---
title: "The Questions of Dīrghanakha the Wandering Mendicant"
toh: "Toh 342"
sanskrit_title: "Dīrghanakhaparivrājakaparipṛcchā"
tibetan_title: "kun tu rgyu ba sen rings kyis zhus pa"
canon_section: "Kangyur › Discourses › General Sūtra Section"
url: https://84000.co/translation/toh342
published: 2021-11-02
collections: []
publisher: "84000: Translating the Words of the Buddha"
translation_team: "Kīrtimukha Translation Group"
translators: ["Laura Goetz", "Celso Wilkinson"]
license: "CC BY-NC-ND 4.0"
license_url: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
citation: "The Questions of Dīrghanakha the Wandering Mendicant (Dīrghanakhaparivrājakaparipṛcchā, Toh 342). Translated by Kīrtimukha Translation Group. Online publication. 84000: Translating the Words of the Buddha, 2021. https://84000.co/translation/toh342."
generated: 2026-11-16
---

# The Questions of Dīrghanakha the Wandering Mendicant

Toh 342 · Kangyur › Discourses › General Sūtra Section · An 84000 translation · Read online: https://84000.co/translation/toh342

> **License:** [CC BY-NC-ND 4.0](https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/). This work is provided under the protection of a Creative Commons CC BY-NC-ND (Attribution - Non-commercial - No-derivatives) 4.0 copyright. It may be copied or printed for fair use, but only with full attribution, and not for commercial advantage or personal compensation. **Cite as:** The Questions of Dīrghanakha the Wandering Mendicant (Dīrghanakhaparivrājakaparipṛcchā, Toh 342). Translated by Kīrtimukha Translation Group. Online publication. 84000: Translating the Words of the Buddha, 2021. https://84000.co/translation/toh342.

> This is the plain-text edition of https://84000.co/translation/toh342. Passage labels (for example 1.2 or i.3) match the online edition. Each label is followed by the passage's permanent ID in square brackets, and by a Toh number when the passage belongs to one Toh only, for example **1.2** [ID] or **i.3** [ID, toh342]. To link to a passage, use https://84000.co/entity/passage/ID?toh=TOH, with TOH = toh342 when no Toh is given. Note numbers in square brackets (such as [n.3]) point to the Notes section. When quoting, cite 84000, *The Questions of Dīrghanakha the Wandering Mendicant* (Toh 342), with the passage label and its link. The summary, introduction and notes are by the translators and are not part of the translated text.

## At a glance

> Machine-generated overview: written by AI from 84000's published summary and introduction, not yet reviewed by an 84000 editor. It is not part of the translation; quote the translation itself.

**In brief:** The Questions of Dīrghanakha the Wandering Mendicant (Toh 342), known in Sanskrit as Dīrghanakhaparivrājakaparipṛcchā, is a sūtra found in the General Sūtra section of the Kangyur. Set on Vulture Peak Mountain in Rājagṛha, it recounts an encounter between the Buddha and the brahmin wandering mendicant Dīrghanakha, who arrives with his staff and challenges the Buddha's teaching that actions reliably produce specific effects in the world. Dīrghanakha then poses ten questions about the karmic origins of the Buddha's distinctive physical attributes, from his vajra body to the raised uṣṇīṣa on his crown. In each case the Buddha identifies a past observance corresponding to one of the eight poṣadha vows — a set of ethical commitments that lay Buddhists undertake as a practice of purification — as the cause. The dialogue concludes with Dīrghanakha laying down his staff, bowing, taking refuge in the Three Jewels, and vowing to uphold the eight poṣadha vows for the rest of his life. The text was translated into English by Laura Goetz and Celso Wilkinson of the Kīrtimukha Translation Group.

**Why read it:** This text offers a concise account of how the Buddha's unique physical marks arise from specific past ethical actions, while illustrating through dialogue how even a skeptical outsider can be moved to take refuge and adopt the eight poṣadha vows.

### Who is Dīrghanakha and why does he approach the Buddha?

Dīrghanakha is a brahmin and wandering mendicant who arrives at Vulture Peak Mountain while the Buddha is teaching the fourfold saṅgha. He challenges the Buddha in somewhat irreverent tones, questioning the teaching that actions reliably produce particular effects in the world, before proceeding to ask ten specific questions about the karmic causes of the Buddha's physical attributes.

### What are the ten questions Dīrghanakha asks in this sūtra?

Dīrghanakha asks about the karmic causes behind ten of the Buddha's attributes: his vajra body, long and webbed fingers, complete faculties and fully developed body, tongue that covers his face, lion's gait, forty even and white teeth, fragrance of moral discipline, thirty-two signs, three seats, and the raised uṣṇīṣa on his crown. The Buddha answers each question by naming a past ethical observance as its cause.

### What are the eight poṣadha vows described in this text?

The eight poṣadha vows, which Dīrghanakha pledges at the end of the sūtra, are to refrain from killing, stealing, sexual misconduct, lying or divisive speech, intoxication, eating at inappropriate times, entertainment such as singing, dancing, and adorning oneself with cosmetics or garlands, and using a high bed. They are observances traditionally undertaken by lay people as a practice of purification.

### How does the sūtra end?

After hearing the Buddha's ten responses, Dīrghanakha sets down his staff, bows his head to the Buddha's feet, and pledges to take refuge in the Buddha, Dharma, and Saṅgha for as long as he lives. He then vows to maintain the eight poṣadha vows continuously in the manner of the arhats, committing not merely to a single day's observance but to a lifelong practice.

### How does this sūtra relate to other accounts of Dīrghanakha found in Buddhist literature?

Accounts of Dīrghanakha appear in several other texts, including the Pali Dīghanakhasutta, the Pravrajyāvastu of the Vinayavastu (Toh 1), the Avadānaśataka, and Nāgārjuna's Mahāprajñāpāramitāśāstra. While those versions often involve discussions of impermanence and sensation and frequently end in monastic ordination, the sūtra translated here focuses specifically on the karmic origins of the Buddha's physical marks and concludes with Dīrghanakha becoming a lay follower.

### Where is this sūtra located in the Kangyur, and what is known about its translation history?

The Questions of Dīrghanakha the Wandering Mendicant is found in the General Sūtra section of the Kangyur. No information about its Tibetan translator or editor is recorded in the colophon or Kangyur indexes, but its listing in both the Denkarma and Phangthangma imperial catalogs indicates it was translated into Tibetan no later than 812 CE. The English translation for 84000 was made by Laura Goetz and Celso Wilkinson of the Kīrtimukha Translation Group.

### What is the significance of the term poṣadha in this text?

Poṣadha refers to both a ceremony performed by monastics at each full and new moon, in which they confess faults and recite their vows, and to the set of eight ethical observances that lay people adopt on the same lunar days. In this sūtra, the Buddha's ten responses to Dīrghanakha trace each of his physical marks to past observances corresponding to these eight vows, and Dīrghanakha's conversion culminates in his commitment to uphold them for life.

## Summary

**s.1** [bd480732-182b-4e4e-8f30-d2b043b105c4] As the Buddha teaches the Dharma to the fourfold saṅgha on Vulture Peak Mountain, the brahmin and wandering mendicant Dīrghanakha approaches and questions the Buddha about his doctrine concerning the incontrovertible relationship between karma and its effects in the world. He then poses a series of ten questions regarding the karmic causes of certain attributes of the Buddha, from his vajra body to the raised uṣṇīṣa on his crown. The Buddha responds to each question with the cause for each attribute, roughly summing up the eight poṣadha vows and the ways he observed them in the past. Dīrghanakha drops his staff and bows to the Buddha, pledging to take refuge in the Three Jewels and maintain the eight poṣadha vows.

## Acknowledgments

**ac.1** [1405aa08-acac-48a5-847b-d842490a41af] This sūtra was translated by the Kīrtimukha Translation Group. Celso Wilkinson, Laura Goetz, and L.S. Summer translated the text from the Tibetan and Sanskrit. William Giddings provided comparisons to the Chinese versions of the text.

The translation was completed under the patronage and supervision of 84000: Translating the Words of the Buddha.

## Introduction

**i.1** [e075d7ea-1c35-47fb-811c-0c31dc6ee9e0] *The Questions of Dīrghanakha the Wandering Mendicant* takes place on Vulture Peak Mountain in Rājagṛha. As the Buddha teaches the Dharma to the fourfold saṅgha, the brahmin and wandering mendicant Dīrghanakha approaches and interrogates the Buddha, in somewhat irreverent tones, about his teaching that actions dependably produce particular effects in the world. He then poses a series of ten questions regarding the karmic causes of certain attributes of the Buddha. These questions refer to the Buddha’s (1) vajra body, (2) long and webbed fingers, (3) complete faculties and fully developed body, (4) tongue that covers his face, (5) lion’s gait, (6) forty even and white teeth, (7) fragrance of moral discipline, (8) thirty-two signs, (9) three seats, and (10) raised uṣṇīṣa on his crown. The Buddha responds to each question by identifying the cause for each attribute, roughly summing up the eight poṣadha vows and the ways he observed them in the past. He also mentions his previous offerings and devotion to the Three Jewels and to his parents, preceptors, scholars, gurus, and other worthy ones. At this point, Dīrghanakha drops his staff and bows to the Buddha, pledging three times to take refuge in the Three Jewels and to maintain continuously and correctly the eight poṣadha vows in the manner of the arhats.

**i.2** [da861125-1a2e-4656-a673-0183c087b3aa] The term *poṣadha* (Tib. *gso sbyong*) refers to the ceremony performed every full and new moon day by monastics, in which they confess any faults or transgressions and recite the prātimokṣa vows. Although lay people are restricted from going to these ceremonies, they traditionally adopt what are called “the eight poṣadha vows,”[n.1] which are observed by lay people on the same lunar day of the poṣadha ceremony or on other occasions, usually for a single day at a time. They are to refrain from (1) killing, (2) stealing, (3) sexual misconduct, (4) lying or divisive speech, (5) intoxication, (6) eating at inappropriate times, (7) entertainment such as singing, dancing, seeing shows, and beautifying themselves with adornments or cosmetics, and (8) using a high bed. These amount to not only an expansion of the standard list of five lay vows (which constitute the first five), but most of the ten vows of a novice monk or nun (with the seventh split in two as in this sūtra), which include the additional vow to not handle money. In a sense, the laity become monastics for a day, and the occasion is understood to be a period of abstinence that often involves fasting as a way to purify one’s conduct, often in conjunction with the monastic community.

**i.3** [3171c380-6a92-467c-9109-f45ab32eaa29] Etymologically, *poṣadha* has its roots in an older Sanskrit term, *upavasatha* (Pali: *uposatha*), which literally means “to dwell near.”[n.2] This can be traced back to Vedic India, where it was a day of rest and preparation preceding a ritual sacrifice.[n.3] Sylvain Lévi notes that while one would expect the Pali *uposatha* to be translated into classical Sanskrit as *upavasatha*, the Buddhists ended up with the translation *poṣadha*, having as it does less of a brahmanical resonance. It means to nourish (*poṣa*) and cleanse (*dha*), which the Tibetans repeated in their rendering as *gso sbyong*.[n.4] However, the older term *upavasatha* has not been entirely replaced by the term *poṣadha*; it is still used, usually with the alternate spelling *upavāsa* (Tib. *bsnyen gnas*, “abstinence”), in reference to the practice of abstinence with regard to the eight poṣadha vows or fasting, while only the term *poṣadha* is used as the name for the ceremony itself. Thus, at the end of the sūtra, Dīrghanakha vows to uphold the eight poṣadha vows in the context of the *upavāsa*, or abstinence. He does not merely vow to follow this for one day but pledges to make the special commitment of practicing them continuously for as long as he lives as “the instrument of my mind, and the accumulation of awakening.”

**i.4** [59fb91d0-3025-4026-b8ff-a26a3e5675e9] The story of Dīrghanakha (Pali: Dīghanakha) is found throughout the Mahāyāna and Pali corpora. In some accounts he is also known in Sanskrit as Koṣṭhila (Long Torso), which is the birth name by which he was known before he left home to wander, and which he later readopts when he becomes a monk under the Buddha Śākyamuni. The variants Kauṣṭhila, Mahākauṣṭhila, and Agnivaiśyāyana (Pali: Aggivessāna) are also found. Dīrghanakha is also known as the uncle of Śāriputra, the famous early disciple of Śākyamuni.

**i.5** [764cacee-c3bd-43a2-961b-e34d1016b4bf] The Pali Majjhima Nikāya contains a sutta called *Dīghanakhasutta* in the *Paribbājakavagga* (The Division on Wanderers).[n.5] This sutta relates the story of how Dīrghanakha became a lay disciple of the Buddha, who addresses him here as Aggivessāna. After Dīrghanakha approaches the Buddha and proclaims that he believes in nothing,[n.6] there follows a conversation in which the Buddha teaches the reasons for abandoning wrong views and the method for attaining liberation by adopting the view of impermanence rooted in the observation of physical sensation. In the *Mahāvastu* of the Mahāsaṅghika-Lokottaravāda school, a sūtra called *The Sūtra of the Wanderer Dīrghanakha* is mentioned as a text to be inserted, but is not included.[n.7]

**i.6** [490a7a0d-c164-4896-a3ec-444a4ea8c5d3] In the *Pravrajyāvastu* (*The Chapter on Going Forth*), the first chapter of the *Vinayavastu* (Toh 1) in the Kangyur, we find a lengthy biography of Dīrghanakha interwoven with that of his nephew Śāriputra.[n.8] This narrative tells of Koṣṭhila (Dīrghanakha)’s upbringing as the son of the learned brahmin Māṭhara who, during the reign of King Bimbisāra, was awarded the entire village of Nālada by winning a debate. We see Koṣṭhila’s privileged upbringing before he is vanquished in debate by his own sister Śārikā and driven to a life of wandering. Finding himself in another country, he becomes a student of the brahmin Tiṣya, a follower of the materialist Lokāyata philosophy that rejected rebirth and the afterlife.

**i.7** [02690586-1a40-4cd4-92b3-c050d0b085d1] After bragging about his hometown and the wisdom of its philosophers, he begins to journey back along with his teacher and his fellow young brahmins. On reaching Rājagṛha, Tiṣya battles Māṭhara in debate before King Bimbisāra and is victorious, thus winning the village of Nālada from Māṭhara. Tiṣya offers to share with Māṭhara, who in gratitude gives him Śārikā, who will later become the mother of Śāriputra, to marry. This upsets Koṣṭhila, who is outraged that the enemy who has robbed his family is now being invited into it. Thinking that the insult is the result of his lack of learning, he goes off again to study the Lokāyata philosophy, vowing not to cut his fingernails as long as he upholds it, thus becoming Dīrghanakha (Long Fingernails).

**i.8** [c6826976-3864-4ee1-8b31-f5a853b7b6d8] Later in the text, Dīrghanakha, still a wandering tīrthika, meets with the Buddha (whom he seems to have met before), and engages in a conversation remarkably similar to that of the Pali sutta. In it Dīrghanakha states that “no self endures [after death],” to which the Buddha replies by summarizing the various views of ascetics and brahmins as they relate to the endurance or nonendurance of a self. He again teaches the way of contemplating impermanence rooted in the observation of physical sensation. Dīrghanakha immediately grasps the Dharma and, unlike in the Pali sutta, takes ordination as a monk. Here his story concludes with these words of the Buddha: “Monks, among my monk disciples who have gained the knowledge of perfect discernment, the monk Koṣṭhila is supreme.”[n.9]

**i.9** [768a4530-2b1c-42c0-aa7a-7315cbcc33bf] The story of Dīrghanakha’s conversion is also told in the Sanskrit collection of Buddhist tales called the *Avadānaśataka*.[n.10] This account also deals with the transitory nature of sensation. Here Dīrghanakha returns to Rājagṛha on learning that Śāriputra has come of age and driven the non-Buddhists from the area after coming under the influence of the Buddha. Dīrghanakha’s conversation with the Buddha, in which he is addressed as Agnivaiśyāyana (Descendent of Agnivaiśya, the name of an old brahmanical family),[n.11] bears great resemblance to the exchange in the *Pravrajyāvastu* and the Pali sutta. As in the *Pravrajyāvastu*, the story ends in ordination.

**i.10** [19f044c0-706b-452f-95ea-6d1077d8a71a] Lastly, Dīrghanakha’s story is told in Nāgārjuna’s *Mahāprajñāpāramitāśāstra*, a commentary, only found in the Chinese canon, on the *Pañcaviṃśatisāhasrikāprajñāpāramitā* (*Perfection of Wisdom in Five Thousand Lines*, Toh 9). Here he is depicted as a fierce and proud scholar, prevailing everywhere in debate like “an enraged mighty elephant,” until he encounters the Buddha while coming to meet with his newly ordained nephew Śāriputra. The exchange here resembles the accounts in other texts, but with the poignant addition of Dīrghanakha’s inner thoughts as he grapples with the Buddha’s interrogation before admitting defeat and becoming a monk.[n.12]

**i.11** [48cdb108-b239-42f8-af4c-9a85c19541c5] Dīrghanakha’s transformative encounter with the Buddha in this text has echoes in several similar stories of dialogues involving other wandering ascetics of fiercely independent bent. One is the story, in the Kangyur, of the ṛṣi Ulka,[n.13] whose questions to the Buddha also seem to be founded in non-Buddhist cosmological views. Another is the story of Śreṇika Vatsagotra (Pali: Vacchagotta), mentioned in all the long Prajñāpāramitā sūtras as significant in passages discussing the Buddha’s omniscience, which Śreṇika Vatsagotra is said to have accepted through conviction alone.[n.14] The Prajñāpāramitā sūtras themselves give little further detail, and Vatsagotra’s questioning of the Buddha does not seem to appear in full in any canonical text in Tibetan translation; it is, however, related in a number of Pali texts and āgamas in Chinese.[n.15] In fact, the Buddha’s omniscience—directly or indirectly—can be seen as the principal focus of the questions put by all these individuals. Dīrganakha’s questions in the vinaya account seek to establish some sort of ultimate reality (although in the sūtra version translated here his questions are limited to the past causes of some of the Buddha’s unique physical marks). Śreṇika Vatsagotra’s questions directly address what have come to be called the twelve or fourteen “unanswerable points” (*avyākṛtavastu*). Ulka begins with the “unanswerable” question of where sentient beings originated from in the first place. In each case, the ways in which the Buddha responds bring about not only a complete resetting of the parameters of the questions, but also a fundamental change in how the questioners perceive him.[n.16] The exchanges typify how the Buddha is said to have convinced even very mature seekers of the truth as to the authenticity of his teaching.

**i.12** [d13cc178-0a89-434c-95eb-ff91a8d77007] *The Questions of Dīrghanakha the Wandering Mendicant* is found in the General Sūtra section (*mdo sde*) of the Kangyur, and in Kangyurs of the Tshalpa line it is classified among predominantly narrative texts of the avadāna genre. No information is given in the colophon or in the different Kangyur indexes as to the translator or editor of the Tibetan. Both the Denkarma and Phangthangma imperial catalogs list the title among their inventories of sūtras.[n.17] This indicates that it was translated into Tibetan in the early translation period at a date no later than that of the Denkarma, 812 *ᴄᴇ*.

**i.13** [6990b3e4-c87c-4c1e-a347-83e759fcdd3e] There was no known Sanskrit witness of *The Questions of Dīrghanakha the Wandering Mendicant* available until recently, when a manuscript containing a collection of twenty sūtras was found in the Potala Palace in Lhasa. Bhikṣuṇī Vinītā published a critical edition and English translation of this collection in the series Sanskrit Texts from the Autonomous Region (2010). Unfortunately, due to the inaccessibility of the manuscript collection and because it is missing a final colophon, its origin and date are currently unknown.[n.18]

**i.14** [3403c96d-7255-4be2-8b6f-dd02cea6d710] There is one translation of the sūtra found in the Chinese Tripiṭaka (Taishō 584) by Yijing (*義淨*, seventh–eighth century) with the title *The Sūtra of the Questions of the Brahmin Dīrghanakha* (*chang zhao fan zha qang wan jang* *長爪梵志請問經*). There is also a complete extant Sogdian version of this sūtra, translated from the Chinese, called *The Sūtra Spoken by the Buddha at the Question of a Religious Man Dīrghanakha* (*pwty prβʾyrtk βrznʾxʾn δynδʾry wpʾrs pwstk*). The first study and (French) translation of this text was published by Robert Gauthiot in 1912 and later extensively commented on by Friedrich Weller (1934) and revised by Émile Benveniste (1940).[n.19]

**i.15** [0590215c-d61f-4b3f-99a3-0c91c1df2996] We have based our translation primarily on the Degé edition of the Tibetan Kangyur, but we consulted the Sanskrit, Chinese, and other Kangyur editions in the case of questionable terms or passages in order to establish the most plausible and accurate readings of the text. Any instance where we have diverged from the Degé has been noted, and any significant differences found in the various versions of the sūtra are recorded and explained in the notes. Citations in the notes of the Sanskrit are given using Vinītā’s emendations of the handwritten manuscript.

## The Translation

**The Questions of Dīrghanakha the Wandering Mendicant**

**1.1** [7a13b9d0-2f9c-4f60-bd94-3ed8644c0c5e] Homage to all buddhas and bodhisattvas!

**1.2** [92ce5f97-d8cb-41a2-a5c9-80e301205044] Thus did I hear at one time. The Blessed One was dwelling in Rājagṛha on Vulture Peak Mountain[n.20] together with a great monastic saṅgha of 1,250 monks.[n.21]

**1.3** [840f241f-dbec-4daf-af1c-608a8332449d] Then the Blessed One taught the Dharma to the fourfold saṅgha. He taught the wholesome conduct that is virtuous in the beginning, virtuous in the middle, and virtuous in the end, and that is excellent in meaning, excellent in words, distinctive, perfect, completely pure, and completely refined.[n.22]

**1.4** [57e20852-51b5-4e47-86c7-395d56aa105f] At that time Dīrghanakha the wandering mendicant journeyed to where the Blessed One was. Arriving in the presence of the Blessed One, he stood there resting on his staff, saying nothing at all. He then looked up and said to the Blessed One, “Hey, Gautama, you say that[n.23] beings of the world take possession of actions, enjoy the legacy of actions, and are bound by the fetters of actions, and you say that these actions are reliable.[n.24] If this is true, then (1) what previous actions has the renunciant Gautama performed and accumulated so that he has come to possess the vajra body?”

**1.5** [976fdcd4-ed81-4b4c-a231-d3b692a0b6b4] The Blessed One replied, “Great brahmin, this is the result of the action of abandoning killing[n.25] in my previous succession of lives.”

**1.6** [4ca4d57d-837d-4287-88a4-c44d808cd1b5] (2) “What previous actions did the renunciant Gautama perform and accumulate so that he came to have fingers that are long and webbed?”

**1.7** [96b1b1b5-fb2c-43b1-ac0a-97e0ef443393] The Blessed One replied, “Great brahmin, this is the result of the action of abandoning taking what is not given[n.26] in my previous succession of lives.”

**1.8** [39018664-9a08-4992-ab50-1089fffd6343] (3) “What previous actions did the renunciant Gautama perform and accumulate so that he came to have complete faculties and a fully developed body?”

**1.9** [e4fe6935-fab0-4ca4-ae41-d39836ee404a] The Blessed One replied, “Great brahmin, this is the result of the action of abandoning desire and sexual misconduct in my previous succession of lives.”

**1.10** [48bf0ef3-e206-4879-8e07-5d5a52dc8150] (4) “What previous actions did the renunciant Gautama perform and accumulate so that he came to have a tongue that covers the entire circle of his face?”[n.27]

**1.11** [baae885a-a18b-43d0-8d72-5698cb7db5b5] The Blessed One replied, “Great brahmin, this is the result of the action of abandoning false speech in my previous succession of lives.”

**1.12** [c5f26e0a-8b8d-4eb4-87f0-5538b4cec4b6] (5) “What previous actions did the renunciant Gautama perform and accumulate so that he came to have the gait of a lion?”[n.28]

**1.13** [668c60e0-4759-4dcc-a671-9cb4969c2217] The Blessed One replied, “Great brahmin, this is the result of the action of abandoning the state of heedlessness induced from being intoxicated with beer or other alcohol[n.29] in my previous succession of lives.”

**1.14** [5ffb3f1d-96a8-42d1-9758-5acba4928b9b] (6) “What previous actions did the renunciant Gautama perform and accumulate so that he came to possess forty even and white teeth?”[n.30][n.31]

**1.15** [51a54894-ca78-4be4-8c87-15a02e678c22] The Blessed One replied, “Great brahmin, this is the result of the action of abandoning eating food at inappropriate times in my previous succession of lives.”

**1.16** [13a0a91f-ebad-4b26-9a66-0602ecdacb39] (7) “What previous actions did the renunciant Gautama perform and accumulate so that he manifested a body anointed with the fragrance of moral discipline?”[n.32]

**1.17** [463bc807-9af3-4f3d-9c08-0a706aff084d] The Blessed One replied, “Great brahmin, this is the result of the action of abandoning the wearing of garlands, perfumes, ointments, and cosmetics in my previous succession of lives.”

**1.18** [0a7c9176-5d09-497f-bd10-b8ab0c5ef6c0] (8) “What previous actions did the renunciant Gautama perform and accumulate so that his body came to be adorned with all of the signs?”[n.33]

**1.19** [fd740173-c8ff-4a9d-9616-8c10056a81ae] The Blessed One replied, “Great brahmin, this is the result of the action of abandoning song, dance, and jewelry[n.34] in my previous succession of lives.”

**1.20** [4348ab2e-3910-4590-96aa-738f985dd5ea] (9) “What previous actions did the renunciant Gautama perform and accumulate so that he enjoys the three seats?”[n.35]

**1.21** [d8010f26-2bb9-4d79-9b13-680687658951] The Blessed One replied, “Great brahmin, this is the result of the action of abandoning high thrones and large beds in my previous succession of lives.”

**1.22** [867de0d3-f631-4d52-9c4a-9d16f8fd514e] (10) “What previous actions did the renunciant Gautama perform and accumulate so that he came to have the raised uṣṇīṣa on his head?”

**1.23** [050c2f8a-0413-4086-a9d4-135d65c0183e] The Blessed One replied, “Great brahmin, this is the result of the actions of placing my limbs and head upon the earth,[n.36] prostrating, and making offerings to the Buddha, Dharma, Saṅgha, parents, preceptors, scholars,[n.37] gurus, and those worthy of offering in my previous succession of lives.”[n.38]

**1.24** [5b546a9f-d095-4766-8184-35ea36807b89] At this point, Dīrghanakha the wandering mendicant set his staff[n.39] on the ground and bowed his head to the feet of the Blessed One. Standing to the side of the Blessed One, he joined his palms together, bowed, and said,[n.40] “Blessed One, for as long as I live, I go for refuge in the Buddha. For as long as I live, I go for refuge in the Dharma. For as long as I live, I go for refuge in the Saṅgha. For as long as I live, I will undertake abstinence relating to the eight poṣadha vows.[n.41]

**1.25** [a5634176-d160-4eac-880b-f1d82ccf35c0] “From now on I will abandon (1) killing any living creatures, (2) stealing another’s wealth, (3) engaging in sex, (4) lying or using divisive speech, (5) becoming intoxicated, (6) eating food at the inappropriate time, (7) garlands, cosmetics, song, dance, and entertainment, and (8) high beds. I will maintain these eight good qualities in the manner of the arhats.”

**1.26** [6f931e2b-de66-44a2-87a7-e182b320b122] In the same way, he repeated this vow a second and third time and said, “I will correctly maintain the vows of the discipline of the poṣadha. This will be the ornament of my mind, the instrument of my mind, and the accumulation of awakening. May I remain in the omniscient wisdom of the ultimate truth and the unsurpassable bliss of nirvāṇa.”[n.42]

The Blessed One said, “Great brahmin, you should do just that! Excellent! Excellent!”

**1.27** [d57daaa7-3c00-4a4f-ac3a-758c17a4c99c] When the Blessed One had thus spoken, those monks and the world with its gods, humans, demigods, and gandharvas rejoiced and praised the words of the Blessed One.

**1.28** [ab46410f-6ff8-43fb-be27-af507e2ca395] This completes “The Sūtra of the Questions of Dīrghanakha the Wandering Mendicant.” It is included among the teachings of the first turning.[n.43]

## Abbreviations

Chinese Seventh–eighth-century Chinese translation (Taishō 584) by Yijing (*義淨*)

D Degé (*sde dge*) Kangyur

H Lhasa (*zhol*) Kangyur

K Peking (*pe cin*) Kangxi Kangyur

N Narthang (*snar thang*) Kangyur

S Stok Palace (*stog pho brang bris ma*) Kangyur

Sanskrit Sanskrit manuscript found in the Potala Palace (see introduction)

U Urga (*ku re*) Kangyur

Y Peking Yongle (*g.yung lo*) Kangyur

## Notes

**n.1** *Aṣṭāṅgikapoṣadha*, *yan lag brgyad pa’i gso sbyong*. This is the usual Tibetan translation. In the text translated here it is *yan lag brgyad pa’i bsnyen gnas*.

**n.2** *Poṣadha* comes from the Prākrit form *posadha* of the Pali *uposatha*. Dutt (1962), p. 73.

**n.3** Dutt (1962), p. 73. Buswell and Lopez (2014), s.v. “upoṣadha.”

**n.4** Lévi (1912), p. 501.

**n.5** This sutta is listed in the Pali Tipitaka as MN 74. See Bhikkhu Ñāṇamoli (1995), pp. 603–6.

**n.6** *Sabbaṁ me na khamati*. See Bhikkhu Ñāṇamoli (1995), p. 1276, fn. 731, for more on Dīrghanakha’s view.

**n.7** *Dīrghanakhasya parivrājakasya sūtraṃ kartavyaṃ*, *Mahāvastu* 3.67 (at the end of the chapter on Śāriputra and Mahāmaudgalyāyana’s going forth).

**n.8** See Miller (2018), *The Chapter on Going Forth* (Toh 1-1) 1.67–1.102 and 1.281–1.312.

**n.9** Miller (2018), *The Chapter on Going Forth* (Toh 1-1), 1.362.

**n.10** See Burnouf (2010), pp. 426–31.

**n.11** Burnouf (2010), p. 427, fn. 43.

**n.12** Lamotte (2001), pp. 58–61. See p. 59, fn. 1, for more details on the accounts of Dīrghanakha.

**n.13** See UCSB Translation Group, trans., Victory of the Ultimate Dharma (*Paramārthadharmavijaya*, Toh 246), 2021.

**n.14** In chapter 1 of the *Aṣṭasāhasrikā* (Toh 12); chapter 11 of the *Daśasāhasrikā* (Toh 11, Padmakara Translation Group 2018, 11.31–11.33); chapter 8 of the *Aṣṭadaśasāhasrikā* (Toh 10, Sparham 2022, 8.35–8.38); chapter 5 of the *Pañcaviṃśatisāhasrikā* (Toh 9, Padmakara Translation Group 2023, 5.53–5.55); and chapter 5 of the *Śatasāhasrikā* (Toh 8, Sparham 2024, 5.423 ff.).

**n.15** See particularly Majjhimanikāya 71–73, Saṃyuktāgama SA 962–964 and SA2 196–198.
                        
**n.16** The first chapter of Nāgārjuna’s *Mahāprajñāpāramitāśāstra* mentions that among the Buddha’s reasons for teaching the Prajñāpāramitā was to bring Dīrghanakha, Śreṇika Vatsagotra, and another interlocutor, Satyaka Nirgranthīputra, to have faith in the Dharma. See Lamotte, vol. 1, pp. 58–61.

**n.17** Denkarma, folio 299.b; Phangthangma (2003), p. 22.

**n.18** Currently the manuscript is kept in the Potala. Vinītā’s critical edition is based on a copy of the manuscript that is kept in the China Tibetology Research Center. For further details on the state of this manuscript, see Vinītā (2010), pp. xv–xvii.

**n.19** See Yoshida (2011) for more details about this text.

**n.20** The Sanskrit has the Veṇuvana Kalandakanivāsa as the setting rather than Vulture Peak Mountain. Both are in Rājagṛha.

**n.21** The Sanskrit omits the audience. The Chinese adds people of various occupations to the list.

**n.22** This description of the teaching is omitted in the Sanskrit.

**n.23** Although the Tibetan *de skad smas pa* does not make it clear whether Dīrghanakha is attributing the following statement to the Buddha or not, the Sanskrit *vasadi* supports the second person subject “you.” It is evident from the fact that Dīrghanakha does not bow, and addresses the Buddha as “Gautama,” that he is not being respectful and so would not be using an honorific register.

**n.24** That is to say that actions reliably cause results. In the Sanskrit this description is slightly different: “Hey Gautama, is it true you say that this world takes actions as its self, is the heir of actions, originates from actions, is bound by actions, and has actions as a refuge?” (*satyaṃ bho gautamaivaṃ karmasvako lokaḥ karmadāyādaḥ karmayoniḥ karmabandhuḥ karmapratisaraṇa iti*). The Buddha then replies to Dīrghanakha’s initial question by affirming that he does propose this statement, before the first question (regarding the vajra body) is asked. In the Chinese, the Buddha likewise affirms Dīrghanakha by repeating the statement.

**n.25** The Sanskrit has “abandoning killing and ceasing killing” (*prāṇātipātaṃ prahāya prāṇātipātāt prativirataḥ*). Similarly, in the Buddha’s other replies to Dīrghanakha’s questions, with the exception of questions (5) and (7), he uses the two verbs *prahāya* and *prativirata*, while the Tibetan uses just the single verb “abandon” (*spong*).

**n.26** Translated from Sanskrit, H, Y, K, N, S, and U, which add “what is not given” (Skt. *adāna*, Tib. *ma byin par*). D just has “abandoning taking” (*len par spangs pa*).

**n.27** In the Sanskrit this is Dīrghanakha’s fifth question.

**n.28** In the Sanskrit this is Dīrghanakha’s sixth question.

**n.29** D: *’bru’i chang* (beer made from grain) or *sbyar ba’i chang* (beer or wine made with combined ingredients).

**n.30** Instead of “even teeth” (Tib. *so mnyam*), the Sanskrit has “very beautiful and very bright teeth” (*suśobhanadantaḥ sudīptadantaḥ*).

**n.31** In the Sanskrit this is Dīrghanakha’s ninth question.

**n.32** In the Sanskrit this is Dīrghanakha’s eighth question.

**n.33** The Sanskrit specifies these as the thirty-two signs of a great being (*dvātriṃśanmahāpuruṣalakṣaṇa*). In the Sanskrit this is Dīrghanakha’s seventh question.

**n.34** The Sanskrit has “playing” (*lalita*) instead of “jewelry” (Tib. *rgyan*).

**n.35** The Sanskrit adds a description of these three seats: “the perfect seat, the eminent seat, and the highest seat” (*aśeṣāsanāni pravarāsanāni uttamāsanāni*). The Chinese reads “the vajra seat and the eminent seat” (*jin gang sheng miao zhi zuo* *金剛勝妙之座*, Skt. *vajrāsana pravarāsana*). In the Sanskrit this is Dīrghanakha’s fourth question.

**n.36** D: *yan lag lnga sa la gtugs*, literally “placing the five limbs on the earth.” The “five limbs” here are the two arms, two legs, and head.

**n.37** The Sanskrit omits “scholars.”

**n.38** The Chinese adds the following section: “Whereupon the brahmin saw that the Buddha’s explanation of causes and their results was not deceptive and said, ‘Gautama, explain how these merits that you have described are obtained.’ The Buddha said, ‘These are said to be the eight poṣadha vows. If one is able through the course of one day and one night, or perhaps even longer over extended periods of time, to obtain mastery over keeping these, then such results are obtained.’ Whereupon the brahmin Dīrghanakha, with regard to all that the Buddha had said about the eight poṣadha vows and keeping them for a day and a night, with the result that the arising of previous far-distant low and wicked actions is turned away from, immediately obtained the subtle adornment of deep confidence and uplifting joy” (Taishō 584, b28–c5).

**n.39** The Sanskrit says he sets down his “staff and water pot” (*daṇḍakamaṇḍalu*). Some dictionaries describe this conjunct term as a water pot with a handle. However, it is clear from the mention of this at the beginning of the sūtra that he does carry a staff (*daṇḍa*). See 1.4.

**n.40** The Sanskrit only has Dīrghanakha setting down his staff and omits the rest of these actions before the following speech.

**n.41** Sanskrit: *āryāṣṭāṅgikapoṣadham upavasāmi*.

**n.42** This section, from “In the same way, he repeated this vow a second and third time” up to this point, is omitted in the Sanskrit.

**n.43** D, H, N, S, and U: *bka’ dang por gtogs so*; Y and K omit.

## Glossary

- **abstinence** · Tibetan: བསྙེན་གནས། (bsnyen gnas) · Sanskrit: upavāsa. As expressed in the Sanskrit and translated literally into Tibetan, the term means “to dwell near.” The term comes from the older Vedic traditions in which during full moon and new moon sacrifices, householders would practice abstinence in various forms such as fasting and refraining from sexual activity. These holy days were called upavasatha days because it was said that the gods that were the recipients of these sacrifices would “dwell” (√vas) “near” (upa) the practitioners of these sacrifices. While sacrificial practices were discarded by Buddhists, the framework of practicing fortnightly abstinence evolved into the poṣadha observance, and in fact the term poṣadha is etymologically related to the term upavasatha. See Dutt (1962), p. 73.
- **blessed one** · Tibetan: བཅོམ་ལྡན་འདས། (bcom ldan ’das) · Sanskrit: bhagavat. In Buddhist literature, this is an epithet applied to buddhas, most often to Śākyamuni. The Sanskrit term generally means “possessing fortune,” but in specifically Buddhist contexts it implies that a buddha is in possession of six auspicious qualities (bhaga) associated with complete awakening. The Tibetan term—where bcom is said to refer to “subduing” the four māras, ldan to “possessing” the great qualities of buddhahood, and ’das to “going beyond” saṃsāra and nirvāṇa—possibly reflects the commentarial tradition where the Sanskrit bhagavat is interpreted, in addition, as “one who destroys the four māras.” This is achieved either by reading bhagavat as bhagnavat (“one who broke”), or by tracing the word bhaga to the root √bhañj (“to break”).
                                      
In this sūtra it is notable that Dīrghanakha does not initially show respect to the Buddha and refers to him using a more neutral register, “renunciant Gautama,” until his conversion at the end of the sūtra (1.24), when he then uses the epithet “Blessed One.”
- **body anointed with the fragrance of moral discipline** · Tibetan: ཚུལ་ཁྲིམས་ཀྱི་སྤོས་ཀྱིས་ལུས་བྱུགས་པ། (tshul khrims kyi spos kyis lus byugs pa) · Sanskrit: śīlagandhānuliptagātra. There are many references in the sūtras to a pleasant fragrance that is the result of moral discipline. Although it is not stated in these exact words, this description echoes some of the eighty excellent signs (asītyānuvyañjana), a subset of the 112 physical characteristics of both buddhas and cakravartins. For example, the list found in the Perfection of Wisdom in Ten Thousand Lines (Toh 11, 2.33) describes these signs: “(34) Their body is immaculate and without unpleasant odors”; and (later down the list) “(40) The pores of their body all emit a pleasant odor.”
- **complete faculties and a fully developed body** · Tibetan: དབང་པོ་ཡོངས་སུ་ཚང་ཞིང་ལུས་རབ་ཏུ་རྒྱས་པ། (dbang po yongs su tshang zhing lus rab tu rgyas pa) · Sanskrit: pūrṇendriyaḥ paripūrṇagātraḥ. Although not stated in precisely the same words, this description echoes some of the eighty excellent signs (asītyānuvyañjana), a subset of the 112 physical characteristics of both buddhas and cakravartins. For example, the list found in the Perfection of Wisdom in Ten Thousand Lines (Toh 11, 2.33) describes these signs: “(15) Their body is well proportioned. (16) Their senses are completely purified. (17) Their understanding is perfectly pure.” And further down the list it reads “(36) Their [sense faculties]—the ‘gates to the sense fields’—are excellent.”
- **Dīrghanakha** · Tibetan: སེན་རིངས། (sen rings) · Sanskrit: dīrghanakha. A brahmin disciple of the Buddha. Also known as Koṣṭhila, Kauṣṭhila, Mahākauṣṭhila, and Agnivaiśyāyana. See introduction, i.4.
- **eight poṣadha vows** · Tibetan: ཡན་ལག་བརྒྱད་པའི་གསོ་སྦྱོང་།, ཡན་ལག་བརྒྱད་པའི་བསྙེན་གནས། (yan lag brgyad pa’i bsnyen gnas, yan lag brgyad pa’i gso sbyong) · Sanskrit: aṣṭāṅgikapoṣadha. To refrain from (1) killing, (2) stealing, (3) sexual misconduct, (4) lying or divisive speech, (5) intoxication, (6) eating at inappropriate times, (7) entertainment such as singing, dancing, seeing shows, and beautifying oneself with adornments or cosmetics, and (8) using a high bed. See introduction (i.2).
- **fingers that are long and webbed** · Tibetan: སོར་མོ་རིང་ཞིང་སོར་མོའི་བར་དྲ་བས་འབྲལ་པར། (sor mo ring zhing sor mo’i bar dra bas ’bral par) · Sanskrit: dīrghāṇgulijālāvanaddha. The Buddha is said to have long and webbed fingers and toes. This is one of the signs included in the thirty-two signs of a great being; sometimes “long” and “webbed” are listed as two separate signs.
- **forty even and white teeth** · Tibetan: སོ་བཞི་བཅུ་དང་ལྡན་ཞིང་སོ་མཉམ་ལ་སོ་དཀར་བ། (so bzhi bcu dang ldan zhing so mnyam la so dkar ba) · Sanskrit: catvāriṃśaddantaḥ śukladantaḥ *samadantaḥ. Having “forty even and white teeth” is included in the thirty-two signs of a great being. Depending on the list, this sign is often divided into two separate signs of having “forty teeth” and having “white teeth.” In the Sanskrit parallel of The Questions of Dīrghanakha the Wandering Mendicant, this quality is described as having “very beautiful and very bright teeth” (suśobhanadantaḥ sudīptadantaḥ).
- **fourfold saṅgha** · Tibetan: འཁོར་བཞི་པོ། (’khor bzhi po) · Sanskrit: catuḥparṣad. The fourfold saṅgha comprises monks, nuns, and female and male lay practitioners.
- **gait of a lion** · Tibetan: སེང་གེའི་སྟབས་སུ་འགྲོ་བ། (seng ge’i stabs su ’gro ba) · Sanskrit: siṃhavikrāntagāmin. Having the “gait of a lion” is included in the list of the eighty excellent signs (asītyānuvyañjana), a subset of the 112 physical characteristics of both buddhas and cakravartins.
- **Gautama** · Tibetan: གོའུ་ཏ་མ། (go’u ta ma) · Sanskrit: gautama. The family name of the historical Buddha. Gautama means “descendant of Gotama,” while his clan name, Gotama, means “Excellent Cow.” When the Buddha is addressed as Gautama in the sūtras, it typically implies that the speaker does not share the respect of his disciples, who would rather refer to him as the “Blessed One” or another such epithet.
- **Lokāyata** · Tibetan: འཇིག་རྟེན་རྒྱང་ཕན་པ། (’jig rten rgyang phan pa) · Sanskrit: lokāyata. The materialist or “worldly” school, one of the many schools of the Indian śramaṇa movement around at the time of the Buddha. Today most of their literature and discourse has been lost, but their view can be compiled through secondary historical literature and the voices of their critics. According to this, they are claimed to have asserted a rigid materialist philosophy in which everything in the universe is composed of only four elements (earth, water, heat, and air). They rejected the moral causality associated with karma, and they rejected transmigration or rebirth. For more on the Lokāyata philosophy, see Chattopadhaya (1992), pp. 22–75.
- **poṣadha** · Tibetan: གསོ་སྦྱོང་། (gso sbyong) · Sanskrit: poṣadha, upoṣadha. The ceremony performed every new and full moon day by monastics, in which they confess any faults or transgressions and recite the prātimokṣa. It also refers to the one-day practice adopted by lay people in which they practice restraint according to the eight poṣadha vows and which may also include fasting. See introduction (i.2).
- **raised uṣṇīṣa** · Tibetan: གཙུག་ཏོར་འཕགས་པ། (gtsug tor ’phags pa) · Sanskrit: uṣṇīṣonnata. The uṣṇīṣa, described in this text as “raised” (Skt. unnata) is one of the most prominent of the thirty-two signs of a great being and is often placed first or last in the list. In its simplest form it is an elevated shape of the head, like a turban (the Sanskrit term uṣṇīṣa in fact means “turban”), or more elaborately a dome-shaped extension. The extension is described as having various magical attributes such as emitting and absorbing rays of light or reaching such an immense height that the gods are incapable of flying over it.
- **Rājagṛha** · Tibetan: རྒྱལ་པོའི་ཁབ། (rgyal po’i khab) · Sanskrit: rājagṛha. Literally “King’s House,” this was the capital city of Magadha ruled by King Bimbisāra. It is currently the modern-day city of Rajgir in Bihar, North India.
- **renunciant** · Tibetan: དགེ་སྦྱོང་། (dge sbyong) · Sanskrit: śramaṇa. The Sanskrit term literally means “one who toils,” i.e., an ascetic, and the term is applied to spiritual renunciants or monks, whether Buddhist or otherwise. The Tibetan translation of this term is dge sbyong, meaning “one who trains in virtue.”
- **seer** · Tibetan: དྲང་སྲོང་། (drang srong) · Sanskrit: ṛṣi. An ancient Indian spiritual title, often translated as “sage” or “seer.” The title is particularly used for divinely inspired individuals credited with creating the foundations of Indian culture. The term is also applied to Śākyamuni and other realized Buddhist figures.
- **sexual misconduct** · Tibetan: འདོད་པ་ལོག་པར་གཡེམ་པ། (’dod pa log par g.yem pa) · Sanskrit: kāmamithyācāra. For laity this would ostensibly constitute any sexual misconduct such as adultery, molestation, or any conduct seen as perverse or improper (mithyā). Refraining from sexual misconduct is the third of the eight poṣadha vows. However, laity practicing the one-day poṣadha additionally practice celibacy, just as monastics do.
- **Śreṇika Vatsagotra** · Tibetan: ཕྲེང་བ་ཅན།, བཟོ་སྦྱངས། (bzo sbyangs, phreng ba can) · Sanskrit: śreṇika vatsagotra. A wandering ascetic, uncle of Śāriputra, whose dialogue with the Buddha is mentioned in the long Prajñāpāramitāsūtras.
- **taking what is not given** · Tibetan: མ་བྱིན་པར་ལེན་པ། (ma byin par len pa) · Sanskrit: adattādāna. Essentially meaning to steal. Refraining from stealing or taking what is not given is the second of the eight poṣadha vows.
- **thirty-two signs of a great being** · Tibetan: སྐྱེས་བུ་ཆེན་པོའི་མཚན་སུམ་ཅུ་རྩ་གཉིས། (skyes bu chen po’i mtshan sum cu rtsa gnyis) · Sanskrit: dvātriṃśanmahāpuruṣalakṣaṇa. Thirty-two of the 112 identifying physical characteristics of both buddhas and cakravartins, in addition to the “eighty excellent signs.” There are significant variations found in this list depending on the source.
- **three seats** · Tibetan: སྟན་གསུམ། (stan gsum) · Sanskrit: trīṇy āsanāni. It is not clear precisely what the three seats are. See n.35.
- **tīrthika** · Tibetan: མུ་སྟེགས་པ། (mu stegs pa) · Sanskrit: tīrthika. Those of other religious or philosophical orders, contemporary with the early Buddhist order, including Jains, Jaṭilas, Ājīvikas, and Cārvākas. Tīrthika (“forder”) literally translates as “one belonging to or associated with (possessive suffix –ika) stairs for landing or for descent into a river,” or “a bathing place,” or “a place of pilgrimage on the banks of sacred streams” (Monier-Williams). The term may have originally referred to temple priests at river crossings or fords where travelers propitiated a deity before crossing. The Sanskrit term seems to have undergone metonymic transfer in referring to those able to ford the turbulent river of saṃsāra (as in the Jain tīrthaṅkaras, “ford makers”), and it came to be used in Buddhist sources to refer to teachers of rival religious traditions. The Sanskrit term is closely rendered by the Tibetan mu stegs pa: “those on the steps (stegs pa) at the edge (mu).”
- **tongue that covers the entire circle of his face** · Tibetan: ལྕེས་གདོང་གི་དཀྱིལ་འཁོར་ཐམས་ཅད་ཁེབས། (lces gdong gi dkyil ’khor thams cad khebs) · Sanskrit: jihvayā sarvamukhamaṇḍalam ācchādyati. This description is in reference to one of the thirty-two signs of a great being. In some lists of the signs, this one is simply described as having a long and slender tongue, but in others it is explained that the tongue is capable of reaching anywhere on the face up to the hairline.
- **Ulka** · Tibetan: མེ་སྒྲོན། (me sgron) · Sanskrit: ulkā. A non-Buddhist seer, the main interlocutor in The Victory of the Ultimate Dharma (Toh 246).
- **vajra body** · Tibetan: རྡོ་རྗེའི་ལུས། (rdo rje’i lus) · Sanskrit: vajrakāyaśarīra. The body of the Buddha is like an indestructible vajra. While the term vajrakāya has specialized meaning in a tantric context, it is unlikely that such meaning is applicable here. In the Chinese, the term is translated as a “vajra-like, indestructible solid body” (jin gang bu huai jian gu zhi shen 金剛不壞堅固之身).
- **Veṇuvana Kalandakanivāsa** · Tibetan: འོད་མའི་ཚལ་བྱ་ཀ་ལན་ད་ཀ་གནས་པ། (’od ma’i tshal bya ka lan da ka gnas pa) · Sanskrit: veṇuvana kalandakanivāsa. The famous bamboo grove near Rājagṛha where the Buddha regularly stayed and gave teachings. It was situated on land donated by King Śreṇya Bimbisāra of Magadha and, as such, was the first of several landholdings donated to the Buddhist community during the time of the Buddha. Kalandakanivāpa means “feeding place of the kalandakas,” where kalandaka could refer to a flying squirrel or bird, as explained by differing sources.
- **Vulture Peak Mountain** · Tibetan: བྱ་རྒྱོད་ཀྱི་ཕུང་པོའི་རི། (bya rgyod kyi phung po’i ri) · Sanskrit: gṛdhrakūtaparvata. The Gṛdhrakūṭa, literally Vulture Peak, was a hill located in the kingdom of Magadha, in the vicinity of the ancient city of Rājagṛha (modern-day Rajgir, in the state of Bihar, India), where the Buddha bestowed many sūtras, especially the Great Vehicle teachings, such as the Prajñāpāramitā sūtras. It continues to be a sacred pilgrimage site for Buddhists to this day.
- **wandering mendicant** · Tibetan: ཀུན་ཏུ་རྒྱུ་བ། (kun tu rgyu ba) · Sanskrit: parivrājaka. Literally, “one who wanders around.” An umbrella term for the class of wandering religious ascetics of diverse religious persuasions who were common at the time of the Buddha.
