---
title: "Transformation of Karma"
toh: "Toh 339"
sanskrit_title: "Karmavibhaṅga"
tibetan_title: "las kyi rnam par ’gyur ba"
canon_section: "Kangyur › Discourses › General Sūtra Section"
url: https://84000.co/translation/toh339
published: 2021-02-25
collections: []
publisher: "84000: Translating the Words of the Buddha"
translation_team: "Bruno Galasek-Hul and team"
translators: ["Bruno Galasek-Hul"]
license: "CC BY-NC-ND 4.0"
license_url: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
citation: "Transformation of Karma (Karmavibhaṅga, Toh 339). Translated by Bruno Galasek-Hul and team. Online publication. 84000: Translating the Words of the Buddha, 2021. https://84000.co/translation/toh339."
part: 1
parts: 3
generated: 2026-11-16
---

# Transformation of Karma

Toh 339 · Kangyur › Discourses › General Sūtra Section · An 84000 translation · Read online: https://84000.co/translation/toh339

> **License:** [CC BY-NC-ND 4.0](https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/). This work is provided under the protection of a Creative Commons CC BY-NC-ND (Attribution - Non-commercial - No-derivatives) 4.0 copyright. It may be copied or printed for fair use, but only with full attribution, and not for commercial advantage or personal compensation. **Cite as:** Transformation of Karma (Karmavibhaṅga, Toh 339). Translated by Bruno Galasek-Hul and team. Online publication. 84000: Translating the Words of the Buddha, 2021. https://84000.co/translation/toh339.

> This is the plain-text edition of https://84000.co/translation/toh339. Passage labels (for example 1.2 or i.3) match the online edition. Each label is followed by the passage's permanent ID in square brackets, and by a Toh number when the passage belongs to one Toh only, for example **1.2** [ID] or **i.3** [ID, toh339]. To link to a passage, use https://84000.co/entity/passage/ID?toh=TOH, with TOH = toh339 when no Toh is given. Note numbers in square brackets (such as [n.3]) point to the Notes section. When quoting, cite 84000, *Transformation of Karma* (Toh 339), with the passage label and its link. The summary, introduction and notes are by the translators and are not part of the translated text.

## Parts of this text

This text is long, so its plain-text edition is split into 3 parts. Each part keeps 84000's passage labels and ends with the notes its passages refer to. The whole text in one file: https://84000.co/translation/toh339/full.md

- [Part 1](https://84000.co/translation/toh339.md): Summary, Acknowledgments, Introduction, The Translation (1.1–1.20)
- [Part 2](https://84000.co/translation/toh339/part-2.md): The Translation, Abbreviations (1.21–1.92)
- [Part 3](https://84000.co/translation/toh339/part-3.md): Glossary

## At a glance

> Machine-generated overview: written by AI from 84000's published summary and introduction, not yet reviewed by an 84000 editor. It is not part of the translation; quote the translation itself.

**In brief:** Transformation of Karma (Toh 339), with the Sanskrit title Karmavibhaṅga, is a sūtra belonging to the General Sūtra section of the Kangyur's Discourses. The text is set in Śrāvastī, at Prince Jeta's grove, where the Buddha is staying with an assembly of twelve hundred fifty monks. A brahmin youth named Śuka, son of Taudeya, visits the Buddha and asks why living beings appear in such great diversity — differing in lifespan, health, beauty, wealth, and knowledge of the Dharma. The Buddha's answer forms the core of the text: individual actions and their karmic ripening are the reason for this diversity. He teaches fifty-one categories of negative and positive actions alongside their consequences, covering the range from rebirth in unfortunate states through the benefits of wholesome conduct. The text also sets out ten negative consequences for each of the five precepts when transgressed, and explains the advantages gained through worshiping a caitya — a reliquary monument — and through generosity, religious life, and the development of confidence.

**Why read it:** This text offers a systematic and detailed account of how specific actions lead to specific consequences, including how intention and remorse can shape karmic outcomes, presented as a direct teaching by the Buddha in response to a single question.

### What question does Śuka ask the Buddha, and why does it matter?

In Transformation of Karma, the brahmin youth Śuka asks the Buddha to explain why living beings appear in such diversity — why some have long or short lives, are healthy or ill, beautiful or ugly, wealthy or poor, and more or less knowledgeable about the Dharma. This question sets up the entire discourse, in which the Buddha explains that individual actions and their karmic ripening are the cause of this diversity among beings.

### What are the main teachings covered in Transformation of Karma?

The Buddha teaches fifty-one categories of negative and positive actions together with their consequences. He then lists ten negative consequences for transgressing each of the five precepts — abstaining from taking life, stealing, sexual misconduct, lying, and consuming intoxicants. Finally, he explains the advantages of building and worshiping a caitya, making offerings, living a secluded religious life, becoming a Buddhist mendicant, and developing confidence.

### What group of texts does Transformation of Karma belong to, and what is distinctive about that group?

Transformation of Karma belongs to the Karmavibhaṅga or Śukasūtra class of Buddhist scriptures. These texts deal extensively with karma and rebirth according to individuals' actions, and are characterized by detailed, catalog-like listings of specific karmic consequences alongside their causative actions. The group appears to have been particularly popular in Central Asia and in China, where multiple translations were made over several centuries.

### What does the Sanskrit title Karmavibhaṅga mean, and how does it relate to the Tibetan title of this text?

The Sanskrit title Karmavibhaṅga uses the word vibhaṅga, which in Buddhist literature means 'explanation' or 'exposition' in the sense of offering detailed elucidation of items in a list. The Tibetan title las kyi rnam par 'gyur ba, by contrast, would suggest a Sanskrit word meaning 'transformation' or 'change.' The translators followed the transliterated Sanskrit title given in the text itself, partly to highlight this text's kinship with the longer related text Toh 338.

### How does Transformation of Karma treat the question of determinism in relation to karma?

The text does not present karmic cause and effect as strict determinism. In several places, Transformation of Karma notes that the presence or absence of intention and remorse are factors that can determine whether a particular karmic result will be experienced, whether its outcome can be influenced, and whether it can be avoided altogether. This nuance distinguishes the text's treatment of karma from a purely mechanical account of cause and effect.

### Who translated Transformation of Karma into English for 84000, and what earlier translation existed?

The 84000 English translation of Transformation of Karma was made by Bruno Galasek-Hul, working from the Tibetan text of the Degé edition, and was first published in 2021. The translation notes the existence of a pioneering French translation by the Sanskritist and Orientalist Léon Feer in 1883, described as the first translation of this text into a European language, though Feer did not have access to the range of comparative materials available today.

### Is a Sanskrit source text for Toh 339 available to translators?

No complete Sanskrit version of Transformation of Karma is extant. A Sanskrit manuscript fragment from Central Asia, the Śukasūtra, exhibits a family likeness to Toh 339 but is not an exact match. Translators consulted this and other Sanskrit witnesses, as well as Pāli, Tibetan, and Khotanese versions of related texts, to help interpret difficult passages in the Tibetan. The Tibetan text of Toh 339 also has no colophon, so the identity of the original Tibetan translator is unknown.

## Summary

**s.1** [9388c146-51cb-4f26-9abd-1227e6b20e30] In *Transformation of Karma* the Buddha is staying in Prince Jeta’s Grove in Śrāvastī, where he is visited by the brahmin youth Śuka, who asks the Blessed One to explain the reason why living beings appear so diversely. The Buddha answers Śuka’s question with a discourse on various categories of actions as well as rebirth and the actions leading to it. The discourse presents fifty-one categories of actions, followed by explanations of the negative consequences of transgressing the five precepts observed by all Buddhists, the advantages gained through caitya worship, and the meritorious results of specific acts of generosity.

## Acknowledgments

**ac.1** [4e3f251c-b0e0-4e6c-b926-8764f2acfd8e] This sūtra was translated by Bruno Galasek-Hul with the help of Lama Kunga Thartse Rinpoche of the Evam Choden Buddhist Center in Kensington (Berkeley), California. Roxanne Shooshani proofread and edited the English version. Thanks are due also to Mr. Yi Ding of Stanford University, who consulted the Chinese translations. The translator also wishes to thank Prof. Stephen Jenkins for his helpful comments.

## Introduction

### Content

**i.1** [21afb650-645e-45c2-b440-528dacdbeac8] *The Dharma Scripture “Transformation of Karma”* (short title: *Transformation of Karma*), which is presented here for the first time in an English translation, takes places in Śrāvastī, in Prince Jeta’s Grove, where the Buddha is staying with a large following of 1,250 monks. The Buddha is visited by a brahmin youth named Śuka, who requests the Buddha to explain how karmic ripening can lead to such a great diversity of beings. In response, the Buddha explains that individual karmic results are the reason for the diversity of beings, and he teaches in detail fifty-one categories of negative and positive consequences together with the specific actions that function as their causes. Next, the Buddha lists ten negative consequences for transgressing each of the five precepts: abstaining from taking life, abstaining from stealing, abstaining from sexual misconduct (here transgressing the vow of celibacy), abstaining from lying, and abstaining from consuming intoxicants. Lastly, the Buddha explains the karmic advantages that result from building and worshiping a caitya of the Tathāgata. Also enumerated are the advantages gained through making offerings and leading a religious life, living a secluded life, becoming a Buddhist mendicant, and developing confidence.

### Textual Classification

**i.2** [c0acc9bc-7842-4dba-8995-29cd3e50a48a] *Transformation of Karma* belongs to a group of Buddhist scriptures that scholars of Buddhism have called the *Karmavibhaṅga* or *Śukasūtra* class.[n.1] The texts in this group deal extensively with the topic of karma and rebirth according to individuals’ actions. Characteristic of the treatment of karma and rebirth in these texts is their detailed, catalog-like listing of specific karmic consequences and their causative actions. It is clear, however, that this is not meant to be understood as determinism. For example, in several places the presence or absence of intention and remorse are mentioned as factors that can determine whether a particular karmic result will be experienced, whether its outcome can be influenced, and whether it can be avoided altogether.

**i.3** [647a6096-9906-475c-91b7-2ea115b71bcf] In the Tibetan canon, *Transformation of Karma* is classified as a sūtra belonging to the Śrāvakayāna, and in the Degé edition of the Kangyur it is listed in the sūtra section under “various sūtras belonging to the Hīnayāna.”[n.2] The Japanese scholar Kudo Noriyuki and others proposed that the related *Karmavibhaṅga* (Toh 338)[n.3] belonged to the canon of the early Buddhist ordination lineage of the Sāṃmitīyas (or Sammatīyas). The Sāṃmitīyas were a branch of the Vātsīputrīya sect, whose adherents were also known as the “Personalists” (Skt. Pudgalavādin) because they posited the existence of the individual or person (Skt. *pudgala*) that transmigrates from one existence to the next and is neither identical with nor different from the five aggregates. Whether *Transformation of Karma*, too, can be considered to have belonged to the canon of the Sāṃmitīyas, however, is difficult to say with certainty without further research.[n.4] However, the text contains some clues that may point in that direction. The first indication is a curious statement found in 1.25, which lists as one of the karmic causes that lead to rebirth in the realm of the asuras “conceiving of nonexistence with regard to the self (Skt. *ātman*).” If our translation of this difficult passage is correct, the view expressed therein may betray the doctrinal position of the Pudgalavādins.[n.5] A second clue is found in 1.88, which contains the following statement: “one will not become lost in the intermediate state between death and rebirth.” We know that not all the early Buddhist sects accepted the concept of an intermediate state between death and rebirth. Those that did, according to André Bareau, included the Sarvāstivādins (Vaibhāṣikas), the Sammatīyas, the Pūrvaśailas, the later Mahīśāsakas, and the Dārṣṭāntikas.[n.6]

**i.4** [c0843542-06a1-4607-bb10-206b4081d353] The *Karmavibhaṅga* group of texts appears to have been particularly popular in Central Asia and in China, where the continued interest in it is shown by the existence in the Chinese Tripitaka of no fewer than six different translations spanning a period of eight centuries from the late third or early fourth century *ᴄᴇ* to the eleventh.[n.7] Four of these are listed in the Tōhoku catalog of the Tibetan canon of the Degé edition as corresponding to the text translated here (particularly the *Fen bie shan e bao ying jing* *分別善惡報應經*, Taishō no. 81). However, none of them seems to be an exact match.[n.8]

### The Title
                             
**i.5** [67f77837-4ed4-4668-85d4-8ef2527a3177] Sanskrit versions of the titles of translations of Indic texts in the Kangyur and Tengyur are traditionally given in transliteration at the beginning of the texts—but for Toh 339, the Sanskrit title differs from its Tibetan title. The Tibetan phrase *rnam par ’gyur ba* would suggest an original Sanskrit *vikāraḥ*, *vikṛtiḥ*, *vikriyā*, or *vipariṇata*, etc.,[n.9] all of which belong to the English semantic field of *change*. The text’s transliterated Sanskrit title, on the other hand, is given as *Karmavibhaṅganāmadharmagrantha*, for which in Tibetan one would rather expect something like *rnam par ’byed pa*.[n.10] The word *vibhaṅga* occurs in Buddhist literature as the title of certain works, for instance, as part of the title of one of the three major parts of the Pāli Vinaya (*Suttavibhaṅga*); as the title of the second, and oldest, book of the Pāli Abhidhamma (*Vibhaṅga*); as the Division of the Expositions (*Vibhaṅgavagga*), which is a section of the Majjhima Nikāya of the Pāli Canon that contains the Pāli “relatives” of the *Karmavibhaṅga*-group of texts (the *Cūḷa*- and *Mahākammavibhaṅga-suttas*, MN 135, 136); or as part of the title of a short work on the twelve links of dependent origination (Skt. *pratītyasamutpāda*) composed in Sanskrit (the *Pratītyasamutpādavibhaṅganirdeśasūtra*) that was found at the site of the great Indian university Nālandā, inscribed on bricks. In those contexts, Sanskrit *vibhaṅga* means “explanation,” in the sense of offering a more detailed explanation or elucidation—occasionally illustrated by examples, stories, or word-for-word explanations—of individual items in a list, such as the list of Vinaya rules or, in this case, a list of categories of karmically relevant actions and results. The derived meanings “exposition” and “commentary” can be regarded as generic terms applied to texts exhibiting certain stylistic features like the ones mentioned.

**i.6** [5cf3f7f9-1b14-4caa-9d04-141d95d1a0a1] The final part of the Tibetan title, *chos kyi gzhung* (Skt. *Dharmagrantha*), seems to be very rare as part of the title of canonical works. A search for the expression *chos kyi gzhung* in the online database Resources for Kanjur and Tenjur Studies of the Tibetan Manuscripts Project of the University of Vienna yielded only the text translated here.[n.11] Instead of translating the Tibetan *rnam par ’gyur ba* literally as “transformation,” “change,” or “ripening,” we have accepted the transliterated Sanskrit given in the text itself as the original title of the work, and have translated it consistent with the common Buddhist usage of the Sanskrit word *vibhaṅga* when applied to texts that exhibit certain characteristics.[n.12] This choice furthermore highlights its kinship with the longer *Karmavibhaṅga* (Toh 338).[n.13]

**i.7** [360b9fbd-ed59-4186-b42f-e5dc2f45d408] Mention must be made here, however, of the fact that the Kangyur editions not belonging to the Tshalpa (*tshal pa*) line preserve variant titles: the versions in the Stok Palace manuscript, the Shey Palace manuscript, and the Shelkar manuscript Kangyurs[n.14]—all belonging to the Thempangma (*them spangs ma*) line—give the Sanskrit name of the text as *Karmavibhaṅganāmadharmaparyāya*.[n.15]

**i.8** [04228b5c-88a8-4457-97c9-4cfc2b01fb67] Furthermore, the Shelkar Kangyur records as the Tibetan title *las kyis rnam par ’gyur ba zhes bya ba’i chos kyi gzhung*: “*The Dharma Scripture Called Transformation through Karma*.” If this is not simply a scribal error (the Stok and Shey Kangyurs read *las kyi rnam par ’gyur ba*), this title may support Sanskrit *pariṇāma* (“transformation,” “change,” “ripening”) as part of a possible original Sanskrit title of the work.

**i.9** [c2ccac2f-fd82-4879-8370-61ab9bd989a6] Yet another variant of the title should be noted. The Denkarma (Tib. *ldan*/*lhan dkar ma*), one of the three imperial catalogs of Tibetan translations made during the early transmission of the Dharma in Tibet during the eighth to ninth centuries, gives the title as *las kyi rnam par ’gyur ba bstan pa’i gzhung*.[n.16]

### On Karma

**i.10** [86e0df45-ad9f-4a81-b153-42f9c2ac4fab] Apart from its occurrence in the title of the sūtra, we have largely avoided the lexicalized English word *karma* as a rendition of the Tibetan *las*. Instead, we translate *las* as “action(s).” We feel that contemporary common usage of the loanword *karma* is often fuzzy or unclear in that it seemingly blends together the senses “the totality of a person’s actions and conduct during successive incarnations,” a resultant state as “fate or destiny,” which is perceived to be causally influenced by the totality of a person’s actions, the “law or principle through which such influence is believed to operate,” and the woolly but popular sense of “a distinctive aura, atmosphere, or feeling.”[n.17] We do, however, use the lexicalized adjective *karmic* (as, for example, in *karmic result*, or *karmic cause and effect*) in the sense of “relating to one’s action (s)” in the translation. We have furthermore used the expression *karma* and *rebirth* in this introduction knowing full well that these terms are equally difficult to define abstractly, but with the understanding that in Indic and Buddhist contexts the terms *karma* and *rebirth* are amalgamated in the term *saṃsāra*.

**i.11** [0297af59-9ba1-4af5-be2f-f7dd07932e7e] As for the “mechanics” of karmic cause and effect, the Buddha explains it in *Transformation of Karma*, 1.6:

**i.12** [98117bf1-8026-45fb-a17f-2989199f744a]
> “Therefore, again, the multiple varieties of sentient beings, due to their being bad, good, or middling, are karmically connected with many kinds of actions, many kinds of sufferings, and many kinds of views, in accordance with what I have taught as the black and white fruits of karmic ripening. Young brahmin, it is like this: Through carrying out black actions, sentient beings are reborn in the unfortunate rebirth destinies; they are reborn as hell beings, animals, ghosts (that is, those who have gone to the afterlife), and asuras. Through carrying out white actions, beings are reborn as devas or as humans.”

**i.13** [484252c8-16f6-4155-af90-bfe843750c95] Two things are noteworthy in this passage regarding Buddhist doctrine. First is the work’s assumption of six realms of rebirth (Skt. *gati*). Some early Buddhist schools accepted only five realms, including the asuras in the god realm. By contrast, here the unfortunate realms or destinations of rebirth (Skt. *durgati*) are constituted by hell beings, animals, ghosts, and asuras; the fortunate realms or destinations of rebirth (Skt. *sugati*) include the devas and humans, omitting the asuras.

**i.14** [b52730f8-698b-4658-988d-882b7bb995b6] The second observation concerns the classification of actions into “black” and “white.” One frequently encounters this classification in Abhidharma-style works where, in an extension of the basic color metaphor, karmically efficacious action is divided into four kinds: (1) wholesome (Skt. *kuśala*, i.e., morally or ethically good), (2) unwholesome (Skt. *akuśala*, i.e., morally or ethically bad), (3) mixed (i.e., actions and results possessing both morally or ethically good and bad aspects and corresponding resultant experiences), and (4) neutral (Skt. *avyākṛta* or *āniñjya*, “undetermined” or “immovable, immobile,” e.g., the actions of an enlightened being, an arhat, etc.). For example, the *Saṅgītisutta* of the *Dīgha Nikāya* (DN 33) explains as follows: “Four kinds of *kamma*: There is (a) black *kamma* with black result, (b) bright [white] *kamma* with bright result, (c) black-and-bright *kamma* with black-and-bright result, (d) *kamma* that is neither black nor bright, with neither black nor bright result, leading to the destruction of *kamma*.”[n.18]

**i.15** [293fd292-4817-4ae2-9722-cb79ccf68f41] The same explanation, but much more technical and elaborate in its interpretive details, is found in Vasubandhu’s *Abhidharmakośabhāṣya*: “Action is of four types, white, black, etc. The sūtra teaches that action is of four types: black, of black retribution; white, of white retribution; black-white, of black-white retribution; neither black nor white, without black or white retribution; and that which destroys the other actions.”[n.19]

**i.16** [9f118b27-c53f-4c68-9441-a02c4839365d] The third type, of black-white action, is further explained: “Good action of the sphere of Kāmadhātu, being mixed with the bad, is black-white; its retribution is mixed, so it is thus black-white. This definition is to be understood as applying not to the nature of the action itself, but to the ‘series’ or the person; in one and the same mental series, good action is mixed with bad action. There is no action which is black-white, nor any retribution which is black-white, which would be a contradiction.”[n.20]

**i.17** [9e43bde5-cfd5-46c4-9923-9a3f0a1299cc] The third kind of action as black-white is not specifically mentioned in *Transformation of Karma*’s explanations of karmic categories, but the possibility seems to be implied. For instance, when a person first experiences happiness, which later changes to the experience of unhappiness due to certain black-white actions as causes (1.44–1.48). Actions of the fourth kind, which are actions after enlightenment and which have no effect in saṃsāra, are more difficult to identify with certainty in *Transformation of Karma*. The explanations in 1.55, 1.57, and 1.58 seem to state that arhats are still subject to karmic punishment and reward. But they do not make any statement about the karmic efficacy (or inefficacy) of acts carried out by arhats, which was a point of contention between, for instance, the Sarvāstivādins and the Theravādins.

### Tibetan and Sanskrit Versions

**i.18** [ba1ef9fd-e2bc-49ee-8c37-f126396e2c89] Three different recensions or versions of the *Karmavibhaṅga* are preserved in different Kangyur editions, which Kudo calls “Tib-1” (Toh 338),[n.21] “Tib-2” (Toh 339, the text translated here), and “Tib-3,” respectively.[n.22] The content of the third version not included in the Degé Kangyur (“Tib-3”) but found in other mixed-lineage Kangyurs and in the Themphangma Kangyurs has been explored by Walter Simon.[n.23] Tib-3 is distinguished by the inclusion, among other things, of an introductory story that is found only in one Sanskrit manuscript, and not in Toh 338 or Toh 339. This introduction to the discourse proper tells the story of the conversion of Śuka, the son of the brahmin Taudeya, who after his death was reborn as a dog in his son’s house; he is identified by the Buddha on one of his visits to Śuka’s house during his rounds to collect alms. Śuka does not believe the Buddha’s assertion that the dog is his deceased father and at first becomes angry; but he is later convinced by the Buddha’s demonstration of the identity of the dog as his late father. After being the addressee of the Buddha’s teachings on karmic cause and effect on several occasions, Śuka eventually becomes a lay follower.

**i.19** [fdb9d13b-226d-4072-bc71-d162caccf992] Walter Simon noted three distinguishing features of Tib-3 in comparison to Toh 338 and 339: (1) “the preservation … of the ‘introductory tale,’ ” (2) the absence of the “illustrative stories,” and (3) “the inclusion of … a table of contents.” These features, he wrote, “point to an earlier Sanskrit original.”[n.24] *Transformation of Karma*, too, contains a a table of contents, and it lacks stories illustrating the various karmic categories. But, more importantly, it also lacks the introductory tale characteristic of the (*Mahā*-)*Karmavibhaṅga* (Lévi 1932, 21–29) and its Tibetan version in the manuscript Kangyur of the British Museum.

**i.20** [f62bd762-07b9-4516-94fe-749f89fdec2b] Like the Tib-3 version of the *Karmavibhaṅga*, the summary of the fifty-one karmic categories at the beginning of *Transformation of Karma* (1.8–1.63) does not include the items contained in 1.64–1.68 (a list of ten negative consequences each of the actions of killing, stealing, lying, unchastity, and drinking alcohol) or 1.69–1.90 (the advantages gained by making various offerings at caityas). The Tib-3 version contains the advantages of venerating and making offerings at caityas, but it does not contain the list of five negative actions and their consequences included in 1.64–1.68 of *Transformation of Karma*. It is reasonable to argue, therefore, that 1.64–1.68 of *Transformation of Karma*, and perhaps a portion of 1.69–1.90, are later additions to the text.

**i.21** [379aa7f6-3ed6-4437-a8b7-abb6afe6560e] As we have already mentioned, no complete Sanskrit version of *Transformation of Karma* is extant. In his study of the Khotanese fragments of the *Karmavibhaṅga*, Mauro Maggi remarks that *Transformation of Karma* “corresponds” to “S2” (that is, a manuscript fragment of the *Śukasūtra* from Eastern Turkestan, in the British Library, Oriental and India Office Collections, London, which was edited by A. F. R. Hoernle in 1916 and reproduced in Lévi 1932, 235–36).[n.25] However, Sylvain Lévi had already observed that although the two texts—the Central Asian Sanskrit fragment and the Tibetan text of *Transformation of Karma* Toh 339 (i.e., Lévi’s “T2”)—exhibit a family likeness, they are different.[n.26] A careful comparison of Lévi’s edition of the extant Sanskrit portions of the *Śukasūtra* fragment from Central Asia (paragraphs VIII–XII) with the corresponding paragraphs in the Tibetan text of *Transformation of Karma* confirms Lévi’s observation.

**i.22** [d54b83ba-e27c-4881-b777-6cee32a8ddf5] To sum up, no exactly corresponding Sanskrit source text of the Tibetan translation of *Transformation of Karma* seems to be extant. Nevertheless, due to their similarity, the Sanskrit fragment of the Central Asian recension allowed us to throw some light on certain obscure terms in the Tibetan text.

**i.23** [42f3a724-78a7-496f-8fa7-b3f02699ea29] Regrettably, we possess no information about who translated the text or when. The Tibetan text in the Degé edition (as well as in the other editions) has no colophon, which usually provides this information, and according to the Tōhoku catalog, the identity of the translator(s) is unknown.[n.27] It is not possible at this point to establish the relationship between these different extant versions of the text, and *Transformation of Karma* thus seems to be the sole textual witness of yet another recension or a different version in the *Karmavibhaṅga* or *Śukasūtra* group.

**i.24** [d56f8200-b3f2-411c-8726-c2c58963cb07] Nevertheless, we have frequently consulted (in a rather unsystematic way and as indicated in the footnotes) the extant Sanskrit witnesses: the two Sanskrit manuscripts in the National Archives of Nepal, Kathmandu, published by Lévi in 1932 and Kudo in 2004; the two-folio fragment of a different recension, published by Fukita in 1990 and Kudo in 2004; a Kuchean Sanskrit fragment of the *Śukasūtra*, published by Lévi in 1932; and the Pāli (MN 135, 136), Tibetan (Toh 338), and Khotanese (in English translation by Maggi in 1995) versions of the related (*Mahā*-)*Karmavibhaṅga* (Lévi 1932) to aid our understanding of this often obscure Tibetan text.

### The Tibetan Translation

**i.25** [fcb823cf-7b97-4a1e-81fc-dc711b65285f] The Tibetan text of Toh 339 is notable for its idiosyncrasies. It contains several nonstandard expressions and names of Buddhist concepts that are worthy of mention, such as *ngan pa*, *ring du ’khyams pa*, and *mya ngan bsring*(*s*).[n.28] Furthermore, it contains an idiosyncratic rendering of the four *formless meditative absorptions* (Skt. *ārūpyasamāpatti*) or, as they are called in *Transformation of Karma*, “the four states of imperturbability.” These observations lead us to believe that the translation of *Transformation of Karma* predates the third Tibetan language revision or language reform of 814 *ᴄᴇ*, as it was codified in the *Mahāvyutpatti* and the *sgra sbyor bam po gnyis pa*. On the other hand, a more detailed analysis of the wording describing the four states of imperturbability, as well as the frequent use of an epithet for the Buddha of *yang dag par gshegs pa*,[n.29] instead of the more standard *de bzhin gshegs pa*, has led us to also consider the possibility that Toh 339 may have been translated from the Chinese.[n.30] A comparison with several of the Chinese versions of our text by Mr. Yi Ding, however, could not confirm this hypothesis.[n.31]

**i.26** [285dc762-45b2-4f79-b7e5-7c48a136efd0] What we can safely say, though, is that *Transformation of Karma* represents a translation that does not strictly adhere to the reformed, standardized language that was prescribed by decree for the translations from Indic originals in the ninth-century Tibetan manuals for translators, the *Mahāvyutpatti* and the *sgra sbyor bam po gnyis pa*.

**i.27** [eb934c12-40c1-4bec-8be2-32a7ce353b2d] It is generally assumed that the Tibetan translation activity of the first dissemination of the Dharma began around the middle of the eighth century *ᴄᴇ*[n.32] and continued until the demise of the Tibetan empire, that is, by 840 *ᴄᴇ*. Since the identity of *Transformation of Karma* with the *las kyi rnam par ’gyur ba bstan pa’i gzhung* (no. [282]) in the Denkarma (Tib. *lhan kar ma*) catalog seems unambiguous, these two dates (i.e., 763 *ᴄᴇ* and 840 *ᴄᴇ*) are likely the earliest and latest dates, respectively, of the translation of *Transformation of Karma* into Tibetan.[n.33] If we additionally consider the fact that Toh 339 contains pre-reform terms and expressions, we may be able to push the date for the *latest date* closer to the beginning of the ninth century. In the absence of a colophon or other pertinent information about the text, however, it is impossible to be more precise.[n.34]

### The English Translation

**i.28** [09bed876-f98c-46b4-b4d7-4e19529e24cd] This translation into English was made directly from the Tibetan text of the Degé edition with the help of its parallel versions. However, mention must be made of the pioneering French translation by Léon Feer in 1883. This French Sanskritist and Orientalist, who was the first to translate Kangyur materials into a European language, gave us the first translation of *Transformation of Karma* in a European language in his *Fragments: Extraits du Kandjour*.[n.35] However, Feer did not have at his disposal the wealth of material on the *Karmavibhaṅga* group of texts that we have today, and he was thus unable to consult similar or related versions of the text to assist him in his efforts to make sense of obscure and difficult passages in the Tibetan text. Our translation refers frequently to Feer’s translation in the notes, especially where Feer’s interpretation of the Tibetan deviates from ours.[n.36] However, our translation should not be considered definitive or final. Rather, it is an attempt to improve upon Feer’s where possible.

**i.29** [0aaf3e43-27ae-4b2d-9c65-3525d4b5aff2] Since the text itself is not very long, and the Tibetan text in the Kangyur does not have any chapter subdivisions, we have likewise refrained from inserting any such divisions. We have, however, referenced Feer’s sensible general outline of the text in the notes to the translation. Feer divided the text into three main parts, each with subdivisions and individually numbered paragraphs, and in the notes to our translation we have noted his general division of the text.

**i.30** [55557d6b-0dcd-4a36-ad0f-34bc5b6f6fa2] In producing the translation, we have used the Degé edition (siglum D) as the basis. We have also perused the Comparative Edition of the Kangyur (Tib. *dpe bsdur ma*) (A), together with its list of variant readings. Where the Degé text seemed ambiguous or was not readily comprehensible, we have directly consulted two versions of the text belonging to the Thempangma line, namely, the Stok Palace manuscript Kangyur (S) and the Shey Palace manuscript Kangyur from Ladakh (Z). For variant readings that affect the meaning of a passage, we have done our best to provide an alternative English translation in the notes. Where we were unable to provide an alternative translation for a variant (e.g., because we didn’t understand it) that nevertheless seemed significant enough to be recorded, the variant is followed by a question mark. Except for the two witnesses (S and Z) belonging to the Thempangma line, all other variant readings (of the Yongle, Lithang, Kangxi, Choné, Narthang, Urga, and Lhasa editions of the Kangyur; see Abbreviations for their sigla) are taken from list of variants in the Comparative Edition edition.

## The Translation

**The Dharma Scripture “Transformation of Karma” in one fascicle**

**1.1** [62019247-227a-4c86-91bf-483a8ed2c4ee] Homage to all buddhas and bodhisattvas!

**1.2** [6672bdf5-d3fe-4b2a-b96e-2ae761657902] Thus did I hear at one time:[n.37] The Bhagavān was staying in Śrāvastī, in Prince Jeta’s grove, Anāthapiṇḍada’s Park, together with a large assembly of twelve hundred fifty monks.[n.38]

**1.3** [d40290be-c167-4b18-9c5f-ea0b28c3a574] On that occasion the brahmin youth Śuka,[n.39] the son of Taudeya, went to where the Bhagavān was staying. Upon his arrival, he exchanged many courteous and amiable pleasantries with the Bhagavān and remained standing to one side.[n.40] The brahmin youth Śuka, the son of Taudeya, then addressed the Bhagavān with the following question: “Gautama, if I ask you a small question, will you kindly give an answer?”[n.41]

**1.4** [4a23c745-2b45-4eca-bfc2-90f66760ba9b] The Bhagavān replied, “Young brahmin, ask whatever you like! I will answer.”

Then the brahmin youth Śuka, the son of Taudeya, asked the Bhagavān the following question: “Sir[n.42] Gautama, there are many types of sentient beings, such as beings who have a short lifespan or a long lifespan, have many illnesses or few illnesses, are ugly or beautiful, have little power or are powerful, are highborn or lowborn, are poor or rich, are ignorant of the Dharma,[n.43] or possess knowledge of the Dharma to a lesser or greater degree, have good or bad fortune, and so forth. How does karmic ripening lead to this diversity of beings?”[n.44]

**1.5** [78967b39-43ab-4676-bf3d-2bca1c65d147] The Bhagavān replied, “Young brahmin, listen[n.45] and pay careful attention to what I shall explain.[n.46] Young brahmin, sentient beings are the owners of their actions committed in former lives;[n.47] sentient beings have actions as their heritage, actions as their origin, actions as their individual causes; sentient beings develop through actions, young brahmin.[n.48]

**1.6** [55d598bc-4a53-4741-860d-8cfdae59d693] “Therefore, again, the multiple varieties of sentient beings, due to their being bad, good, or middling, are karmically connected with many kinds of actions, many kinds of sufferings, and many kinds of views, in accordance with what I have taught as the black and white fruits of karmic ripening.[n.49] Young brahmin, it is like this: Through carrying out black actions, sentient beings are reborn in the unfortunate rebirth destinies;[n.50] they are reborn as hell beings, animals, ghosts (that is, those who have gone to the afterlife[n.51]), and asuras.[n.52] Through carrying out white actions, beings are reborn as devas or as humans.

**1.7** [df74a765-52c5-4746-9cf0-bcedd4068c9c] “Therefore, young brahmin, as a result of one’s actions,[n.53] one’s life is short or long, one has many or few illnesses, one is ugly or beautiful, one is insignificant or influential, one is lowborn[n.54] or highborn, one is poor or rich, one is ignorant of the Dharma,[n.55] or one has extensive knowledge of the Dharma;[n.56] as a result of one’s actions, one is reborn as a hell being, an animal, a ghost, an asura, a human, a deva possessing a physical body,[n.57] or a deva without a physical body; as a result of one’s actions, one’s rebirth is determinate in accordance with the action,[n.58] one’s rebirth is indeterminate,[n.59] there is rebirth in a foreign country, there is rebirth through carrying out an action without intent,[n.60] there is rebirth when one has intended an action but not carried it out, there is rebirth when one has intended an action and carried it out, and there is rebirth when one has neither intended an action nor carried it out. There are also actions that, when accumulated,[n.61] lead to rebirth into a new existence only after the lifespan in hell has been completed; furthermore, there are actions that, when accumulated, lead to rebirth into a new existence after only half the lifespan in hell is exhausted, as well as actions that lead to rebirth immediately upon arriving in hell.[n.62] There are actions that, when accumulated, lead to future unhappiness following upon past happiness.[n.63] There are actions that, when accumulated, lead to to future happiness following upon past unhappiness.[n.64] There are actions that, when accumulated by people and sentient beings,[n.65] lead to future happiness following upon past happiness. There are actions that, when accumulated, lead to miserliness, to being poor and generous, to being wealthy and generous, and to being poor and miserly. There are individuals whose lifespans are exhausted but not their actions,[n.66] there are individuals whose actions are exhausted but not their lifespans, and there are individuals whose lifespans and actions are simultaneously exhausted. There are individuals who will eliminate their sufferings although neither their lifespans nor their actions are exhausted. There are individuals who will become unwell in their minds while their bodies are well.[n.67] There are actions that lead an individual to be well in their mind while their body is unwell,[n.68] or to be well in mind and body,[n.69] or to be unwell in both mind and body.[n.70] There are actions that, when accumulated, lead to having a body that is graceful,[n.71] beautiful looking, and pretty, with a nice and glossy complexion, a feast for the eyes, although an individual is reborn in an inferior form of existence.[n.72] There are actions that, when accumulated, lead to having an inferior physique, a crude body and an unpleasant and unsightly appearance for an individual reborn in an inferior form of existence. Furthermore, young brahmin, it is like this: through carrying out the ten nonvirtuous courses of action, conditions in one’s environment will deteriorate.[n.73]

**1.8** [1504fde1-945a-4654-a281-6abe05a77aa9] “Now, in what way does action lead to a short[n.74] lifespan?[n.75] Due to ten factors,[n.76] one’s lifespan will be shortened. What are the ten?[n.77] (1) Taking life,[n.78] (2) encouraging others to take life,[n.79] (3) speaking praise of killing, (4) resolving to[n.80] kill, (5) aborting a fetus, (6) encouraging abortion, (7) wishing one’s enemy to be killed, (8) feeling joy at the death of one’s foe,[n.81] (9) preparing the ground for slaughtering animals and killing them there, and (10) watching a battle and delighting in it.[n.82] Through these ten factors, one’s lifespan will be shortened, and one will suffer many illnesses.

**1.9** [82153eb6-8655-4d4e-9bf8-c7a519e04235] “How can one achieve a long life through carrying out good actions? Ten factors lead to a long life. What are the ten? (1) Abstaining from killing; (2) preventing others from killing; (3) speaking praise of abstaining from killing; (4) resolving to abstain from killing; (5) freeing sentient beings who have been captured in order to be slaughtered; (6) freeing imprisoned humans who are to be executed; (7) giving refuge to sentient beings[n.83] who are frightened and terrified; (8) having a compassionate attitude toward those who are without protection; (9) embracing with one’s love those who are ill; and (10) giving clothing, food, and drink to the destitute. Through these ten factors, one will have a long life and be free from illness.

**1.10** [a1286fe3-d655-4199-972f-c6190baf04c3] “In what way does action lead to having many illnesses? Ten factors lead to having many illnesses. What are the ten? (1) Beating somebody with a stick, with the hand,[n.84] or with something else; (2) encouraging someone to beat somebody with a stick, with the hand, or with something else; (3) praising the action of beating somebody with a stick, with the hand, or with something else; (4) resolving to beat somebody with a stick, with the hand, or with something else; (5) distressing one’s parents; (6) distressing monks and nuns;[n.85] (7) feeling joy about one’s enemies falling ill; (8) feeling joy when one’s enemies do not recover from an illness; (9) giving them the wrong medicine; and (10) eating indigestible food.[n.86] These are the ten. Through these ten factors, one will have many illnesses.

**1.11** [ec3ea453-2c1e-4c3b-b25c-062737b304fc] “How will one have few illnesses through carrying out good actions? Ten factors lead to having few illnesses. What are the ten? (1) Not beating somebody with a stick, with one’s hand, or with something else; (2) preventing others[n.87] from beating somebody with a stick, with their hands, or with something else; (3) not speaking praise of beating somebody with a stick, with a hand, or with something else; (4) resolving not to beat[n.88] somebody with a stick, with one’s hand, or with something else; (5) serving[n.89] one’s ill parents; (6) serving monks and nuns when they are ill; (7) being unhappy when one’s enemies have fallen ill; (8) feeling joy when one’s enemies recover from an illness; (9) giving medicine to the sick; and (10) eating digestible food.[n.90] These are the ten. Through these ten factors, one will have few illnesses.

**1.12** [0b5a50c6-6eef-475b-a821-a216b17f72a5] “In what way does action lead to ugliness?[n.91] Ten factors lead to ugliness. What are the ten? (1) Anger; (2) inflicting harm;[n.92] (3) holding a grudge,[n.93] even for a trifle; (4) rage; (5) reviling one’s parents;[n.94] (6) reviling monks and nuns;[n.95] (7) corrupting the dwelling of monks and nuns;[n.96] (8) extinguishing the offering lamps at a caitya[n.97] of the Tathāgata;[n.98][n.99] (9) treating ugly persons with contempt;[n.100] and (10) being uncleanly.[n.101] These are the ten factors.[n.102]

**1.13** [b4b7f7dc-795e-4407-8dac-2236c4fee0e1] “In what way does action lead to being beautiful?[n.103] Ten factors lead to being beautiful. What are the ten? (1) Non-hatred; (2) donating clothing; (3) sweeping often at a caitya of the Tathāgata; (4) sweeping clean the shrine hall; (5) speaking pleasingly to one’s parents; (6) speaking pleasingly to monks and nuns;[n.104] (7) not treating ugly persons with contempt;[n.105] and (8) being very cleanly.[n.106] These are the ten factors.[n.107]

**1.14** [09bafff5-5c50-41de-bdcd-78782af6cbbc] “In what way does action lead to having little power?[n.108] Ten factors lead to having little power. What are the ten? (1) Envying others’ achievements;[n.109] (2) being happy when others fail; (3) being unhappy about others’ attainments; (4) being happy about others’ unhappiness, dishonor, bad reputation, obscurity, and criticism;[n.110] (5) being unhappy about others’ happiness, glory, good reputation, and renown; (6) not venerating[n.111] one’s parents and one’s virtuous spiritual teacher; (7) not serving monks and nuns;[n.112] (8) generating the roots of unwholesome states with regard to those who have little power;[n.113] (9) cutting off the roots of wholesome states with regard to those who are powerful;[n.114] and (10) praising those who act wickedly. These are the ten factors.

**1.15** [0344d48c-9500-43c2-b8b8-547940e160c0] “In what way does action lead to possessing power? Ten factors lead to being powerful. What are the ten? (1) Not envying others’ achievements; (2) rejoicing in others’ achievements; (3) not rejoicing in others’ failures; (4) not rejoicing in others’ unhappiness, disgrace, bad reputation, obscurity, or criticism; (5) rejoicing in others’ happiness, glory, good reputation, and renown; (6) arousing the mind of enlightenment; (7) erecting a stūpa and (8) a caitya for the Tathāgata;[n.115] (9) cutting off the roots of unwholesome states with regard to those who are powerless;[n.116] and (10) generating the roots of wholesome states with regard to those who are powerful. These are the ten factors.

**1.16** [3f5974bc-1145-4fab-8534-507928869622] “In what way does action lead to being lowborn? Ten factors lead to being lowborn. What are the ten? (1) Not honoring one’s parents;[n.117] (2) not honoring[n.118] ascetics;[n.119] (3) not honoring brahmins; (4) not esteeming those of noble birth;[n.120] (5) not serving, not respecting,[n.121] or not regaling[n.122] one’s monastic preceptor,[n.123] one’s teacher, or those who have entered the path of liberation;[n.124] (6) not revering one’s parents; (7) showing contempt for and not venerating one’s monastic preceptor, one’s teacher, or those who have entered the path of liberation; (8) shunning those coming from powerful families; and (9) commending people who do bad deeds. These are the ten factors.

**1.17** [7b02e8f3-e690-4a9b-8b3d-cfa77c69fe20] “In what way does action lead to being highborn? Ten factors lead to being highborn. What are the ten? (1) Commemorating one’s parents; (2) honoring those who have entered the path of liberation; (3) honoring brahmins; (4) esteeming those who are of noble birth;[n.125] (5) arising from one’s seat and preparing it,[n.126] bowing respectfully, and then offering one’s seat and so forth to one’s monastic preceptor, one’s teacher, those who have entered the path of liberation, and those others who apply themselves to the path [of liberation];[n.127][n.128] (6) venerating one’s parents; (7) venerating one’s preceptors, teachers, those who have entered the path of liberation, and others;[n.129] (8) making no distinction between one who is of high social status and one who is of low social status, and equating them; (9) planting the life tree inside a stūpa of the Tathāgata; and (10) hanging floral wreaths and raising parasols. These are the ten factors.

**1.18** [129d27eb-fbfc-4fa1-9101-43fe9ef4f67f] “In what way does action lead to poverty? Ten factors lead to becoming poor. What are the ten? (1) Stealing;[n.130] (2) encouraging others to commit theft; (3) commending theft; (4) resolving to steal; (5) depriving one’s parents of their sustenance; (6) depriving one’s preceptors, teachers, or those who have entered the path of liberation of their temples,[n.131] living quarters, offerings, or service;[n.132] (7) being unhappy about others’ gains;[n.133] (8) rejoicing in others’ losses;[n.134] (9) hindering others from obtainment; and (10) wishing[n.135] for a famine to occur. These are the ten factors.

**1.19** [b27fe6e3-c0ba-453d-a601-279f24121cac] “In what way does action lead to wealth? Ten factors lead to becoming rich. What are the ten? (1) Abstaining from stealing; (2) encouraging others to give up stealing; (3) rejoicing when others give up stealing; (4) providing one’s parents with sustenance;[n.136] (5) providing one’s monastic preceptor,[n.137] one’s teacher, and the other members of the monastic saṅgha[n.138] with a temple, living quarters, service,[n.139] robes, a bed,[n.140] medicine[n.141] to cure illness, a servant,[n.142] or sustenance; (6) having joyful thoughts about others’ gains; (7) making an effort so that others can acquire [wealth];[n.143] (8) not rejoicing in others’ losses; (9) praying for a good harvest everywhere;[n.144] and (10) rejoicing in the actions of those who practice generosity and so forth liberally. These are the ten factors.

**1.20** [37510471-8b63-43f3-b122-876051db36c0] “In what way does action lead to being ignorant of the Dharma?[n.145] Ten factors lead to being ignorant of the Dharma. What are the ten? (1) Not valuing inquiry of a qualified person,[n.146] (2) fostering all that is not the true Dharma, (3) abandoning the true Dharma, (4) not honoring and venerating those who teach the true Dharma, (5) praising well those who speak inconsequentially,[n.148][n.147] (6) attending to and serving those who are ignorant of the Dharma, (7) abandoning those who are truly learned in the Dharma,[n.149] (8) regarding wrong views as authoritative and praising them, (9) abandoning correct views, and (10) abandoning those who are knowledgeable. These are the ten factors.

## Notes for this part

**n.1** The latter designation—which is also the actual title of some of the texts or recensions belonging to this group of texts, named after one of the protagonists of these *sūtras*, Śuka (Pāli: *Subha*), the son of Taudeya—originated with Yamada Ryūjō, who surveyed all the texts belonging to this group in 1935; see Kudo 2004, viii. For a synopsis of all the texts that constitute the *Śukasūtra* class, see Kudo 2004, Introduction and specifically pp. xx–xxii (Bibliography and Abbreviations); see also Kudo 2008, 366–68.

**n.2** Tibetan: *mdo sde, sa*; *theg dman gyi mdo mang*. For a full list of the text’s location, classification, and context in the different Kangyur editions, see Resources for Kanjur and Tenjur Studies, online database by the Tibetan Manuscripts Project Vienna (TMPV), located at the Department of South Asian, Tibetan and Buddhist Studies, University of Vienna, accessed 2 December, 2017, http://www.rkts.org/cat.php?id=339&typ=1.

**n.3** See Bruno Galasek-Hul and Lama Kunga Thartse Rinpoche, trans., The Exposition of Karma (*Karmavibhaṅga*), Toh 338 (84000: Translating the Words of the Buddha, 2023).

**n.4** Although *Transformation of Karma* is thematically closely related to the longer (*Mahā-*)*Karmavibhaṅga*, it is quite different in terms of style and lexicon. Since these are two essential criteria for the determination of a text’s school-affiliation, we avoid jumping to conclusions about its potential school-affiliation.

**n.5** Cf. Priestley 1999, ch. 5: “The Reality of the Pudgala,” specifically p. 83.

**n.6** See Bareau 1955, app. I, 289.

**n.7** For a list of the Chinese translations, see Kudo 2004, Bibliography, p. xx.

**n.8** See the chapter concordance in Kudo 2008, 370–72. Mr. Yi Ding, who kindly consulted us on the Chinese translations, suggests that Taishō 80 may be an even closer match than Taishō 81. Another interesting text, extant in Chinese, Tibetan, and Sogdian, the *Sutra of the Causes and Effects of Actions* (*shan wo yin guo jing*; Taishō vol. 85, no. 2881), although very different in content, shows some structural resemblance to *Transformation of Karma* (see MacKenzie 1970). It was, probably like the majority of Buddhist literature in Sogdian, translated from the Chinese.

**n.9** The Mvy lists Sanskrit *vipariṇatam* as translation equivalent of Tibetan *rnam par ’gyur ba* (cf. Sakaki 7315). Cf. also the Sanskrit equivalents for *rnam par ’gyur ba* provided by Negi, 3047. Negi (3047, II, 6.) cites the title of this work as the only instance of *rnam par ’gyur ba* to render Sanskrit *vibhaṅga*. Perhaps the Tibetan title could also be interpreted as meaning “The Dharma Scripture on the Ripening of Karma,” if we interpreted Tibetan *rnam par ’gyur ba* as non-standard rendering of Sanskrit *pariṇāma* or *pariṇāmana* (see BHSD, s.v. *pariṇāma* and *parṇāmana*). In Sanskrit, *pariṇāma* seems to cover two distinct lexical fields: *change* and *transference*. The concept of *transference of merit* (Skt. *puṇyapariṇāma*) played an important role in the practices of Central Asian lay Buddhists, especially in the context of pilgrimage and pilgrimage sites (among the Uyghurs in particular; see Jens Wilkens, “Buddhismus bei den Türkischen Völkern in Zentralasien,” in Hutter, Manfred, *Der Buddhismus II* (Stuttgart: Kohlhammer, 2016), 482.

**n.10** Cf., e.g., the Mvy, s.v. *vibhaṅga* (Sakaki 1372, 1425). Cf. also the work immediately preceding this one in the Kangyur, the Karmavibhaṅga (Toh 338). Sanskrit *vibhaṅga* is also found rendered as *rnam par dbye ba* in Tibetan, probably hinting at a confusion or the interchangeable usage of Sanskrit *vibhaṅga* and Sanskrit/Pāli *vibhajana*, *vibhāga*, meaning “division,” “classification,” “distinction,” “distribution,” or “detailing.” Cf. also Edgerton, BHSD, s.v. *vibhaṅga*. In the old canonical texts of Buddhism in Pāli, the opposite term of *vibhaṅga* is *uddesa*: “indication in outline” (CPD, s.v. uddesa 2.). Thus *vibhaṅga* was understood as detailed explanation of a teaching given in outline, and later may have taken on the sense of commentary and developed into a genre designation.

**n.11** See Resources for Kanjur and Tenjur Studies: https://www.istb.univie.ac.at, accessed 2 December, 2017. Similarly, the only reference in Negi’s Tibetan-Sanskrit dictionary (Negi, 1259) for Tibetan *chos kyi gzhung* (Skt. *dharmagrantha*) is to the title of Toh 339.

**n.12** The Sanskrit word *vibhaṅga* can also mean “classification,” etc. Thus, the words chosen by L. Feer (Feer 1883, 252: *partage*) and Sylvain Lévi (Lévi 1932: *classification*) in the titles of their translations.

**n.13** See The Exposition of Karma, Toh 338.

**n.14** This is an eighteenth-century copy of a manuscript kept in the Shelkar monastery; it is also known as the London Kangyur or British Museum Kangyur after its current location.

**n.15** See Resources for Kanjur and Tenjur Studies, accessed 4 December, 2017, http://www.rkts.org/cat.php?id=339&typ=1.”

**n.16** See Herrmann-Pfandt 2008, 155: No. [282].

**n.17** See The American Heritage Dictionary of the English Language (website), last accessed May 21, 2020, https://ahdictionary.com/word/search.html?q=karma). Equally problematic are the definitions of the individual senses themselves, and that the Dictionary entry treats the Buddhist and the Hindu understanding of the term karma indiscriminately.

**n.18** *Cattāri kammāni. Atth’ āvuso kammaṃ kaṇhaṃ kaṇha-vipākaṃ. Atth’ āvuso kammaṃ sukkaṃ sukkavipākaṃ. Atth’ āvuso kammaṃ kaṇha-sukkaṃ kaṇha-sukka-vipākaṃ. Atth’ āvuso kammaṃ akaṇhaṃ asukkaṃ akaṇha-asukka-vipākaṃ, kammakkhayāya saṃvattati* (DN III, 230). Trans. by Walshe 1995, 492.

**n.19** Abhidh-k-bh(P), 234,26–235,3, ad AKK 4.59 c,d: *kṛṣṇaśuklādibhedena punaḥ karma caturvidham || 4.59 || asti karma kṛṣṇaṃ kṛṣṇavipākam | asti karma śuklaṃ śuklavipākam | asti karma kṛṣṇaśuklaṃ kṛṣṇaśuklavipākam | asti karmākṛṣṇamaśuklamavipākam | yat tatkarma karmakṣayāya saṃvartata iti |.* Trans. by Pruden 1988–91, 635*.*

**n.20** Trans. by Pruden 1988–91, 635.

**n.21** See The Exposition of Karma, Toh 338.

**n.22** See Kudo 2004, ix, xx–xxi.

**n.23** See Simon 1970. This version may be identical with the title no. 280: *las rnam par ’byed pa chung ngu* in the Denkarma (Tib. *lhan kar ma*) catalog (Herrmann-Pfandt 2008, 154). It is represented by the Tibetan translation H343 in the Lhasa Kangyur (despite the misleading entries in the *dkar chag*), S287 in the Stok Palace manuscript Kangyur, B346 in the Berlin manuscript Kangyur, and N784 in the Narthang Kangyur’s supplementary (*kha skong*) volume, as well as by a Dunhuang version (PT944). 84000 hopes to add an English translation to this collection in future.

**n.24** Simon 1970, 161. These characteristics seem to be shared by all the witnesses of the of the *Karmavibhaṅga* mentioned above in n.23.

**n.25** Maggi 1995, 20.

**n.26** Lévi 1932, 235, n. 1: “Cf. Kandjour, Mdo XXVI, 468a, *texte très voisin, mais différent*.”

**n.27** Kanakura, Yenshô, Munetada Suzuki, and Hakuju Ui. 1934. *A Complete Catalogue of the Tibetan Buddhist Canons (Bkaḥ-ḥgyur and Bstan-ḥygur)* (= *Chibetto daizōkyō sōmokuroku*). Sendai: Tôhoku Imperial Univ., p. 63, no. 339: *que* *闕*, translator unknown.

**n.28** For translations and short comments on these terms, see glossary entries: “ignorant of the Dharma,” “ghost,” “monks and nuns.”

**n.29** Equivalent to Skt. “tathāgata.”

**n.30** See McKeown 2010, 1–96 (for a discussion of *yang dag par gshegs pa*, see pp. 10, 19, 23, 24, 29).

**n.31** Mr. Yi Ding states the following in two emails to the translator: “Based on my impression, I don’t think that anyone in Japan has raised the question whether D 339 [the *las kyi rnam par ’gyur ba zhes bya ba’i chos kyi gzhung*] is a translation from China, which might indicate that there are no obvious giveaways. Also, Ch-1, Ch-2 and Ch-3 are too different from D 339; Ch-4 and Ch-6 were translated into Chinese at a very late stage when there was virtually no known cultural exchange between Tibet and China,” (May 29, 2017), and “[…] among the Chinese translations, Taishō no. 80 is the closest to D 339 but not close enough for a direct relationship. And I totally agree that D 339’s language is pre-reform and very idiosyncratic,” (June 1, 2017). For a complete list of the Chinese translations, see Kudo 2004, Bibliography, p. xx. We are very grateful to Mr. Yi Ding (Stanford University) for providing us with his comments and information about the Chinese translations as well as the Japanese scholarly literature on the group of (*Mahā-*)*Karmavibhaṅga* texts, in particular the works written in Japanese by Noriyuki Kudo (see bibliography).

**n.32** Cf. Apple & Apple 2017, 83: “Cristina Scherrer-Schaub (2002) has proposed that Tibetan translation practices began as early as 763 C.E. with the arrival to Tibet of the Indian scholar Śāntarakṣita.”

**n.33** See Herrmann-Pfandt 2008, 155. The catalog lists a text with an almost identical title (*las kyi rnam par ’gyur ba bstan gyi gzhung*) and the same length (270 *ślokas* and 1 *bam po* correspond almost exactly to the 23 folios of Toh 339 in the Degé edition.

**n.34** The reader should keep in mind that these dates should not be accepted without skepticism, for much of the early history of Tibet and the history of the transmission of Buddhism to Tibet remains obscure, due to a lack of reliable historical sources. Also, we should not forget that this does not tell us anything about the history of the transmission of the *Karmavibhaṅganāmadharmagrantha* before its translation into Tibetan, let alone the history and geographical origin of its composition.

**n.35** See Feer 1883, pp. 250–79.

**n.36** Sylvain Lévi mentioned in the introduction to his edition and translation of the *MahāKarmavibhaṅga* that Feer’s translation contained some “grave errors” (Lévi 1932, 4).

**n.37** According to D, S *’di skad bdag gis thos pa dus gcig na|*. V.l. Y, K, L *’di skad bdag gis thos pa’i dus gcig na|*.

**n.38** According to Feer, part one starts at this point.

**n.39** This form of the name according to D *shu ko*; vv.ll., S *sho ko*; L *sho go*.

**n.40** Part of ancient Indian etiquette when interacting with prominent and respected religious leaders was to never position oneself directly in front of the person, but to stand or sit slightly to one side. Also, when leaving, one would first circumambulate the teacher clockwise, i.e., with one’s right shoulder toward the teacher, before leaving from the side.

**n.41** A, D *gau ta ma khyod la bdag cung shas shig* [C *cung shes shig*] *’dri na*; S, Z *go’u ta ma khyod la | bdag cung shas shig ’dri na |*. The spelling of the quantifier *cung shas* here is unusual, and we have not seen it elsewhere so far (usual spelling is *cung zad* or *chung zad*). However, all Kangyur editions that we have consulted use this spelling. Moreover, the entire sentence strikes us as rather unusual in this context of a sūtra introduction.

**n.42** Tibetan *kye* here probably translates the Middle Indic/Buddhist Sanskrit expression *bho* (contracted form of the vocative of Sanskrit *bhagavant*; cf. PED, s.v. *bho*: “sir, friend, you, my dear [… ].”

**n.43** Tibetan *ngan pa* in this context means “ignorant” or being without knowledge or understanding of the Dharma and—more specifically in this context of the teachings on karmic cause and effect and Buddhist ethics—knowing which actions to choose and which to avoid, including respect for and belief in those who possess such knowledge and understanding. L. Feer (1883, 254), in accord with the context, translates this as *C’est par les actes qu’on est dans le mal de (l’ignorance)*. See 1.20 below for the detailed account of this category.

**n.44** The Tibetan is unclear (D 299.a,6: *kye gau ta ma las kyi rnam par smin pa gang gi phyir na sems can sna mang por ’gyur*); more literally perhaps “Sir Gautama, [how] do beings become varied due to karmic ripening?” The Tibetan syntax bears some resemblance to a corresponding sentence in the Sanskrit Mh-karmav (Lévi 1932, 29): *kasya nu bho gautama karmaṇo vipākenedaṃ satvānāṃ nānātvaṃ prajñāyate* (“How, sir Gautama, can one understand the apparent diversity of human beings in terms of (or by way of) karmic results of actions?”), which has guided our translation here.

**n.45** This translates a unique version of the otherwise familiar stock phrase found at the opening of many sūtras (*khyod nyon la dge bar shin tu yid la zung shig*). L. Feer translates the Tibetan *dge bar (shin tu yid la zung shig)* literally as “virtuously” (cf. Feer 1883, 253). However, it is probably just equivalent to the Sanskrit *sādhu-* or Chinese *shan zai* *善(哉)* here of the commonly found stock phrase. Cf. Mvy. (Sakaki 6315) for the standard rendering of the common Sanskrit version of this phrase: *dena hi śṛṇu sādhu ca suṣṭhu ca manasikuru* (Tib. *de’i phyir legs par rab tu nyon la yid la zungs shig*).

**n.46** Tibetan *de’i phyir* (Skt. *tena hi*?), “now then,” which Feer (1883, 253) has translated as “I will speak *on this subject*” (*Je vais parler sur ce sujet*).

**n.47** D *tshe rabs kyi las las gyur te*; S, L have a sentence terminating particle instead: *las gyur to*.

**n.48** The diction of this paragraph is challenging, and our translation is uncertain. Due to the similarity of this passage with another variant of this group of terms in *Karmavibhaṅga* (Toh 338, 1.2) and in order to make the text more intelligible, we tentatively assume that *tshe rabs kyi las las gyur te* was supposedly intended to render Skt. *karmasvaka*, *sbyin pa’i rnams kyang las* Skt. *karmadāyāda*, *skye ba’i rnams kyang las* Skt. *karmayoni*, *so sor rgyu ba yang las* Skt. *karmabandhu*, and *sems can rnams ni las kyis rnam par bsgyur* Skt. *karmapratisaraṇa*. This rendition here seems to be closer to the parallel version in the Pāli canon (MN III, 203,4–6): *Kammassakā, māṇava, sattā kammadāyādā kammayonī kammabandhū kammapaṭisaraṇā. Kammaṃ satte vibhajati yad idaṃ hīnappaṇītatāyāti*. Translation Bhikkhu Ñāṇamoli and Bhikkhu Bodhi 2009, 1053, paragraph 4: “Student, beings are owners of their actions, heirs of their actions; they originate from their actions, are bound to their actions, have their actions as their refuge. It is action that distinguishes beings as inferior and superior.” Cf. the standard renditions in Mvy of these otherwise well-known terms: Tib. *las bdag gyir byed pa* renders Skt. *karmasvakaḥ* (Sakaki 2313); *las kyi skye gnas pa* renders *karmayoniḥ* (Sakaki 2315); *las kyi bgo skal la spyod pa* renders *karmadāyādaḥ* (Sakaki 2314); *las brten par bya ba* renders *karmapratisaraṇam*/*karmapratiśaraṇam* (Sakaki 2316). Feer (1883, 253) translates: “*Manava, les êtres provenant des actes de leurs existences (antérieures), le don et tout ce qui s’y rattache étant un acte, la naissance et tout ce qui s’y rattache étant un acte, la cause individuelle de chaque être étant un acte, Manava, les êtres se transforment par l’effet des actes.*”

**n.49** We have retained the agricultural metaphor here. An alternative translation of Tibetan *las rnam par smin pa’i ’bras bu* may be: “the result of one’s acts” or “karmic punishment and reward” (cf. The Hundred Deeds (Toh 340). A slightly different translation is offered by L. Feer (1883, 253): “It follows that, according to the good, the evil or the in-between (good and bad), the varieties of beings are associated with many different kinds of acts, with many different kinds of sufferings, with many different kinds of views; I will say, for example: the [respective] fruit results from [either] a black act or a white act. Thus, Manava, by the effect of black acts, a being is born (goes) in a bad direction, such as Narakas, Animals, *Yaxas* (sic), roamers (?), Asuras, etc. Those who have done white acts are reborn among gods or humans.” (*Il s’ensuit que, selon le bien, le mal ou l’entre-deux (du bien et du mal), beaucoup d’espéces d’ètres sont liés à beaucoup d’espéces d’actes, à beaucoup d’espéces de douleurs, à beaucoup d’espéces de vues; je veux dire, par exemple: le fruit résultant d’un acte noir et d’un acte blanc. Ainsi, Manava, par l’effet des actes noirs, un être naît (pour aller) dans la mauvaise direction, telle que le Naraka, les animaux, les Yaxas, les rôdeurs, les Asuras, etc. Ceux qui ont fait des actes blancs renaissent parmi les dieux et les hommes.*) It is noteworthy that this particular Tibetan translation deviates strongly from parallel passages in related texts in Sanskrit and Pāli, respectively: *karma māṇava satvān vibhajati. yad idaṃ hīnotkṛṣṭamadhyamatāyām. tadyathā* … . (Mh-karmav paragraph 30); *Kammaṃ satte vibhajati yadidaṃ hīnappaṇītatāyāti* (MN III, 203). Both of these may be translated as “Living beings are differentiated by their actions, namely, [with regard to their] inferiority or superiority.” (Sanskrit adds “mediocrity.”) The diction in the Shelkar (London) Kangyur (L 353b,2–3) version of the related *Karmavibhaṅga* (Toh 338) is clearer: *sems can rnams kyi las sna tshogs dang| nyon mongs pa sna tshogs dang| lta ba sna tshogs dang| spyod pa sna tshogs rig nas| las nag po dang| dkar po rnams kyi ’bras bu rnam par smin pa brjod par bya ste|*, “having discerned the manifold actions, defilements, views, and modes of conduct of sentient beings, I will describe the resultant ripening (or the ripening of the result, Skt. *phala-vipāka*) of black and white acts.”

**n.50** Tibetan *ngan song*, Sanskrit *apāya*, is synonymous with Sanskrit *durgati*, more commonly translated as the “lower realm(s).”

**n.51** Tibetan *ring du ’khyams pa*. Feer (1883, 254) seems to have missed the mark: *C’est par les actes qu’on nait parmi les rôdeurs*, “It is through acts that one will be born as a prowler” (Germ. *Herumtreiber*). See the glossary for the term “ghost.”

**n.52** Here, the asuras, or demigods, are counted among the unfortunate rebirth destinies, or lower realms, which are more commonly known as Tibetan *ngan ’gro gsum*, the “three lower realms” (hells, animal realms, and ghosts).

**n.53** This is a free translation of the Tibetan, which reads literally: “through/due to the “ripening” of an action/actions” (*las kyi rnam par smin pas*), and which we have otherwise translated as “karmic ripening” throughout (See the glossary, s.v. *las kyi rnam par smin pa*, for a more detailed explanation). We have also abbreviated the Tibetan in our English translation. The sentences after the first one start with *las kyis* which we interpret to be short for *las kyi rnam par smin pas*.

**n.54** Tibetan *ma rabs kyi rigs su ’gyur ba*. According to Lama Kunga Rinpoche, “In colloquial Tibetan, *ma rabs* refers to a person who is very vulgar, rude, mostly low-class, and uneducated, with very bad manners; and whose mere presence causes nothing but trouble for everyone around, by being loud and disrespectful.”

**n.55** D *ngan par*; L, S *ngan por*.

**n.56** We understand “the Dharma” to be implied here, as becomes clear in 1.21. Tibetan *shes rab*, Sanskrit *prajñā*, is a notoriously difficult term to translate. Common translations include “wisdom,” “gnosis,” “insight,” “cognition,” “discriminating awareness,” etc. In this particular text, context most often suggests a sense of the word that expresses an analytical quality (or aspect) of one’s mental faculty that is based on prior knowledge or learning of a moral code. Feer (1883, 254) translates Tibetan *shes rabs chen po* as “extensive knowledge” (*une connaissance grande et etendue*). See the glossary entry on *shes rab* for an explanation.

**n.57** Tibetan *gzugs yod pa’i lha* is an uncommon term for Sanskrit *rūpāvacaradeva* (Tib. *gzugs yod pa na spyod pa’i lha*).

**n.58** Tibetan *las bzhin du mi ’gyur bar skye ba yang yod* (possible Skt. *astyapi karmamukhā aniyatopapattiḥ*). However, later in the text (at 1.7), the Tibetan reads: *las kyis bzhin mi ’gyur bar skye ba yang zhe na|*. See also 1.35. The karmic category spoken of here is that of Sanskrit (*a*)*niyata*, i.e., determined, fixed, definite, or inevitable, which means that the karmic result cannot be altered or averted, i.e., it is certain to be experienced in this life, in a future life or, in the case of the evil actions that bring immediate karmic retribution, immediately after death. Furthermore, its experience corresponds to the moral quality of the action. Cf. Abhidh-k-bh(P), ad AKK IV.54. Tr. by Leo M. Pruden (Pruden 1988–91, 629): “Action accomplished through intense defilement or through intense faith, with regard to the field of qualities, continually, and the murdering of a father and a mother, are determinate.”

**n.59** Feer (1883, 254) translates: “It is through actions that rebirth occurs without change; it is through actions that rebirth occurs with change.” (XXIII. *C’est par les actes que la naissance se produit sans changement*; XXIV. *C’est par les actes que la naissance se produit avec changement*.)

**n.60** According to D, L, S *ma bsams par byas pas*; vv.ll. Y, K *ma bsams par byas pa ma|*; U *ma bsams par bya bas*. Feer (1883, 254) translates: “When one has carried out actions without thinking about them (or having intended them; Tib. *bsams pa*), there will nonetheless be rebirth.” (*Quand on a fait des actes sans les méditer, la naissance se produit tout de même*). However, Tibetan *skye bar ’gyur ba* here as in the following three categories may be a dittography. The paragraphs corresponding to this category later in the text (cf. 1.38–1.40 below) make no mention of any specific kind of rebirth as the karmic result of (unintended) actions, but rather generally qualify or define actions with regard to the absence or presence of intention.

**n.61** Tibetan *’dus pa* (literally “collect,” “accumulate”; “assemble”) in *gang zag las ’di lta bu ’dus pas na* has a technical sense when applied to karmically relevant actions (see also BHSD, s.v. *upacita* and Lévi 1932, 9, 47–48, n. 8). The differentiation between the technical expressions “action that is carried out” (Skt. *karma kṛtaṃ*) and “action that is accumulated” (Skt. *karmopacita*) is explained in detail in Vasubandhu’s *Abhidharmakośabhāṣya*, verse IV,120 (see Abhidh-k-bh at AKK IV,120 Abhidh-k-bh(P) 271,20-272,3 = Pruden 1988–91, 701–702): “Action ‘done’ (Skt. *kṛta*) is distinguished from ‘accumulated’ (Skt. *upacita*) action. What are the characteristics and conditions of accumulated action? 120. Action is termed ‘accumulated’ by reason of its intentional character, by its completion, by the absence of regret and opposition, by its accompaniments, and by its retribution.” Although the phrase “to accumulate an action” is not natural English, we have kept this rather clumsy literal translation to indicate the specialized meaning of *’dus pa* (Skt. *upacita*) here and throughout this translation. Sylvain Lévi opted for a more elegant solution in his French translation of the closely related *Karmavibhaṅga* (Toh 338, 1.48) by employing a translation equivalent that expresses the sense of *’dus pa* in accordance with Vasubandhu’s definition: “*Quel est l’acte qui, étant fait, n’est pas aggravé*?” (Lévi 1932, 121).

**n.62** The syntax of the Tibetan in this sentence (and below) is obscure. The meaning of the karmic categories can be more clearly understood from the parallel passages in the *Karmavibhaṅga* (Toh 338, 1.48–1.50).

**n.63** In light of the explanations of the items listed in the full paragraphs later in the text, we have translated them in a way that tries to bring out the fact that both the former and the latter states (of happiness and unhappiness) are seen as being related by a combination of certain actions.

**n.64** According to D (*phyi nas bde bar*) *gyur pa’i las*; v.l. H (*phyi nas bde bar*) *’gyur ba’i las*. Here, the sentence structure differs from the preceding, parallel sentence, which reads *phyi nas mi bde ba’i las*. We have attempted to make this difference recognizable in our English translation.

**n.65** It is not clear why the Tibetan reads *sems can gang zag thams cad* here.

**n.66** While the sentence structure is generally the same as in the preceding sentences, here the word *las* (“action”) is missing, so that the subject of the sentence becomes *gang zag* (“person”). Although it may be the case that *las* should be supplied in this and the following sentences, we have translated according to the syntax as it is. Feer (1883, 255) translates: “For such an individual the [life]time is exhausted (but) the actions are not.” (*Pour tel individu, le temps est épuisé, l’acte ne l’est pas*). An individual’s actions not being exhausted means that this person still must experience the karmic consequences in the future.

**n.67** Tibetan *lus bde la*.

**n.68** According to D, L *gang zag lus mi bde la sems bde bar ’gyur ba’i las kyang yod|*. The editor, in consultation with the translator, settled for this perhaps less accurate but less wordy translation. The Kangyur editions of K, Y, J, N, C read: “well in body as well as in mind.” (Vv.ll. K, Y *gang zag lus kyang bde ba sems kyang bde bar ’gyur ba’i las ba yang yod|*; J, N, C *gang zag lus kyang bde la sems kyang bde bar ’gyur ba’i las kyang* [J, C *ba yang*] *yod|*; H *gang zag lus mi bde la sems kyang mi bde bar ’gyur ba’i las ba’ang yod|*).

**n.69** According to D, S, Z; L reads *gang zag lus kyang bde la sems kyang ’gyur ba yang yod|* (which could be a scribal omission). K, Y, J, N, C read: “unwell in body as well as in mind.”

**n.70** According to D, L, S, Z; K, Y, J, N, C omit this sentence.

**n.71** According to S, Z *gzugs legs pa dang*; v.l. D, L *gzugs ngan pa* [L: *ngan ba*] *dang|*. Feer (1883, 255) translates: “The individual who has accumulated such actions and who was born in the region of bad beings(?), will be physically beautiful, agreeable, with a charming complexion, good-looking, with a body that is pleasing to the sight, by virtue of his karma.” (*L’individu qui a accumulé tels et tels actes et qui est né sur le terrain des êtres-pervers sera physiquement beau, agréable, d’un teint charmant, de bonne mine, avant un corps agréable á la vue en vertu de son karma*).

**n.72** Meaning in a lower realm of saṃsāric rebirth (Tib. *sems can ngan pa’i sar yang skyes te|*).

**n.73** According to D *phyi rol gyi yul sa’i don ngan du ’gyur ba*, which agrees with the reading and the content of the corresponding paragraph (see 1.63 below). V.l. S, Z, L *phyi rol gyi yul sa’i don du ’gyur ba yang yod do||*, “there is (or will be) benefit for the external environment(?),” must be an error. Feer (1883, 255) translates: “Manava, it is like this: through following the path of the ten negative actions, one will arrive at a bad destination, the adverse region[s] [of rebirth?]. (*Manava, cela est ainsi: c’est parce qu’on a suivi le chemin des dix actions vicieuses, c’est à cause de cela que l’on arrive au but mauvais de la région adverse*).

**n.74** According to D, L, S, Z *tshe thung*. V.l. C *’thung* (possibly w.r. for *thung*).

**n.75** In classical Tibetan, the verb is generally impersonal, and the expression *zhe na* is often found in philosophical discourses or in treatises in which a (hypothetical) opponent’s position is presented before being refuted. Thus, common translations are “if someone asks (or says),” or “if it is asked (or said).” We have chosen a translation that is reflective of the sūtra’s narrative frame and its dialogic structure. In the following paragraphs, we have therefore treated Tibetan *zhe na* simply as signifying a question.

**n.76** “Factors” is our translation of Tibetan *chos* (*bcus na/ni*) in this context (literally: “when (or because) ten factors are present”). D, L *chos bcus na*; S, Z *chos bcus ni* (later *chos bcus na* throughout). Feer (1883, 256) translates Tibetan *chos bcus* as “ten conditions” (*Ici, tu me demandes par l’effet de quel genre d’actes le temps de la vie est court. Je te dirai que dix conditions font que la vie est courte. — Quelles sont ces dix? Si tu les demandes (les voici)*, “Here, you ask me, through the effect of which kind of act one’s lifespan is short. I will tell you that there are ten conditions that make one’s life short. What are the ten? If you wish to hear them, they are as follows.”) In an earlier draft of this translation, we chose to translate *chos* with “factors,” which, while not wrong, seemed too vague. Feer’s choice of “conditions,” on the other hand, does not seem to capture the idea that the respective actions enumerated in the text are major factors able to produce a karmic result, and not just conditions that need to be present for a result manifest. *Chos* in this text appears to be a different way of saying “(karmically relevant) action.”
                             
**n.77** According to D (*de la ji ltar las kyis tshe thung bar ’gyur zhe na| chos bcus na tshe thung bar ’gyur zhe na| bcu gang zhe na|*), “if you ask,” (*zhe na*) is at the end of each subset, thus apparently interpreting the whole to be Śuka’s question. We think, however, that the sentence beginning with *chos bcus* constitutes the Buddha’s answer to the initial question, and not a new question or part of the first one. This interpretation may be corroborated by the vv.ll. K, Y, N, U, L, S, Z *chos bcus na* [L *| shad* after *na*] [S, Z *ni*] *tshe thung bar ’gyur te* [H *ste*].

**n.78** According to D *gcod pa*; L, S, Z *bcad pa* (perfective of verb *gcod*, “having taken life; killed; murdered”); v.l. K, Y *bcod* (seems to be a relatively common variant of *gcod*).

**n.79** According to D, L, S, Z *srog gcod du bcug pa|*. V.l. N *srog gcod du bcod pa|*.

**n.80** According to D, L, S, Z *smon pa*; vv.ll. J *smin pa*; N *sman pa*.

**n.81** The Tibetan here uses *mi mdza’ ba*, which is synonymous with *dgra bo* “enemy, foe” used in the preceding item.

**n.82** The Tibetan is not entirely clear, but cf. (Toh 338, 1.8), for a similar content and context, where the meaning of *’thab mo* is unmistakably that of battle. A, D read *thab mo* [C, H, S, Z: *’thab mo*] *la lta zhing dad pa dang bcu ste|*. The preferable reading, however, seems to be that of C, H, S, Z: *’thab mo* “quarrel, fight; battle.” Z, moreover, has just *’thab mo la lta zhing dad pa dang|*. Feer’s (incorrect) translation (1883, 256) may result from reading *thab* (*mo*) without considering the vv.ll.: “Having one’s desires and one’s view focused on the hearth (where the meat is cooking?) …” (*porter ses désirs et ses regards sur le foyer (où cuit la viande?) …*).

**n.83** D, S, Z: *sems can rnams la skyabs byas*. V.l. L, Y, J, K, N, C: *sems can rnams skyabs byas* (without *la*).

**n.84** Tibetan *thal mo* (*la sogs pas*), literally “the palm of one’s hand.”

**n.85** This translates the obscure Tibetan *mya ngan bsring ba rnams* (D). See the Glossary of Terms, s.v. “monks and nuns” for a discussion of this term and a possible literal meaning. Vv.ll. L *mya ngan sring ba rnams*; S, Z *mya ngan srid pa rnams*.

**n.86** Tibetan *zas mi zhu ba za ba*. However, cf. a very similar passage in the Sanskrit text of the Mh-karmav, paragraph 4, (Lévi 1932, 37): “giving [someone] indigestible foods ([…-]*pradānaṃ tathāparijīrṇabhojanaṃ*).”

**n.87** According to D, L *’tshog* [S, Z *tshog*] *tu mi gzhug pa*; N *mchog tu mi gzhug pa*.

**n.88** The Tibetan means literally “not aspiring (or desiring) to beat” (*’tshog pa la mi smon pa*).

**n.89** Tibetan *rim gro byed pa*, in contexts like this, can have two main senses: (1) honoring, worshiping (also in form of rites and rituals), reverence; and (2) service, to serve, attend to (or upon), to aid, to see after. We have adopted the latter sense, considering the context of illness. Exact translation into English is complicated by the fact that the Tibetan seems to carry both senses at the same time: tending to or caring for someone with respect or reverence because he or she is in an elevated position, which demands one’s respect and reverence (parents, clerics).

**n.90** The Tibetan is unclear (*zas zhu nas za ba*) and could perhaps also be interpreted as “[only] eating food that one has begged for (or received).” But based on a corresponding and very similar passage in the Sanskrit text of the Mh-karmav, paragraph 4 (Lévi 1932, 37), we are somewhat confident that Tibetan *zas zhu ba* must mean “digestible foods,” and the passage here originally (i.e., in the source text for the Tibetan translation) perhaps meant “providing them with digestible food.” Cf. also the preceding 1.10 above.

**n.91** Feer (1883, 257) politely rendered Tibetan *mi sdug pa* into French idiomatically: “a moderately pleasant [i.e., unpleasant] situation” (*Comment, diras-tu, arrive-t-on par l’effet des actes à une situation peu agréable.*). Lévi (1932, 37, n. 2) has identified the corresponding paragraph of the *Karmavibhaṅga* (Toh 338, 1.15) with relief 21 of the hidden base of the Borobudur (cf. ibid. for references), carrying the inscription “*virūpa*” (possibly meaning “deformed” or “ugly”). All consulted editions of *Transformation of Karma* (A, D, L, S, Z) read *mi sdug pa*. The *Karmavibhaṅga* (Toh 338, F.278.b) reads *kha dog mi sdug pa*, “complexion, color; appearance” (corresponding to Skt. *durvarṇa*; Lévi 1932, 37); L *mdog mi sdug pa*.

**n.92** According to S, Z *khro ba| gnod bcas pa|* (two items are needed here in order to parse ten items in this paragraph). D *khro ba gnod bcabs pa|*; vv.ll. L *khro ba gnong* (?) (read *gnod*) *bcas pa*|. The reading and the interpretation of this passage, however, is not clear. Is D *khro ba gnod bcabs pa* meant to constitute one term, two terms, or three terms (“anger, harming, disparaging”)? Feer (1883, 257) interpreted this phrase as containing two expressions: “enmity and concealed [*bcabs pa*, perfective of the Tibetan verb *’chab pa* (Skt. *mrakṣa*, “resentment”)] hostility” (*l’animosité*; *l’hostilité secréte*). The related *Karmavibhaṅga* (Toh 338) in its corresponding 1.15 even contains four terms: anger (*khro ba*), enmity (*’khon du ’dzin pa*), resentment (*’chab pa*), and spite (*’tshig pa*), as does the Mh-karmav (Lévi 1932, 37: *krodhaḥ*, *upanāhaḥ*, *mrakṣaḥ*, *pradāśaḥ* [read *paridāghaḥ*?], cf. Kudo 2009, 52; the last term, however, is doubtful, since the following Mh-karmav, paragraph 6, which contains the antipodes of the first three terms mentioned in Mh-karmav, paragraph 5, does not contain the opposite of *pradāśaḥ*). The Khotanese *Karmavibhaṅga* (Maggi 1995, 67) gives a curious interpretation of the apparent juxtaposition of terms signifying anger and jealousy or jealous disparagement (Tib. *khro ba gnod bcabs pa*?): “[The] first act is (if) he should see the advantage of a man being angry and violent, harsh (and such) that envy of the other (man) arises in him because of it.” (Note that the different terms here seem to constitute one “act” and not individual acts as in *Transformation of Karma*).

**n.93** D *’khon du ’dzin pa*; Y, K, L, S, Z *khon du ’dzin pa|*.

**n.94** The Tibetan is not entirely clear here. D and L (*gtum pa pha ma rnams la ngan du smra ba|*) do not seem to separate *gtum pa* from the following act (reviling ones’ parents), while S, Z do (*shad |* between *gtum pa* and the following sentence). Alternatively, one could perhaps interpret the passage to mean “being haughty (*gtum pa* is Old Tibetan for *gzu lum(s) che ba*), one is not welcoming (Tib. *ngan du smra*; Skt. *durāgata*) toward one’s parents, toward monks and nuns.” Parsing the Tibetan in this way, however, would leave one with fewer than ten acts in this category.

**n.95** According to D, which reads *mya ngan bsrings pa* in both instances: *mya ngan bsrings pa rnams la ngan du smra ba|*; L, S, Z *mya ngan bsrings* [L: *srings*] *pa rnams la ngan du smra ba| mya ngan srid pa’i spyad pa kun la ngan du byed pa|*.

**n.96** D *mya ngan bsrings pa’i spyad pa kun la ngan du byed pa|*; L, S, Z *mya ngan srid pa’i spyad pa kun la ngan du byed pa|*. A corresponding passage in the *Karmavibhaṅga* (Toh 338) of the London manuscript Kangyur (*mdo sde*, *ci*, 357a,6,7) reads *’phags pa’i yongs su spyad pa ma rung bar byed pa dang|*, “destroying the dwelling (or property, shrine) of a noble one.” Our translation follows the parallel passage of the London manuscript which seems clearer. However, the exact meaning of (*yongs su*?) *spyad pa* (Skt. *paribhoga*) here remains ambiguous, and the collocation with the predicate *ngan du byed* seems to carry moral overtones (Skt. *duṣ* + *√kṛ*? Or cf. the Tibetan expression *spyod ngan byed*, “to misbehave”).

**n.97** According to the Mvy Tibetan *mchod rten* should be used to translate both Sanskrit *stūpa* and *caitya* (see Sakaki 6999, 7000). The Sanskrit word *caitya* can refer to a stūpa, but also to a shrine, sacred place or any sacred object. We have therefore rendered *mchod rten* with the broader term *caitya* in this translation to retain and express this ambiguity, except where it is clear that specifically a *stūpa* is referred to.

**n.98** Feer, in his French translation of *Transformation of Karma*, uses the Sanskrit reconstruction *samyaggata* to render Tibetan *yang dag par gshegs pa*, whereas the standardized rendering of Sanskrit *tathāgata* is *de bzhin gshegs pa* (Sakaki 3). Feer (1883, 257, n. 2) comments: “ ‘He who has come, once and for all,’ one of the epithets of the Buddha. I use the Sanskrit word which corresponds to the Tibetan term of our text. It seems to me preferable to a translation that could otherwise only be bizarre.” (*“ ‘Celui qui est venu réellement, venu une fois pour toutes,’ une des épithétes du Buddha. J’emploie le mot sanskrit auquel correspond le terme tibétain de notre texte. Il me paraît préférable à une traduction qui ne pourrait être que bizarre.”*). However, as far as we know, *samyaggata* is not usually used as an epithet of the Buddha in Indic Buddhist texts (in the Sanskrit and Pāli texts we have searched, *samygaggata* is exclusively an adjective). The Sanskrit adjective *samyaggata* (Pāli *sammaggata*) generally means “behaving properly,” or “(being) of correct or perfect conduct.” In our interest to preserve the text’s idiosyncratic character, we would have liked to adopt Feer’s very original choice of *samyaggata* for our translation. However, we chose *Tathāgata* instead, which is what one would expect in the Sanskrit original.

**n.99** Feer (1883, 257) translates: “To refuse to keep a caitya of the Samyaggata (i.e., Tathāgata) clean.” (*le refus de la propreté au caitya du Samyaggata*). In a parallel paragraph to this one, (Toh 338, 1.15) has two different sentences: “soiling stūpas and monasteries and the site of a stūpa,” and “extinguishing offering lamps at stūpas and images.” Literally, Tibetan *’od gcod pa* can also mean “eliminate the luster (or brightness).” We have decided to follow the reading of the *Karmavibhaṅga* (Toh 338, F.278.b: *mar me gsad pa*).

**n.100** According to S, Z *rngan chan byed pa* (archaic for *brnyas thabs* “to despise; treat contemptuously”; cf. BGT, s.v.). Vv.ll. D, L *dngan can byed pa* (Old Tibetan orthography for *ngan* (see Rnam rgyal tshe ring 2001, s.v. *dngan can*); J, N, C, H *mngon can*. The passage seems corrupt: *Karmavibhaṅga* (Toh 338, 1.15, (F.278.b)) reads A, D *phyas ’dogs pa* [vv.ll. J *phyas ’drogs*; K *phyes ’dogs*], which is obscure. The *Karmavibhaṅga* (Toh 338) of the London manuscript Kangyur has *dbang za ba*, which has the sense of feeling entitled to despise, belittle, or humiliate, and to manipulate or exploit others (cf. BGT, s.v.). The Mh-karmav is clear: Sanskrit *avahasanam* (Lévi 1932, 38) means “ridiculing someone.”

**n.101** This is a free translation of Tibetan *ci la yang mi gtsang bar byed pa|*, literally “making everything dirty.”

**n.102** The sentence “Through [the presence of] these ten factors one will…,” is omitted here (*chos ’di bcus* … *-r’gyur ro*).

**n.103** Feer (1883, 258) translates Tibetan *bzang po* as “prosperity” (*situation prospère*). But context and a parallel passage in the *Karmavibhaṅga* (Toh 338, 1.16 (F.278.b): *mdzes pa* as the antonym of *kha dog mi sdug pa*) suggest “beautiful” as the more appropriate translation.

**n.104** D *mya ngan las* [T, K omit *las*] *bsrings pa rnams*; L, S, Z *mya ngan bsrings par rnams*.

**n.105** See above, 1.12, D, L *dngan*; vv.ll. J, N, H *mngan*; C *ngan*.

**n.106** The Tibetan (D *ci la yang gtsang bar byed pa ste|*) says literally “making everything clean”; vv.ll. Y, K *gcad par byed pa*; J, N, C *gcod par byed pa*.

**n.107** Note that this paragraph includes only eight items. Some of the following paragraphs also include less than ten items. We will not note this in every case, but only when it is connected to linguistic problems, or when there is a conflict between different readings of the various Kangyur editions.

**n.108** Tibetan *dbang chung ngu*, from Buddhist Sanskrit *alpeśākhya* (Pāli *appesakkha*); cf. CPD, s.v. *appesakkha*; BHSD, s.v. *alpeśākhya*. The word originally meant “unrespected, insignificant; of little esteem” (It has been accepted that the Middle Indic form of the term is derived from an original Sanskrit form *alpa-/mahā-yaśas-ka*). The respective Sanskrit form of the word (*alpa-/mahāśakya* vs. *alpe-/maheśākhya*) can be an indicator of a text’s school affiliation (see O. von Hinüber, “Die Bestimmung der Schulzugehörigkeit buddhistischer Texte nach sprachlichen Kritertien,” 1985, in Bechert 1985). The form *alpa-/mahāśakya* is surmised by F. Edgerton to have originated as a folk-etymological alteration of *alpe-/maheśākhya* (see BHSD, s.v. *mahāśakya*). It is predominantly found in the texts affiliated with the Sarvāstivādins. The traditional derivation or analysis of the term is *alpa-īśa-ākhya* (with *maheśākhya* being an analogical formation), perhaps meaning literally “named after an insignificant chief or master, or low origin” (see Apte, s.v.). This meaning is reflected in the standardized Tibetan translation as given in the Mvy. (Sakaki 6412): *dbang chung bar grags pa*. The Tibetan form present here, however, *dbang chung ngu* appears to be closer to Sanskrit *alpaśakya*, or perhaps even Chinese *shao shi* *少勢*.

**n.109** It is not clear whether Tibetan *thob pa* should be rendered into English in the sense of “achievement” (HTOED semantic field 01.15.16.02 n.: success), “acquisition” (HTOED semantic field 02.06.08 n.: acquisition), or rather “profit, gain” (HTOED semantic field 01.15.14 n.: advantage). Given the apparent context of social prestige in this paragraph, we have leaned toward the first in our translation.

**n.110** “Criticism” is our rendition of Tibetan *sgra bstod pa med pa*, *sgra bstod being a variant* of *sgras (b)stod*.

**n.111** For Tibetan *sri zhu mi byed pa*, cf. Dan Martin’s entry in the Rangjung Yeshe Dictionary, *sri zhu*: “ ‘reverence’ (for elders, parents, etc.). Coblin in JAOS 111, p. 317. As translation of a Sinitic concept, see Stein, Tibetica Antiqua I 163, 195. *khrus dang sku mnye dang dril phyis byed pa. bka’ drin bsam nas bkur sti byed pa*. Btsan-lha.” However, *sri zhu* is an ancient Tibetan term that may or may not exactly correspond content-wise to Chinese *xiao* *孝*, “filial piety.”

**n.112** According to D *mya ngan bsrings pa*; vv.ll. L *srings pa*; J, N, C *bsings pa*.

**n.113** It is also possible to translate this sentence as “causing the roots of unwholesome states to arise *in* those who have little power.” However, it may be more likely that the meaning of the passage has been that which is preserved in the *Karmavibhaṅga* (Toh 338) of the London manuscript Kangyur (*mdo sde*, *ci*, 357b,6): *dge ba’i rtsa ba chung ngu yang dag par phar ’dzin du ’jugs pa dang| dge ba’i rtsa ba chen po’i rgyun gcod pa dang*, “Causing someone to overly(?) esteem small (or weak) roots of wholesome states, while cutting off a stream of strong roots of wholesome states.” Cf. also the extant Central Asian Sanskrit fragment from Eastern Turkestan (the *Śukasūtra*; cf. Lévi 1932, 235f.): [*mahā-*]*śakyāt kuśalamūlād vicchandanam alpaśakyānāṁ pudgalānāṁ paribhavaḥ*, “cutting [oneself or another?] off from powerful roots of wholesome states; contempt for persons with little power.”

**n.114** The “roots of unwholesome states” are the three mental poisons: greed, hate, and delusion.
                                                                                              
**n.115** Tibetan *yang dag par gshegs pa’i mchod rten dang gnas byed pa|*. Tibetan *gnas* here likely means “a holy place” or “object of veneration” (Sanskrit *caitya*; cf. BHSD, s.v. *caitya*). The *Śukasūtra* fragment (Lévi 1932, 235f.) reads *tathāgatabimbakaraṇam* “making an image (or statue) of the Tathāgata.” The *las rnam par ’byed* of the London manuscript Kangyur (*mdo sde*, *ci*, 358a,3) reads *de bzhin gshegs pa’i mchod rten gyi khang pa byed pa dang|*, which could mean (depending on what one assumes to have been the cultural milieu of the text) “erecting a raised platform on which a stūpa can be built,” or, literally, “building a caitya-hall (a house or a cave?) for a stūpa.”

**n.116** Translating D, L, S, Z *dbang chung ngu*; v.l. Y, K *des chung ngu*. The *Karmavibhaṅga* (Toh 338) of the London manuscript Kangyur *(mdo sde*, *ci*, 358a,3-4) reads *dge ba’i rtsa ba chung ngu rgyun mi gcod pa dang| dge ba’i rtsa ba chen po yang dag par ’dzin du ’jug pa’o|*. The *Śukasūtra*-fragment (Lévi 1932, 235) reads *alpaśakyāt kuśalamūlāt vicchandanam*, “separating [oneself or another?] from weak roots of wholesome states,” and *mahāśakye kuśalamūle samādāpanam*, “encouraging/motivating [oneself or another?] [to make an effort] with regard to the strong roots virtue,” respectively.

**n.117** Tibetan *pha ma la pha mar mi ’dzin pa|* seems pleonastic. Tibetan *mar/phar mi ’dzin pa* translates the (Buddhist?) Sanskrit idiomatic expression *amātajñaḥ*/*amātajñatā* and *apitṛjña*/*apitṛjñatā* respectively (or as one compound, *amātāpitṛjñatā*; see Mh-karmav, paragraph 9; cf. Negi 3497, II).

**n.118** Tibetan [*phar*] *mi shes pa* = *phar mi ’dzin pa*, cf. Negi 3497, II.

**n.119** According to D, S, Z *dge sbyong* (Skt. *śramaṇa* “renunciate, ascetic”); v.l. L, Y, K: *dge slong* (Skt. *bhikṣu* “mendicant”). This phrase may translate Sanskrit *aśrāmaṇyatā* (see Lévi 1932, 235).

**n.120** D, L, S, Z *rigs kyis btsun pa*, which should nevertheless be corrected to *rigs kyi btsun pa* (see also below 1.17).

**n.121** D, S, Z *bsti stang*; vv.ll. L, Y, K, N, C *sti stang*; J *sti stong*.

**n.122** This passage seems corrupt. D *nams* [K, N, C, H *rnams*] *kyang mgron* [Y, J, K, N *’gron*] *mi gnyer ba|*; L *nams kyang mgon mi gnyer ba|*, “not offering protection”?; S, Z *nams kyang mgron du mi gnyer ba*.

**n.123** According to D, L, S, Z. N adds *nga ba dang*, H adds *pha ma dang* before *mkhan po dang|*.

**n.124** Here and throughout, we have opted for a literal translation of Tibetan *thar par zhugs pa rnams* (Skt. *pravrajitāḥ*; see Negi, 2004, II). See also “those who have entered the path of liberation” in the glossary.

**n.125** (Realm of the asuras) The vv.ll. might support emendation to *rigs kyi btsun pa*: N, H: *kyi* instead of D *kyis*. Sanskrit or Pāli *abhijāta* (“noble birth”) is well attested (cf. pw and CPD, s.v.).

**n.126** We are not entirely sure what *spag* here means; cf. however BGT, s.v. *spags* (perfective of *spog*): 2) (*rnying*) *sta gon byas pa* “to make preparations.”

**n.127** It is unclear to what exactly the Tibetan term *thar par spyod pa* refers; perhaps “lay Buddhist practitioners?”

**n.128** A similar sentence in the *Śukasūtra*-fragment (Lévi 1932, 235) reads *kule jyeṣṭhānupālakatvam āsanāt paryutthānam āsanenābhinimantraṇam* (*mātāpitroḥ śuśrūṣā*) “respecting/preserving [the right or custom?] of seniority in the family, getting up from one’s seat [and] offering the seat [to the elder?]; (obeying/revering one’s parents).”

**n.129** According to D, L *gzhan*; S, Z *gzhun*, “those who have been tamed?”

**n.130** Y, N, J, K, C omit Tibetan *ma byin par len pa* “stealing.”

**n.131** Tibetan *gtsug lag khang* can also mean “house/building where the Buddhist scriptures (Tib. *gtsug lag* = *sde snod*; Skt. *tripiṭaka*) are kept.”

**n.132** Tibetan *mchod cing spyod pa kun gcod pa|*. The suffix *cing* (*zhing*, *shing*) here seems to indicate coordination of what appear to be the verbs *mchod* and *spyod*, the former in the sense of “to venerate,” with the specialized sense “to make offerings,” and “to honor” (cf. BGT, s.v. *mchod pa*), here rendered as nouns.

**n.133** The Tibetan uses the same word here (*thob pa*) as in 1.14 and 1.15 above, where we translated it as “achievement.” We think, however, that the context in this paragraph demands the sense of (material) obtaining (HTOED semantic field 02.06.08 n.: acquisition).

**n.134** Literally “Rejoicing when [something] was not obtained (or acquired) by others.”

**n.135** According to D *mu ge byung* [U *’byung*] *du smon pa*; L, S, Z *mu ge byung na smon pa*; v.l. J, C *smod* “to loathe, deprecate,” does not fit this context. The D reading may be confirmed by the reading in the *Śukasūtra*-fragment (Lévi 1932, 235): *durbhikṣāyācanā ca|*.

**n.136** J adds *la don*: *’tsho ba la sbyin pa*, instead of D *’tsho ba sbyin pa|*.

**n.137** Feer (1883, 260) translates Tibetan *mkhan po* as *savant*, “scholar.”

**n.138** The structure of this sentence seems to be parallel to D 302a,1: *mkhan po dang bla ma thar par zhugs pa rnams la gzhan la yang*, where *thar par zhugs pa rnams* is replaced (abbreviated?) by *ltag ma* (or *lhag ma*). D, Y, H *mkhan po dang bla ma ltag ma* [A, p. 875, line 5: *lhag ma*!] *dang gzhan rnams la*, which may mean “the head teacher and all others (i.e., all those who are *thar par zhugs pa* following in the order of their rank / seniority).” S *mkhan po dang| bla ma dang| ltag ma dang gzhan rnams la*. The v.l. of L, Z *mkhan po dang| bla ma dang| lhag ma dang| gzhan rnams la* (if one understands *lhag ma* to mean “rest.” But *lhag ma* can have a meaning similar to *ltag ma*), although “the monastic preceptor, the teacher, the rest, and all others,” seems to make less sense. For D *bla ma* [*bla*] *ltag*/*lhag ma*, cf. also Negi, 3910: *bla lhag pa* (Skt. *adhikaḥ*; *upacayaḥ*; *ādhikyaṃ*).

**n.139** The meaning of Tibetan *rim par spyod pa* is not entirely clear (“service,” “veneration,” “attendant/servant?”), but given the context, it seems to express the same as *mchod cing spyod pa* “offerings and service” in the previous paragraph. The parallels of the word formation to Tibetan *rim gro*, “veneration,” can hardly be accidental. Feer (1883, 260) translates: “[providing them with the possibility of] the regular exercise of their practices” (*L’exercice régulier de leurs pratiques*).

**n.140** Tibetan *mal stan*; Sanskrit *śayanāsana*; Chinese *臥具*.

**n.141** D *gsos sman*; L, S, Z *gso sman*; and J *gsol sman* are not different in meaning.

**n.142** Tibetan *g.yog* here probably means “servants,” but could also just mean “service.”

**n.143** Feer (1883, 260) (mis)understood Tibetan *gzhan gyis don thob par nan tan du bsgrubs pa* to mean “To regard one’s own success as others’ success” (*regarder comme ses propres succès les succès d’autrui*.) Or should we translate “assisting (= translating *nan tan tu bsgrubs pa* as *nan tan sgrub pa* = Skt. *adhiṣṭhāna*) others in obtaining wealth?” Our translation may be confirmed by the reading in the *Śukasūtra*-fragment (Lévi 1932, 236): *parasya lābhodyogaḥ*.

**n.144** Reading D *lo legs par smon pa|* (Y, K *lo legs pa smon pa|*) may again be confirmed by the *Śukasūtra*-fragment (Lévi 1932, 237): *subhikṣāyācanā ca* (vv.ll. L, S, Z *lo legs par ston pa|*).

**n.145** Tibetan *ngan pa*. We have added “of the Dharma” here. According to our interpretation, it becomes clear in this paragraph that *ngan pa* refers to people with poor or no understanding or knowledge of the Dharma, and that it must mean the opposite of knowing, following, and applying the Dharma (cf. Negi, 935, II, s.v. *ngan pa*, for *ngan pa* in the sense of Sanskrit *ajñaḥ*, “not knowing, devoid of knowledge; stupid, foolish,” etc.).

**n.146** D, L *gang zag su yang rung ste|*; S, Z *gang zag su’ang ste ’dri mi shes pa|*. Perhaps D, L *gang zag su yang rung ste* could also be interpreted as “not knowing how to ask a qualified (Tib. *rung* as free morpheme) person questions.” However, Tibetan *’dri mi shes pa* here seems to have the same sense as the Sanskrit suffix *-jña* has in Sanskrit (*a*)*mātṛjñaḥ* and (*a*)*pitṛjña* (i.e., Tibetan *mar/phar mi ’dzin pa*, cf. 1.16 (F.301.b) above), “not appreciating.” This sentence makes the impression of being a summary, or abbreviation, of a similar sentence in a parallel passage in the *Karmavibhaṅga* (Toh 338, F.280.a): *de ni ’di la la la zhig dge sbyong ngam bram ze gzhan dag la chos ni gang yin| chos ma yin pa ni gang yin| bdag gis ci zhig byas na legs par ’gyur zhes mi ’dri’i|* (see also Mh-karmav paragraph 13). Thus, Tibetan *rung*, “qualified” or “appropriate,” here might refer to *śramaṇas* and brahmins, explicitly mentioned in the *Karmavibhaṅga* (Toh 338).

**n.148** D, S, Z *ma gtsigs* [N: *btsigs*] *par smra ba la dge bar stod* [L, Y, K, C, H: *bstod*] *pa|*.

**n.147** According to D, L *gtsigs*; v.l. N *btsigs*. The most apparent and straightforward reading seems to be *ma gtsigs par smra ba*, also because it has an attested possible Sanskrit equivalent in *asambaddha* [*-pralāpa*?], “incoherent/inconsequential [palaver?],” in the *Yogācārabhūmi*, cf. Yokoyama & Hirosawa 1996, s.v. *不相應* *bu xiang ying*.

**n.149** We have added “in the Dharma.”

Continued in part 2: https://84000.co/translation/toh339/part-2.md
