---
title: "The Dhāraṇī of the Jewel Torch"
toh: "Toh 145"
also_in_canon_as: ["Toh 847"]
sanskrit_title: "Ratnolkādhāraṇī"
tibetan_title: "dkon mchog ta la la’i gzungs"
canon_section:
  Toh 145: "Kangyur › Discourses › General Sūtra Section"
  Toh 847: "Kangyur › Dhāraṇī › Compendium of Dhāraṇīs"
url: https://84000.co/translation/toh145
published: 2021-03-04
collections: []
publisher: "84000: Translating the Words of the Buddha"
translation_team: "David Jackson"
translators: ["David Jackson"]
license: "CC BY-NC-ND 4.0"
license_url: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
citation: "The Dhāraṇī of the Jewel Torch (Ratnolkādhāraṇī, Toh 145). Translated by David Jackson. Online publication. 84000: Translating the Words of the Buddha, 2021. https://84000.co/translation/toh145."
part: 1
parts: 4
generated: 2026-11-16
---

# The Dhāraṇī of the Jewel Torch

Toh 145 · Kangyur › Discourses › General Sūtra Section · An 84000 translation · Read online: https://84000.co/translation/toh145

> **License:** [CC BY-NC-ND 4.0](https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/). This work is provided under the protection of a Creative Commons CC BY-NC-ND (Attribution - Non-commercial - No-derivatives) 4.0 copyright. It may be copied or printed for fair use, but only with full attribution, and not for commercial advantage or personal compensation. **Cite as:** The Dhāraṇī of the Jewel Torch (Ratnolkādhāraṇī, Toh 145). Translated by David Jackson. Online publication. 84000: Translating the Words of the Buddha, 2021. https://84000.co/translation/toh145.

> This is the plain-text edition of https://84000.co/translation/toh145. Passage labels (for example 1.2 or i.3) match the online edition. Each label is followed by the passage's permanent ID in square brackets, and by a Toh number when the passage belongs to one Toh only, for example **1.2** [ID] or **i.3** [ID, toh145]. To link to a passage, use https://84000.co/entity/passage/ID?toh=TOH, with TOH = toh145 when no Toh is given. Note numbers in square brackets (such as [n.3]) point to the Notes section. This translation is also catalogued as Toh 847; this one file covers both. When quoting, cite 84000, *The Dhāraṇī of the Jewel Torch* (Toh 145), with the passage label and its link. The summary, introduction and notes are by the translators and are not part of the translated text.

## Parts of this text

This text is long, so its plain-text edition is split into 4 parts. Each part keeps 84000's passage labels and ends with the notes its passages refer to. The whole text in one file: https://84000.co/translation/toh145/full.md

- [Part 1](https://84000.co/translation/toh145.md): Summary, Acknowledgments, Introduction, The Translation, Chapter 1 (1.1–1.140)
- [Part 2](https://84000.co/translation/toh145/part-2.md): Chapter 1, Chapter 2 (1.141–2.153)
- [Part 3](https://84000.co/translation/toh145/part-3.md): Chapter 2, Colophon (2.154–2.402)
- [Part 4](https://84000.co/translation/toh145/part-4.md): Glossary

## At a glance

> Machine-generated overview: written by AI from 84000's published summary and introduction, not yet reviewed by an 84000 editor. It is not part of the translation; quote the translation itself.

**In brief:** The Dhāraṇī of the Jewel Torch (Toh 145), Sanskrit title Ratnolkādhāraṇī, is a Mahāyāna sūtra found in the General Sūtra section of the Kangyur, also catalogued separately as Toh 847 in Kangyurs that include a Dhāraṇī section. The text opens with the Buddha Śākyamuni at the Vulture Peak in Rājagṛha, where the bodhisattva Samantabhadra initiates a discussion on the nature of the dharmadhātu, the ultimate sphere of reality, and its relation to emptiness and awakening. The bodhisattva Dharmamati then enters a profound meditative absorption and, encouraged by millions of buddhas, delivers a detailed teaching on the ten progressive categories of bodhisattva development. This exposition of the bodhisattva path is central to the text and closely connects it to the Avataṃsakasūtra, with two long passages matching complete chapters of that work. The text also contains a mantra presented as the dhāraṇī of the jewel torch, and a lengthy verse section in which the bodhisattva Bhadraśrī praises the qualities of bodhisattvas, including a celebrated passage on faith widely quoted in both Indian and Tibetan literature.

**Why read it:** This text offers a sustained account of how bodhisattvas progress toward awakening, combined with teachings on the nature of reality and a celebrated verse passage on faith that influenced Indian and Tibetan Buddhist literature across traditions.

### Where is The Dhāraṇī of the Jewel Torch set, and who is present at the teaching?

The text is set on the Vulture Peak in Rājagṛha, where the Buddha Śākyamuni teaches before a great gathering of more than a thousand fully ordained monks and a large assembly of bodhisattvas. The most prominent bodhisattvas present include Samantabhadra, Mañjuśrī, Dharmamati, and many others named in the opening.

### What is the main doctrinal content of the text?

The Dhāraṇī of the Jewel Torch covers three main areas: a philosophical exchange on the dharmadhātu, emptiness, and awakening; Dharmamati's detailed exposition of the ten progressive categories of bodhisattva development; and a long verse section in which the bodhisattva Bhadraśrī praises the qualities and conduct of bodhisattvas, including a well-known passage on faith.

### Why is this text described as both a sūtra and a dhāraṇī?

The text is classified as both because it contains a mantra-like formula referred to as the dhāraṇī of the jewel torch, and because teachings within it are also described as dhāraṇīs in the sense of detailed instructions to be retained by practitioners. The word dhāraṇī can refer to an encoding formula, a capacity for memorization, or a teaching itself, and the text uses the term in several of these senses at different points.

### How is The Dhāraṇī of the Jewel Torch related to the Avataṃsakasūtra?

Two long passages in The Dhāraṇī of the Jewel Torch correspond to complete chapters of the Avataṃsakasūtra. Dharmamati's exposition of the ten categories of bodhisattvas matches chapter 20 of the Tibetan Avataṃsakasūtra, and the final verse section on Bhadraśrī's teachings matches chapter 17. The Chinese translation of this text is also classified as an Avataṃsaka text.

### Who quoted this text in other works, and what significance did those quotations have?

Śāntideva quoted from this sūtra more than from any other work in his Śikṣāsamuccaya, and his Sanskrit text preserves the only known Sanskrit remnants of The Dhāraṇī of the Jewel Torch. The text was also quoted by Atiśa, Vimalamitra, and many Tibetan authors across traditions. The verses on faith were especially influential, serving as a scriptural source for there being—variously—three, four, or six kinds of faith in Tibetan literature.

### Who translated The Dhāraṇī of the Jewel Torch into Tibetan, and who translated it into English for 84000?

The Tibetan translation was made during the early imperial period by the Indian master Surendrabodhi and the chief editor and translator the monk Yeshé Dé, as recorded in the colophon. The English translation published by 84000 was made by David Jackson and first published in 2021.

### Why does the Tibetan title of the text differ from its Sanskrit title?

The Sanskrit title Ratnolkādhāraṇī contains the word ulkā, meaning a fiery phenomenon in the sky, a meteor, or a torch. The Tibetan canonical title uses the archaic word ta la la, meaning lamp or torch, giving dkon mchog ta la la'i gzungs. Some Tibetan treatises and later authors use instead the more common Tibetan word for lamp, sgron ma, leading to variant titles that were not always recognized as referring to the same canonical text.

## Summary

**s.1** [0e9caec0-5ab1-494c-b36c-fff42480a6f3] *The Dhāraṇī of the Jewel Torch* starts with a profound conversation between the Buddha and the bodhisattvas Samantabhadra and Mañjuśrī on the nature of the *dharmadhātu*, buddhahood, and emptiness. The bodhisattva Dharmamati then enters the meditative absorption called *the infinite application of the bodhisattva’s jewel torch* and, at the behest of the millions of buddhas who have blessed him, emerges from it to teach how bodhisattvas arise from the presence of a tathāgata and progress to the state of omniscience. Following Dharmamati’s detailed exposition of the “ten categories” or progressive stages of a bodhisattva, the Buddha briefly teaches the mantra of the *dhāraṇī* and then, for most of the remainder of the text, encourages bodhisattvas in a long versified passage in which he recounts teachings by a bodhisattva called Bhadraśrī on the qualities of bodhisattvas and buddhas. Some verses from this passage on the virtues of faith have been widely quoted in both India and Tibet.

## Acknowledgments

**ac.1** [95b93162-bff2-4ff1-8fd4-4b4c40705c7d] Translated by David Jackson and edited by the 84000 editorial team. The introduction, also by the 84000 editorial team, expands on an original version by David Jackson. The translation was completed under the patronage and supervision of 84000: Translating the Words of the Buddha.

**ac.2** [2eb2944d-6aa3-42af-b2f2-3dcb34e98172] The generous sponsorship of Make and Wang Xiao Juan (*馬珂和王曉娟*), which helped make the work on this translation possible, is most gratefully acknowledged.

## Introduction

### Overview

**i.1** [dc8580e4-4b15-40a0-ad33-347165c1e9dc] In this profound Mahāyāna sūtra, *The Dhāraṇī of the Jewel Torch*, the Buddha Śākyamuni explains, with the help of the bodhisattvas Mañjuśrī, Samantabhadra, and Dharmamati, how bodhisattvas progress toward awakening.

**i.2** [ed5d1737-8955-4e7f-8d11-e0c917ec1875] Although seen as a sūtra in its own right, it is closely connected to the family of texts belonging to the *Avataṃsakasūtra*, two chapters of which it shares. As its title suggests, it can also be seen as a *dhāraṇī*, or as a sūtra about a dhāraṇī.

**i.3** [da6e31b6-3fd4-445b-a4de-fd2faa5d8d33] Substantial passages were quoted by Śāntideva in the *Śikṣāsamuccaya*, and these extracts are now the only remnants of the Sanskrit text. The Tibetan translation, by the Indian master Surendrabodhi and the chief-editor translator the monk Yeshé Dé, dates to the early, imperial translation period, and its verses on faith later had a wide impact in Tibetan works. The Chinese translation, by Fatian, dates to the late tenth century and is classified as an *Avataṃsaka* text.

### Narrative and Doctrinal Content

**i.4** [03dac45f-8045-4c50-af61-676ce544c556] The setting of the text is the Vulture Peak in Rājagṛha. Its audience is a great gathering of highly accomplished monks and bodhisattvas, headed by Samantabhadra who, as the initial interlocutor, asks the Buddha how dharmadhātu should be understood. A brief but profound exchange follows.

**i.5** [e9fbaa26-afad-4bca-90a8-5d7569f8cdeb] Mañjuśrī then appears and requests the Buddha to teach the dhāraṇī of *the jewel torch* (1.11). The Buddha insists that Mañjuśrī should request Samantabhadra to teach it instead, and Samantabhadra’s dialog with Mañjuśrī starts with the meaning of *buddha*. A brief interlude follows (1.40–1.54) in which Śāriputra (here Śāradvatīputra) compares his own understanding unfavorably with Mañjuśrī’s vast wisdom, and professes his inability and unwillingness to debate with him; similar brief conversations between Śāriputra and Mañjuśrī recur at several points in the text.

**i.6** [6eb65643-9750-49b1-b8c5-4f030c5a051a] The bodhisattva Dharmamati then makes his appearance (1.55) and enters the meditative absorption called *the infinite application of the bodhisattva’s jewel torch*. Blessed and encouraged by millions of buddhas to summon the eloquence to teach, Dharmamati sets out the ten categories of bodhisattva (1.59–1.84) in the long passage that follows. A number of wonders then occur, after which Dharmamati summarizes the ten categories in verse (1.88–1.178).

**i.7** [7f301498-ff7b-44eb-ae76-c6001885fc6f] The Buddha, in response to several ensuing requests to teach, briefly teaches the mantra of the dhāraṇī (1.213) and comments on its meaning. At Samantabhadra and Mañjuśrī’s request, he then explains the benefits that hearing this sūtra will have for future disciples (1.228–1.256). Here several stark warnings are given to future hearers (mainly future monks) who might one day criticize or reject this sūtra.

**i.8** [2d544612-0d82-43e9-ba6a-75d9db1c4180] The final main section of the sūtra is a very long passage (twenty folios in the Degé edition) of versified encouragement for bodhisattvas, introduced by a prologue featuring Ānanda. The main versified part (2.20–2.397) is spoken by the Buddha as a narrative that introduces, relates, and concludes teachings given by the bodhisattva Bhadraśrī on the good qualities and modes of conduct of the bodhisattva. Bhadraśrī first eulogizes the thought of awakening (*bodhicitta*) and then a few verses later praises faith in a well-known passage, parts of which were quoted by Śāntideva (see below) and subsequently by many Tibetan authors. Bhadraśrī then describes many of the other qualities of bodhisattvas and their ability to manifest miraculously in different ways, including the astounding visual and other sensory content of their meditative absorptions, the many kinds of miraculous rays of light with which they bring benefit to the world and beings, and comparisons with the powerful magical displays of the ordinary gods such as Indra and the king of the nāgas.[n.1]

**i.9** [afe8cd6e-940f-4fe5-9f7c-1ff479ed706d] At the end of the teaching, its importance and future benefits are expressed by Subhūti and others, and Ānanda promises to retain it.

### The Sūtra, the *Avataṃsaka*, and the Chinese Translation

**i.10** [a8b42ae4-0296-4474-9a2a-6e69d9b2591a] Although it is found in the Kangyur among other Mahāyāna sūtras in the General Sūtra section (as Tōh 145 in the Degé Kangyur) and is listed as belonging to that general category in the Denkarma inventory of translated texts[n.2] (as well as to the Dhāraṇī section, see below), the sūtra also belongs to the family of texts related to the *Avataṃsakasūtra* (*phal po che*, “*A Multitude of Buddhas*,” Toh 44). Indeed, in the other imperial period inventory, the roughly contemporary Phangthangma, it is listed under the heading of “the works included in the group of sūtras of the noble, great, very extensive *Buddhāvataṃsaka*.”[n.3]

**i.11** [26a3379f-de8a-4f1b-8285-80f24180c19d] The prominent role of the bodhisattva Samantabhadra; the centrality of the dharmadhātu; the vast numbers of buddhas who gather and the mention of the Buddha Vairocana in the pivotal passage about the absorption and blessing of Dharmamati; the tenfold division and subdivision of the categories of bodhisattva; the repeated vocative “O sons of the victors”;[n.4] and many other features of this work, above all the central theme of how bodhisattvas first emerge in the presence of a tathāgata and progressively develop access to the buddha qualities, culminating in their regency and consecration, are all strongly reminiscent of the *Avataṃsaka*.
 
**i.12** [51a0a784-b9db-4386-8a37-882a7224d984] Two long passages in the text represent two complete chapters of the *Avataṃsakasūtra*.[n.5] In terms of content they are close to being exact matches, although the translations in Tibetan are different. The long passage recounting Dharmamati’s absorption and his ensuing revelations in both prose and verse (from 1.55 to 1.178) is almost identical to the whole of chapter 20 of the Tibetan *Avataṃsakasūtra*, “The Ten Categories of Bodhisattvas” (chapter 15 of the Chinese),[n.6] while almost the entirety of the final verse section recounting the teachings by Bhadraśrī (from 2.27 to 2.397 near the conclusion of the text) matches the whole of chapter 17 of the Tibetan *Avataṃsakasūtra*, “Bhadraśrī” (chapter 12 of the Chinese).[n.7]

**i.13** [bd349054-257d-4b2d-96ae-8e0d4e44db1f] The Chinese translation of this text, Taishō 299,[n.8] made by Fatian almost a hundred years later than the Tibetan, in the year 983, is also classified as a sūtra of the *Avataṃsaka* family. It is placed in the Taishō in the Huayan volume, volume 10, along with the *Avataṃsakasūtra* itself and the other standalone texts related to it.[n.9]

### Why Is the Sūtra Also a Dhāraṇī?

**i.14** [44d57d5f-f178-45c2-a514-d81d996d8184] The text is classified not only as a sūtra, but also as a *dhāraṇī*, and in those Kangyurs that have an additional Dhāraṇī section it is duplicated there (as Tōhoku no. 847[n.10] in the Degé Kangyur). Indeed, the title itself includes the word *dhāraṇī*, and the teaching requested of the Buddha is referred to as “the dhāraṇī of the jewel torch.”

**i.15** [003281c9-b084-4219-b804-8e80aef00bd3] The term *dhāraṇī* is derived from the Sanskrit root √*dhṛ* (“to hold” or “to maintain”), and among its wide range of meanings most are closely related to the retaining—in the mind, in memory, in words, or in writing—of a particular teaching, realization, or approach to awakening. Perhaps the two most widespread senses in which the term is used are when it refers to a mantra-like formula that “encodes” its meaning without necessarily expressing it in comprehensible speech, or when it describes the highly developed capacity of advanced practitioners to memorize and accurately retain a set of detailed and profound instructions. But as well as signifying the means by which such meanings or sets of instructions are retained (i.e., what holds them), it can also designate a specific meaning or instruction itself (i.e., what is held).

**i.16** [805def49-c5ce-4cd0-a158-528d422c9047] Furthermore, by extension from these senses of the term, a text that either *contains* a (mantra-like) dhāraṇī, or is *about* a dhāraṇī in any of these senses, may itself be referred to *as* a dhāraṇī. This is the basis for the term dhāraṇī having also come to designate a whole scriptural genre of Mahāyāna texts—well represented in the Kangyur, which contains some two hundred fifty texts in that category. However, as a genre it is both quite diverse in its composition and shares most of the texts it contains with other genres. It is often not entirely clear whether any one text is labeled a dhāraṇī because the text itself *is* a dhāraṇī, *contains* a dhāraṇī, or is *about* a dhāraṇī.

**i.17** [fca864cc-09bd-4723-ae5d-910ee3b8f1bc] For all these reasons, each text placed in this genre deserves its own analysis of what makes it “a dhāraṇī.” In the case of the present text, mentions are made throughout to a “dhāraṇī of the jewel torch,” but it is difficult to determine whether they all have the same reference, or whether they variously refer to a particular realization of bodhisattvas, to a teaching on that realization, or to the text itself.

**i.18** [50b4abd8-4bbf-4666-b9e9-595dc8f76c19] In the first chapter, there are four separate occasions on which the dhāraṇī seems to be taught. Although the corresponding mentions could conceivably all be understood as referring to one and the same instance of the dhāraṇī, three of the four occasions end with a statement that the dhāraṇī has now been taught, in the past tense. In the first of the four instances, the exchange between Mañjuśrī, Samantabhadra, and the Buddha (starting at 1.11) is termed an explanation of the dhāraṇī in the initial request. In the second instance, Dharmamati’s long teaching on the ten levels of bodhisattvas is also described as a dhāraṇī immediately afterward by Samantabhadra (1.179). The third instance is a dialog between Mañjuśrī and Śāriputra (starting at 1.196) in response to the latter’s request for an explanation of the dhāraṇī, which is lauded as a teaching on that dhāraṇī afterward (1.205). The fourth instance is when yet another request is made to the Buddha, this time by Samantabhadra, to teach the dhāraṇī (1.211); the Buddha teaches what is described as a mantra, and in the discussions that follow it is made clear that the meaning it carries is that of the ineffable ultimate nature of reality.[n.11]

**i.19** [288231ba-acf9-4113-9930-6a756ea0e710] Along with dhāraṇīs, a number of sūtras mention gateways (Skt. *mukha*, Tib. *sgo*), meditative absorptions (Skt. *samādhi*, Tib. *ting nge ’dzin*), and liberations (Skt. *vimokṣa*, Tib. *rnam par thar pa*) as different kinds of qualities attained by bodhisattvas. That some of the mentions of the dhāraṇī in this sūtra fall into the category of such attained qualities is suggested by the first of the four instances instance here being also termed an “access” or gateway (1.34), and by the second instance being described as arising from the gnosis that Dharmamati has attained while immersed in a meditative absorption called “the infinite application of the jewel torch.”[n.12] Nevertheless, this second instance, the long teaching on the ten levels of bodhisattvas, is clearly also seen as a teaching, in the sense of presenting specific doctrinal content. The third instance is heralded by Śāriputra’s announcement that a sūtra is to be taught, yet what happens turns out to be a short and somewhat cryptic dialog equating explanation with emptiness, and demonstrating how neither can be taught. Only the fourth instance, the mantra, can be reasonably clearly placed in the category of dhāraṇīs that are encoding formulae, and the meaning that the mantra can be assumed to express is linked to the first and third instances in the teaching by Samantabhadra that follows it, on how the dhāraṇī should be “retained” and cultivated as a teaching on thatness, the ultimate (Skt. *tathatā*, Tib. *de bzhin nyid*).

**i.20** [ec0007ec-4dec-4ffe-b18b-23108d09b1f1] Most of the subsequent mentions of the dhāraṇī as such, in what remains of the first chapter and at the beginning of the second (it is not mentioned at all in the long verse section), are made in the context of its future holders and of its past history, intermingled with descriptions of it as a Dharma discourse. In other words, as a teaching—but also, in the kind of internal self-reference that is a common feature of many Mahāyāna sūtras, designating this very text itself.

**i.21** [c94577c3-ecf2-4336-9d97-bb0f23dec7e2] The frequent mentions in this text of the “dhāraṇī of the jewel torch” are therefore quite varied in terms of the sense in which the term is being used. We have made no attempt to use capitalization or punctuation to distinguish those that may refer to the text itself, to a teaching, to the mantra, or to a realization.

**i.22** [69649691-e483-48ca-a9cd-39bc052c3286] Neither of the two long sections that appear as chapters in the *Avataṃsakasūtra* make any mention of a dhāraṇī. None of the excerpts in Sanskrit quoted by Śāntideva (see below) include passages where the dhāraṇī is mentioned in the Tibetan text, but the title Śāntideva uses to introduce his citations does include the designation *dhāraṇī*.

### The Title and Its Variants

**i.23** [f6907ea2-e768-4c2a-8d05-e33af032632c] The Sanskrit title transliterated in the Tibetan text, *Ratnolkādhāraṇī* in its short form, is the same as the title that appears in the Sanskrit manuscripts of the *Śikṣāsamuccaya* (see below). The Sanskrit *ulkā* can mean a fiery phenomena in the sky, i.e., a meteor, and also a firebrand or torch.

**i.24** [fc8bb95d-3fa1-4036-8520-4291d4ce6cdd] Of the title in Tibetan, however, there are several different renderings. In all Kangyurs, the title is *dkon mchog ta la la’i gzungs*, incorporating the unusual, archaic word *ta la la*, meaning “lamp” or “torch.” In some of the twenty or so Tengyur treatises that quote the text (including the Tibetan translation of the *Śikṣāsamuccaya*), the *ta la la* title is used, even if in some cases the word *gzungs* (dhāraṇī) is dropped or replaced by the word *mdo* (sūtra). In others, however, the title is rendered in various forms that use, instead of *ta la la*, the more usual Tibetan term for “lamp” or “torch,” *sgron ma* or *sgron me*.[n.13] Probably as a consequence, later Tibetan authors of indigenous works (see below) use sometimes one version of the title, sometimes the other, and only some authors who use the *sgron ma* variants seem to be aware that the canonical work they are quoting is in the Kangyur under a different title.

### The Sūtra in Śāntideva’s *Śikṣāsamuccaya* and Other Treatises

**i.25** [f46c1f7d-fd1a-47ff-aa02-7353a0a128d0] The sūtra is quoted a little over twenty times in treatises in the Tengyur, notably by Atiśa, Vimalamitra, and Śāntideva, but also by lesser known authors. As noted above, both the *dkon mchog ta la la* and *dkon mchog sgron ma* forms of the title can be found, and there are considerable minor variations. Most, but not all, of the quotations are from the long verse section of the second chapter.

**i.26** [3ac5a116-9859-4e1f-8c97-cd36281c1af2] The most extensive extracts appear in Śāntideva’s *Śikṣāsamuccaya* (*Training Anthology*), and indeed the sūtra appears to have been among Śāntideva’s favorite texts, as he quotes from it more than from any other work. His text contains two short extracts, one longer passage, and one very extensive section of the verses from the second chapter that makes up more than half of one of his chapters.[n.14] The *Śikṣāsamuccaya* has survived in Sanskrit, as well as in its Tibetan translation in the Tengyur, and its Sanskrit text thus contains the only known remnants of the sūtra in Sanskrit.

### The Sūtra’s Impact on Tibetan Works

**i.27** [6433d690-fab2-4238-b040-4ef356e95c9d] The sūtra is listed in the *Mahāvyutpatti* as one of the hundred or so Dharma texts that were presumably best known at the time,[n.15] and is frequently quoted by Tibetan authors of all the main traditions. The passages on the importance of faith are the most commonly quoted, and for some authors it is the scriptural source for there being—variously—three, four, or six kinds of faith.[n.16] Other parts of both chapters are also cited.

**i.28** [970a193a-6162-4ab7-8ef8-469375bd5b8f] Identifying quotes from the sūtra is made more difficult by the variety of titles used.[n.17] In the case of several authors, including Chomden Rikpa Raltri (*bcom ldan rig pa ral dri*, thirteenth century), Longchen Rabjampa (*klong chen rab ’byams pa*, fourteenth century), and many of the early Sakya scholars, quotes using both the *dkon mchog sgron ma* and the *dkon mchog ta la la* forms of the title can be found in the same work, suggesting that in some cases they may have been consulting treatises or other sources that used these different titles as well as the canonical text itself without always recognizing that both titles designate the same sūtra. Shākya Chokden (*shA kya mchog ldan*, fifteenth century) specifically mentions the identity of both titles.

### The Translation

**i.29** [8e08906a-379c-4269-98e7-46a5e0256c90] This translation is based principally on the Degé block print and the Comparative Edition (*dpe bsdur ma*) of the Kangyur. Yeshé Dé’s early-ninth-century translation contains a few archaic words that have survived subsequent editing, including the *ta la la* in the title, mentioned above. A few other noteworthy archaic spellings, recorded in the notes, are *byin* as a verb of the Buddha’s speech (see 1.31); *dbung*, “center” (see 1.84);[n.18] and the spelling *nod pa* for *mnod pa* (*prahaṇam*, “to receive”).[n.19] In a few passages we have suggested a change in the text reading in an endnote, often in consultation with the Stok Palace version.

## The Translation

**The Noble Mahāyāna Sūtra** **The Dhāraṇī of the Jewel Torch**

## Chapter 1

**1.1** [0dfac739-0461-407f-83c4-c5c1a4a34de2] Homage to all buddhas and bodhisattvas!

**1.2** [df68f324-7280-483a-a47c-81a59b233033] Thus did I hear at one time. The Blessed One was dwelling on the Vulture Peak of Rājagṛha, seated together with a great gathering of fully ordained monks, all of whom had perfected virtuous qualities, roared mighty lion’s roars as great teachers, and were expert in seeking an immeasurable accumulation of gnosis, in all more than a thousand fully ordained monks.

**1.3** [eafd3644-7414-40d9-a1fc-f8786f86bafc] A great gathering of bodhisattvas was also assembled there, including the bodhisattva great being Samantabhadra, the bodhisattva great being Ratnamudrāhasta, the bodhisattva great being Nityodyukta, the bodhisattva great being Ornamented by Good Qualities, the bodhisattva great being Announcing Merits, the bodhisattva great being Mahāmati, the bodhisattva great being Array of Good Qualities, the bodhisattva great being Vajra Intelligence, the bodhisattva great being Vajragarbha, the bodhisattva great being Light of a Vajra, the bodhisattva great being Weapon of a Vajra, the bodhisattva great being Adamantine Vajra, the bodhisattva great being Dhāraṇīdhara, the bodhisattva great being Dhāraṇīmati, the bodhisattva great being Seeing All Purposes, the bodhisattva great being Avalokiteśvara, the bodhisattva great being Mahāsthāmaprāpta, the bodhisattva great being Dṛḍhamati, the bodhisattva great being Vajrapāṇi, the bodhisattva great being Mañjuśrī Kumārabhūta, the bodhisattva great being Avoiding Evil Destinies, the bodhisattva great being Overcoming All Sorrow and Darkness, the bodhisattva great being Suvikrāntavikrāmin, the bodhisattva great being Not Taking or Rejecting, the bodhisattva great being Essence of Sandalwood, the bodhisattva great being Sāgaramati, the bodhisattva great being Durabhisambhava, the bodhisattva great being Arising Joy, the bodhisattva great being Intelligence of Conduct, the bodhisattva great being Pratibhākūṭa, the bodhisattva great being Essence of Speed, and the bodhisattva great being Maitreya.

**1.4** [81bba0aa-3b55-4d76-a193-ff35e3cf2e10] Those and other bodhisattva great beings all dwelled in inconceivable emancipation, had left everything behind[n.20] through the meditative absorption *heroic progress*, had unimpeded melodic voices, and were skilled in holding sway over limitless buddha realms. They all dwelled in fearlessness, were devoid of attachment and anger, possessed pleasant-sounding voices, were not attached to the three realms of existence, possessed undivided retinues of attendants, were arisen from omniscience, and possessed limitless meditative absorptions and meditative attainments. They all fulfilled every hope, experienced the perfection of discriminating wisdom, were inclined toward meaningful goals in their bodily, verbal, and mental deeds, were intent on omniscience, were blessed to have limitless[n.21] meditative absorptions and conduct, had attained fearlessness, had emptiness as their sphere of experience,[n.22] and dwelled in the absence of phenomenal marks.

**1.5** [87027f6f-5252-4deb-a462-b957fc4d4e53] The bodhisattva great being Samantabhadra, who was seated as part of that assembly, bowing with his head to the feet of the Blessed One, said, “Blessed One, how should we understand dharmadhātu?”

The Blessed One answered, “Son of a good family, dharmadhātu is to be understood as the absence of entities. Son of a good family, you should understand dharmadhātu as follows: as space-like, as without conceptual elaborations, as unelaborated, as without accepting, as without rejecting, as the absence of entities, and as foundationless.”
                                                                                                       
**1.6** [ce7363ed-1626-4eeb-9b3f-4e43bcbf79ca] The bodhisattva Samantabhadra asked, “Blessed One, does dharmadhātu arise?”

The Blessed One answered, “Son of a good family, dharmadhātu has no arising. Son of a good family, dharmadhātu is inconceivable. You should understand it as the absence of entities: entities are in no way expressible, nor can they be shown in any way.”

**1.7** [5628cc35-99a2-4c49-aed6-6c9dc69378ea] The bodhisattva Samantabhadra asked, “Blessed One, how many aspects does awakening have?”

The Blessed One answered, “Son of a good family, the aspects of awakening are measureless; they cannot be shown to have a fixed measure.”

**1.8** [07f5f937-9ce9-474b-bde9-99e5bc151ef4] The bodhisattva Samantabhadra asked, “Blessed One, can dharmadhātu be conceptualized?”

The Blessed One answered, “Son of a good family, dharmadhātu is nonconceptual.”

**1.9** [cfba52cb-b4fa-4d24-8a9a-eb45ba1b4cce] The bodhisattva Samantabhadra asked, “If dharmadhātu is nonconceptual, how could it be that spiritually immature ordinary people would think of it?”

The Blessed One answered, “All spiritually immature ordinary people have arisen from thinking, conceptualizing, and imagining.”

**1.10** [4bf9f837-9787-4a85-8920-c90649ca7ce9] The bodhisattva Samantabhadra said, “Blessed One, the awakening of the tathāgatas is profound.”

The Blessed One said, “So it is. As you say, son of a good family. Moreover, the fact that all phenomena are without conceptual elaborations is what is called *awakening*.”

**1.11** [8ecba4a6-3bdb-4437-82a1-516dd71f53e9] Then Mañjuśrī Kumārabhūta, who had already arrived at that assembly and was already seated, bowed his head to the Blessed One’s feet and addressed him with these words: “I request that the Blessed One explain the dhāraṇī of *the jewel torch*.”

The Blessed One answered, “Son of a good family, ask the bodhisattva Samantabhadra. He possesses eloquent confidence that is unhindered with respect to all dharmas.[n.23] He will teach it to you.”

**1.12** [7f5a7565-edd6-43e1-b4c3-42f6928df26e] Then Mañjuśrī seated himself directly facing the Blessed One with palms joined in supplication and said, “Why cannot the Blessed One himself, who is omniscient and all-seeing, explain it?”

The Blessed One said, “Son of a good family, where there is a bodhisattva who possesses such excellent qualities, there the tathāgatas remain in indifference.”

Mañjuśrī said, “Blessed One, tathāgatas do not remain in indifference.”

**1.13** [1be0c956-5290-4a57-aeb6-d19c4b9bf4fa] The Blessed One said, “Son of a good family, I am not abandoning the realm of sentient beings. Nevertheless, the teaching of the bodhisattvas is an immeasurable and inconceivable teaching.”

Then Mañjuśrī repeated, “I request the Blessed One to explain the dhāraṇī of *the jewel torch*.”

**1.14** [e10ec29a-7214-48b9-b47b-9dc4380edac0] The Blessed One answered, “Son of a good family, ask the bodhisattva Samantabhadra! He will teach it to you. Why? Because that sublime man remains in the accumulation of gnosis.”

Mañjuśrī said, “If it is the Tathāgata’s intention that I do so, I will request it from that sublime man.”

**1.15** [037c0f8e-08be-4761-9d26-e3f6c2b841ba] The Blessed One said, “Mañjuśrī, if you have attained as many meditative absorptions as there are atoms, what need is there for you to request it from the Tathāgata? Son of a good family, you possess fortunate endowments regarding all the qualities of a buddha.”

**1.16** [65ac8d9d-c4b3-41a6-9c96-5e6685137b3a] Mañjuśrī said, “Blessed One, all the qualities of a buddha that I have relied on, cultivated, and enhanced should be understood as the power of the person of the Tathāgata.”

**1.17** [a893d3e4-8c07-4098-b1c8-a4a3e38a6d59] The Blessed One said, “Son of a good family, excellent, excellent! You have spoken well. But I request you, Mañjuśrī, to ask the bodhisattva Samantabhadra to teach.”

**1.18** [403324c3-0054-41e7-92fd-abe78ba0fc8a] Then Mañjuśrī Kumārabhūta said to the Blessed One, “This bodhisattva Samantabhadra teaches the exceedingly profound. He has mastered the Mahāyāna.”

**1.19** [a6643b8b-cb03-40f5-bf7c-538498a27219] The Blessed One said, “Son of a good family, you, too, are a king whose might extends over all dharmas;[n.24] do not address me. You also possess the inconceivable meditative absorption of abiding in emptiness.”

**1.20** [4bc731b6-23c9-4e2d-9c4f-972235e30c6e] So Mañjuśrī Kumārabhūta respectfully paid homage to the bodhisattva Samantabhadra, pressing the ten fingers of his hands together and saying to him, “O son of the victors, if you grant me the occasion, I would like to ask you a few words.”

**1.21** [893c1fa7-b2b9-41c9-8843-8ce042ff5f8b] The bodhisattva Samantabhadra said, “Son of a good family, if you know the right time to have come, ask!”

**1.22** [50a6fb2d-ceed-4ffa-af27-a98bcb58b9e9] Then Mañjuśrī Kumārabhūta asked the bodhisattva great being Samantabhadra, “O son of the victors, what is the basic meaning behind calling the Buddha ‘Buddha’?”

**1.23** [4508991e-0325-440f-b192-e4310d3a5952] The bodhisattva Samantabhadra said, “O son of the victors, the basic meaning of *buddha* is groundlessness.[n.25] The basic meaning of *buddha* is the absence of entities. The basic meaning of *buddha* is inconceivability. The basic meaning of *buddha* is to be equal to the unequaled.[n.26] The basic meaning of *buddha* is the absence of conceptual elaborations. The basic meaning of *buddha* is unelaborated. The basic meaning of *buddha* is the absence of accepting. The basic meaning of *buddha* is the absence of rejecting. The basic meaning of *buddha* is space-like. The basic meaning of *buddha* is ineffability. Son of a good family, such is the nature of the qualities of a buddha.”

**1.24** [eb67e900-30ce-4f69-b78d-4b338bc4edf8] Mañjuśrī said, “O son of the victors, but if all phenomena are without conceptual elaborations, how can you teach ‘qualities of a buddha’?”[n.27]

The bodhisattva Samantabhadra said, “O son of the victors, such a ‘teaching’ is unteachable.”

**1.25** [0d8c955b-3543-4c49-bb79-34e3c2d3550b] Mañjuśrī said, “O son of the victors, if it is unteachable, what is taught?”

The bodhisattva Samantabhadra said, “Mañjuśrī, that which is the unteachable is taught through designation.”

**1.26** [95a045d4-7f56-43e0-aff1-1c62782f7a04] Mañjuśrī said, “O son of the victors, what does one designate through designation?”

The bodhisattva Samantabhadra said, “Mañjuśrī, through designation one designates neither entities nor the absence of entities.”

**1.27** [c6d29868-c8dd-4e51-9345-2238724dc9e2] Mañjuśrī said, “O son of the victors, if one does not designate entities through designation and does not designate the absence of entities either, then how could the Three Vehicles ever be taught?”

**1.28** [11f89ae2-0d96-4565-90db-ce369de2e8ac] The bodhisattva Samantabhadra said, “Mañjuśrī, do not be attached to the dharmadhātu, which is free of attachment! Why not? Mañjuśrī, it is because the Tathāgata taught that all phenomena are the absence of entities. Why are they the absence of entities? It is because the five aggregates are not apprehended.”[n.28]

**1.29** [c3550c9d-f389-42c0-b35b-817cc9597fe2] Mañjuśrī asked, “Is awakening something with conceptual elaborations? Or is it something that is without conceptual elaborations?”

**1.30** [9c46349f-62b0-4310-b305-dee984d2fd98] The bodhisattva Samantabhadra replied, “Son of a good family, awakening is neither something with conceptual elaborations, nor is it something that is without conceptual elaborations. Thus, awakening exists neither in terms of having elaborations nor as being devoid of elaborations; it is indivisible into two.”

**1.31** [0e0c413a-516d-4dfb-8e89-83a02a6250fe] Then the Blessed One said[n.29] to the bodhisattva great being Samantabhadra, “Son of a good family, this inconceivable teaching is excellent, excellent! Yet, through the teaching of this discourse, the world with its gods will become confused.”

**1.32** [16d59d85-1753-4825-92f9-2df8ff61242f] Mañjuśrī said, “Blessed One, to teach the Dharma in this way is not best suited to its being understood.”

The Blessed One replied, “Son of a good family, just as you say, it is not.”

**1.33** [182ab0a0-86b4-40fe-9fdf-6d440bdc8386] Then Mañjuśrī Kumārabhūta asked the Blessed One, “Blessed One, are all phenomena designated by this type of designation?”

The Blessed One said, “Son of a good family, just as you say, they are.”

**1.34** [9711104f-518d-4cba-85c6-0722067bb67d] Then the bodhisattva Samantabhadra said to the Blessed One, “This pure access to the Dharma[n.30] is difficult to appreciate!”

The Blessed One said, “Son of a good family, just as you say, it is.”

**1.35** [6960e74d-4d74-4d56-a100-8318969f213f] Then the bodhisattva Sāgaramati said to the Blessed One: “This pure access to the Dharma that was taught by the bodhisattva Samantabhadra was well expressed.”

The Blessed One said, “Son of a good family, just as you say, it was. Moreover, son of a good family, this is the natural result[n.31] of all phenomena. It is a great rain of the Dharma.”

**1.36** [7b9c83db-c5a4-4a42-bac1-9b6698ff64e9] Then a brahmin who was like a great śāla tree[n.32] and who dwelled in sameness said, “Blessed One, awakening is inconceivable sameness. No letters or words are perceived in it.”

**1.37** [156aaead-cedf-4d28-883f-da2a92ddfe39] The Blessed One said, “Son of a good family, it is so; in the dharmadhātu no words are perceived, nor are any sense objects perceived.”

**1.38** [5e7e69cd-b474-40ed-9921-dc7e14725966] Then Mañjuśrī Kumārabhūta said to the Blessed One, “Blessed One, what is the natural result of emptiness? What is its aspect? What is its sign? What is its phenomenal mark?”

**1.39** [611d083f-75a2-491d-890c-393ae2ae9198] The Blessed One said, “Mañjuśrī, emptiness is inexpressible and ineffable. That which partakes of its inexpressible nature is what is called *emptiness*. Emptiness is without letters, and thus it is called *emptiness*. Emptiness is ineffable, and hence it is called *emptiness*. Son of a good family, all phenomena are empty of their own essential nature.”

**1.40** [579d4d12-2477-4850-a5f9-567156afe683] Then the venerable Śāradvatīputra said to the Blessed One: “Blessed One, look at the magical displays of the bodhisattvas who dwell in the inconceivable reality.”

**1.41** [bf89fd21-17c8-472c-b37b-b1ba206ffe36] The Blessed One said: “Venerable Śāradvatīputra, the knowledge of a bodhisattva who has generated the thought of awakening for the first time is sublime, while the knowledge of an arhat is not like that. Why not? It is because the arhat remains far removed from the qualities of a buddha, while the bodhisattva will become a blessed buddha.”

**1.42** [9c26e678-ceee-425a-b851-f1eb2bc8d4d0] The bodhisattva great being Sarvadharmeśvara then said to the Blessed One, “Blessed One, according to my understanding of the sense of what the Blessed One has taught, the śrāvaka has simply not obtained the qualities of a śrāvaka.”

**1.43** [c2f4798c-cf42-43d7-a13d-44d6d14b6d2a] The Blessed One said, “Son of a good family, it is not that the śrāvaka has not obtained the qualities of a śrāvaka, but rather, how could śrāvakas answer questions together with bodhisattvas or have the power and potency to bring about a transformation of their conduct?”

**1.44** [6d273a04-bff5-4e54-a4c3-a98537c744ff] Then Mañjuśrī Kumārabhūta said to the Blessed One, “Blessed One, if the Tathāgata taught that this Śāradvatīputra was foremost among disciples possessing discriminating wisdom, what did that teaching reveal?”

The Blessed One said, “Mañjuśrī, what I taught was without teaching.”

**1.45** [f11d3d6f-0eb0-4503-9ff1-9543f8ebc64b] Then Mañjuśrī Kumārabhūta said to the elder Śāradvatīputra, “Elder, did you obtain the qualities of a śrāvaka?”

He answered, “No, I did not.”

**1.46** [4ab08f64-1ea8-413a-9f2c-eadf2fe20a5f] Mañjuśrī said, “In that case, are you an ordinary person?”

“No.”

**1.47** [037cd767-4cbc-46f3-af54-0c003fd60735] “So, are you a trainee?”

“No.”

**1.48** [ee0e0ea6-4b60-48bb-9385-4ab90d11efb0] “Are you foremost among those who possess discriminating wisdom?”

“No.”

**1.49** [03e98a8f-85c6-4aaf-a20e-232a1cba5b40] Mañjuśrī said, “Honorable Śāradvatīputra, if you are neither an ordinary person nor a trainee, nor foremost among those possessing discriminating wisdom, that can only mean you are someone who adheres to a heretical view.”[n.33]

**1.50** [b8a5f248-ebf2-4507-9fb4-129ce56259fa] Śāradvatīputra said, “Son of a good family, I am not going to debate with you, a sublime person whose profound depth is as unfathomable as the ocean.”

Mañjuśrī said, “Honorable Śāradvatīputra, do not say that! You are the most prominent of the older generation.”

**1.51** [f2d9434a-2ad9-4991-bb3d-9e70fc235531] The elder said, “The fact of my age will not itself achieve anything, nor will it lead to realization. To make it better understood, son of a good family, I will give you an analogy. Consider how with a small diamond even a great boulder may be destroyed. Likewise, the discriminating wisdom that you have in a single pore of your body is more than a sentient being like myself has in all the particles of my body put together. Son of a good family, to make it understood, I will use another analogy for you. It is like, for instance, how a powerful man can, with just a small iron hook, tame a huge frightful elephant. Son of good family, likewise, you possess power. I am weak. How can I debate with a great elephant like this?”

**1.52** [625659a4-45c1-49e5-a3e0-3344e36efc3f] Then the elder Śāradvatīputra said to the Blessed One, “Blessed One, it is like this: if a blind man cannot follow after someone or see a city, how would he manage to go from house to house? That would be impossible. Similarly, I see myself as blind in the presence of great elephants like these. The qualities of a buddha are that vast. I am not a suitable vessel for the qualities of a buddha. Now there is nothing for me to do.”

**1.53** [17d5d85e-2f72-4b0a-995d-ea10fe395ffa] The Blessed One said, “Śāradvatīputra, do not talk like that! Consider, for example, that however many sentient beings may be touched by light from a tathāgata, all will obtain the qualities of a buddha. Likewise, Śāradvatīputra, you will be a recipient of limitless and inconceivable meditative absorptions.”

**1.54** [b74e0d90-f71d-4783-8d3c-a19d8aee28e9] When the Blessed One explained this Dharma discourse, ninety-two thousand among the gods and humans gained a clear understanding of the Dharma.

**1.55** [bc87a230-b3c0-4215-a020-14472904f4aa] It was at this point[n.34] that the bodhisattva Dharmamati entered the bodhisattva’s meditative absorption called *the infinite application of the jewel torch*.[n.35] No sooner had the bodhisattva Dharmamati entered that meditative absorption than, from the world systems in each of the ten directions that exceed in number the atoms of ten thousand buddhafields, blessed buddhas numbering as many as the atoms of ten thousand buddhafields showed their faces. Those blessed buddhas all had but one and the very same name: Vajra Quintessence.

**1.56** [50d21010-772f-4253-93bc-b6b916f7d932] As though they were in just one place despite issuing from the ten directions, those blessed buddhas said to him, “Dharmamati, that you have entered the bodhisattva’s meditative absorption of the infinite application in this way is excellent, excellent! Son of a good family, it is like this. Through the previous aspirations and previous blessings of this blessed tathāgata Vairocana himself, and reinforced by your own roots of virtue, all we buddhas from the ten directions, numbering as many as the atoms of ten thousand buddhafields and each one with the same name, bless you, so that you may teach all Dharma teachings, purify the gnosis of buddhahood, increase the gnosis of buddhahood, enter into the dharmadhātu, liberate the realms of sentient beings, enter and penetrate unbound gnosis, engage with gnosis, speak all languages, enter into omniscient gnosis, become unobstructed with respect to all phenomena, and engage in teaching the Dharma through knowing all three times. Through the strength and blessing of the Buddha, expound the Dharma with inspired speech, beginning with the ten categories of the bodhisattva!”[n.36]

**1.57** [e8ed0f76-144d-4a97-a50c-388e61474b26] Then those blessed buddhas caused that blessed bodhisattva Dharmamati to attain the light of unimpeded gnosis, with a very nature that was free of obstruction, free of interruption, and not forgetful; a gnosis free from differentiation, with a very nature that was morally blameless, inviolable, dauntless, inalienable; and excellent speech. Why so? Because he had thus obtained the very nature of that absorption.

**1.58** [0a22991f-f798-4c4f-8d16-c4f3639f08e8] Then those blessed buddhas extended their right hands and touched[n.37] the head of the bodhisattva Dharmamati. As soon as those blessed buddhas had touched the bodhisattva Dharmamati, he rose from that absorption and said to the bodhisattvas, “O sons of the victors, this family of bodhisattvas is as follows: it is vast owing to the boundlessness of the dharmadhātu and of the element of space. O sons of the victors, the bodhisattva great beings were born into the family of past blessed buddhas, future blessed buddhas, and present blessed buddhas.”

**1.59** [e47f5466-c60f-4f13-86fb-42bc5ad0a35e] Then those bodhisattvas said to the bodhisattva Dharmamati, “O son of the victors, who are those bodhisattva great beings who were born into the family of the past, future, and present blessed buddhas? Tell me what thought they came from. O son[n.38] of the victors, explain what those ten categories of bodhisattvas are!”

**1.60** [3f577ee5-a990-4de2-8755-1fc191d8fc1e] The bodhisattva Dharmamati said to those bodhisattvas, “O sons of the victors, ten categories of bodhisattvas were taught, are taught, and will be taught by buddhas of the past, present, and future. What are those ten? They are: (1) bodhisattvas who have generated the initial thought of awakening, (2) beginners, (3) those who engage in yogic practice, (4) those who have taken rebirth, (5) those who have perfected application, (6) those who have perfected intention, (7) those who are irreversible, (8) those who are still youths,[n.39] (9) those who are regents, and (10) those who have been consecrated. O sons of the victors, those ten categories of bodhisattvas were taught, are taught, and will be taught by buddhas of the past, present, and future.

**1.61** [128e8aa7-2987-48a8-8b0d-a33c05d628a1] (1) “O sons of the victors, what is the category of bodhisattvas who have generated the initial thought of awakening? O sons of the victors, these bodhisattvas who have generated the initial thought of awakening will, as soon as they see the blessed buddhas, see an excellent or beautiful form with a completely excellent and brilliant complexion,[n.40] miracles of magical displays, miracles of mind reading,[n.41] or miracles of insightful admonition,[n.42] or see suffering sentient beings, or hear the praises of the Tathāgata, such that they will long for all-knowing gnosis and from the very beginning generate the intention to attain the highest insuperable awakening. And as soon as that very first intention to attain awakening is generated, those beings will have taken up ten things that are difficult to approach. What are those ten? They are: (1) the knowledge of what is possible and impossible,[n.43] (2) the knowledge of deeds[n.44] that occur in the past, present, and future and qualities that were obtained, (3) the knowledge of everywhere that paths lead, (4) the knowledge of the numerous and varied constituents of beings, (5) the knowledge of numerous spiritual inclinations and liberations, (6) the knowledge of the superior and inferior faculties, (7) the knowledge of the meditative concentrations, emancipations, absorptions, and meditative attainments in their defiled and purified forms and their arising,[n.45] (8) the knowledge that remembers previous lives, (9) the knowledge of the divine eye, and (10) the knowledge of the exhaustion of defilements. Thus, they will have taken up those ten things that are difficult to approach. O sons of the victors, such is the category of bodhisattvas who have generated the initial thought of awakening.

**1.62** [bc4cd0c6-0086-4dca-8114-0962355915f9] “O sons of the victors, these bodhisattva great beings who have generated the initial thought of awakening should worship the Buddha and apply the requisites for a bodhisattva’s happiness. Concerning that, they should provide explanations on becoming the lord of the world, acting sublimely, not being outshone, meeting with an immeasurable number of buddhas, engaging in yogic practice in the absorption of *complete pacification*, turning back the wheel of saṃsāra, setting in motion the wheel of the holy Dharma, and protecting suffering sentient beings. Why so? It is because upon generating the thought of awakening, they apply themselves for the most part to all the qualities of a buddha, and those subjects of learning acquired previously are mastered with their own application and without recourse to dependence on others. O sons of the victors, such is the category of bodhisattvas who have generated the initial thought of awakening.

**1.63** [9093a958-6b44-4379-bf92-da47871dc843] (2) “O sons of the victors, what is the category of beginner bodhisattvas? O sons of the victors, these beginner bodhisattvas have from the start generated ten aspects of mind. What are the ten aspects? They are: (1) a mind that brings benefit, (2) a mind that brings happiness, (3) a mind of kindness, (4) a mind that is flexible, (5) a mind that feels sadness, (6) a mind that intends to help, (7) a mind that aims at protecting everyone, (8) a mind of equality, (9) a mind of becoming a teacher, (10) and a mind of becoming a great teacher. They have generated these ten aspects of mind. O sons of the victors, such are beginner bodhisattvas.[n.46]

**1.64** [de70caa9-d779-4fe2-9345-69a9b7222e0e] “O sons of the victors, such beginner bodhisattvas should apply themselves to receiving instructions on scriptures and recitation. After becoming learned, they should devote themselves to retiring into solitude. Having retired into solitude, they should devote themselves to pleasing their spiritual teachers. Having pleased their teachers, they should devote themselves to delighting in following their instructions. Having followed their instructions with delight, they should devote themselves to awareness of temporality.[n.47] Having become aware of temporality, they should devote themselves to fearlessness. Having become fearless, they should devote themselves to knowing the meaning. Having become knowledgeable in the meaning, they should devote themselves to following the Dharma. Having become a follower of Dharma, they should apply themselves to the nature of non-confusion.[n.48] Having become free of confusion, they should apply themselves to formulating the Dharma. Why so? Because upon first generating the thought of awakening, for the most part they apply themselves with diligence to all the teachings of the Buddha, and those subjects of learning acquired previously are mastered with their own application and without recourse to dependence on others. O sons of the victors, such is the category of beginner bodhisattvas.

**1.65** [afd4f465-497b-4bb4-a3f6-ca1ee85e0a23] (3) “O sons of the victors, what is the category of bodhisattvas who engage in yogic practice? O sons of the victors, concerning this,[n.49] bodhisattvas who engage in yogic practice will understand entities by means of ten aspects of apprehending. What are those ten? They are: (1) understanding all phenomena to be impermanent, (2) understanding all phenomena to be suffering, (3) to be without a self, (4) to be empty, (5) to be immovable, (6) to be without increase, (7) to be without any situation, (8) to be nonconceptual, (9) to be effortless, and (10) not to be produced. These bodhisattvas should understand those ten aspects, but since they are followers of the Dharma, they practice neither application nor non-application. O sons of the victors, such are bodhisattvas who engage in yogic practice.

**1.66** [7234ab5f-cb4c-431c-838e-9ea70c19de0d] “O sons of the victors, bodhisattvas who engage in yogic practice should apply themselves to investigating the constitution[n.50] of sentient beings. They should apply themselves to investigating the dharmadhātu. They should apply themselves to investigating the world realm. They should apply themselves to investigating the element of earth. They should apply themselves to investigating the elements of water, fire, air, and space, and the form and formless realms.[n.51] Why is that? It is because for the most part they have direct insight that operates regarding all phenomena, and those subjects of learning acquired previously are mastered with their own application and without recourse to dependence on others. O sons of the victors, such is the category of bodhisattvas who engage in yogic practice.

**1.67** [95cf531a-f149-4740-af46-3f3b3581fc28] (4) “O sons of the victors, what is the category of bodhisattvas who have taken rebirth? O sons of the victors, bodhisattvas who have taken rebirth are born as exalted in sacred scripture[n.52] thanks to ten purifiers. What are those ten? They are: (1) Not turning back from ultimate reality, (2) accomplishing what will become the highest undivided faith in the Buddha, (3) contemplating the Dharma, (4) investigating sentient beings, (5) investigating the pure lands, (6) investigating the world, (7) investigating deeds, (8) investigating karmic consequences, (9) investigating saṃsāra, and (10) investigating nirvāṇa. Bodhisattvas will take rebirth as exalted in sacred scripture thanks to those ten purifiers. O sons of the victors, such is the category of bodhisattvas who have taken rebirth.

**1.68** [854a315a-2dec-45ef-a235-ae5fde80330e] “O sons of the victors, these bodhisattvas who have taken rebirth should apply themselves to investigating the sameness of the dharmas of all past buddhas, apply themselves to investigating the sameness of the dharmas of all future buddhas, and apply themselves to investigating the sameness of the dharmas of all present buddhas. They should apply themselves to investigating the sameness of the dharmas of all buddhas.

**1.69** [f2026200-f7c5-435c-8951-857eb88db839] “They should apply themselves to the investigation that correctly establishes the dharmas of past buddhas, apply themselves to the investigation that correctly establishes the dharmas of future buddhas, and apply themselves to the investigation that correctly establishes the dharmas of present buddhas. They should apply themselves to the investigation that correctly establishes the dharmas of all buddhas.

**1.70** [c4f880d6-d8bf-448c-b81d-aca112eb7a0c] “They should apply themselves to investigating the sameness of the perfection of the qualities of past buddhas,[n.53] apply themselves to investigating the sameness of the perfection of the qualities of future buddhas, and apply themselves to investigating the sameness of the perfection of the dharmas of present buddhas. They should apply themselves to investigating the sameness of the perfection of the dharmas of all buddhas.

**1.71** [ed6b1756-67d7-4681-9219-c3f6b9511a4d] “Why is that? It is because for the most part they understand the sameness of the three times, and those subjects of learning acquired previously are mastered with their own application and without recourse to dependence on others. O sons of the victors, such is the category of bodhisattvas who have taken rebirth.

**1.72** [347457d7-c8d2-46ca-81d3-2fa598099284] (5) “O sons of the victors, what is the category of bodhisattvas who have perfected application? O sons of the victors, these bodhisattvas who have perfected application will perform whatever virtuous deeds they may undertake (1) for the sake of protecting all sentient beings, (2) with the desire to benefit all sentient beings, (3) with the resolve to make all sentient beings happy, (4) with kindness toward all sentient beings, (5) in order to liberate all sentient beings, (6) in order that all sentient beings avoid harm, (7) in order to guide all sentient beings, (8) in order that all sentient beings have faith, (9) in order to train all sentient beings, and (10) in order to cause all sentient beings to enter perfect nirvāṇa. O sons of the victors, such are bodhisattvas who have perfected application.

**1.73** [77f13182-ce6e-4c8f-8b53-6d912033b033] “O sons of the victors, to those bodhisattvas who have perfected application ten topics ought to be expounded. What are they? They are (1) that sentient beings are boundless, (2) that sentient beings are inestimable, (3) that sentient beings are innumerable, (4) that sentient beings are inconceivable, (5) that sentient beings are incomparable, (6) that sentient beings are immeasurable, (7) that sentient beings are empty, (8) that sentient beings are immovable, (9) that sentient beings are nonexistent, and (10) that sentient beings have no intrinsic nature. Why is that? It is because for the most part they settle their minds in non-attachment, and those subjects of learning acquired previously are mastered with their own application and without recourse to dependence on others. O sons of the victors, such is the category of bodhisattvas who have perfected application.

**1.74** [944e1b2a-c371-4f07-89b7-3a028d09f568] (6) “O sons of the victors, what is the category of bodhisattvas who have perfected intention? O sons of the victors, these bodhisattvas who have perfected intention, if they learn ten factors, will be decisively intent on the qualities of a Buddha. What are those ten? They are: (1) their resolve will be set on the qualities of a buddha regardless of whether someone teaches in praise of or not in praise of a buddha, (2) their resolve will be set on the qualities of a buddha regardless of whether someone teaches in praise of or not in praise of the Dharma, (3) their resolve will be set on the qualities of a buddha regardless of whether someone teaches in praise of or not in praise of bodhisattvas, (4) their resolve will be set on the qualities of a buddha regardless of whether someone teaches in praise of or not in praise of the conduct of bodhisattvas, (5) their resolve will be set on the qualities of a buddha regardless of whether someone teaches that the realm of sentient beings is small or vast in scope, (6) their resolve will be set on the qualities of a buddha regardless of whether someone teaches that the realm of sentient beings is defiled or not, (7) their resolve will be set on the qualities of a buddha regardless of whether someone teaches that the realm of sentient beings is easy or difficult to train, (8) their resolve will be set on the qualities of a buddha regardless of whether someone teaches that the dharmadhātu is small or vast in scope, (9) their resolve will be set on the qualities of a buddha regardless of whether someone teaches that the world realms perish or do not perish, and (10) their resolve will be set on the qualities of a buddha regardless of whether someone teaches that the dharmadhātu exists or does not exist. O sons of the victors, such are bodhisattvas who have perfected intention.

**1.75** [17f94112-585f-4241-90e4-df0bf56fcc8f] “O sons of the victors, bodhisattvas who have perfected intention will be taught ten things that conform with phenomena. What are those ten? They should be taught that all phenomena: (1) are the very absence of phenomenal marks, (2) are without defining marks, (3) are not entities, (4) are nonexistent, (5) are deceptive, (6) are disengaged, (7) are essenceless, (8) are like illusions, (9) are like dreams, and (10) are without conceptual thought. Why is that? It is because since they are thus inalienable they possess for the most part the quality of increasing their excellent intention, and those subjects of learning acquired previously are mastered with their own application and without recourse to dependence on others. O sons of the victors, such is the category of bodhisattvas who have perfected intention.

**1.76** [6370927e-9ff1-4ead-9014-f47d061e9010] (7) “O sons of the victors, what is the category of bodhisattvas who are irreversible? O sons of the victors, bodhisattvas who are irreversible will not turn back from their progress toward the qualities of a buddha if they learn ten objectives. What are those ten? They are: (1) to progress irreversibly toward qualities of a buddha whether one hears that a buddha exists or does not exist, (2) to progress irreversibly whether one hears that the Dharma exists or does not exist, (3) to progress irreversibly whether one hears that bodhisattvas exist or do not exist, (4) to progress irreversibly whether one hears that the conduct of bodhisattvas exists or does not exist, (5) to progress irreversibly whether one hears that in bodhisattva conduct a bodhisattva leaves everything behind or does not leave everything behind, (6) to progress irreversibly whether one hears that the tathāgatas have passed away or have not passed away, (7) to progress irreversibly whether one hears that the tathāgatas have come into the world or not, (8) to progress irreversibly whether one hears that the tathāgatas have presently appeared or not, (9) to progress irreversibly whether one hears that the gnosis of the Buddha is exhausted or is not exhausted, and (10) to progress irreversibly whether one hears that the three times have the same defining mark or that they have dissimilar defining marks. O sons of the victors, such are bodhisattvas who are irreversible.

**1.77** [9cd4e76e-1c0d-423e-91f7-47f4f3918642] “O sons of the victors, to those bodhisattvas who are irreversible, ten continuities of phenomena should be explained. What are those ten? They are: (1) explaining all phenomena as the same and different in nature, (2) as multiple and single in nature, (3) as meanings attributed to words, (4) as words attributed to meanings, (5) as the absence of entities attributed through entities, (6) as entities attributed through the absence of entities, (7) as the absence of phenomenal marks attributed through phenomenal marks, (8) as phenomenal marks attributed through the absence of phenomenal marks, (9) as the absence of defining marks attributed through defining marks, and (10) as defining marks attributed through the absence of defining marks. Why is that? It is because they have, for the most part, left everything behind as do those who have brought their expertise in all phenomena to fruition, and those subjects of learning acquired previously are mastered with their own application and without recourse to dependence on others. O sons of the victors, such is the category of bodhisattvas who are irreversible.

**1.78** [0ff113c0-8309-45d0-8230-872a7737b74e] (8) “O sons of the victors, what is the category of bodhisattvas who are still youths? O sons of the victors, bodhisattvas who are still youths possess ten understandings of the Dharma. What are those ten? They are: (1) knowing bodily deeds together with their karmic results, (2) knowing verbal deeds together with their karmic results, (3) knowing mental deeds together with their karmic results, (4) knowing how to obtain a new birth merely by generating the thought of doing so, (5) knowing the thoughts of other sentient beings and people and understanding their inclinations, (6) knowing the different realms of sentient beings, (7) knowing the different desire realms, (8) knowing the different form realms, (9) knowing the different formless realms, and (10) swiftly gaining clairvoyance for the sake of beings present in different time periods. O sons of the victors, such is the category of bodhisattvas who are still youths.

**1.79** [07d0b65b-221b-4836-8f32-7910f5c3a13f] “O sons of the victors, to bodhisattvas who are still youths should be taught ten ways of perfecting the Dharma. What are those ten? They are being correctly shown how to (1) comprehend buddhafields, (2) shake buddhafields, (3) bless buddhafields, (4) investigate buddhafields, (5) journey to buddhafields, (6) journey to countless world realms, (7) ask countless questions, (8) fully achieve a mental body, (9) have measureless translations of words and languages, and (10) accomplish countless buddhafields by generating the thought of doing so. Why is that? It is because for the most part they apply themselves to expertise in perfecting things, and those subjects of learning acquired previously are mastered with their own application and without recourse to dependence on others. O sons of the victors, such is the category of bodhisattvas who are still youths.

**1.80** [df96075f-f71f-48b5-b7ca-709affde354b] (9) “O sons of the victors, what is the category of bodhisattvas who are regents? O sons of the victors, bodhisattvas who are regents are expert in ten factors to be understood. What are those ten? They are: (1) expertise in understanding the births of sentient beings, (2) expertise in understanding the flux of the defilements, (3) expertise in understanding the connections of latent tendencies, (4) expertise in understanding the engagement in the object domains, (5) expertise in understanding ultimate reality, (6) expertise in understanding experiences, (7) expertise in understanding the sphere of the world, (8) expertise in understanding the past and the future, (9) expertise in understanding the present, and (10) expertise in understanding the investigation of the relative truth.[n.54] O sons of the victors, such are bodhisattvas who are regents.

**1.81** [5d88bd8c-e3d6-4c75-9b92-ac808edcdb4a] “O sons of the victors, to these bodhisattvas who are regents should be taught ten things. What are those ten? They consist in being correctly taught: (1) the expertise concerning the royal palace,[n.55] (2) the modes of conduct in the royal palace, (3) the entering of the royal palace, (4) the investigation of the royal palace, (5) the consecration as a Dharma king, (6) the blessings as a Dharma king, (7) the punishment of the opponents of a Dharma king, (8) the abode of a Dharma king, (9) and the orders of a Dharma king.[n.56] Why is that? It is because for the most part their minds engage in realization without obscurations regarding all phenomena, and those subjects of learning acquired previously are mastered with their own application and without recourse to dependence on others. O sons of the victors, such is the category of bodhisattvas who are regents.

**1.82** [3cb55aed-20a0-41d7-aa49-bcac99527d4d] (10) “O sons of the victors, what is the category of bodhisattvas who have received consecration? O sons of the victors, bodhisattvas who have received consecration possess ten realizations of knowledge. What are those ten? They consist in: (1) many ways of making innumerable spheres of the world shake, (2) many ways of blessing innumerable spheres of the world, (3) many ways of passing beyond innumerable spheres of the world with a single thought, (4) many ways of purifying innumerable spheres of the world, (5) many ways of making innumerable sentient beings known with a single thought, (6) many ways of viewing innumerable spheres of the world, (7) expertise in investigating the mental activity of innumerable sentient beings with a single thought, (8) expertise in making understood the faculties of innumerable sentient beings with a single thought, (9) expertise in disciplining innumerable sentient beings, and (10) expertise in introducing innumerable sentient beings to the mind of omniscience.

**1.83** [92816a1e-fa69-4dd6-901a-80f774314b6d] “O sons of the victors, bodhisattvas on the level of regent and below cannot know the bodily deeds of bodhisattvas who have received consecration. Nor can they understand their verbal deeds, mental deeds, magical power, or magical vision. Neither do they know how to see what is in past times, nor can they know their karmic conditioning. They do not know how they see with the mind, nor can they know their objects of mind or the sphere of their experience of gnosis. O sons of the victors, such are bodhisattvas who have received consecration.

**1.84** [eaf0fa8a-9ac1-4d7b-9cfe-5e5dd8faeff1] “O sons of the victors, to bodhisattvas who have received consecration will be taught ten things by the blessed buddhas. What are these ten? They are: (1) knowing the three times, (2) knowing the Buddhadharma, (3) knowing that the dharmadhātu is indivisible, (4) knowing that the dharmadhātu is without limit and without center,[n.57] (5) knowing how to suffuse all the spheres of the world, (6) knowing how to illuminate all the spheres of the world, (7) knowing how to bless all the spheres of the world, (8) thorough knowledge of all sentient beings, (9) clairvoyant knowledge of all phenomena, and (10) the infinite gnosis of the Buddha. Why is that? Because for the most part they apply their minds to knowing everything. O sons of the victors, such is the category of bodhisattvas who have received consecration.”

**1.85** [09269ec5-b737-42a1-afe8-09fd735432d4] Immediately after the bodhisattva Dharmamati explained the ten bodhisattva categories of bodhisattva great beings through the power of the Buddha,world realms numbering as many as the atoms in ten thousand buddhafields shook in every direction. They shook strongly and shook violently. They quaked, quaked strongly, and quaked violently. They trembled, trembled strongly, and trembled violently. They were disturbed, strongly disturbed, and violently disturbed. They shuddered, shuddered strongly, and shuddered violently. And they were agitated, strongly agitated, and violently agitated.[n.58]

**1.86** [cdd6de29-5a84-4dab-a1e7-c4abf22273df] By the power of the Buddha and through the attainment of the ultimate nature, a shower of divine flowers poured down from the clouds. From the clouds, there also fell showers of divine incense, of divine fragrance, of divine incense powder, of divine flower garlands, of divine textiles, of divine jewels, of divine lotuses, of divine necklaces, and of divine ornaments. Divine cymbals sounded without being played, divine light shone forth, and divine cheers sounded forth.

**1.87** [3e667aa9-370e-47e9-a6c4-202699c4ad24] In this world with its four continents, and in all world realms, this Dharma teaching pervaded everywhere without omission or repetition, just as in the dwelling place of the king of gods on Mount Meru. And by these very words, this same meaning was taught. Through the power of the Buddha, as many bodhisattvas as there are atoms in ten thousand buddhafields arrived from beyond as many world realms as there are atoms in ten thousand buddhafields. Filling up space throughout the ten directions, they said, “O son of the victors, it is excellent, excellent that you are teaching the true nature of bodhisattvas. O son of the victors, we, too, are all named Dharmamati. We have come here from world realms called Dharmamegha, from the presence of tathāgatas who are all named Dharmamatibhadra. By the blessing-power of the Buddha, this Dharma instruction occurred for all of them; within an audience such as this, the same sense is being expressed by these very words, with nothing added or left out. O son of the victors, we have come under your power, and by the power of the Buddha we all came to this world sphere. And just as we came to this world sphere, so too as many bodhisattvas as there are atoms in ten thousand buddhafields went to the residences of the lords of gods at the peak of Mount Sumeru of all the four-continent worlds in every world sphere throughout the ten directions.”

**1.88** [38c320aa-abce-4560-8e66-54b4da32ad8f] Then, by the power of the Buddha, the bodhisattva Dharmamati looked in the ten directions and, after seeing the fully-equipped retinue and the dharmadhātu, spoke these verses:

**1.89** [ff2b8362-78eb-41c9-966e-597269f9524c] “Having seen the Buddha, who has a mind that is self-arisen and immaculate,
Who possesses beauty and power of body,
And who is ornamented by marks difficult to approach,[n.59]
They set their mind firmly on the goal of awakening.[n.60]

**1.90** [73d6437f-aac8-4845-8e1c-24b7c27dd323] “Having seen the Buddha’s matchless magical powers,
Excellent miracles of clairvoyant prophecy, and miracles of insightful instruction,
And having seen living beings of the world with their unbearable suffering,
They set their thought firmly on the goal of awakening.

**1.91** [ebdc2fa0-6db3-468a-a2be-2a266807d733] “Having heard about the qualities of Samantabhadra
And the source of all qualities, the tathāgata,
They set their thought firmly on the goal of awakening
That is unchanging like the sphere of space.

**1.92** [77f3c570-d154-4ff9-9711-a6832fac401f] “To gain understanding of the extent of all that is possible—
What is present, and other possibilities that may intrinsically exist—
And also of all else that is not,
They set their thought firmly on the goal of awakening.[n.61]

**1.93** [3a56a232-a638-4070-9e14-a30064f2086c] “Whatever virtuous and nonvirtuous deeds exist
In the three times—past, present, and future—
To gain understanding of their causes
They set their thought firmly on the goal of awakening.

**1.94** [b9816a29-2307-4387-8399-5a8fdd798e84] “The absorptions, concentrations, and the practice of the emancipations,
And similarly the meditative accomplishments, pure and ultimate—
In order to understand them provisionally
They set their thought firmly on the goal of awakening.

**1.95** [0c67062c-9557-4111-880e-2420367ea1a7] “In order to understand the progressive stages
Of mundane diligence, powers, and faculties
As they really are, each and every one of them,
They set their thought firmly on the goal of awakening.

**1.96** [17d7ba2d-1abf-48aa-8df7-7d63237ae5de] “In order to understand numerous treatises
According to the inclinations of the whole world
And out of the three distinct kinds of excellent intention,
They set their thought firmly on the goal of awakening.

**1.97** [6fb98e87-4dd2-4034-86ba-94b54515f531] “All the numerous constituents in all their varieties,
That exist here in the three worlds—
In order to understand the nature of those constituents
They set their thought firmly on the goal of awakening.

**1.98** [0d3c9c58-71c9-4439-8f54-c95127424856] “In this Dharma where there are ways that go everywhere,
In order to correctly understand the nature of those
Whom they will introduce to virtuous action and establish them there,
They set their thought firmly on the goal of awakening.

**1.99** [6f057c11-af9c-41c8-91d6-9fabac8a3e41] “ ‘How do all the realms arise?
And how do sentient beings arise from the earth?’—
In order to open wide the eye of nonattachment
They set their thought firmly on the goal of awakening.

**1.100** [120c851c-e5bc-4fdc-b748-09a0d56b96a3] “In order to understand what characteristics and types of sentient beings
Existed in the past, and also now in present times,
As well as the places of their previous lives,
They set their thought firmly on the goal of awakening.

**1.101** [4d6b0b63-2325-4499-b4a7-7b2965fc5124] “In order to understand the exhaustion
Of the fetters that there are in the world
Binding sentient beings to their migrations, the defilements,
They set their thought firmly on the goal of awakening.

**1.102** [5a3b37bc-999d-47cb-aa33-93e00ed2edce] “In order to understand the truth as expressed in symbols,
Including all the designated terms in use in the three worlds
And all the forms of mantra that are pathways of speech,
They set their thought firmly on the goal of awakening.

**1.103** [91f4393b-560d-4635-8a9c-6eea93f3c924] “All phenomena being inexpressible,
Their nature and essence never moving from the empty,
In order to understand the ultimate truth
They set their thought firmly on the goal of awakening.
                       
**1.104** [bab8b1ac-0882-4e47-ae7f-33386a4d8cd6] “In order to display the wonders of the Tathāgata,
Manifesting earthquakes in the worlds
And the violent churnings of oceans,
They set their thought firmly on the goal of awakening.

**1.105** [0d514242-8a39-49bd-8334-87af267cb18c] “In order to understand as one light
The light rays that spread out in the ten directions
From the tip of every light ray,
They set their thought firmly on the goal of awakening.

**1.106** [95aaf000-50a8-4415-8f65-7d745ac53ca2] “Making magically appear in their own hands
Unimaginably numerous realms,
In order to understand how everything is illusory
They set their thought firmly on the goal of awakening.

**1.107** [4ecd9703-310b-4dc6-93ca-824c0ac2930d] “Placing, just like those realms, all sentient beings
On the palms of their hands without harming them
In order to understand that all phenomena are without life-force,
They set their thought firmly on the goal of awakening.

**1.108** [9258891e-4b8d-41e7-8fad-db6a1309135e] “Taking all the water of the great ocean
And placing it as a single drop on the tip of a hair,
In order to understand the ultimate extent,
They set their thought firmly on the goal of awakening.

**1.109** [c41e26ce-7b61-4ab9-98bd-0f6b91dd2aee] “Counting all the infinitesimal particles,
However tiny, that constitute all the worlds,
In order to understand the number of those infintesimal atoms,
They set their thought firmly on the goal of awakening.

**1.110** [6e412c02-d7ac-4f8d-b271-9357dd8465c9] “In order to understand how eons come to an end,
How in this world in the past there has been a time of destruction by burning[n.62] in this world in the past
That will happen likewise in the future,
They set their thought firmly on the goal of awakening.

**1.111** [454b18ec-e1ba-49a1-bb44-a16afb157de8] “In order to understand the nature of the teachings
Of the tathāgatas of the three times, of the teachers,
Of pratyekabuddhas, and of śrāvakas,
They set their thought firmly on the goal of awakening.

**1.112** [919c8fba-a02d-4e04-ab1a-7adf7df4b163] “In order to understand the nature of entities,
To bind inexpressibly vast worlds with a hair
And weigh them on a scale,
They set their thought firmly on the goal of awakening.

**1.113** [d156c133-06af-4b4c-bd9d-575bf20fe008] “In order to understand coarse and fine,
To bind a ring of unimaginably huge mountains with a hair
And weigh them on a scale,
They set their thought firmly on the goal of awakening.

**1.114** [29adb3c9-aa2e-4665-a065-6f5c0f9cea8c] “In order to display the pure aspects of speech
Whose sounds bring understanding in a single instant
In all realms of the world without exception,
They set their thought firmly on the goal of awakening.

**1.115** [7ea18e6b-c21d-4f08-a454-d8138edf0eb5] “In order to understand the nature of peace,
Describing it in one instant in a single voice
In the languages of all worlds, however they may be,
They set their thought firmly on the goal of awakening.[n.63]

**1.116** [5f52f017-0535-44a8-a733-4fd609238e60] “In order to understand the Buddha’s vast, wide tongue
That informs all three worlds
And is known by all sentient beings,
They set their thought firmly on the goal of awakening.

**1.117** [4238e02c-a1dd-408a-ab6c-77d83709f7c8] “Just as what it pronounces, too, throughout all realms,
Clears away views in a single instant,
In order to understand discursive doctrines,
They set their thought firmly on the goal of awakening.

**1.118** [310db8ba-44d8-47f1-b4e5-0615bb924065] “Here, in order to understand in an instant
The self-arising teachings
Of the tathāgatas filling all worlds,
They set their thought firmly on the goal of awakening.

**1.119** [f8ca80cb-48e1-4000-a97a-1464545762a0] “In order to understand that world realms like diverse atoms
Are magically emanated in all their aspects
And have arisen from mind,
They set their thought firmly on the goal of awakening.

**1.120** [aaa47255-9ea0-4e28-8443-e9b99ca54feb] “All those buddhas of the past as well as those to come,
However many may exist in the world—
In order to understand them in a single instant of mind,
They set their thought firmly on the goal of awakening.

**1.121** [d7deca08-ab43-4e9f-88d5-ff673e9c013b] “Even a single word they have spoken,
In order to analyze it in detail with no diminution
Even if inconceivably many eons pass,
They set their thought firmly on the goal of awakening.

**1.122** [73842124-5760-4918-adf7-ffac1ba50c0b] “In order to understand in a single instant of mind
How beings go to all worlds
In all ten directions, and how they return,
They set their thought firmly on the goal of awakening.

**1.123** [ad9dd0f6-e024-4dc5-be97-c2e4cc941eba] “To go in all directions, yet with no attachment
Of body, speech, or mind to anything;
In order to understand the three times as empty,
They set their thought firmly on the goal of awakening.

**1.124** [e2a01855-1c75-482a-b636-f84cc25b8e40] “To tell them, just as they resolved in their thought of awakening,
For infinite eons to go in all directions
And worship in the presence of the buddhas there—
That is the teaching for those who do not turn back.[n.64]

**1.125** [e9acc955-251e-4171-89f8-8a9534475827] “In the different worlds of the ten directions,
To the lords of those worlds should they, who are the victors’ offspring,
Proclaim as befits them all that is most sublime—
That is the teaching for those who do not turn back.

**1.126** [67341f43-001e-4de0-9d09-102e5cd1d6f1] “When performing deeds in worldly existence for the sake of awakening,
To constantly express their praise
Of what has brought them the wellbeing of bodhisattvas—
That is the teaching for those who do not turn back.

**1.127** [f0b49346-6ee6-4c8a-bb46-f7c87fb52529] “The highest Dharma, the superior Dharma that is preeminent,
And the extraordinary Dharma that is unsurpassed,
These are what should be taught to bodhisattvas—
That is the teaching for those who do not turn back.

**1.128** [e3c35bea-e8a9-4a4d-a7d9-c39e6907af9f] “Bodhisattvas should apply themselves to none other
Than the great ones[n.65] themselves, the tathāgatas,
Those who are endowed with all good qualities—
That is the teaching for those who do not turn back.

**1.129** [d1079e7e-2ed2-4f73-a65e-dfade15e76e2] “Those bodhisattvas should be taught
How it is to meet infinite, incalculable,
And inconceivable buddhas.
That is the teaching for those who do not turn back.

**1.130** [a578ed5e-b615-448e-b1b3-1396ad3e3f33] “As many meditative absorptions as may exist,
And likewise the absorptions that are aspects of their mindstream,
Should be taught to the offspring of the sugatas.
That is the teaching for those who do not turn back.

**1.131** [b71af20d-f169-4d23-9001-bba429775bce] “To turn back the wheel of saṃsāra,
To turn the wheel of the holy Dharma,
And never to be turned around by anyone in the world—
Bodhisattvas should be taught such things.

**1.132** [2f00fa9f-1ca0-4e44-a22f-4eb7f877028e] “To become, for all in worlds where sufferings are intense,
And for those tormented in the places of the lower realms,
Their basis, refuge, and defender—
Bodhisattvas should be taught such things.

**1.133** [554ca440-9de7-4a66-9f59-707dd0da893f] “Those who have set their thoughts on the goal of awakening
Are, it is taught, beginner bodhisattvas.
The instructions for their training as they have been ascertained
Are as they are detailed for them in this presentation.

**1.134** [63ec059e-e033-4f59-8493-779570b517af] “Those who, to begin with, have thus generated the thought of awakening
For the sake of benefiting the entire world
Just as is taught by those who are free from all ailments—
These are the second kind of bodhisattva: the fortunate beginners.

**1.135** [84b79813-d4f7-4089-908c-4c7b1f0acec7] “A mind that brings benefit, is good, and brings happiness,
That is friendly, feels sadness, and likewise gathers together;
A mind that protects everything, a mind of equality,
The mind of a teacher, and a mind that teaches equally—

**1.136** [39646a13-97a1-4aff-9e8c-a5bb29385a42] “Those who have in these ways transformed their mind
Should apply themselves to hearing the scriptures and to the performance of recitations.
Once they are learned, they should devote themselves to retiring into solitude.
Having retired into solitude, they should devote themselves to serving their spiritual teacher.

**1.137** [d0c450ad-024a-404f-94b4-be44cfc28226] “They should delight in following the instructions of their teachers.
In becoming aware of temporality, they should be conscientious.
Aware of temporality, they should become utterly fearless.
Being fearless, they should exert themselves in knowing the meaning.

**1.138** [172610f4-163e-458c-9cae-3c63d750f0b8] “Knowing the meaning, they should expound the Dharma likewise.
Regarding all the teachings of Dharma, they should be without confusion.
Having become free of confusion, the offspring of the victors
Should apply themselves to abiding in the well-taught Dharma.

**1.139** [c6016416-18ab-4340-9fc4-ce4f6b7fa469] “These are what are called fortunate beginners—
Bodhisattvas who have entered the state of awakening.
These are the instructions, and these the teachings;
Those who train in them are the offspring of the Buddha.

**1.140** [0f7222b6-6e4a-48fd-9ad6-2d6f1c7e0b6a] “Bodhisattvas of the third kind[n.66] are those
Who apply themselves to the teaching of the King of Dharma.
They should understand that all phenomena are impermanent, suffering, empty,
Without self, and immovable;

## Notes for this part

**n.1** It is from this section that the long passage of some two hundred and thirty stanzas making up much of the eighteenth chapter of the *Śikṣāsamuccaya* is quoted, constituting the longest quotation of any scripture in Śāntideva’s text; see below.

**n.2** See Denkarma F.297.b.4.

**n.3** See Phangthangma (F.2) p. 5. The other texts in the Phangthangma list, apart from the 105 *bam po* *Buddhāvataṃsaka* itself, are the *Lokottaraparivarta* (ch. 44 in the Degé version of Toh 44), the *Daśabhūmika* (ch. 31), and the *Tathāgatotpattisambhavanirdeśa* (ch. 43).

**n.4** See Skilling and Saerji (2012).

**n.5** See Skilling and Saerji (2013) p. 199, n35.

**n.6** See n.34 and n.81.

**n.7** See also n.100 and n.141. The equivalent passage in the Tibetan *Avataṃsakasūtra* starts on Degé Kangyur vol. 35 (phal po che, ka) F.219.b.

**n.8** *大方廣總持寶光明經* (*Da fangguang puxian suoshuo jing*).

**n.9** See the entry for Volume 10 of the Taishō at ntireader.org, and the entry K 1095 in *The Korean Buddhist Canon: A Descriptive Catalogue*. The Chinese text was not considered essential for producing this translation.

**n.10** Note that there is a discrepancy among various databases for cataloging the Toh 847 version of this text within vol. 100 or 101 of the Degé Kangyur. See Toh 847, n.10, for details.

**n.11** The four instances here come close to covering, between them, the four types of dhāraṇī set out in the commentarial literature, notably the *Bodhisattvabhūmi*: the dhāraṇī (1) of Dharma (*dharmadhāraṇī*, *chos kyi gzungs*), sometimes also called dhāraṇī of words (*tshig gi gzungs*); (2) of meaning (*arthadhāraṇī*, *don gyi gzungs*); (3) of mantras (*mantradhāraṇī*, *gsang sngags kyi gzungs*); and (4) to attain the bodhisattvas’ acceptance (*bodhisattvakṣāntidhāraṇī*, *byang chub sems dpa’ bzod pa ’thob par byed pa’i gzungs*), i.e., acceptance of the non-arising of phenomena. See Negi 1993–2005, vol. 6, p. 2318. For more on dhāraṇī, their different types, their history, and their place in the literature, see Braarvig 1985, Buswell and Lopez 2013, Davidson 2009 and 2014, Gyatso 1992, and McBride 2005.

**n.12** Eight examples of this kind of dhāraṇī are explained at length and very clearly in the *Tathāgatamahākaruṇānirdeśa* (Toh 147) at F.218.b et seq., (for translation see Burchardi 2020, *The Teaching on the Great Compassion of the Tathāgata*, 2.524–2.604). Interestingly the same text mentions, a little later at F.231.b (see idem 2.614–2.652), another dhāraṇī called “the Jewel Lamp” for which the Tibetan in this case is *rin chen sgron ma*, but which among other possibilities could have been, as here, the Sanskrit *ratnolkā*.

**n.13** In the *Mahāvyutpatti*, the three different Tibetan terms given under Skt. *ulkā* (Mvy. 6899) are *skar ma* (“star”), *sgron ma*, and *ta la la* in a list of 97 general terms, while the title *Ratnolkā* (without any text-type ending) is listed as *dkon mchog ta la la* (Mvy. 1375) in a list of 105 *saddharma* titles. The equivalence of *ta la la* to *sgron ma* is mentioned in the *li shi’i gur khang*, a fifteenth century glossary of archaic terms and their later renderings by Kyok Lotsāwa Ngawang Rinchen Tashi (skyogs lo tsA ba ngag dbang rin chen bkra shis), although he appears to have misspelt it *tal la*.

**n.14** Of the four quotations from this work in the *Śikṣāsamuccaya*, the first, describing the virtues of faith, comprises verses 2.37–2.61 followed almost immediately by the second, verses 2.387 and 2.391; these excerpts appear in the first chapter (on the perfection of giving), see Bendall’s 1902 Sanskrit edition pp. 2–5; for translations see also Bendall and Rouse (1922) pp. 3–5 and Goodman 2016, pp. 3–5. The third quotation, a brief one comprising the paragraph 1.63 on the second category of bodhisattva, appears in the seventh chapter (on protection), see Bendall (1902) p. 153; for translations see Bendall and Rouse p. 152 and Goodman p. 153. The fourth, a very long quotation (and perhaps the longest of all quotations in the *Śikṣāsamuccaya*), comprises verses 2.123–2.323 and then selected verses culminating in 2.355 and appears in the eighteenth chapter (on the recollection of the Three Jewels), see Bendall (1902) pp. 327–47; for translations see Bendall and Rouse pp. 291–306 and Goodman pp. 304–322.

**n.15** See *Mahāvyutpatti* no. 1375, in section 65, *saddharmanāmāni*; it lists 105 items, mostly names of sūtras but also some vinaya texts, as well as category terms.

**n.16** See, for example, the fifteenth chapter of Longchen Rabjampa’s *yid bzhin rin po che’i mdzod*, which first enumerates these three, four, and six kinds of faith, and then explains the six using quotations from 2.37 onward (the same passage that Śāntideva cites, see n.104). The six kinds of faith are: (1) yearning faith (*’dod pa’i dad pa*), (2) inspired faith (*mos pa’i dad pa*), (3) respectful faith (*gus pa’i dad pa*), (4) clear faith (*dang ba’i dad pa*), (5) confident faith (*yid ches pa’i dad pa*), and (6) faith from conviction in the profound teachings (*chos zab mo nges par sems pa’i dad pa*).

**n.17** Titles used include the canonical *dkon mchog ta la la’i gzungs*, *dkon mchog ta la la’i mdo*, erroneous renderings such as *dkon mchog ta la*, and a range of secondary variants using the *dkon mchog sgron ma* form.

**n.18** The word is found neither in Goldstein or Inagaki. Negi says it is a synonym of *dbus*, and also notes the similar (rare) verb *dbung ba* (=*khro ba*).

**n.19** Also found in Negi as an old spelling.

**n.20** Tib. *nges par byung ba*; Skt. *niṣkrānta*. The Comparative Edition notes that the Yongle, Lithang, Kangxi, and Choné read *nges par ’byung ba* (p. 207).

**n.21** Tib. *tshad med par*. The Comparative Edition notes that the Narthang and Lhasa editions read *tshad med pas*, which seems preferable (p. 207). The Stok Palace version also reads *tshad med pas* (F.149.b.6).

**n.22** Tib. *stong pa nyid spyod yul ba*. The Comparative Edition observes that the Narthang and Lhasa editions read *stong pa nyid kyi spyod yul ba* (p. 207). The Stok Palace also reads *stong pa nyid kyi spyod yul ba* (F.149.b.6).

**n.23** Here “all dharmas” (Tib. *chos thams cad*; Skt. *sarvadharma*) denotes both teachings and matters taught.

**n.24** I.e., the teachings and phenomena.
   
**n.25** Tib. *gzhi med pa’i don*. The Stok Palace version reads *med pa’i don* “the meaning of nonexistence” (F.152.a.3).

**n.26** Note that Tib. *mi mnyam pa dang mnyam pa*; Skt. *asamasama* means, according to Inagaki, “equal to the unequaled.” According to Edgerton, it means “unequalled,” lit. “having no equal like him.”

**n.27** Note that the Stok Palace version has *zhes* instead of *shes* (F.152.a.7), which we follow here.

**n.28** Tib. *dmigs pa med pa*. The Comparative Edition notes that the Narthang and Lhasa editions read *mi dmigs pa* (p. 208). The Stok Palace version also reads *mi dmigs pa* (F.152.a.5).

**n.29** Note that here Tib. *byin*, an archaic verb, is used with the meaning to say or speak.

**n.30** Tib. *rnam par dag pa’i sgo*. We have here added “the Dharma” for the sake of clarity.

**n.31** Tib. *rgyu mthun pa*. The Comparative Edition follows the Degé and others by including *rgyu ’thun pa*, though the more common spelling *rgyu mthun pa* is reflected in the Kangxi, Narthang, Lhasa, and Stok Palace versions. See Comparative Edition, p. 208; Stok Palace, F.153.b.1.

**n.32** Tib. *sā la*. The Comparative Edition notes that the Yongle, Lithang, Kangxi, and Choné read *sa la* (p. 208). The Stok Palace version reads *sā la* (F.153.b.1).

**n.33** Here we have the very rare term: Tib. *dmigs pa can*; Skt. *aupalambhika*, which refers to someone with a heretical view according to Edgerton.

**n.34** The passage from here down to and including 1.178 (see n.81) is paralleled as chapter 20 of the Tibetan *Avataṃsaka*, “The Ten Categories of Bodhisattvas” starting in the Degé *Avataṃsaka* in volume 35 (phal po che, ka) on folio 245.a.1. The Tibetan translations of these two versions are not the same but the content matches closely, except for the names of the meditative absorption (see next note). In the Chinese *Avataṃsaka* the equivalent is chapter 15.

**n.35** In the Chinese *Avataṃsaka* this meditative absorption is called “of infinite techniques of bodhisattvas,” and in the Tibetan *Avataṃsaka* “the bodhisattva’s meditative absorption called ‘infinite refining’” (*byang chub sems dpa’i ting nge dzin sbyong ba mtha’ yas pa zhes bya ba*).

**n.36** Tib. *byang chub sems dpa’ rnam par gzhag pa bcu*. The term *rnam par gzhag pa* probably renders Skt. *vyavasthāna*, which can also mean “differentiation” (see Edgerton) i.e., “classification,” and by association, “category” and the “distinctive features” of each category. Hence, here it is “the ten categories of the bodhisattva.”

**n.37** Tib. *nyug pa* is an old term meaning “to touch,” according to Negi.

**n.38** Note that we should here read this as Tib. *sras* (singular) rather than *sras dag* (plural).

**n.39** Tib. *gzhon nur gyur pa*. Skt. *Kumārabhūta* according to Edgerton, “while still a youth/remaining a youth.”

**n.40** Tib. *kha dog bzang po rgyas pa’am/ rgya che ba’am/ gzi brjid che ba’am*. Here we read *rgyas pa*, *rgya che ba*, and *gzi brjid che ba* as modifiers of *kha dog bzang po*. Compare, in the Tibetan *Avataṃsaka*, *mdzad pa dang bzang ba dang / myig tu ’ong ba dang / kha dag rgyas pa dang*.

**n.41** Tib. *kun tu brjod pa’i cho ’phrul*; Skt. *ādeśanā-prātihārya*, as explained in Edgerton.

**n.42** I.e., miracles of insightful admonition effecting destruction of one’s vices. Tib. *rjes su bstan pa’i cho ’phrul*, Skt. *anuśāseniprātihārya*, as explained in Edgerton.

**n.43** On “possible” and “impossible” for Tib. *gnas dang mi gnas*; Skt. *sthānāsthāna*, see Edgerton.

**n.44** The Comparative Edition notes that the Yongle, Lithang, Kangxi, and Choné versions omit *las dang* (pp. 208–209).

**n.45** Tib. *ldang ba*. The Comparative Edition notes that the Narthang and Lhasa versions here read *ldan pa* (p. 209). The Stok Palace version also reads *ldan pa* (F.157.b.4).

**n.46** This paragraph is quoted in chapter 7 of the *Śikṣāsamuccaya* (see Bendall 1902, p. 153).

**n.47** Lit. “knowing time” (Tib. *dus shes pa*; Skt. *kālajña*). Edgerton refers only to the entry for *sarvakālajña*, which means knowing past, present, and future, but that is too early in the training here.

**n.48** Tib. *brjed pa med pa*, lit. “without forgetfulness,” but probably rendering Skt. *asammoṣa*; see Edgerton. Indeed the next sentence begins with Tib. *rmongs pa med pa* as its synonym.

**n.49** The Comparative Edition notes that the Narthang and Lhasa versions omit *’di la* (p. 209). The Stok Palace version also omits *’di la* (F.158.b.7).

**n.50** Here the word *khams* could be understood in several ways: as the realms inhabited by beings, as the constituent elements of which beings are made up, as the various propensities of beings, or possibly of the “constituent” or “element” (the buddha-nature) present in them. It has here been rendered as “constitution” to avoid what might be a mistaken choice of interpretation.

**n.51** Note that the desire realm is found below in the verse restatement.

**n.52** Note that our rendering here is tentative since the expression *gsung rab ’phags par skyes pa* is unknown.

**n.53** Here and in the next few phrases we should either add *du* or understand *mnyam pa nyid du*, “*as* sameness.”

**n.54** The Narthang, Lhasa, and Stok Palace versions all have “expertise in understanding the three times” as item 8, “expertise in understanding the relative truth” as item 9, and “expertise in understanding ultimate truth” for item 10. This is important to note, given that the appearance of “exprtise in understanding” (*mkhas pa yin*) after all three statements suggests that they form a single item in the list, and thus we should prefer the Narthang, Lhasa, and Stok Palace readings. See Comparative Edition, p. 209; Stok Palace, F.163.b.1–3.

**n.55** In the term *rgyal po’i pho brang ’khor*, the entire expression (including *’khor*) means “royal palace.”

**n.56** In all editions consulted, only nine things that bodhisattvas who are regents are to be taught are listed.

**n.57** Note that Negi gives *dbung* (“center”) as a normal synonym of *dbus*, but it and the verb *dbung ba* are both archaic spellings. Also, the Comparative Edition indicates that the Yongle, Lithang, Kangxi, Choné, and Lhasa editions all read *dbus* (p. 210). Interestingly, the Stok Palace edition preserves the archaic spelling *dbung* (F.164.b.5), suggesting that it is a reading from the Thempangma recension.

**n.58** This passage consists of repeated verbs with changes in prefixes, which we choose to reflect with adverbial modifiers in the English.

**n.59** *bsnyen dka’* in such contexts usually means “difficult to approach” in the sense of being dazzling or overpowering, but here an alternative interpretation might be that it refers rather to the marks of having attained the “ten things that are difficult to approach” (*bsnyen par dka’ ba’i gnas bcu*) listed in the equivalent prose passage above, at 1.61.

**n.60** The phrase *byang chub don du brtan pa sems ’jog byed* (“They set their thought firmly on the goal of awakening”) is repeated in many of the verses, although most of these lines in the Stok Palace version read *byang chub don du bstan pa sems ’jog byed* (“They set their thought on the teachings for the sake of awakening”). See Stok Palace F.166.a.3 for the first occurrence. The reading *bstan pa* (“teaching”) appears only a couple of times in the present General Sūtra version in the editions consulted in the Comparative Edition (p. 210), but the equivalent lines in the Tibetan *Avataṃsaka* also vary somewhat between several variants with either *brtan pa* or *bstan pa* (Degé Kangyur vol. phal po che, ka, F.253.a et seq.. These verses refer back to the prose description of bodhisattvas of the first category above (at 1.61) and the “firmly” (*brtan pa*) variant seems the better fit.

**n.61** This stanza does not seem to exist in the Chinese *Avataṃsaka*. It is not entirely clear whether it refers to places, or to what is possible and impossible; but the latter, given the order of the items in 1.61, seems considerably more likely. In the Tibetan *Avataṃsaka* the equivalent stanza (Degé Kangyur, vol. 35, phal po che, ka, F.253.a.3) reads: *khams gsum kun na gnas ni ’di dag yin/ /gnas myin rang bzhin dag kyang ’di yin zhes/ /ma nor dngos po khong du chud bya’i phyir/ /brtan pa byang chub don du sems bskyed do.*

**n.62** A detailed account of the cosmological eons (Skt. *kalpa*) is found in the *Abhidharmakośa* ch. III, stanzas 89–102.

**n.63** In the Tibetan *Avataṃsaka* version (Degé Kangyur vol. 35, phal po che, ka, F.254.a.6) the meaning of the equivalent stanza is clearer and probably justifies translating the second *skad cig* here in line 2 as “in a single voice.” That version is: *sems can kun gyi sgra skad ji snyed pa/ dbyangs gcig brjod pas ji ltar brjod bya bar/ sgra yi rang bzhin khong du chud bya’i phyir/ brtan pa byang chub don du sems bsgyur ro.* However, in that version the object of the understanding is “sound” or “language” (*sgra*) instead of “peace,” as here.

**n.64** There are a number of different ways in which this stanza could be interpreted. In the Tibetan *Avataṃsaka* version (Degé Kangyur vol. 35, phal po che, ka, F.254.b.5–6) the equivalent stanza supports the probability that the buddhas mentioned here are those in the buddha realms of all directions: *de ltar byang chub don du bskyed byed pa/ phyogs bcu’i sangs rgyas brjod du med pa kun/ mchod par bya la yongs su bskul bar bya/ ’di ni phyir mi ldog gi gdams ngag go*. Note also that these verses, down as far as 1.132, still refer to the first of the ten categories of bodhisattva, and the recurring description in the final line in this group of seven stanzas, “those who do not turn back” (*mi ldog rnams*), is not quite the same as that of the “irreversible” (*phyir mi ldog pa’i*) bodhisattvas, the seventh category.

**n.65** The Degé Kangyur here reads *yon tan kun ldan de bzhin gshegs pa yi/ tshe nyid ’di na …*, while the Stok Palace, Yongle, Lithang, Kangxi and Choné Kangyurs all read *che* instead of *tshe*. The latter reading is more likely as well as closer to the equivalent stanza in the Tibetan *Avataṃsaka* version (Degé Kangyur vol. 35, phal po che, ka, F.255.a.2): *de bzhin gshegs pa yon tan kun ldan pa/ ’jig rten mgon po bdag nyid che ba kun*.

**n.66** I.e., bodhisattvas who engage in yogic practice (see 1.65).

Continued in part 2: https://84000.co/translation/toh145/part-2.md
