taking pleasure in stolen goods” (ma byin par blangs pas dga’ ba).

**n.80** The Tibetan reads shes rab chung ba. The Tibetan translation equivalent of the Sanskrit duṣprajña prescribed by the Mvy is shes rab ’chal ba “misconception, wrong understanding” (see Mvy [Sakaki 2470]).

**n.81** According to the Sanskrit, which adds paṇḍitān (Kudo 2004, pp. 64 and 65, MS[A] and MS[B], respectively; Lévi 1932, p. 41).

**n.82** This sentence (chos ma yin pa ni gang yin) is missing in Y, J, K, N, and C.

**n.83** The Sanskrit reads, “What is Dharma/right? Practicing which Dharma promotes happiness?” (Lévi 1932, p. 41: ko dharmaḥ kiṃ dharmaṃ kurvataḥ śreyaskaram iti; Kudo 2004, pp. 64 and 65).

**n.84** This translates the variant reading sten in Y, J, K, and N. D has bston, which seems to be corroborated by the Sanskrit (both MS[A] and MS[B]; Kudo 2004, pp. 64 and 65, respectively) sevati (“to stay/remain with someone”; “to associate with someone”).

**n.85** This is a free translation of the Tibetan ’jungs pa’i sems yod pas, corresponding to the Sanskrit abhiniveśa in the extant Sanskrit editions.

**n.86** D reads glegs bam ’dri ba. The better reading is perhaps that of Y and K: bri ba.

**n.87** According to the Tibetan (yongs su ’dri phod pa). The Sanskrit term paripṛcchakajātīyaḥ “inclined to inquire/ a questioner” occurs in the *Aṣṭasāhasrikā Prajñāpāramitā*, published on the website *Bibliotheca Polyglotta* by the University of Oslo, accessed December 6, 2019. See also Gareth Sparham, trans., The Perfection of Wisdom in Eighteen Thousand Lines (84000: Translating the Words of the Buddha, 2022).

**n.88** According to the Sanskrit of MS[B] (Kudo 2004, p. 69): dharmabhāṇakānāṃ vaiśāradyaṃ varṇṇayati. MS[A] (Kudo 2004, p. 68) reads varddhaya{ṃ}ti, which according to Kudo (2004, p. 68, n. 10) is a scribal error for varṇṇayanti. The Tibetan chos smra ba rnams la mi ’jigs pa nye bar sgrub pa dang does seems to be a standard translation of the Sanskrit; nye bar sgrub suggests some form of the Sanskrit upa + √hṛ (see Mvy [Sakaki 6395]: upasaṃhāra).

**n.89** Sanskrit sahita literally means “connected, sensible, coherent, reasonable” (see BHSD, s.v. “sahita”: “of speech, *connected*, *coherent*, *sensible*”), which seems to be the sense chosen by the Tibetan translators. The Sanskrit could also be interpreted as “one applauds/acclaims those who speak what is beneficial/good [for others] (sa-hita), and one avoids those who speak what is unbeneficial/not good (a-hita) [for others]” (sahitabhāṣiṇāṃ sādhukāraṃ dadāti | ahitabhāṣiṇaḥ pariharati according to the emended Sanskrit version in Kudo 2004, p. 69, MS[B]). Lévi (1932, p. 44, n. 6) records saṁhitabhāṣitānām; according to Kudo’s new transliteration of MS[A], however, the part up to hita- is illegible in the manuscript (Kudo 2004, p. 68).

**n.90** Translating Y and K smad pa instead of dmod pa (D and other Kangyur versions).

**n.91** For “ink,” reading N, U, and H snag tsha instead of D snag tsa. D reads glegs bam dang snag tsa dang smyug gu la sogs pa’i sbyin pa byed pa, which faithfully (except that it has glegs bam, translating pustaka, first) renders the Sanskrit masīpustakalekhanīpradādāni dadāti (according to Lévi 1932, p. 44; MS[A] and MS[B] [Kudo 2004, pp. 68 and 69], give the same reading), “making gifts of ink, books (or leaves of birch bark?), and reed pens.” For the loanwords masi and pustaka, see Falk 1993, pp. 241 and 305–6 (pustaka [“skin”] perhaps meant tree bark).

**n.92** For identification of the *Nandikasūtra* (Toh 334), see Kudo 2004, p. 230, n. 3; p. 233, n. 6; and p. 240, n. 13. For an English translation of the Tibetan version of the *Nandikasūtra*, see The Sūtra of Nandika (Toh 334). For an edition and English translation of the extant Skt. witness, the *Āryanandikaparipṛcchāsūtra*, see Vinīta 2010, pp. 97–114.

**n.93** MS[A] instead mentions forty faults of drinking alcohol (catvārīṃśad ādīnavāḥ madyadoṣāḥ; Kudo 2004, p. 70). The Tibetan follows MS[B].

**n.94** According to the Sanskrit akuśalapakṣeṇa (Lévi 1932, p. 44; Kudo 2004, pp. 70 and 71: MS[A] akuśalapakṣena; MS[B] akuśalapathe). The Tibetan reads dge ba’i phyogs su, which corresponds to kuśalapakṣeṇa (or -pakṣe?), instead of akuśalapakṣeṇa in the Sanskrit. This refers to the section below which starts with the sentence, “Regarding the loss of mindfulness induced by drinking beer made from fermented barley and other intoxicating liquors…”

**n.95** According to the Tibetan, which omits the Sanskrit akriyādṛṣṭiḥ (Lévi 1932, p. 44; Kudo 2004, pp. 70 and 71: MS[B] furthermore adds asatkriyāvādaḥ).

**n.96** According to the Sanskrit matsarivādaḥ (“one who speaks with hostility”). The Tibetan reads ser sna che ba, which one might literally translate as “(having) strong jealousy” or “great with regard to jealousy,” although that does not fit the context of the hell realms here. Edgerton’s definition in BSHD, s.v. “matsarin,” does not seem to apply here: “(Skt. id., Pali maccharin), in deśanā-°riṇaś ca Mv i.90.3, of backsliding would-be Bodhisattvas, prob. *resentful of religious instruction*.”

**n.97** This well-established “Buddhist Hybrid English” term translates Tibetan (dud ’gro’i) skye gnas su, which renders Sanskrit (tiryag-)yoni, “mode/realm of existence” (German Daseinsform; see pw, s.v. “yoni”). As an alternative, one may perhaps translate this as “rebirth as an animal” or “rebirth in the animal kingdom.”

**n.98** Sanskrit akalpikapradānam, Tibetan tshul dang mi ’dra (the translation equivalent of the antonym tshul dang ’dra ba according to Mvy (Sakaki 7073) is Sanskrit sārūpya): a gift that would *not* be appropriate with respect to the status and/or vows of its recipient.

**n.99** According to the Sanskrit avahasana, which means to make fun of someone by either laughing about/ridiculing or mocking a person’s ailment, condition, or disability. The Tibetan here reads phyas byed pa “to reproach, blame.”

**n.100** According to the Sanskrit *kukkurravratika* (Kudo 2004, p. 73). The Tibetan, strangely, reads *bya’i brtul zhugs can* (“observing a bird vow”), which is most probably a mistake in the manuscript or due to a misreading on the part of the translators, who read *kukkuṭa* (“cock”) instead of *kukkura* (“dog”) in the Sanskrit original. The “ox ascetics” and “dog ascetics” are well known from the Pāli Canon (see for example the *Kukkuravatikasutta* of the Majjhima Nikāya, no. 57; Bhikkhu Ñāṇamoli and Bhikkhu Bodhi 2009, pp. 493–97).

**n.101** According to the Tibetan. The Sanskrit reads *atra*, probably in the sense of “there” or “in that direction” (see Apte, s.v. “atra”; Lévi 1932, p. 44): *atropapadyeyam iti*. This appears to be a (deliberately?) warped understanding of these penance practices, the goal of which, according to the *Kukkurravatikasutta* (MN 57; Bhikkhu Ñāṇamoli and Bhikkhu Bodhi 2009, pp. 493–97), seems to have been rebirth in heaven.

**n.102** According to the Sanskrit, which reads *avadānaṃ*. The Tibetan has *ched du brjod* instead (= Sanskrit *uddāna*; see BHSD, s.v.). All available Sanskrit editions read *avadānaṃ*, Tibetan *rtogs par brjod pa* (see Lévi 1932, p. 44; Kudo 2004, pp. 72 and 73). The *avadāna*s are illustrative moral stories of the former rebirths of the Bodhisattva Siddhārtha Gautama before becoming a buddha, in addition to the stories of other bodhisattvas.

**n.103** According to the Sanskrit. The translation of the following story follows the Tibetan. According to Kudo’s and Lévi’s notes, this story is not found in any of the known jātaka or avadāna collections (see Lèvi 1932, p. 44, n. 13; Kudo 2004, p. 247, n. 17). However, some version of it seems to be contained in Buddhaghosa’s commentary on the *Gopakamoggallānasutta* (MN 108) of the Majjhima Nikāya, *Majjhimanikāyāṭṭhakathā* (*Majjhimanikāya-atthakathā* II, 854; see also DPPN, s.v. “Vassakāra”). Here, the minister Vassakāra sees the elder Mahākassapa walking down the slope of Vulture Peak, when he makes the derogatory remark that the elder Mahākassapa looked like a monkey climbing down the hill. The Buddha reprimands him for having said this and adds that he may be reborn as a monkey if he does not apologize to the elder.

**n.104** According to the Tibetan, which leaves out *ṛṣigiriparśvaṃ parvvataṃ* (MS[A], MS[B]: *girmakaparvataṃ*) but otherwise corresponds almost literally to the Sanskrit (see Kudo 2004, pp. 72 and 73, respectively): “The brahmin Varṣākāra saw the elder Mahākāśyapa in the sky above the city of Rājagṛha, flying from Vulture Peak to the Mount of the Seers.”

**n.105** The Sanskrit literally says, “he committed a wrongdoing with his speech” (*vāgduścaritaṃ kṛtam*).

**n.106** According to the Tibetan. The Sanskrit reads, “When Varṣākāra learned that the Bhagavān had said that during five hundred lives he would certainly be reborn as a monkey, he became upset and developed faith [in the Buddha]” (*tatas tena Varṣākāreṇa śrutaṃ Bhagavānā nirdiṣṭas tvaṃ kila pañca janmāntaraśatāni markaṭo bhaviṣyatīti, sa saṃvignacittam prasāditavān*; Sanskrit text according to Lévi’s emendation and MS[A]: Lévi 1932, p. 45; Kudo 2004, pp. 72 and 74).

**n.107** This specification is unclear. No known story of the Buddha’s *parinirvāṇa* contains this episode.

**n.108** According to the Tibetan, which reads “where” (*gang du*). The Sanskrit reads “when” (*kadā*) in all editions.

**n.109** The Sanskrit text of MS[B] adds “karmic ripening (of this deed)” (*vipākaḥ*; Kudo 2004, p. 75). Degé reads *bcom ldan ’das sug las de gang du bas par ’gyur zhes zhus pa dang*. The compound *sug las* (literally “manual work/labor,” “toil,” etc., in the sense of making or carrying out something with one’s own hands) does not seem to fit this context. We have translated it here as “deed” in accordance with its context (see the term *karmabhūmi*, Negi, s.v. “sug las kyi dog sa”). For *bas par ’gyur* (= Sanskrit *kṣīyate*) as an old Tibetan expression for *zad pa*, see Martin 2003, s.v. “bas pa.”

**n.110** According to the Sanskrit of MS[B]. The Tibetan interpretation of this passage is not entirely clear. This sentence is possibly corrupt. See Lévi 1932, p. 45, n. 16. The Sanskrit reads *bhagavān āha. tāny eva pañca janmāntaraśatāni kiṃ tu rājagṛhe utpatsyase yathā* [MS[B]: *yayā*] *jambvā jambudvīpe jāyate* [MS[A], MS[B]: *jñāyate*] *yatroṣṭrikāmātrāṇi phalāni, yathā kṣaudramadhv aneḍakam evamāsvādāni. tatropapattir bhaviṣyati* (Lévi 1932, p. 45; Kudo 2004, pp. 74 and 75). That the Rose-Apple Continent (i.e., the known human world or, more specifically, the Indian subcontinent) derives its name from the rose-apple tree(s) growing there is a well-known trope. The Tibetan here seems to say, “The Bhagavān said, ‘Through/after these five hundred lives [your karma] will be exhausted. For a short time, however, when [the jambu–?] tree in Jambudvīpa carries approximately five hundred fruits called *jambū*, which are sweet like honey and irresistibly tasty, you will be reborn there.” This Tibetan interpretation perhaps followed a Sanskrit version that read *yadā* instead of *yathā*, and *jāyate* instead of *jñāyate*.

**n.111** According to the Sanskrit. The Tibetan reads, “Then, having been reborn in Rājagṛha and died there, you will be liberated and reborn in heaven.” Lévi’s translation (1932, p. 120) of the whole section reads, “During five hundred births, you will be born in Rājagṛha; as the jambū is born only in the Jambudvīpa, where the fruit is the size of an uṣṭrikā pot, and its flavor is like that of clarified bee honey, this is where you will be born. Then you will part from there and have a good rebirth [in heaven]. (This is how the impiety of thought arises among lions.) And it is on this subject that the Most Holy pronounced this stanza.” (Pendant cinq cents naissances, tu naîtras a Rājagṛha; comme le jambū ne naît que dans le Jambudvīpa; là où les fruits ont la taille d’une cruche uṣṭrikā, et que leur saveur est comme celle du miel d’abeilles clarifié, c’est là que tu naîtras. Ensuite tu te relèveras et tu auras une bonne Destination. [C’est ainsi que l’impiété de la pensée fait naître parmi les lions.] Et c’est à ce sujet que le Très Saint a prononce cette stance.)

**n.112** This is our tentative interpretation of the Tibetan. It is unclear what exactly this sentence refers to, but it may allude to the *Siṃhajātaka* mentioned above, in which the Bodhisattva is born as a lion (Haribhaṭṭa’s *Jātakamālā* contains a *Siṃhajātaka*, but it does not contain this verse). The Sanskrit editions of the *Karmavibhaṅga* print this sentence as belonging to the story of Varṣākāra’s rebirth as a monkey and thus to the Bhagavān’s speech. However, we fail to see the logical connection between this (or the following stanza) and the foregoing narrative. Furthermore, in the Tibetan the sentence starts with *dper na* (“for example”), which is regularly employed in the *Karmavibhaṅga* to introduce a scriptural quotation, an illustrative story, or a simile, and the Tibetan sentence is clearly signaled to end before *dper na* with *zhes gsungs pa lta bu* (“like that it was/is said”). Even Lévi’s translation is unfortunately not very helpful here: “C’est ainsi que l’impiété de la pensée fait naître parmi les lions” (Lévi 1932, p. 120; see also n.111).

**n.113** The Sanskrit of this verse (Lévi 1932, p. 46; Kudo 2004, pp. 74 and 75) is identical with a verse from the *Udānavarga*: *dīrghā jāgarato rātrir dīrghaṃ śrāntasya yojanam / dīrgho bālasya saṃsāraḥ saddharmam avijānataḥ* (Uv I.19 = *Patna-Dharmapada* 185 = *Dhammapada* 60). The Tibetan translated here, however, differs from the Tibetan *Udānavarga* (*ched du brjod pa’i tshoms*) translation, *Chapters of Utterances on Specific Topics*:

> /*mel tse byed la mtshan mo ring* / /*lam gyis dub la rgyang grags ring* //*dam chos rnam par mi shes pa’i*/ /*byis pa rnams la ’khor ba ring* /

**n.114** According to the Sanskrit. The Tibetan reading *gshin rje’i ’jig rten* is confirmed by MS[A], which reads *yamalokaḥ*. Lévi (1932, p. 46) has adopted the reading of MS[A]. The Sanskrit of MS[B], however, reads *pretaloka*, which seems to be an alternative term for *yamaloka* (see also Tom Tillemans, trans., *Questions Regarding Death and Transmigration*, Toh 308 [84000: Translating the Words of the Buddha, 2019], ). The inhabitants of the realm of the dead are also often designated “ghosts”; however, this particular translation is possibly more specific to a Chinese Buddhist cultural context. We have here opted for the translation “ghosts” because we see a cultural parallel in the Western concept of ghosts, but readers should keep in mind that this is the translator’s interpretation and that there are also important differences between Western and Buddhist notions of supernatural beings.

**n.115** Tibetan *ngan du spyad* seems to be a nonstandard rendition of Sanskrit *duścarita*. Mvy (Sakaki 1682) lists Tibetan *nyes pa spyad pa* as the translation equivalent.

**n.116** English translation adopted from Edgerton; see BHSD, s.v. “mithyājīva.”

**n.117** The title of this unidentified work is according to the Sanskrit versions. The Tibetan reads *brgya bsdus pa’i mdo* (**Śatavargasūtra*?). Lévi (1932, p. 97, n. 9) identified a partial correspondence of this citation in a passage of the Pāli *Mahākammavibhaṅgasutta* (MN III, 214–15). See also Kudo 2004, p. 248, n. 20.

**n.118** Tentative translation. Presumably, the reader is supposed to supply “…leads to rebirth in the realm of ghosts.” The quotation nevertheless remains cryptic, and its connection to the theme of the paragraph is unclear.

**n.119** MS[B] (Kudo 2004, p. 77) reads *apamāna* (“contempt, disregard”; German *Verachtung*, *Gerinschätzung*; see pw, s.v.) and furthermore adds *adhimāna* (“conceit”; the Tibetan translation equivalent would be *lhag pa’i nga rgyal* but is omitted in the Tibetan), which is defined as lying about one’s spiritual accomplishments and constitutes a very grave offence according to the Vinaya.

**n.120** Tibetan *nga’o zhes pa’i nga rgyal* literally means “the conceit ‘I [am].’ ” Mvy (Sakaki 1949) lists the variant *nga’o snyam pa’i nga rgyal* as standard translation equivalent for the Sanskrit *asmimāna*. This is defined as the pride of identifying with the five *skandha*s (psycho-physical aggregates that constitute the empirical person) and regarding them as “self” and “mine” based on false views.

**n.121** According to the Tibetan *chung ba’i nga rgyal*. The Sanskrit translation equivalent would be *ūnamāna* (see Mvy [Sakaki 1951], where the prescribed translation equivalent for Sanskrit *ūnamāna* is *cung zad snyam pa’i nga rgyal*. *Ūnamāna*, according to Vasubandhu (with Sthiramati’s commentary; see Jacobi 1932, pp. 33–4, commentary on *Triṃśikā*, v. 12a), conveys the following meaning: when encountering a person who far outshines one’s own moral and other qualities, one downplays the difference by saying that one is only slightly inferior to that person. The Sanskrit in all editions instead has *mithyāmāna*, “hypocrisy” (Lévi 1932, p. 47; Kudo 2004, pp. 76 and 77). Furthermore, we have here followed the Tibetan text’s listing of four different kinds of pride instead of the Sanskrit version’s five. MS[A]: *mānaḥ*, *abhimānaḥ*, *adhimānaḥ*, *asmimānaḥ*, *mithyāmānaḥ*; MS[B]: *mānaḥ*, *apamānaḥ* (or *alpamānaḥ*? see Lévi 1932, p. 47, n. 1), *adhimānaḥ*, *asmiṃmānaḥ* [*sic*], *mithyāmānaḥ* (Kudo 2004, pp. 76 and 77, respectively). For definitions of the different kinds of pride enumerated in Abhidharma literature, see Abhidh-k-bh ad V.10a = Abhidh-k-bh(P), 284,23–285,18): *sapta mānāḥ māno ’timāno mānātimāno ’smimāno ’bhimāna ūnamāno mithyāmānaśca*, etc. See also Sthiramati’s commentary on Vasubandhu’s *Triṃśikā*, v. 12a (Jacobi 1932), which mentions *mānaḥ*, *atimānaḥ*, *asmimānaḥ*, *abhimānaḥ*, *ūnamānaḥ*, *mithyāmānaḥ*.

**n.122** According to the Sanskrit. The Tibetan leaves out *asuralokopapatti* [*-pariṇāmitaṃ*] (Lévi 1932, p. 47; Kudo 2004, pp. 76 and 77) and just reads *der* “[transfer to] there.”

**n.123** The Tibetan literally means “taking what was not offered or given.”

**n.124** Tibetan here translates very literally: *gzhan gyi nor la chags sems su byed pa* (“coveting others’ possessions”). The standardized translation according to Mvy (Sakaki 1696) is *brnab sems*.

**n.125** According to the Tibetan. The Sanskrit text instead positively states the cultivation of the ten virtuous actions as the cause for rebirth as a human and, unlike the Tibetan, qualifies the extent to which the ten virtuous actions have been cultivated, namely, only weakly or halfheartedly (*mandabhāvita*) (see Lévi 1932, p. 47; Kudo 2004, pp. 76 and 77; MS[B] in fact reads *abhāvita*, which is explained by Kudo as “scribal error for *subhāvita*”). The Sanskrit does not list the ten virtuous courses of action but merely states, “the threefold bodily actions, the fourfold vocal actions, and the threefold mental actions.”

**n.126** The Sanskrit translation equivalent for the Tibetan *’dod pa’i khams* is *kāmadhātu* (see Mvy [Sakaki 3072]). The Sanskrit manuscripts, however, have *kāmāvacara* instead (see Kudo 2004, pp. 78 and 79). The Tibetan *’dod pa’i khams na spyod pa’i lha* would translate to Sanskrit as *kāmadhātvāvacaradeva*, which literally means “a deva whose sphere/range of activity/action is the realm of desire (*kāmadhātu*).”

**n.127** An alternative translation of Tibetan *nam mkha’ mtha’ yas so snyam nas* may be “experiencing that space is infinite,” since conceptualization, and thus thought, is said to be suspended in these meditative states.

**n.128** The Sanskrit editions only list the names of the four formless absorptions of the formless realm without their standard descriptions, which the Tibetan translation provides (see Lévi 1932, p. 47; Kudo 2004, pp. 78 and 79). Mvy (Sakaki 1492–95) gives the following as Sanskrit equivalents of the module describing the formless attainments: *sa sarvaśo rūpasaṃjñānāṃ samatikramāt pratighasaṃjñānām astaṃgamān nānātvasaṃjñānām amanasikārād anantam ākāśam ity ākāśānantyāyatanam upasaṃpadya viharati*. For an alternative rendering/interpretation, especially of the first of the four formless absorptions, see Karen Liljenberg, trans., *The Question of Maitreya (1)*, Toh 85 (84000: Translating the Words of the Buddha, 2016), 1.20.

**n.129** This sentence corresponds to the Sanskrit *sa sarvaśa ākāśānantyāyatanaṃ samatikramyānantaṃ vijñānam iti vijñānānantyāyatanam upasaṃpadya viharati* (Mvy [Sakaki 1493]).

**n.130** This sentence corresponds to the Sanskrit *sa sarvaśo vijñānānantyāyatanaṃ samatikramya nāsti kiṃcid ity ākiṃcanyāyatanam upasaṃpadya viharati* (Mvy [Sakaki 1494]).

**n.131** This sentence corresponds to the Sanskrit *sa sarvaśo ākiṃcanyāyatanaṃ samatikramya naivasaṃjñānāsaṃjñāyatanam upasaṃpadya viharati* (Mvy [Sakaki 1495]).

Continued in part 2: https://84000.co/translation/toh338/part-2.md
