---
title: "Distinctly Ascertaining the Meanings"
toh: "Toh 317"
sanskrit_title: "Arthaviniścaya"
tibetan_title: "don rnam par nges pa"
canon_section: "Kangyur › Discourses › General Sūtra Section"
url: https://84000.co/translation/toh317
published: 2021-08-26
collections: []
publisher: "84000: Translating the Words of the Buddha"
translation_team: "Dharmachakra Translation Committee"
translators: ["Mattia Salvini"]
license: "CC BY-NC-ND 4.0"
license_url: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
citation: "Distinctly Ascertaining the Meanings (Arthaviniścaya, Toh 317). Translated by Dharmachakra Translation Committee. Online publication. 84000: Translating the Words of the Buddha, 2021. https://84000.co/translation/toh317."
part: 1
parts: 3
generated: 2026-11-16
---

# Distinctly Ascertaining the Meanings

Toh 317 · Kangyur › Discourses › General Sūtra Section · An 84000 translation · Read online: https://84000.co/translation/toh317

> **License:** [CC BY-NC-ND 4.0](https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/). This work is provided under the protection of a Creative Commons CC BY-NC-ND (Attribution - Non-commercial - No-derivatives) 4.0 copyright. It may be copied or printed for fair use, but only with full attribution, and not for commercial advantage or personal compensation. **Cite as:** Distinctly Ascertaining the Meanings (Arthaviniścaya, Toh 317). Translated by Dharmachakra Translation Committee. Online publication. 84000: Translating the Words of the Buddha, 2021. https://84000.co/translation/toh317.

> This is the plain-text edition of https://84000.co/translation/toh317. Passage labels (for example 1.2 or i.3) match the online edition. Each label is followed by the passage's permanent ID in square brackets, and by a Toh number when the passage belongs to one Toh only, for example **1.2** [ID] or **i.3** [ID, toh317]. To link to a passage, use https://84000.co/entity/passage/ID?toh=TOH, with TOH = toh317 when no Toh is given. Note numbers in square brackets (such as [n.3]) point to the Notes section. When quoting, cite 84000, *Distinctly Ascertaining the Meanings* (Toh 317), with the passage label and its link. The summary, introduction and notes are by the translators and are not part of the translated text.

## Parts of this text

This text is long, so its plain-text edition is split into 3 parts. Each part keeps 84000's passage labels and ends with the notes its passages refer to. The whole text in one file: https://84000.co/translation/toh317/full.md

- [Part 1](https://84000.co/translation/toh317.md): Summary, Acknowledgments, Introduction, The Translation (1.1–1.54)
- [Part 2](https://84000.co/translation/toh317/part-2.md): The Translation, Colophon, Abbreviations (1.55–1.163)
- [Part 3](https://84000.co/translation/toh317/part-3.md): Glossary

## At a glance

> Machine-generated overview: written by AI from 84000's published summary and introduction, not yet reviewed by an 84000 editor. It is not part of the translation; quote the translation itself.

**In brief:** Distinctly Ascertaining the Meanings (Toh 317), Sanskrit title Arthaviniścaya, is a sūtra belonging to the General Sūtra section of the Kangyur's Discourses collection. The Buddha, addressing an assembly of bhikṣus at Śrāvastī, presents a systematic survey of twenty-seven topics central to Buddhist thought and practice, beginning with the five aggregates and ending with the eighty minor marks of a great person. The text moves from fundamental categories of experience, such as the aggregates, the sense bases, and dependent arising, through the path teachings on meditation and mindfulness, and culminates in the qualities exclusive to a fully awakened buddha. Three interlocking concerns run throughout: the analysis of phenomena as a method for overcoming mental afflictions, the understanding of impermanence, suffering, and selflessness, and the progressive stages of realization leading to liberation. The text closes with the Buddha urging the bhikṣus to meditate in solitude and avoid negligence. The English translation was prepared by the Dharmachakra Translation Committee, with Mattia Salvini as translator, and first published by 84000 in 2021.

**Why read it:** This text offers a structured survey of core Buddhist teachings, from the five aggregates to the marks of a buddha, organized to support memorization, contemplation, and insight into the nature of phenomena and the path to liberation.

### What is the Arthaviniścaya and what does it cover?

The Arthaviniścaya, translated as Distinctly Ascertaining the Meanings (Toh 317), is a sūtra in which the Buddha presents a comprehensive, step-by-step outline of twenty-seven topics central to Buddhist teaching and practice. These range from the five aggregates and dependent arising through the path factors such as the four placements of mindfulness and the noble eightfold path, up to the ten strengths of the Tathāgata and the eighty minor marks of a great person.

### Where is the sūtra set and who are the main figures?

The sūtra opens with the Buddha, referred to as the Bhagavat, residing in Śrāvastī at the eastern pleasance in the palace of Mṛgāra's mother, in the company of a great assembly of one thousand two hundred and fifty bhikṣus. The Buddha is the sole teacher throughout, addressing his instructions directly to the gathered bhikṣus.

### What is the purpose of analyzing phenomena as explained in this text?

According to the eighth-century Nālandā master Vīryaśrīdatta, who wrote a commentary on this sūtra, the analysis of phenomena serves to pacify mental afflictions. Without such analysis, it is not possible to see clearly that conditioned things are impermanent, that everything leading to defilement involves suffering, and that nothing has a permanent, independent self. Pacifying the afflictions, in turn, leads to the attainment of the ultimate state.

### How does Distinctly Ascertaining the Meanings relate to other Buddhist texts and traditions?

The sūtra is cited by Yaśomitra in his commentary on Vasubandhu's Treasury of Abhidharma as an example of a sūtra in which the Buddha taught abhidharma directly, rather than in separate treatises. It shares features with The Discourse on the Twenty-Two Faculties, another sūtra in the Sarvāstivāda tradition. It was also commented on by Vīryaśrīdatta, whose Gathering reproduces much of the content of Vasubandhu's Treasury of Abhidharma.

### Who translated the sūtra into Tibetan, and when was the English translation made?

According to the colophon, the Sanskrit text was translated into Tibetan by the Indian preceptors Jinamitra and Prajñāvarman, together with the chief editor-translator Bandé Yeshé Dé. This would place the translation in the early ninth century. The English translation was prepared by the Dharmachakra Translation Committee with Mattia Salvini as translator, based primarily on the Tibetan in the Degé Kangyur, and was first published by 84000 in 2021.

### How is the structure of the sūtra analyzed in the commentary tradition?

Vīryaśrīdatta's commentary, the Gathering, divides the sūtra into six structural elements: the introductory presentation of the occasion (nidāna), the Buddha's opening remarks (upodghāta), the purpose of the teaching (prayojana), the initial list of topics (uddeśa), the explanation of each topic (nirdeśa), and the connections between expressions (anusandhi). This framework illuminates both the thematic logic and the internal progression of the text.

### In what languages has this text survived, and what versions exist?

Distinctly Ascertaining the Meanings survives in Sanskrit manuscript form, in Tibetan translation in the Kangyur, and in two Chinese translations from the tenth and eleventh centuries. Scholars have identified at least six distinct recensions, including a Ngor monastery palm-leaf manuscript, Nepalese manuscripts, the two Chinese translations, the Tibetan translation, and the text underlying Vīryaśrīdatta's commentary. There are also at least three prior modern translations into Italian and English.

## Summary

**s.1** [94ce24b1-3273-419d-952a-4ce8c7a13c3a] The sūtra *Distinctly Ascertaining the Meanings* begins with an introductory section, offering the context of the teachings. An explanation of twenty-seven topics is then presented by the Buddha, starting with the five aggregates and ending with the eighty minor marks of a great person. The Buddha then concludes by exhorting the bhikṣus to meditate in solitude and avoid negligence.

## Acknowledgments

**ac.1** [7390c7b1-9030-4535-96db-8b5cc316bae0] This text was translated by the Dharmachakra Translation Committee under the supervision of Chokyi Nyima Rinpoche. Mattia Salvini translated the text from Sanskrit and Tibetan into English and wrote the introduction. Thomas Doctor and James Gentry checked the translation against the Tibetan and edited the translation. Thankful for his profound kindness, the translators dedicate the merit of this translation to the swift reappearance of Kyabje Tsikey Chokling Rinpoche in this world.

**ac.2** [58deed1c-146b-4b21-9efb-ff96fbbb6387] The translation was completed under the patronage and supervision of 84000: Translating the Words of the Buddha.

## Introduction

**i.1** [b5b5e109-e978-4eeb-9031-a04cd4f71b16] > “Since apart from analyzing the dharmas
There is no other means to pacify mental afflictions,
And since due to mental afflictions people wander in this ocean of existence,
For the sake of that analysis, this has indeed been taught by the Teacher.”[n.1]

–Vasubandhu

**i.2** [e58ea282-500a-44bb-9297-59da096d4c6b] > “The instructions found in *Distinctly Ascertaining the Meanings* are for the purpose of analyzing the dharmas, since without the sūtras’ instructions a disciple cannot analyze the dharmas. Analyzing the dharmas is for the purpose of pacifying the afflictions; pacifying the afflictions is for the purpose of attaining the ultimate state.”[n.2]

–Vīryaśrīdatta

**i.3** [467568e9-f27a-4bed-806d-09de66f29644] Vīryaśrīdatta (fl. eighth century *ᴄᴇ*), the Nālandā master who commented on this sūtra, explains the expression *distinctly ascertaining the meanings* as a synonym of *analyzing the dharmas*, or classifying entities, so as to see directly both their unique traits and their shared features. This analysis constitutes a path to the realization that everything produced by assemblages of causes and conditions is impermanent, that everything leading to mental defilement is suffering, and that nothing whatsoever is or has a permanent and independent self.

**i.4** [dbb2157d-bce3-4810-8546-7a43d03fd3b1] According to a well-established tradition, having the right view is to recognize impermanence, suffering, selflessness, and that nirvāṇa is peace. This liberating vision vanquishes the mind’s poisons of attraction, aversion, and confusion. The mind then turns toward the virtues of merit and wisdom, gradually giving way to the peace of nirvāṇa.

**i.5** [25a77f2b-300b-420c-b469-278293096bda] *Distinctly Ascertaining the Meanings* is a step-by-step contemplation of all facets of reality and freedom from suffering. It starts with the five aggregates that constitute the common basis of defilement and purification and goes through the teachings on selflessness, the path to realize selflessness, and the higher stages of realization, and it culminates in the special features that belong exclusively to a fully awakened buddha. This invaluable archive of Buddhist terms and ideas is to be well absorbed and remembered, so as to make all other teachings easier to comprehend.

**i.6** [6aeb1860-005c-4406-832a-f06a4376ee03] Masters of the great monasteries of ancient India such as Nālandā, Vikramaśīla, and Odantapurī are likely to have held this text in high regard as an authoritative outline of the Dharma. The sūtra’s detailed and accessible commentary, the *Gathering* (*Nibandhana*) by Vīryaśrīdatta, is a didactically subtle and comprehensive manual of Buddhist philosophy. The *Gathering* reproduces much of the content of Vasubandhu’s *Treasury of Abhidharma* (*Abhidharmakośa*), an unsurpassed and thorough treatise of fundamental Buddhist thought; but while Vasubandhu’s text goes into much detail with the subject matter, the *Gathering* offers a much more accessible presentation of the same topics.

**i.7** [26ed0a72-d21f-4848-9f84-681942a21367] Vīryaśrīdatta shows the purpose and structure of the sūtra, connects it to other texts, and offers convincing, cogent, and well-supported interpretations. He explains the structure of the sūtra by analyzing it into six topical elements:

**i.8** [6a6b498a-d523-4962-9cfd-a83c51a3bf86] 1. the introductory presentation of the occasion when the sūtra was spoken (*nidāna*), which starts from the very beginning and goes up to the mention of the number of bhikṣus present;

**i.9** [9a635c2e-13e3-4cf2-b0b1-060b728986cb] 2. the opening remarks by the Buddha (*upodghāta*), which immediately follow, in which he tells the bhikṣus that he is going to teach and they agree to pay attention;

3. the purpose of the teaching (*prayojana*), embedded in the very title of the sūtra, which is wisdom or, more precisely, “analysis of the dharmas” (*dharmapravicaya*);

**i.10** [888353fb-1550-4820-9734-879aafdffb53] 4. the initial list of topics (*uddeśa*), which is the long list of twenty-seven topics that follows the opening remarks;

5. the explanation of the topics (*nirdeśa*) mentioned in the initial list, which starts right after the initial list and continues to the end of the sūtra;

**i.11** [9e467852-53b3-4ea6-b017-2f61dcc2821d] 6. the connection between the different expressions (*anusandhi*), more specifically showing how a later expression is thematically and/or logically connected to a prior one, which applies to the whole text.

**i.12** [62ae79ed-3aa8-410d-8394-63cbcff4fc79] The sūtra is also mentioned by Yaśomitra, the author of an extensive explanation (*vyākhyā*) on Vasubandhu’s *Treasury of Abhidharma*. Yaśomitra writes that according to “those who emphasize the sūtras” (Sautrāntika), while it is correct to say that the Buddha taught abhidharma, he did not teach separate abhidharmic treatises (as the Vaibhāṣika think); he taught the abhidharma in specific sūtras, such as *Distinctly Ascertaining the Meanings*. As the Buddha’s own paradigmatic statement on the actual nature of reality (*dharmalakṣaṇa*), the sūtra can be considered an authoritative overview of insight meditation (*vipaśyanā*). It shares some features with another sūtra transmitted in the Sarvāstivāda tradition, *The Discourse on the Twenty-Two Faculties*.[n.3]

**i.13** [a979cd2c-867f-49ea-96e7-2de899d36043] The Sanskrit text of *Distinctly Ascertaining the Meanings* was first edited by Alfonsa Ferrari in 1944 on the basis of two incomplete manuscripts: one she describes as a “modern copy of a Nepalese manuscript from around the fourteenth century”[n.4] in twenty-eight folios, about one third of which, she informs, contains the *Nibandhana* commentary, and another consisting of three folios photographed by Giuseppe Tucci in Ngor monastery in Ü-Tsang (an institution famous for its library of Sanskrit texts), which cover the first five paragraphs as per her edition. Ferrari points out that the Ngor manuscript may have been produced in Nālandā,[n.5] and she further writes that “Professor Tucci has noted the presence of copies of the *Arthaviniścaya*, in Sanskrit, at Žalu and in other monasteries of Tibet.”[n.6]

**i.14** [72b42887-d0bd-4637-997e-c66ea5cac1e5] A complete edition, on the basis of a Nepalese paper manuscript dated to 1858, preserved in Baroda, was published by P. L. Vaidya in 1961. Vaidya reports that, according to the postscript, the manuscript was copied from an older palm-leaf manuscript, in Newari script, from the Bir Library in Kathmandu.[n.7] One rather striking feature of this manuscript, Vaidya reports, is that it contains the following sentence in Sanskrit, showing its awareness of Tibetan texts: “The complete information about this is found in the sūtra called *Abhiniṣkramaṇa*; thus it is related in the Tibetan language.”[n.8] The anonymous Sanskritist was also a Tibetanist, it seems, or at least someone in dialogue with Tibetanists.

**i.15** [a4b4d4f7-cff6-494a-97fa-462f53776cd9] In 1971, N. H. Samtani offered a much-improved and complete edition, including the first edition of the *Nibandhana* commentary, based on the photographs taken by Rahul Sankrityayan of a palm-leaf manuscript from Ngor monastery.[n.9] Samtani’s edition, based as it is on the photographs of the oldest-available complete manuscript, is particularly valuable, and we have used it as the primary reference for the Sanskrit. However, all the above Sanskrit versions differ, in various respects, from the Kangyur version, and the Nepalese manuscripts edited by Ferrari, although not comparably old, contain sections that match the Tibetan translation more closely. Overall, the hypothetical Sanskrit original of (almost all) the Tibetan translation can be evinced by comparing the existing Sanskrit versions and looking at parallel passages in other Sanskrit and Pāli texts. This is extremely helpful, for it can greatly clarify the intended syntax of the Tibetan and, in a few cases, show how some obscure expression may be due to a mistake (even a printing mistake) in the transmission of the Tibetan.

**i.16** [7a9d0e87-90cd-4eaa-b4a2-42e667b82b89] This English translation was prepared based on the Tibetan translation in the Degé Kangyur in consultation with the Comparative Edition (*dpe bsdur ma*) and the Stok Palace Kangyur. According to the Tibetan translators’ colophon, the Sanskrit text was translated into Tibetan by the Indian preceptors Jinamitra and Prajñāvarman, and the Tibetan translator Yeshé Dé. This would place the translation in the early ninth century, but it is worth noting that the translation is absent from both the Denkarma and Phangtangma inventories of Tibetan translations dated to that time. It is also worth mentioning that Jinamitra and Yeshé Dé figure among the compilers of the great Sanskrit–Tibetan lexicon the *Mahāvyutpatti*, which is a useful point to bear in mind when trying to understand the relationship between the Tibetan translation and the various Sanskrit versions.

**i.17** [6d8b23a1-e2fb-4ee7-a853-87c74144a974] The sūtra was also translated, twice, into Chinese: once by Faxian in the tenth century, and later by Jin Zong Chi in the eleventh century (Taishō 762 *佛說決定義經* and Taishō 763 *佛說法乘義決定經*, respectively). Samtani (to whom the present translation is heavily indebted) points out that the two Chinese translations are based on a shorter and longer version, respectively, and discusses to some extent the differences between the different transmissions of this sūtra. According to De Jong, “Strictly speaking one can distinguish six different recensions: (1) the Ṅor manuscript; (2) the Nepalese manuscripts; (3) the first Chinese translation; (4) the second Chinese translation; (5) the Tibetan translation; (6) the text on which the commentary is based.”[n.10]

**i.18** [bfb3b300-335c-4d6f-8c2a-fa66acbaa83e] We could add the version commented on in the anonymous *don rnam par gdon mi za ba’i ’grel pa* (*Arthaviniścayaṭīkā*, Toh 4365), an elaborate commentary that survives only in its Tibetan translation. This commentary follows a different scheme than the one adopted by the *Nibandhana*. It is worth noting that the Tibetan terminology differs, to some extent, from the one employed in the Kangyur version of the sūtra. For example, the very title of the sūtra (*Distinctly Ascertaining the Meanings*) is translated as *don rnam par gdon mi za ba* rather than *don rnam par nges pa*; this is significant, considering also that the *Mahāvyutpatti* has an entry rendering *arthaviniścaya* with *don rnam par nges pa*. Similarly, *śrāvastī* is translated as *mnyan du yod pa*, rather than just *mnyan yod* as in the Kangyur translation of the sūtra, even when the term appears as a quote of the root text. Alfonsa Ferrari described this commentary as “very long but pedestrian and attached to the letter,”[n.11] comparing it unfavorably to the *Nibandhana*, which she describes as “shorter and juicier.”[n.12] We are not sure whether this is a fair assessment, but “juicy” may be a very good way to speak of the rewards of reading Vīryaśrīdatta’s comments, some of which will be found in the notes and in the glossary, so as to offer at least glimpses of what one may be missing by not reading the *Nibandhana*. The *Mahāvyutpatti* explicitly relied on Vasubandhu’s work, and so does Vīryaśrīdatta in explaining the contents of this sūtra. His glosses thus offer some keys to the subtlety, greatness, and extraordinary dedication of the ancient translators from Sanskrit into Tibetan.

**i.19** [6b659f14-d0ea-49b8-84c9-661fae979e8b] There are at least three modern translations of *Distinctly Ascertaining the Meanings*: one in Italian by Ferrari (1944), and two in English by Samtani (1971) and Ānandajoti (2016). None of these translations represents the Kangyur version, and we furthermore differ from all three in certain matters of interpretation. We hope this translation carries at least some of the flavor of the original with its recurrent phrases and topical lists so conducive to chanting and memorization.

## The Translation

**The Dharma Instruction “Distinctly Ascertaining the Meanings”**

**1.1** [997de509-b973-4680-be93-d4b2cff22ebb] I bow to all buddhas and bodhisattvas.

**1.2** [0b3139bb-13d7-443f-aef8-ba365239cd96] Thus did I hear at one time.[n.13] The Bhagavat was residing in Śrāvastī, at the eastern[n.14] pleasance in the palace of Mṛgāra’s mother, with a great saṅgha of one thousand two hundred and fifty bhikṣus.

**1.3** [5ef1ec74-cd36-458b-9d68-5eee8a7bb0c1] There, with a Brahmā voice that, like a cloud, was deep, delightful, and vast, the Bhagavat addressed the bhikṣus: “Bhikṣus, I will teach you the Dharma that is auspicious in the beginning, auspicious in the middle, and auspicious in the end,[n.15] that has good meaning and is well expressed.[n.16] I will clarify the unique, complete, pure, and purified Brahman conduct, the Dharma instruction *Distinctly Ascertaining the Meanings*. Listen properly and keep it firmly in your mind;[n.17] I am going to speak.”

“Good, Bhagavat,” the bhikṣus answered.

**1.4** [750b8b16-2756-43e9-8afc-6910b5c7a32f] The Bhagavat spoke to them thus: “What, bhikṣus, is the Dharma instruction *Distinctly Ascertaining the Meanings*? It consists of the five aggregates, the five aggregates of clinging, the eighteen bases, the twelve entrances, dependent arising with twelve parts, the four truths of the noble ones, the twenty-two faculties, the four meditations,[n.18] the four Brahma abodes, the four courses, the four cultivations of samādhi, the four placements of mindfulness, the four right efforts, the four footings of success, the five faculties, the five strengths, the seven parts of awakening, the noble path with eight parts, mindfulness of inhalation and exhalation with sixteen aspects, the four parts of entering the stream, the ten strengths of the Tathāgata, the four confidences, the four special knowledges, the eighteen dharmas exclusive to a buddha, the thirty-two marks of a great person, and the eighty minor marks. This, bhikṣus, is the list of topics for the Dharma instruction *Distinctly Ascertaining the Meanings*.

**1.5** [ddc0b56d-9a4e-4ac0-8fd4-ae57f81f75e4] “Now, bhikṣus, what are the five aggregates? They are the aggregate of form, the aggregate of feeling, the aggregate of notion[n.19], the aggregate of assembled factors, and the aggregate of consciousness. These, bhikṣus, are the five aggregates.

**1.6** [32105042-212c-415a-bd98-e84a605d443e] “Now, bhikṣus, what are the five aggregates of clinging? They are the aggregate of clinging of form, the aggregate of clinging of feeling, the aggregate of clinging of notion, the aggregate of clinging of assembled factors, and the aggregate of clinging of consciousness. These, bhikṣus, are the five aggregates of clinging.

**1.7** [d9a6f7aa-647b-4565-8898-86194fd6266a] “Now, bhikṣus, what are the eighteen bases? They are the eye base, form base, eye-consciousness base, ear base, sound base, ear-consciousness base, nose base, smell base, nose-consciousness base, tongue base, flavor base, tongue-consciousness base, body base, tangibles base, body-consciousness base, thought base, dharma base, and thought-consciousness base. These, bhikṣus, are explained as the eighteen bases.

**1.8** [5b4b59b0-6859-4113-a69a-5a4c7a2428a5] “Now, bhikṣus, what are the twelve entrances? They are the internal entrance of the eye, the external entrance of form, the internal entrance of the ear, the external entrance of sound, the internal entrance of the nose, the external entrance of smell, the internal entrance of the tongue, the external entrance of flavor, the internal entrance of the body, the external entrance of tangibles, the internal entrance of thought, and the external entrance of dharmas. These, bhikṣus, are explained as the twelve entrances.

**1.9** [f561e1cd-77dc-4f98-bd8b-8cfaeecfd99b] “Now, bhikṣus, what is dependent arising with twelve parts?[n.20] It is thus: assembled factors with ignorance as their condition, consciousness with assembled factors as its condition, name-and-form with consciousness as its condition, the six entrances with name-and-form as their condition, contact with the six entrances as its condition, feeling with contact as its condition, craving with feeling as its condition, clinging with craving as its condition, existence with clinging as its condition, birth with existence as its condition, and decay, death, grief, lamentation, suffering, mental anguish, and ensuing weariness with birth as their condition come into existence. Thus is the arising, in its entirety, of what is purely a great aggregate of suffering.[n.21]

**1.10** [f5b110e0-c60a-4588-b25c-fa6b03f94b54] “Due to the cessation of ignorance, assembled factors cease; due to the cessation of assembled factors, consciousness ceases; due to the cessation of consciousness, name-and-form ceases; due to the cessation of name-and-form, the six entrances cease; due to the cessation of the six entrances, contact ceases; due to the cessation of contact, feeling ceases; due to the cessation of feeling, craving ceases; due to the cessation of craving, clinging ceases; due to the cessation of clinging, existence ceases; due to the cessation of existence, birth ceases; due to the cessation of birth, decay, death, grief, lamentation, suffering, mental anguish, and ensuing weariness cease. Thus is the cessation, in its entirety, of what is purely a great aggregate of suffering.

**1.11** [c8d1d83d-2cab-4303-a3ed-5a775543ae53] “Now, what is ignorance? It is this: nonawareness regarding the prior limit, nonawareness regarding the following limit, nonawareness regarding the prior and the following limit,[n.22] nonawareness regarding what is internal, nonawareness regarding what is external, nonawareness regarding what is internal and what is external, nonawareness regarding karma, nonawareness regarding maturation, nonawareness regarding karma and its maturation, nonawareness regarding the karma that is a good deed, nonawareness regarding the karma that is a bad deed, nonawareness regarding the karma that is a good and bad deed,[n.23] nonawareness regarding the cause, nonawareness regarding the result, nonawareness regarding the cause and the result, nonawareness regarding dharmas that arise due to causes, nonawareness regarding dharmas that are dependently arisen,[n.24] nonawareness regarding the Buddha, nonawareness regarding the Dharma, nonawareness regarding the Saṅgha, nonawareness regarding suffering, nonawareness regarding its origin, nonawareness regarding cessation, nonawareness regarding the path, nonawareness regarding virtuous and nonvirtuous dharmas, nonawareness regarding blameworthy and blameless dharmas and regarding dharmas that should and should not be practiced,[n.25] and, regarding the six contact-entrances, nonawareness of the way they are,[n.26] not seeing, not comprehending, no clear understanding, darkness, confusion, and the blinding darkness of ignorance. This is explained as *ignorance*.

**1.12** [e41b4214-243f-4f63-b63c-013b0db13cca] “As for ‘assembled factors with ignorance as their condition,’ what are assembled factors? Assembled factors are of three kinds: assembled factors pertaining to the body, assembled factors pertaining to speech, and assembled factors pertaining to thought. What are the assembled factors pertaining to the body? They are inhaling and exhaling, for these are bodily dharmas,[n.27] based on the body, and bound to the body; they come about on the basis of the body. Therefore, inhaling and exhaling are explained as *the assembled factors pertaining to the body*. What are the assembled factors pertaining to speech? A person speaks after deliberating and after analyzing, not without deliberating and analyzing. Therefore, deliberation and analysis are explained as *assembled factors pertaining to speech*. What are the assembled factors pertaining to thought? They are the intention of someone who has attraction, the intention of someone who has aversion, and the intention of someone who has confusion, for this is a mental dharma, based on the mind and bound to the mind; it occurs on the basis of the mind. Therefore, intention is explained as *the assembled factor pertaining to thought*. These, bhikṣus, are explained as assembled factors.[n.28]

**1.13** [998104cd-980a-4871-bff0-927452c32fae] “As for ‘consciousness with assembled factors as its condition,’ what is consciousness? It is the six collections of consciousness. What are the six? They are eye consciousness, ear consciousness, nose consciousness, tongue consciousness, body consciousness, and thought consciousness. These are the six collections of consciousness.[n.29]

**1.14** [acf45a21-a901-4a64-b879-e861a3468371] “As for ‘name-and-form with consciousness as its condition,’ what is name-and-form? ‘Name’ refers to the four formless aggregates:[n.30] the aggregate of feeling, the aggregate of notion, the aggregate of assembled factors, and the aggregate of consciousness. This is *name*. What is form? Whatever form exists, it all consists in the four great elements and in what depends on the four great elements.[n.31] What are the four? They are the earth element, the water element, the fire element, and the wind element. What is the earth element? It is heaviness, hardness, and roughness.[n.32] What is the water element? It is fluidity and flow. What is the fire element? It is heat and maturation. What is the wind element? It is contraction, expansion, lightness, and motility. Such ‘form’ and the preceding ‘name’ are abbreviated as one thing, which is then called *name-and-form*.

**1.15** [d382f069-ca05-430e-8fa2-69c441d6db16] “As for ‘six entrances with name-and-form as their condition,’ what are the six entrances?[n.33] They are the entrance of the eye, the entrance of the ear, the entrance of the nose, the entrance of the tongue, the entrance of the body, and the entrance of thought. These are explained as the six entrances.

**1.16** [fefe9bcc-783e-4202-913e-643be3adaffe] “As for ‘contact with the six entrances as its condition,’ what is contact? It is the six collections of contact. What are the six? They are eye, ear, nose, tongue, body, and thought contact.[n.34]

**1.17** [72ec8f14-ce7e-4038-b2a5-59c5261273a7] “As for ‘feeling with contact as its condition,’ what is feeling? It is the six collections of feeling. What are the six? There is feeling born from eye contact, which is pleasant, painful, or neither painful nor pleasant. Likewise, there are also feelings born from ear, nose, tongue, body, and thought contact. Each of these may in turn be pleasant, painful, or neither painful nor pleasant.[n.35]

**1.18** [df8de58d-2e9d-415f-933b-35b4db060647] “As for ‘craving with feeling as its condition,’ what is craving? It is the six collections of craving. What are the six? They are craving for form, craving for sound, craving for smell, craving for flavor, craving for tangibles, and craving for dharmas.

**1.19** [6269c88d-1d25-4f43-9ea9-c9ccf9cea9ce] “As for ‘clinging with craving as its condition,’ what is clinging? It is the four types of clinging. What are the four? They are clinging to desire, clinging to views, clinging to discipline and vows, and clinging to the proposition of a ‘self.’

**1.20** [57f66fbc-ce0d-476e-ad58-8796e08fbbcb] “As for ‘existence with clinging as its condition,’ what is existence? It is the three existences. What are the three? They are existence with desire, existence with form, and formless existence. What, then, is existence with desire? It is the sentient beings of the great hell called Unwavering below up to the deities in Control of Others’ Emanations. This is explained as existence with desire.[n.36] What is existence with form? It is the deities of the Brahmā group up to the deities of Lesser than None. This is explained as existence with form.[n.37] What is formless existence? It is the deities placed in the abode of the infinity of space up to the deities placed in the abode of neither perception nor no perception. This is explained as formless existence.[n.38]

**1.21** [d53a7ed9-0115-48ae-aada-38363f61ee6f] “As for ‘birth with existence as its condition,’ what is birth? It is the birth of sentient beings in a specific class of sentient beings, and it is their descent, full birth, and coming forth, the coming into existence of the aggregates, the obtainment of the entrances, the coming into existence of the life faculty, and the fact of being brought together within a shared class. This is explained as birth.[n.39]

**1.22** [1720daa7-d638-4831-84c8-48412ff4caa1] “As for ‘decay and death with birth as their condition,’ what is decay? It is baldness, grayness, an abundance of wrinkles, decrepitude, crookedness, being bent down like rafters; having a body that breathes in and out with wheezing sounds,[n.40] is marred by black moles, and leans forward, supported by sticks; and the complete maturation and breaking apart of the faculties, the aging of the assembled factors, lassitude,[n.41] dullness, slowness, loss, and all-around loss. This is explained as decay.

**1.23** [636b2561-eabc-4c3a-b3ba-b9b4d4963b6b] “What is death? It is the falling away of sentient beings from a specific class of sentient beings, their movement, separation,[n.42] impermanence,[n.43] and death, the completion of one’s time,[n.44] the loss of lifespan, the loss of heat, the cessation of the life faculty, and the casting away of the aggregates. This is explained as death. Such ‘death’ and the preceding ‘decay’ are abbreviated as one thing, which is then called *decay and death*.

“This, bhikṣus, is dependent arising with twelve parts.

**1.24** [5f3800e5-8508-47e8-849e-8a2fbc01b137] “Now, what are the four truths of the noble ones? They are the noble ones’ truth of suffering, the noble ones’ truth of the arising of suffering, the noble ones’ truth of the cessation of suffering, and the noble ones’ truth of the path that leads to the cessation of suffering.

**1.25** [c0c66513-a09c-4082-b64f-782e6667f1ca] “What is the noble ones’ truth of suffering? Birth is suffering, decay is suffering, illness is suffering, death is suffering, separation from what one likes is suffering, conjunction with what one dislikes is suffering, and failing to obtain what one wants despite searching for it is suffering; in brief, the five aggregates of clinging are suffering. This is explained as the noble ones’ truth of suffering.

**1.26** [bc16e738-2cfc-446a-a3d4-0039a7a81e59] “What is the noble ones’ truth of the arising of suffering? It is craving that is conducive to a new existence and that is accompanied by rejoicing and attraction,[n.45] furthermore delighting in this and that. This is explained as the noble ones’ truth of the arising of suffering.

**1.27** [a5ddd8b6-d358-4f25-8713-383d087f96bf] “What is the noble ones’ truth of the cessation of suffering? It is the complete abandonment of, thorough relinquishment of, termination of, destruction of, nonattraction to, cessation of, pacification of, and disappearance of that very craving that is conducive to a new existence and that is accompanied by rejoicing and attraction, furthermore delighting in this and that. This is explained as the noble ones’ truth of the cessation of suffering.

**1.28** [adeaae2d-da21-4f5b-ad40-8cf01a326804] “What, then, is the noble ones’ truth of the path that leads to the cessation of suffering? It is the noble path with eight parts: right view, right thinking, right speech, right activity, right livelihood, right effort, right mindfulness, and right samādhi. This is explained as the noble ones’ truth of the path that leads to the cessation of suffering.

“These are the four truths of the noble ones.

**1.29** [d2b0f71a-d9a1-4eb1-bae0-4b78e6f4e7d8] “Then, what are the twenty-two faculties? They are the eye faculty, the ear faculty, the nose faculty, the tongue faculty, the body faculty, the thought faculty, the male faculty, the female faculty, the life faculty, the suffering faculty, the pleasure faculty, the mental well-being faculty, the mental anguish faculty, the neutrality faculty, the faith faculty, the heroism faculty, the mindfulness faculty, the samādhi faculty, the wisdom faculty, the ‘I will completely know what I don’t yet know’ faculty, the complete-knowledge faculty, and the ‘I have completely known’ faculty. These, bhikṣus, are the twenty-two faculties.

**1.30** [35a00851-0a44-443a-8361-be5e901b303e] “Now, what are the four meditations?

“Here, bhikṣus, a bhikṣu[n.46] isolated from desires, isolated from sinful, nonvirtuous dharmas, endowed with deliberation and analysis, and having the joy and pleasure born from isolation reaches and abides in the first meditation. Due to the pacification of deliberations and analyses, due to being inwardly very well disposed, and due to the mind having a single texture, one reaches and abides in the second meditation, without deliberation or analysis and having the joy and pleasure born from samādhi. Due to nonattraction to joy, one abides with equanimity, and one is mindful, discerning, and feels pleasure in one’s body. Hence, the noble ones say, ‘equanimous and mindful, he abides in pleasure.’ Thus, one reaches and abides in the third meditation, which is without joy.[n.47] Due to the abandonment of pleasure, due to the prior abandonment of pain, and due to the disappearance of mental well-being or anguish, one reaches and abides in the fourth meditation, which is without pleasure or pain and purified in terms of equanimity and mindfulness. These, bhikṣus, are the four meditations.[n.48]

**1.31** [a83d25b8-16ca-4eb9-995a-3e758e9ee6ce] “Now, what are the four Brahma abodes? Here, bhikṣus, a bhikṣu, with (1) a mind accompanied by friendliness, a mind without enmity, antagonism, or harming, an expansive, great mind without duality, without measure, and well cultivated, becomes intent upon one direction, fills it, reaches it, and abides thus. He then does the same for the second, the third, and the fourth direction and above, below, and across; for this world on all sides and on all ends, he, with a mind accompanied by friendliness, a mind without enmity, antagonism, or harming, an expansive, great mind without duality, without measure, and well cultivated, becomes intent upon one direction, fills it, reaches it, and abides thus. In the same way, with (2) a mind accompanied by compassion, (3) a mind accompanied by rejoicing, and (4) a mind accompanied by equanimity, a mind without enmity, antagonism, or harming, an expansive, great mind without duality, without measure, and well cultivated, he becomes intent, fills, reaches, and abides thus. These are the four Brahma abodes.

**1.32** [64ba4182-4ba6-4765-8bb4-d0b143560453] “Then, what are the four courses? There is the course that is painful and that is slow in superior cognition. There is the course that is painful and that is quick in superior cognition. There is the course that is pleasant and that is slow in superior cognition. There is the course that is pleasant and that is quick in superior cognition.

**1.33** [6e7f64b9-cec9-4d37-b17f-d8373c00abc0] “Among those, what is the course that is painful and that is slow in superior cognition? Here someone has, by his very nature, intense attraction, intense aversion, and intense confusion. Due to his intense attraction, he constantly feels pain and mental anguish born of attraction; due to his intense aversion, he constantly feels pain and mental anguish born of aversion; due to his intense confusion, he constantly feels pain and mental anguish born of confusion. His five supramundane faculties are slow; they are weak and not intense, not carrying him swiftly toward the destruction of the fluxes. What are the five? They are the faith faculty, heroism faculty, mindfulness faculty, samādhi faculty, and wisdom faculty. Thus, because these five supramundane faculties are slow, weak and not intense, and do not carry him swiftly, he will only slowly reach the samādhi that immediately precedes the destruction of the fluxes. This is the course that is painful and that is slow in superior cognition.

**1.34** [0bc40a19-f5cd-4bb4-b329-744d06c0e01f] “Among those, what is the course that is painful and that is quick in superior cognition? Here someone has, by his very nature, intense attraction, intense aversion, and intense confusion. Due to his intense attraction, he constantly feels pain and mental anguish born of attraction; due to his intense aversion, he constantly feels pain and mental anguish born of aversion; due to his intense confusion, he constantly feels pain and mental anguish born of confusion. His five supramundane faculties are above measure, intense, and carry him swiftly. What are the five? They are the faith faculty, heroism faculty, mindfulness faculty, samādhi faculty, and wisdom faculty. Thus, because these five supramundane faculties are above measure, intense, and carry him swiftly, he will very quickly reach the samādhi that immediately precedes the destruction of the fluxes. This is the course that is painful and that is quick in superior cognition.

**1.35** [f20d3e7b-805d-45f7-a82b-990da72f1d50] “Among those, what is the course that is pleasant and that is slow in superior cognition? Here someone has, by his very nature, little attraction, little aversion, and little confusion. Having little attraction, he does not constantly feel pain and mental anguish born of attraction; having little aversion, he does not constantly feel pain and mental anguish born of aversion; having little confusion, he does not constantly feel pain and mental anguish born of confusion. His five supramundane faculties are slow; they are weak and not intense, not carrying him swiftly toward the destruction of the fluxes. What are the five? They are the faith faculty, heroism faculty, mindfulness faculty, samādhi faculty, and wisdom faculty. Thus, because these five supramundane faculties are slow, weak and not intense, and do not carry him swiftly, he will only slowly reach the samādhi that immediately precedes the destruction of the fluxes. This is the course that is pleasant and that is slow in superior cognition.

**1.36** [b74f8588-932c-43c8-b10f-2e356dc6fd47] “Among those, what is the course that is pleasant and that is quick in superior cognition? Here someone has, by his very nature, little attraction, little aversion, and little confusion. Having little attraction, he does not constantly feel pain and mental anguish born of attraction; having little aversion, he does not constantly feel pain and mental anguish born of aversion; having little confusion, he does not constantly feel pain and mental anguish born of confusion. His five supramundane faculties are above measure, intense, and carry him swiftly. What are the five? They are the faith faculty, heroism faculty, mindfulness faculty, samādhi faculty, and wisdom faculty. Thus, because these five supramundane faculties are above measure, intense, and carry him swiftly, he will very quickly reach the samādhi that immediately precedes the destruction of the fluxes. This is the course that is pleasant and that is quick in superior cognition.

“These are the four courses.

**1.37** [3eaf677a-c255-4de0-8567-f5ace408bf27] “Now, what are the four cultivations of samādhi? There is, bhikṣus, a cultivation of samādhi that, once it is practiced, cultivated, and repeated, brings about the abandonment of attraction. There is a cultivation of samādhi that, once it is practiced, cultivated, and repeated, brings about a pleasant abiding in this very life. There is a cultivation of samādhi that, once it is practiced, cultivated, and repeated, brings about the obtainment of the vision of awareness. There is a cultivation of samādhi that, once it is practiced, cultivated, and repeated, brings about the obtainment of wisdom.

**1.38** [22e5b4ca-1ac0-42ab-a477-8ce139bdd39d] “Among those, what is the cultivation of samādhi that, once practiced, cultivated, and repeated, brings about the abandonment of desirous attraction?[n.49] Here, bhikṣus, a bhikṣu, having gone to the forest, to the root of some tree, or to an empty house, observes this very body as it is,[n.50] upwards from the soles of the feet and downwards from the hair and head, in its entirety, to be full of many types of impurities:[n.51] ‘In this body there are hairs of the head, body hairs,[n.52] teeth, nails, dirt, filth, skin, flesh, bones, sinews, channels, kidneys, heart, lungs, liver, stomach for the raw, stomach for the ripe,[n.53] entrails, mesentery, bladder, spleen, excrement, tears, sweat, snot, spit, grease, fluid, marrow, fat, pus, phlegm, bile, blood, head, head membrane, and urine.’ Thus, he observes it to be full of many types of impurities, as it is.[n.54]

**1.39** [26122511-f866-4db2-8428-977e327a35a4] “Just as, bhikṣus, when there is a granary with its doors open on both sides and full of many types of grains such as śāli rice, grain, barley, wheat, beans, lentils, horse gram, corn, split red lentils, mat beans, sesame, millet, and white mustard seeds,[n.55] any person with eyes who looks at all that will know ‘This is śāli rice, this is rice, this is barley, this is wheat, these are beans, these are lentils, this is horse gram, this is corn, these are split red lentils, these are mat beans, this is sesame, this is millet, these are white mustard seeds.’[n.56] In the same way, bhikṣus, a bhikṣu, having gone to the forest, or to the root of some tree, or to an empty house, observes this very body as it is, upwards from the soles of the feet and downwards from the hair and head, in its entirety, to be full of many types of impurities, as before up to head, head membrane, and urine.[n.57] This, bhikṣus, is the cultivation of samādhi that, once practiced, cultivated, and repeated, brings about the abandonment of desirous attraction.

**1.40** [d7f8cf79-e4e6-446d-8959-86fd32b2eebf] “Among those, bhikṣus, what is the cultivation of samādhi that, once it is practiced, cultivated, and repeated, brings about a pleasant abiding in this very life? Here, bhikṣus, a bhikṣu, having gone to the forest, or to the root of some tree, or to an empty house, drenches wholly and thoroughly, completely fills, satiates, and suffuses this very body with the joy and pleasure born from the samādhi of isolation.[n.58] There is no place in his body that is not filled and suffused with the joy and pleasure born from the samādhi of isolation.[n.59] Just as, bhikṣus, water lilies, lotuses, joy lilies, or white lotuses, born in water and immersed in water, are wholly and thoroughly drenched, completely filled, satiated, and suffused by the cool water, in the very same way, bhikṣus, a bhikṣu, having gone to the forest, or to the root of some tree, or to an empty house, drenches wholly and thoroughly, completely fills, satiates, and suffuses this very body, inwardly, with the joy and pleasure born from samādhi.[n.60] There is no place in his body that is not filled and suffused with the joy and pleasure born from samādhi.[n.61] This is the cultivation of samādhi that, once it is practiced, cultivated, and repeated, brings about a pleasant abiding in this very life.

**1.41** [22922abf-c552-4d07-9b93-2eda4a5e399f] “Among those, bhikṣus, what is the cultivation of samādhi that, once it is practiced, cultivated, and repeated, brings about the obtainment of the vision of awareness? Here, bhikṣus, a bhikṣu has well and properly[n.62] grasped the perception of light; he has placed it well in the mind, practiced it well,[n.63] and thoroughly penetrated it. He cultivates a mind sustained by the perception of daylight,[n.64] with the same brightness: as by day, so by night; as by night, so by day; as in front, so behind; as behind, so in front; as below, so above; as above, so below. Thus, with an open and unbound mind, he cultivates a mind sustained by the perception of daylight, with the same brightness.[n.65] Just as, indeed, bhikṣus, during the last month of summer, at midday on a cloudless day free of any impediment to light, everything appears very clearly, bright and luminous, and untouched by darkness, in the very same way, bhikṣus, a bhikṣu has well and properly grasped the perception of light; he has placed it well in the mind, practiced it well,[n.66] and thoroughly penetrated it. He cultivates a mind sustained by the perception of daylight,[n.67] with the same brightness: as by day, so by night; as by night, so by day; as in front, so behind; as behind, so in front; as below, so above; as above, so below. Thus, with an open and unbound mind sustained by the perception of daylight, he cultivates a mind with the same brightness. This is the cultivation of samādhi that, once it is practiced, cultivated, and repeated, brings about the obtainment of the vision of awareness.

**1.42** [ab59e5c6-2211-441a-8c0e-4729a0c8c967] “Among those, bhikṣus, what is the cultivation of samādhi that, once it is practiced, cultivated, and repeated, brings about the obtainment of wisdom? Here, bhikṣus, a bhikṣu, having gone to the forest, to the root of some tree, or to an empty house, may—due to the abandonment of pleasure, the prior abandonment of pain, and the disappearance of mental well-being or anguish—reach and abide in the fourth meditation, which is without pain or pleasure and is purified in terms of equanimity and mindfulness. This is the cultivation of samādhi that, once it is practiced, cultivated, and repeated, brings about the obtainment of wisdom.

“These are the four cultivations of samādhi.

**1.43** [238bd622-6527-4015-bdf9-c9f5f69636ca] “Now, bhikṣus, what are the four placements of mindfulness? Here, bhikṣus, with respect to his own body, a bhikṣu abides contemplating the body—ardent, perfectly cognizant, mindful, and having removed coveting or mental anguish regarding the world. With respect to an outer body, with respect to his own and an outer body, with respect to his own feelings, with respect to outer feelings, with respect to his own and outer feelings, with respect to his own mind, with respect to any outer mind, with respect to his own and an outer mind, with respect to dharmas belonging to himself, with respect to outer dharmas, and with respect to dharmas belonging to himself as well as outer dharmas, he abides contemplating dharmas. These, bhikṣus, are the four placements of mindfulness.

**1.44** [95edfd7d-db7b-4021-9151-99647a5a55c2] “Now, bhikṣus, what are the four right efforts? Here, bhikṣus, a bhikṣu generates zeal, strives, brings forth heroism, takes hold of his mind, and properly sets it so as to abandon sinful, nonvirtuous dharmas that have already arisen. He generates zeal,[n.68] strives, brings forth heroism, takes hold of his mind, and properly sets it toward the nonarising of sinful, nonvirtuous dharmas that have yet to arise. He generates zeal, strives, brings forth heroism, takes hold of his mind, and properly sets it toward the arising of virtuous dharmas that have yet to arise. He generates zeal, strives, brings forth heroism, takes hold of his mind, and properly sets it toward the abiding, non-loss, non-destruction, recurrence, greatness, and fulfillment of virtuous dharmas that have already arisen. These, bhikṣus, are the four right efforts.

**1.45** [8d2133ea-d678-443f-b7e1-d0189f54d0cb] “Now, bhikṣus, what are the four footings of success? Here, bhikṣus, a bhikṣu, endowed with the zeal samādhi and with the factors of abandonment, cultivates the footing of success based on isolation, based on nonattraction, based on cessation, and matured by relinquishment. His own zeal is neither too absorbed nor too tightly grasped. Endowed with the heroism samādhi and with the factors of abandonment, he cultivates the footing of success based on isolation, based on nonattraction, based on cessation, and matured by relinquishment. His own heroism is neither too absorbed nor too tightly grasped. Endowed with the mind samādhi and with the factors of abandonment, he cultivates the footing of success based on isolation, based on nonattraction, based on cessation, and matured by relinquishment. His own mind is neither too absorbed nor too tightly grasped. Endowed with the investigation samādhi and with the factors of abandonment, he cultivates the footing of success based on isolation, based on nonattraction, based on cessation, and matured by relinquishment. His own investigation is neither too absorbed nor too tightly grasped. These, bhikṣus, are the four footings of success.

**1.46** [4525b288-8bb0-4e44-8bed-603ba18d081c] “Now, bhikṣus, what are the five faculties? They are the faith faculty, heroism faculty, mindfulness faculty, samādhi faculty, and wisdom faculty.

**1.47** [24e36e35-896a-4cb0-a434-9008c4e9958a] “Among these, what is the faith faculty? It is that faith thanks to which one has faith in four dharmas. Which four? One has faith in the worldly right view that applies to saṃsāra. One goes for refuge in the maturation of karma. One thinks, ‘Whatever karma I perform, whether virtuous or nonvirtuous, I will experience the maturation of that karma only.’ Even for the sake of one’s own life, one does not perform sinful karma. This is explained as the faith faculty.

**1.48** [ddcd30e2-a5ce-48a0-a04a-aca8da2d0275] “Among these, what is the heroism faculty? Through the heroism faculty, one establishes those dharmas that one has faith in thanks to the faith faculty. This is explained as the heroism faculty.

**1.49** [508134f0-7a7a-4095-a599-7b8a4410c5ed] “Among these, what is the mindfulness faculty? Thanks to the mindfulness faculty, one does not cause the disappearance of those dharmas that one establishes through the heroism faculty. This is explained as the mindfulness faculty.

**1.50** [1e832c69-ff17-47ad-b02d-fb98532eb07c] “Among these, what is the samādhi faculty? Through the samādhi faculty, one makes one-pointed those dharmas that one does not cause to disappear thanks to the mindfulness faculty. This is explained as the samādhi faculty.

**1.51** [6a4e4be8-93a6-4d3f-98fe-ccdeefdc4978] “Among these, what is the wisdom faculty? Through the wisdom faculty, one penetrates those dharmas that one makes one-pointed through the samādhi faculty; one becomes the type that carefully observes those dharmas. This is explained as the wisdom faculty.

“These, bhikṣus, are the five faculties.

**1.52** [a6d6732c-2962-446f-8f16-b582c1144dda] “Now, bhikṣus, what are the five strengths? They are the strength of faith, the strength of heroism, the strength of mindfulness, the strength of samādhi, and the strength of wisdom. These, bhikṣus, are the five strengths.

**1.53** [ec2e845a-2df4-4646-8bdd-ab6c97874456] “Now, bhikṣus, what are the seven parts of awakening? They are the part of awakening of mindfulness, the part of awakening of classifying the dharmas, the part of awakening of heroism, the part of awakening of joy, the part of awakening of ease, the part of awakening of samādhi, and the part of awakening of equanimity.[n.69] Here, bhikṣus, a bhikṣu cultivates the part of awakening of mindfulness: this is based on isolation, based on nonattraction, based on cessation, and matured by relinquishment. In the same way, he cultivates the part of awakening of classifying the dharmas: this is based on isolation, based on nonattraction, based on cessation, and matured by relinquishment. He cultivates the part of awakening of heroism: this is based on isolation, based on nonattraction, based on cessation, and matured by relinquishment. He cultivates the part of awakening of joy: this is based on isolation, based on nonattraction, based on cessation, and matured by relinquishment. He cultivates the part of awakening of ease: this is based on isolation, based on nonattraction, based on cessation, and matured by relinquishment. He cultivates the part of awakening of samādhi: this is based on isolation, based on nonattraction, based on cessation, and matured by relinquishment. He cultivates the part of awakening of equanimity: this is based on isolation, based on nonattraction, based on cessation, and matured by relinquishment. These, bhikṣus, are the seven parts of awakening.

**1.54** [b276dcd8-73e6-48b6-a9b2-065f452e066d] “Now, bhikṣus, what is the noble path with eight parts? It is right view, right thinking, right speech, right activity, right livelihood, right effort, right mindfulness, and right samādhi. This, bhikṣus, is the noble path with eight parts.

## Notes for this part

**n.1** *dharmāṇāṁ pravicayam antareṇa nāsti kleśānāṁ yata upaśāntaye ’bhyupāyaḥ | kleśaiś ca bhramati bhavārṇave ‘tra lokas taddhetor ata uditaḥ kilaiṣa śāstra* (*Abhidharmakośakārikā* 1.3).

**n.2** *tasyārthaviniścayasūtrasya dharmapravicayārtham upadeśaḥ | na hi vinā sūtropadeśena śiṣyaḥ śakto dharmaṁ pravicetum | dharmapravicaya upakleśopaśamanārtham | tadupaśamo ‘pi naiṣṭhikapadāvaptaye bhavati* (*Arthaviniścayasūtranibandhana*, Samtani 1971, p. 72). We read *dharmapravicaya upakleśopaśamanārtham* rather than *dharmapravicayopakleśopaśamanārtham* as per Samtani’s printed text.

**n.3** Skilling 2012.

**n.4** Ferrari 1944, p. 617; translation ours.

**n.5** Ferrari 1944, p. 522.

**n.6** Ferrari 1944, p. 549; translation ours.

**n.7** Vaidya 1961, p. 319.

**n.8** *asya sarvaṁ vṛttāntaṁ abhiniṣkramaṇanāmasūtre vidyate iti tibbatabhāṣayā kathitam*, Vaidya 1961, p. 319. The term employed for “Tibetan” is *tibbata*.

**n.9** See Samtani 1971, pp. 8–9.

**n.10** De Jong 1975, p. 116.

**n.11** Ferrari 1944, p. 551; translation ours.

**n.12** “Succoso,” Ferrari 1944, p. 552; translation ours.

**n.13** The Tibetan opts for one of two possible ways of parsing the syntax of the first paragraph, rather than retaining the ambiguity of the Sanskrit; the original may be understood as taking “at one time” (*ekasmin samaye*) either with what precedes or with what follows, as commentators including Vīryaśrīdatta point out (see Samtani 1971, pp. 75–76). As Vīryaśrīdatta also points out, saying “this is what I heard at one time” implies that one has heard other teachings at other times, thus indicating the arhat Ānanda’s quality of having heard a lot (*bāhuśrutya*), i.e., being learned in the Dharma.

**n.14** The *Nibandhana* (Samtani 1971, p. 78) explains that it is “eastern” either because it is in the eastern part of Śrāvastī or because it is to the east of the Jeta Grove, the location of the very famous pleasance offered by the foremost of male lay practitioners, Anāthapiṇḍada.

**n.15** The *Nibandhana* (Samtani 1971, pp. 80–81) explains that this expression means two things: it refers to the three trainings, i.e., discipline, mental concentration, and wisdom (*adhiśīlaśikṣā*, *adhicittaśikṣā*, and *adhiprajñāśikṣā*); and it also indicates that the beginning, middle, and end of the Dharma are not mutually contradictory.

**n.16** It is worth noting that Pāli Suttas read this as “with meaning” and “with expression” (*sātthaṁ sabyañjanam*); Vasubandhu is also aware that “some” (*kha cig*) read something along those lines, although it is difficult to say whether he was referring specifically to the Pāli texts or to parallel Sanskrit transmissions (**sārthaṁ savyañjanam*): *kha cig ni don dang ldan pa dang / tshig ’bru dang ldan pa shes ’don te* (Lee 2001, p. 5; see also Nance 2012, p. 131 for a translation).

**n.17** The *Nibandhana* explains that this sentence is meant to ensure that the listeners avoid three defects: not listening, listening but understanding the meaning of what was heard in a distorted manner, and not being able to retain even what has been heard and understood correctly, since it was not listened to with the necessary reverence. These three defects are exemplified by a vase upside down, a dirty vase, and vase with holes: such a vase will not be able to profit from the rain of Dharma (Samtani 1971, p. 83). This example is also found in Vasubandhu’s *Vyākhyāyukti*, in the *Pratītyasamutpādādivibhaṅganirdeśa*, in the *Gāthārthasaṁgrahaśāstra*, and in Haribhadra’s *Abhisamayālaṁkārālokā*, where he attributes it to Vasubandhu (see Skilling 2000, p. 301).

**n.18** In addition, the four *ārūpyasamāpattayaḥ* (“formless attainments”) are found right after this item in the Sanskrit (Samtani 1971, p. 2; p. 18).

**n.19** *Saṁjñā* is not easy to translate: it refers to a concept or idea through which one identifies, correctly or incorrectly, the object of cognition by determining that it has a certain “sign” (*nimitta*, a term closely connected to perceptual experiences). Its function is associated with naming, since *saṁjñā* can be verbalized by those who are acquainted with language, as pointed out in Abhidharma texts. It can also refer to an evaluative belief about something, such as it being desirable, etc., or a notion that one should develop through training (such as the idea that the Dharma teacher is the Buddha). In some forms of Abhidharma, it is explained that the consciousnesses based on the five senses have weak *saṁjñā*, while it is sharp in case of thought-consciousness. *Saṁjñā* complements the perception of objects (*vijñānaskandha*) with enough determination to become fit to be put into words, expressing specific referents and their features. It is regarded as a mental state (*caitta*), accompanying the basic mind (*citta*) that is defined as the mere perception of objects, incapable of grasping their specificities.

**n.20** Here there is an additional sentence in Samtani’s edition of the Sanskrit that reads *yaduta asmin satīdaṁ bhavati asyotpādād idam utpadyate* (Samtani 1971, p. 5). This additional sentence in Samtani’s edition of the Sanskrit could be translated as “It is thus: this being there, this comes about; due to the arising of this, this arises.”

**n.21** The *Nibandhana* explains *kevalasya* as implying that the aggregate of suffering has no self, i.e., it is “nothing more than” an aggregate of suffering; Pāli commentaries often prefer another possible sense of *kevala*, “entire,” and previous translators have rendered parallel passages accordingly. However, we do find Pāli commentators including the *Nibandhana* understanding of *kevala* (*suddhassa vā, sattavirahitassāti attho*). We could not find a single English word carrying both the sense of “which is no more than” and “in its entirety,” hence we have used a longer expression to translate the single term *kevala*.
                                                                                    
**n.22** The Sanskrit in Samtani’s edition (Samtani 1971, p. 6) has “the present” (*pratyutpanne*) instead of “the prior and the following limit” (*pūrvāparānte*); this agrees with the Chinese translations and, importantly, with some of the Sanskrit manuscripts (F and ANe in Samtani’s edition). “Prior limit” and “following limit” are technical terms referring generally to the past and future, but more specifically to past and future lifetimes, and are often used while describing the twelve parts of dependent arising and its subdivision into three lifetimes and when describing wrong views about identity or difference between lifetimes. Thus, the referent of “prior limit” and “following limit” is occasionally the “past” and “future,” but the meaning of the terms is different (they indicate what marks the border between the present life and other lifetimes, hence the use of -*anta*, here translated as “limit”).

**n.23** Samtani’s edition does not contain the word karma (*karmaṇi*), but he reports that *karmaṇi* is found in F (Samtani 1971, p. 6, n. 3). The third type of karma, according to the *Nibandhana* commentary, refers to a mixture of the first two.

**n.24** Before this phrase, the Sanskrit in Samtani’s edition also has “nonawareness in respect to instances of dependent arising” (*pratītyasamutpādeṣv ajñānam*, Samtani 1971, p. 6), and Samtani reports ANe as having the alternative “nonawareness in respect to dependent arising” (*pratītyasamutpāde ’jñānam*, Samtani 1971, p. 6, n. 5).

**n.25** Here there is an additional portion in Sanskrit in Samtani’s edition that reads *sāvadyānavadyeṣu dharmeṣu ajñānam sevitavyāsevitavyeṣ dharmeṣu ajñānam hīnapraṇīteṣu kṛṣṇaśukleṣu dharmeṣu ajñānam* (Samtani 1971, p. 6). This could be translated as “nonawareness in respect to blameworthy and blameless dharmas, nonawareness in respect to dharmas that should and should not be practiced, nonawareness in respect to low and foremost, or black and white dharmas.”

**n.26** Samtani did not consider *yang dag pa ji lta ba bzhin* as one of the possible renderings of *yathābhūta*, rather understanding it as matching a hypothetical **samyak yathāvat* (Samtani 1971, p. 7, n. 1). However, parallels suggest that here the Tibetan matches the Sanskrit.

**n.27** Here the Degé version has *lus ’di ni lus las byung ba*; Ferrari usefully pointed out that here *lus ’di ni* is probably a printing mistake for *chos**’* *di ni* (Ferrari 1944, p. 557); we agree that here we should read the Tibetan as *chos**’* *di ni lus las byung ba*, matching the Sanskrit *kāyiko hy eṣa dharmaḥ*, since the transmitted reading would make little sense.

**n.28** Here the Sanskrit reads *ime bhikṣavaḥ trayaḥ saṁskārā ucyante* (Samtani 1971, p. 8). This could be translated as “the three assembled factors.”

**n.29** Here the Sanskrit reads *ime ṣaḍ vijñānakāyā vijñānam ity ucyante* (Samtani 1971, p. 8). This could be translated as “These six collections of consciousness are explained as *consciousness*.”

**n.30** Here the Sanskrit reads *tatra kataman nāma catvāro’rūpiṇaḥ skandḥāḥ | katame catvāraḥ* (Samtani 1971, p. 8). This could be translated as “What, then, is name? It is the four formless aggregates. What are the four?”

**n.31** Here the Tibetan lacks the expression “and in what depends on the four great elements”; we have nevertheless included it on the basis of Samtani’s Sanskrit (*catvāri ca mahābhūtāny upādāya*, Samtani 1971, p. 9), as it represents a standard definition of “form,” and thus the omission seems odd. We have also included the rhetorical question that immediately follows, which is absent in the Tibetan.

**n.32** Samtani’s Sanskrit edition (Samtani 1971, p. 9) does not include “roughness,” nor does the *Nibandhana* seem to read it. The Tibetan suggests the following hypothetical Sanskrit: **gurutvaṁ khakkhaṭatvaṁ karkaśatvaṁ ca*.

**n.33** Here the Sanskrit reads *ṣaḍ ādhyātmikāny āyatanāni | tadyathā* (Samtani 1971, p. 9). This could be translated as “the six internal entrances; they are…”

**n.34** Here the Sanskrit reads *cakṣuḥsaṁsparśaḥ śrotrasaṁsparśaḥ ghrāṇaśaṁsparśaḥ jihvāsaṁsparśaḥ kāyasaṁsparśaḥ manaḥsaṁsparśa iti | ayam ucyate sparśaḥ* (Samtani 1971, p. 10). This could be translated as follows: “Eye contact, ear contact, nose contact, tongue contact, body contact, thought contact. This is explained as contact.”

**n.35** Here the Sanskrit reads *idam ucyate vedanā* (Samtani 1971, p. 10): “This is explained as feeling” (additional sentence not found in the Tibetan translation).

**n.36** Here the Sanskrit reads *tadyathā uṣṇanarakā aṣṭau | katame ’ṣṭau tadyathā saṁjīvaḥ kālasūtraḥ saṅghātaḥ rauravaḥ mahārauravaḥ tapanaḥ pratāpanaḥ avīciś ca | śītanarakā aṣṭau | [katame’ṣṭau] tadyathā arbudaḥ nirarbudaḥ aṭaṭaḥ hahavaḥ huhuvaḥ utpalaḥ padmaḥ mahāpadmaḥ | pretāḥ tiryañcaḥ manuṣyāḥ ṣaṭ kāmāvacarāś ca devāḥ | katame ṣaṭ cāturmahārājikāḥ trāyastriṁśāḥ yāmāḥ tuṣitāḥ nirmāṇaratayaḥ paranirmitavaśavartino devāḥ* (Samtani 1971, p. 11). The Sanskrit text could be translated as “It is the eight hot hells. What are the eight? They are Reviving, Black Thread, Crushing, Howling, Great Howling, Burning, Intense Burning, and Unwavering. It is the eight cold hells. What are the eight? They are Swelling, Thorough Swelling, Aṭṭa, Hahava, Huhuva, Blue Lotus, Lotus, and Great Lotus. It is the pretas, animals, humans, and the six deities within the sphere of desire. What are the six? They are the Four Great Kings, the deities of the Thirty-Three, Yāma, Tuṣita, Emanation-Delight, and Control of Others’ Emanations.” Samtani also points out that the order differs in Fe and ANe (Samtani 1971, p. 11, n. 5). See also the *Nibandhana* (Samtani 1971, pp. 140–41) for useful explanations of the names of these different classes of deities.

**n.37** Here the Sanskrit reads *tatra rūpabhavaḥ katamaḥ tadyathā brahmakāyikāḥ brahmapurohitāḥ mahābrāhmaṇaḥ parīttābhāḥ apramāṇābhāḥ ābhāsvarāḥ parīttaśubhāḥ śubhakṛtsnāḥ anabhrakāḥ puṇyaprasavāḥ bṛhatphalāḥ avṛhāḥ atapāḥ sudṛśāḥ sudarśanāḥ akaniṣṭhāś ceti* (Samtani 1971, p. 12). This could be translated as “What, then, is existence with form? It is those in the Brahmā group, the Provosts of Brahmā, the Great Brahmās, Limitedly Splendid, Splendid without Measure, Wholly Good, Unclouded, Merit Increasing, Abundant Result, Not Great, Without Pain, Seeing Well, Good Sight, and Lesser than None.”

**n.38** Here the Sanskrit reads *ime trayo bhavāḥ* (Samtani 1971, p. 12): “These are the three existences” (additional sentence found in the Sanskrit but not in F and ANe or the Tibetan; Samtani 1971, p. 12, nn. 9–10). See also the *Nibandhana* (Samtani 1971, pp. 141–44) for useful explanations of the names of these classes of deities.

**n.39** Here the Sanskrit reads *bhavapratyayā jātiḥ | jātiḥ katamā yā teṣāṁ teṣāṁ sattvānāṁ tasmiṁs tasmin sattvanikāye jātiḥ saṁjātiḥ upapattiḥ avakrāntiḥ abhinirvṛttiḥ prādurbhāvaḥ skandhapratilambhaḥ dhātupratilambhaḥ āyatanānāṁ pratilambhaḥ skandhānām abhinirvṛttiḥ jīvitendriyasyodbhavaḥ nikāyasabhāgatāyāḥ samavadhānam* (Samtani 1971, pp. 12–13). This could be translated as “ ‘As for birth with existence as its condition,’ what is birth? It is the birth of such and such sentient beings in such and such specific classes of sentient beings; it is their thorough birth, descent, coming forth, and manifestation, the obtainment of the aggregates, the obtainment of the bases, the obtainment of the entrances, the proceeding of the aggregates, the coming into being of the life faculty, and the fact of being brought together within the commonality of a specific class. This is explained as birth.”

**n.40** Here the Sanskrit reads *khurukhuruniśvāsapraśvāsakaṇṭhatā* (Samtani 1971, p. 13): “having a throat that sounds like *khurukhuru* when exhaling and inhaling.” The Sanskrit *khurukhuru* and the Tibetan *ngar ngar* resemble the English term “wheezing,” whose etymology is also onomatopoeic.

**n.41** Samtani points out that ANe and F lack the *ca* after *jarjarībhāvaḥ*, and we think this matches the Tibetan and seems altogether preferable.

**n.42** The commentary explains this as “the separation of the collection of name from the collection of form” (*arūpiṇo hi nāmakāyasya rūpakāyād viśleṣo bhedaḥ*; Samtani 1971, p. 154).

**n.43** Here the Sanskrit reads *antarhāṇiḥ* (Samtani 1971, p. 14), meaning something like “disappearance.” The Tibetan *mi rtag par ’gyur ba* could correspond to *anityabhāva.* Samtani (1971, p. 14, n. 4) proposes *anityatābhāvaḥ*, but we do not think the Tibetan is intended to represent the *tal-pratyaya*.

**n.44** The *Nibandhana* commentary explains this as the loss of the projecting force of karma, which “throws” the assembled factors (like an arrow), at birth, only for a determinate length of time (*pūrvopāttāyuḥsaṁskārāṇām āvedhakṣayaḥ*, Samtani 1971, pp. 155–56).

**n.45** The Tibetan *dga’ ba’i ’dod chags* may suggest rather a genitive case relationship between *dga’ ba* and *’dod chags*, but this seems highly unlikely and is not supported by the *Nibandhana*; in general, we would read the usage of particles in Tibetan texts translated from the Sanskrit with some degree of flexibility, and not necessarily in their most idiomatic sense.

**n.46** The Tibetan here has a plural marker, *rnams*, but it seems out of place and is not supported by any parallels we could find.

**n.47** Samtani (1971, p. 17) does not have anything that matches *dga’ ba med pa* (“without joy”). He proposes that it could translate *prītirahitam* (Samtani 1971, p. 17, n. 8). We think, on the other hand, that the probable Sanskrit original should be *niṣprītikam*, which is attested in a sūtra quotation, very close to our passage (indeed we wonder whether this is a quote of *Distinctly Ascertaining the Meanings*), that appears in Ratnākaraśānti’s *Sāratamā*: *yat tad āryā ācakṣate upekṣakaḥ smṛtimān sukhavihārīti niṣprītikaṁ tṛtīyaṁ dhyānam upasampadya viharatīti* (Jaini 1979, p. 50). In the same context of the third meditation (*dhyāna*), the term *niṣprītikam* also appears in the *Saṅghabhedavastu* (Gnoli 1978a, p. 144).

**n.48** Samtani’s Sanskrit edition here includes a section on the four formless attainments that is absent in the Tibetan (Samtani 1971, p. 18).

**n.49** Tib. *’dod chags* does sometimes translate *rāga*, instead of *kāmarāga* as we have in the Sanskrit edition. However, *’dod chags* is elsewhere attested as a translation of *kāmarāga*, not only of *rāga*, and we have translated accordingly.

**n.50** Here the Sanskrit reads *yathāvasthitam yathāpraṇihitam* (Samtani 1971, p. 23): “as it is disposed and placed/set/directed.”

**n.51** Here the Sanskrit reads *iha bhikṣavo bhikṣur araṇyagato vā vṛkṣamūlagato vā śūnyāgāragato vā imam eva kāyam ūrdvaṁ yāvat pādatalād adhaḥ keśamastakāt tvakparyantaṁ yathāvasthitaṁ yathāpraṇihitaṁ pūrṇaṁ nānāprakārasyāśucer yathābhūtaṁ samyak prajñayā pratyavekṣate* (Samtani 1971, p. 23): “Here, monks, a monk, having gone to the forest, or to the root of some tree, or to an empty house, observes with right wisdom this very body, up from the soles of the feet and down from the hairy head, enclosed in skin, just as it is disposed and placed, full of many types of impurities, as it is.” The Tibetan has some small differences; it could be back-translated as **tatra katamā samādhibhāvanā āsevitā bhāvitā bahulīkṛtā kāmarāgaprahāṇāya saṃvartate iha bhikṣavo bhikṣur imam eva kāyam ūrdhvaṃ pādatalād adhaḥ keśamastakāt paryantaṃ pūrṇaṃ nānāprakārasyāśucer yathābhūtaṃ pratyavekṣate*.

**n.52** Samtani remarks, convincingly, that *kha spu* should be in fact read as *ba spu* (Samtani 1971, p. 24, n. 10).

**n.53** These two terms refer to Āyurvedic physiological categories.

**n.54** Here the Sanskrit reads *santi asmin kāye keśā romāṇi nakhā dantā rajo malaṁ tvak māṁsam asthi snāyu śirā vṛkkā hṛdayaṁ plīhā klomakam antrāṇi antraguṇā āmāśaya pakkāśaya udaryaṁ yakṛt purīṣam aśru svedaḥ kheḍaḥ siṁhāṇako vasā lasikā majjā medaḥ pittaṁ śleṣmā pūyaṁ śoṇitaṁ mastakaṁ mastakaluṅgam iti pūrṇe nānāprakārasyāśucer yathābhūtaṁ pratyavekṣate* (Samtani 1971, pp. 23–24): “In this body there are hair, body hairs, nails, teeth, dirt, filth, skin, flesh, bones, sinews, channels, kidneys, heart, spleen, lungs, entrails, mesentery, stomach for the raw, stomach for the ripe, bowel content, liver, excrement, tears, sweat, spit, snot, grease, fluid, marrow, fat, bile, phlegm, pus, blood, head, and head membrane.” We would here propose to emend *āmāśaya* to *āmāśayaḥ*.

**n.55** Samtani also counts thirteen types of grain in the Tibetan (Samtani 1971, p. 24, n. 5). We are especially uncertain about “corn,” which is a possible translation of *nivāpa* (assuming that *nisvapa* in the Tibetan is a misspelling of *nivāpa*). “Mat bean” is a possible translation of *mukuṣṭa*/*makuṣṭa*, assuming that the Tibetan *mon sran na gu* is a mistake for *mon sran nag gu* (the Stok Palace Kangyur edition has, in fact, *nag gu*). The list in Samtani 1971, p. 24 is as follows: *dhānyatilasarṣapamudgayavamāṣāṇām* (“rice, sesame, mustard, lentils, barley, and beans”).

**n.56** Here the Sanskrit reads *imāni śūkadhānyāni imāni haladhānyāni* (Samtani 1971, p. 25): “These are grains with awn, and these are grains to be ploughed.” The Tibetan repeats the whole list, but the Sanskrit only presents this abbreviated sentence.

**n.57** Here the Sanskrit reads *evam eva bhikṣavo bhikṣur imam eva kāyaṁ yathāvasthitam yathāpraṇihitam yāvat pratyavekṣate* (Samtani 1971, p. 25): “In the same way, bhikṣus, a bhikṣu thus observes this very body … up to … just as it is disposed and placed.” The Sanskrit contains the abbreviation *yāvat*, which is often difficult to interpret conclusively: it is quite likely that in some cases it is meant as just an abbreviation for saving space in manuscripts, so that the *yāvat* should then be understood as outside of the main text, not in the voice of the speaker. The Tibetan also has an abbreviation here, *snga ma bzhin du* (“just as before”), which we think would be translating **pūrvavat*.

**n.58** Here the Sanskrit reads *adhyātmaṁ vikekajena samādhijena* (Samtani 1971, p. 25): “born from isolation and born from samādhi,” instead of Tibetan *dben pa’i ting nge ’dzin las skyes pa’i*.

**n.59** See n.58.

**n.60** *vivekajena* (Samtani 1971, p. 26): “from isolation” is here added in the Sanskrit, right before “born from samādhi.”

**n.61** *adhyātmaṁ vivekajena* (Samtani 1971, p. 26): “born from inward isolation.”

**n.62** The Tibetan here has *shin tu legs par*, while the Sanskrit has *sādhu ca suṣṭhu ca* (“well and properly”). According to Samtani, what has not been translated in the Tibetan is *suṣṭhu*; on the other hand, *shin tu legs par* is an attested translation of *suṣṭhu*, which suggests that perhaps what was not translated was *sādhu*. Since, however, *sādhu* would be *legs par*, we suggest that *shin tu legs par* may be meant as a translation of *sādhu ca suṣṭhu ca*.

**n.63** Samtani (1971, p. 26, n. 6) suggests that *reg par* should be corrected to *rig par*, which would give *suviditā* and somehow be related to *sudṛṣṭā* (“seen it well”); he also reports that the manuscript that he calls N*3* has a correction to *sujuṣṭā*. Having found a number of parallels where *supratividdha(ā)* is preceded by some form of *dṛś*, Samtani’s suggestion of *sudṛṣṭā* sounds like a good suggestion. However, the *Nibandhana*’s gloss to *sudṛṣṭā* is *bhāvanākāle viśeṣotpattiyogāt sudṛṣṭā | susevitety arthaḥ*, which suggests that adopting the reading of the manuscript that Samtani refers to as N, *sujuṣṭā*, would be more sensible (in fact, *sudṛṣṭā* there hardly makes any sense). We propose to read *sujuṣṭā* in the Sanskrit and consider *reg par byas* as a possible translation of *juṣṭā*.

**n.64** Reading *divasasaṁjñādhiṣṭhitaṁ* for *divasasaṁjñādhiṣṭhitā*, in analogy with the subsequent section. The commentary does not seem to read *adhiṣṭhita*.

**n.65** Here the Sanskrit adds *sarvāntam imam lokam* (Samtani 1971, p. 27): “throughout this world on all sides.” This additional phrase, however, as Samtani reports, is not in ANe (Samtani 1971, p. 27, nn. 5–6).

**n.66** See n.63 on *reg par*.

**n.67** Here too reading *divasasaṁjñādhiṣṭhitaṁ* for *divasasaṁjñādhiṣṭhitā*, in analogy with the previous section; Samtani notices that “the reading is corrupt” in ANe (Samtani 1971, p. 27, n. 10).

**n.68** Tibetan here has *dran pa*, but we agree with Samtani (1971, p. 29, n. 5) that this seems most likely a mistake for *’dun pa*, since this is a stock expression repeated in this very passage (and in many other texts).

**n.69** This sentence is lacking in the Tibetan, but given the overall structure of the sūtra, we have decided to include it on the basis of Samtani’s Sanskrit edition: *tadyathā | smṛtisambodhyaṅgaṁ dharmapravicayasaṃbodhyaṅgaṁ vīryasaṁbodhyaṅgaṁ prītisaṃbodhyaṅgaṁ praśrabdhisaṃbodhyaṅgaṁ samādhisaṃbodhyaṅgaṁ upekṣāsaṃbodhyaṅgam* (Samtani 1971, p. 33).

Continued in part 2: https://84000.co/translation/toh317/part-2.md
