---
title: "The Chapter on Going Forth"
toh: "Toh 1-1"
sanskrit_title: "Pravrajyāvastu"
tibetan_title: "rab tu ’byung ba’i gzhi"
canon_section: "Kangyur › Discipline › Chapters on Monastic Discipline"
url: https://84000.co/translation/toh1-1
published: 2018-10-31
collections: ["Finding Your Path"]
publisher: "84000: Translating the Words of the Buddha"
translation_team: "Robert Miller and team"
translators: ["Robert Miller"]
license: "CC BY-NC-ND 4.0"
license_url: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
citation: "The Chapter on Going Forth (Pravrajyāvastu, Toh 1-1). Translated by Robert Miller and team. Online publication. 84000: Translating the Words of the Buddha, 2018. https://84000.co/translation/toh1-1."
part: 1
parts: 9
generated: 2026-11-16
---

# The Chapter on Going Forth

Toh 1-1 · Kangyur › Discipline › Chapters on Monastic Discipline · An 84000 translation · Read online: https://84000.co/translation/toh1-1

> **License:** [CC BY-NC-ND 4.0](https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/). This work is provided under the protection of a Creative Commons CC BY-NC-ND (Attribution - Non-commercial - No-derivatives) 4.0 copyright. It may be copied or printed for fair use, but only with full attribution, and not for commercial advantage or personal compensation. **Cite as:** The Chapter on Going Forth (Pravrajyāvastu, Toh 1-1). Translated by Robert Miller and team. Online publication. 84000: Translating the Words of the Buddha, 2018. https://84000.co/translation/toh1-1.

> This is the plain-text edition of https://84000.co/translation/toh1-1. Passage labels (for example 1.2 or i.3) match the online edition. Each label is followed by the passage's permanent ID in square brackets, and by a Toh number when the passage belongs to one Toh only, for example **1.2** [ID] or **i.3** [ID, toh1-1]. To link to a passage, use https://84000.co/entity/passage/ID?toh=TOH, with TOH = toh1-1 when no Toh is given. Note numbers in square brackets (such as [n.3]) point to the Notes section. When quoting, cite 84000, *The Chapter on Going Forth* (Toh 1-1), with the passage label and its link. The summary, introduction and notes are by the translators and are not part of the translated text.

## Parts of this text

This text is long, so its plain-text edition is split into 9 parts. Each part keeps 84000's passage labels and ends with the notes its passages refer to. The whole text in one file: https://84000.co/translation/toh1-1/full.md

- [Part 1](https://84000.co/translation/toh1-1.md): Summary, Acknowledgments, Introduction, The Translation (p1.1–1.116)
- [Part 2](https://84000.co/translation/toh1-1/part-2.md): The Translation (1.117–1.335)
- [Part 3](https://84000.co/translation/toh1-1/part-3.md): The Translation (1.336–1.549)
- [Part 4](https://84000.co/translation/toh1-1/part-4.md): The Translation (1.550–3.19)
- [Part 5](https://84000.co/translation/toh1-1/part-5.md): The Translation (3.20–4.178)
- [Part 6](https://84000.co/translation/toh1-1/part-6.md): The Translation (4.179–4.378)
- [Part 7](https://84000.co/translation/toh1-1/part-7.md): The Translation, Appendix, Abbreviations (4.379–ap1.1)
- [Part 8](https://84000.co/translation/toh1-1/part-8.md): Glossary
- [Part 9](https://84000.co/translation/toh1-1/part-9.md): Glossary

## At a glance

> Machine-generated overview: written by AI from 84000's published summary and introduction, not yet reviewed by an 84000 editor. It is not part of the translation; quote the translation itself.

**In brief:** The Chapter on Going Forth (Toh 1-1), known in Sanskrit as the Pravrajyāvastu, is the first of seventeen chapters in The Chapters on Monastic Discipline, a four-volume work belonging to the Discipline section of the Kangyur. The text traces the development of the rite by which postulants were admitted into the Buddhist monastic order, beginning with the Buddha Śākyamuni's informal invitation "Come, monk. Live the holy life," progressing through the Early Rite, and arriving at the more elaborate Present Day Rite. Central to the chapter is the story of Śāriputra and Maudgalyāyana, whose spiritual search through the competing renunciant orders of the north Indian region of Magadha culminates in their joining the Buddha's community. Woven throughout are origin stories explaining the admission criteria for the rite, accounts of untrained monks whose conduct prompted the creation of the roles of preceptor and instructor, and narrative asides that together paint a vivid picture of the religious landscape of ancient Greater Magadha. The chapter exemplifies the Mūlasarvāstivāda Vinaya's distinctive blend of community guidelines, narrative, and didactic stories.

**Why read it:** This text offers a close account of how Buddhist monastic ordination developed, from a simple spoken invitation to a formal rite, while also narrating the spiritual journeys of the Buddha's foremost disciples and the religious world they inhabited.

### What is the Chapter on Going Forth about?

The Chapter on Going Forth describes the historical development of the rite by which postulants were admitted into the Buddhist monastic order. It moves from the Buddha Śākyamuni's earliest informal ordinations by saying "Come, monk," through a short Early Rite, to the more elaborate Present Day Rite. The chapter also narrates the spiritual search of Śāriputra and Maudgalyāyana and explains the criteria for admission into the order through a series of origin stories.

### Who are the key figures in the Chapter on Going Forth?

The central figures are the Buddha Śākyamuni and his two foremost disciples, who appear in the chapter under their pre-ordination names Upatiṣya and Kolita and later as Śāriputra and Maudgalyāyana. Other important figures include the six tīrthika teachers the two seekers question, the monk Saṅgharakṣita, the teacher Sañjayin, and the monk Upasena, whose apprenticeship defines the roles of preceptor and instructor.

### Where is the Chapter on Going Forth set?

The chapter is set primarily in the north Indian region of Magadha and its surroundings, including the city of Rājagṛha. The opening sections depict the conflict between the kingdoms of Aṅga and Magadha, and the religious landscape of Greater Magadha provides the backdrop for Śāriputra and Maudgalyāyana's encounters with competing renunciant teachers and their eventual entry into the Buddha's order.

### How did the ordination rite change over time according to this text?

The Chapter on Going Forth describes three stages in the development of the ordination rite. The earliest form was the Buddha's personal invitation, "Come, monk. Live the holy life." As the order grew and travelling to see the Buddha became impractical, the saṅgha was permitted to conduct a short Early Rite requiring a postulant to request admission three times. Problems with untrained new monks then led to the more formal Present Day Rite, with stricter criteria and the roles of preceptor and instructor.

### What is the broader work that the Chapter on Going Forth belongs to, and how does it fit within the Mūlasarvāstivāda Vinaya?

The Chapter on Going Forth is the first of seventeen chapters in The Chapters on Monastic Discipline, which is itself the Vinayavastu, the first of four Scriptural Divisions of the Mūlasarvāstivāda Vinaya. The Vinayavastu details the statutes and procedures governing monastic community life, and its seventeen chapters together contain one of the most extensive biographies of the Buddha available, woven across community guidelines, narratives, and ritual handbooks.

### What is the Sanskrit title of this text, and what does it mean?

The Sanskrit title is Pravrajyāvastu. The key term pravrajyā refers to the act of going forth, that is, renouncing the settled life of a householder to live as a wandering ascetic. In the translation, pravrajyā is rendered as "to go forth" or, in a small number of cases, "to join the renunciant order," while one who goes forth is called a renunciant.

### Who translated the Chapter on Going Forth into English for 84000?

The English translation published by 84000 was made by Robert Miller. The ancient Tibetan translation, which serves as the primary basis for the English, was made by the Kashmiri preceptor Sarvajñādeva, the Indian preceptor Vidyākaraprabha, the Kashmiri preceptor Dharmākara, and the translator Palgyi Lhünpo, and was later revised and finalized by Vidyākaraprabha and the managing editor-translator Paltsek.

## Summary

**s.1** [32af304a-2185-448d-8fa7-4bc985939064] “The Chapter on Going Forth” is the first of seventeen chapters in *The Chapters on Monastic Discipline*, a four-volume work that outlines the statutes and procedures that govern life in a Buddhist monastic community. This first chapter traces the development of the rite by which postulants were admitted into the monastic order, from the Buddha Śākyamuni’s informal invitation to “Come, monk,” to the more elaborate “Present Day Rite.” Along the way, the posts of preceptor and instructor are introduced, their responsibilities defined, and a dichotomy between elders and immature novices described. While the heart of the chapter is a transcript of the “Present Day Rite,” the text is interwoven with numerous narrative asides, depicting the spiritual ferment of the north Indian region of Magadha during the Buddha’s lifetime, the follies of untrained and unsupervised apprentices, and the need for a formal system of tutelage.

## Acknowledgments

**ac.1** [775db6e6-2000-4062-92fd-7df837b203ed] This translation was carried out from the Tibetan by Robert Miller with the guidance of Geshé Tséwang Nyima. Ven. Lhundup Damchö (Dr. Diana Finnegan) provided her draft translation of the extant Sanskrit portions of this chapter. Dr. Fumi Yao and Maurice Ozaine kindly identified numerous misspellings and mistakes in the glossaries. Both Ven. Damchö and Dr. Yao generously shared their extensive knowledge of the Mūlasarvāstivādin Vinaya and furnished invaluable assistance in researching the translation. Matthew Wuethrich served as style consultant and editor.

The translation was completed under the patronage and supervision of 84000: Translating the Words of the Buddha.

**ac.2** [34938bf6-6347-434d-9156-bb4afcc1ccb3] The generous sponsorship of Zhou Tian Yu, Chen Yi Qin, Irene Tillman, Archie Kao, and Zhou Xun, which helped make the work on this translation possible, is most gratefully acknowledged.

## Introduction

### The Vinaya

**i.1** [b90c960b-dc9d-4a17-8d08-40d236882337] According to traditional accounts, after the Buddha had entered parinirvāṇa, the elder Kāśyapa proposed that the Blessed One’s teachings be recited for posterity. During the rains retreat at Rājagṛha that followed, Kāśyapa asked the venerable Upāli to recall the Buddha’s pronouncements on monastic discipline and the venerable Ānanda to recite the Buddha’s discourses. One hundred years later, a second council was convened at Vaiśālī to resolve disagreements that had arisen in relation to the code of monastic discipline, or *vinaya*.[n.1]

**i.2** [d8384e0e-e234-419a-9c06-301f322bea6e] Shortly after the Second Council, the monastic community split into two factions, “the Elders” (Skt. *Sthavira*) and “the Majority” (Skt. *Mahāsāṃghika*). In time, for reasons of discipline, doctrine, or geography, the two factions branched further into eighteen schools. Among these were the Mūlasarvāstivādins.[n.2]

**i.3** [f8de2532-860e-441d-832c-a513fc8b043e] Although there is, as yet, no scholarly consensus on the exact origins of this school, we know the Mūlasarvāstivādins were well established in northwest India, between Mathura, Kashmir, and Gandhāra, during the Kuṣāṇa Kingdom’s zenith in the second and third centuries *ᴄᴇ*. We also know that they eventually compiled the longest of the six complete codes of monastic discipline still available to us.[n.3]

### The Mūlasarvāstivāda Vinaya

**i.4** [84e99445-8f43-4ee4-95be-24630d92fb62] The Mūlasarvāstivādins’ monastic code is comprised of several texts,[n.4] which Tibetans, the foremost inheritors of this tradition, group into the “Four Scriptural Divisions of the Vinaya”: the *Vinayavastu*, *Vinayavibhaṅga*, *Kṣudrakavastu*, and *Uttaragrantha*. The *Vinayavastu* details the statutes and procedures that govern the institutions of monastic community life. The *Vinayavibhaṅga* narrates the circumstances that prompted the formulation of each of the monastic vows given in the *Prātimokṣasūtra*. The *Kṣudrakavastu* discusses miscellaneous minutiae of monastic life under eight headings. The *Uttaragrantha*, in its complete form, contains eleven texts including Upāli’s questions to the Buddha regarding monastic discipline, along with the *Vinītaka*, the *Nidāna*, and the *Kathāvastu*.

**i.5** [3e8156e2-dad8-4bd0-b2f9-193126070445] Though similar in general outline to most of the other extant monastic codes, the Mūlasarvāstivāda Vinaya is more eclectic in content and character.[n.5] It is no dry legal code or mere *vade mecum* for disciplinary measures. Instead it is a rich bricolage of stories, discourses, ritual handbooks, community guidelines, and catalogs of monastic discipline, with passages and texts from a diverse range of genres like *sūtra*, *avadāna*, and *nidāna*.[n.6]

### The Vinayavastu

**i.6** [0b4a19bd-5008-4bea-b341-cfe721885259] The first of the Mūlasarvāstivāda Vinaya’s four Scriptural Divisions is the *Vinayavastu*. A partial translation into Chinese, containing at least seven of the chapters, was made by the Chinese monk Yijing, in the late seventh to early eighth centuries *ᴄᴇ*,[n.7] but the only complete redaction of all seventeen chapters of the *Vinayavastu* is the ninth-century translation into Tibetan made by Palgyi Lhünpo under the guidance of the Kashmiri preceptor Sarvajñādeva, the Indian preceptor Vidyākaraprabha, and the Kashmiri preceptor Dharmākara. Their work was later proofread and finalized by Vidyākaraprabha and the translator/editor Paltsek.

**i.7** [31df9455-d55c-4003-8b34-4cdf418b77cc] For centuries the *Vinayavastu*, and indeed much of the Mūlasarvāstivāda Vinaya, was known only through these Tibetan and Chinese translations, or from thematic excerpts like the *Divyāvadāna*,[n.8] and all Sanskrit manuscripts of the full text appeared to have disappeared without a trace. Then, in 1931, a cowherd from a small village near Gilgit dug up one of many mounds dotting his community’s pasturelands. He was looking for wood, which could sometimes be found at such sites, but instead stumbled upon a large chamber littered with coin-like clay tablets. Thinking he had disturbed a grave, he grew scared and fled. Word of his find spread quickly and before long a more intrepid local went in search of treasure. What he found was a wooden chest of Buddhist manuscripts dating from the fifth or sixth century *ᴄᴇ*, which wound up in the hands of the district headman in whose possession Sir Aurel Stein found them. After two further excavations and much work by both European and South Asian scholars, Nalinaksha Dutt edited and published the finds as *The Gilgit Manuscripts*.[n.9] Most of the vinaya manuscripts enshrined in the reliquary near Gilgit come from the *Vinayavastu*.[n.10]

**i.8** [20ec65ab-3aee-4828-a733-98fdfa484467] Although large portions of the *Vinayavastu* in Sanskrit were thus recovered in the Gilgit manuscripts, the ninth-century Tibetan translation remains the only complete version known today, and it is primarily on the basis of the Tibetan that the translations to be published here have been, and are being, made. The present translation is of the first chapter, and subsequent chapters will appear in due course.

**i.9** [e7985874-e39d-4ad1-be5d-c21ebc2fe512] The *Vinayavastu* is similar in its themes to the Theravādin *Khandhaka* (Skt. *Skandhaka*) still extant in Pali.[n.11] Both detail the communal rites, formal procedures, and disciplinary measures that give order and coherence to the monastic community as well as the types of clothes, food, shelter, and medicine allowed community members.[n.12] To appropriate Prebish’s useful explanation of the differences between the Skandhaka and Sūtravibhaṅga[n.13] and apply it here by way of analogy, while the *Vinayavibhaṅga* describes the vows that govern individual behavior, the *Vinayavastu* spells out the rules that govern communal behavior. This communal emphasis is immediately apparent when one considers the contents of the *Vinayavastu*’s seventeen chapters:
- 1. The *Pravrajyāvastu* (*The Chapter on Going Forth*) details the development of the rite by which one goes forth and becomes a Buddhist monk.[n.14]
- 2. The *Poṣadhavastu* (*The Chapter on the Restoration Rite*) describes the twice-monthly *poṣadha* ceremony.[n.15]
- 3. The *Pravāraṇavastu* (*The Chapter on Lifting Restrictions*) describes the *pravāraṇa* ceremony in which restrictions adopted for the rains retreat are lifted, marking the end of the rains retreat.[n.16]
- 4. The *Varṣāvastu* (*The Chapter on the Rains*) describes the timing and procedures for the annual rains retreat.[n.17]
- 5. The *Carmavastu* (*The Chapter on Leather*) details the rules regarding the use of leather hides for clothing, footwear, bedding, and seating.
- 6. The *Bhaiṣajyavastu* (*The Chapter on Medicines*) discusses the medicines allowed monastics, such as ghee, sesame oil, honey, and molasses; what monastics should not consume, such as human flesh; and related subjects, such as how medicine should be stored, under what circumstances monastics are allowed to cook for themselves, and how to respond to a hostile doctor.[n.18]
- 7. The *Cīvaravastu* (*The Chapter on Robes*) describes the types of material suitable to be turned into robes, such as silk, cotton, wool, linen, hemp, *dugūla*, koṭampa, and Aparāntin cloth, and presents specifications about the shape and form of those robes.[n.19]
- 8. The *Kaṭhinavastu* (*The Chapter on Turning Cloth into Robes*) describes the rules regulating the acceptance of cloth and turning it into robes.[n.20]
- 9. The *Kauśāmbakavastu* (*The Chapter on the Monks of Kauśāmbī*) outlines the procedures adopted to arbitrate disputes and allows for expulsion from the saṅgha community. These procedures were formulated in the wake of a major dispute that arose when the monks of Kauśāmbī expelled a group of monks from Vaiśālī.
- 10. The *Karmavastu* (*The Chapter on Formal Acts of the Saṅgha*) gives a short summary of the one hundred and one different official acts that require the saṅgha community’s sanction. These acts all fall into one of three categories depending on the procedure needed for ratification: acts of motion alone require only a motion; acts whose second member is a motion require a motion followed by the statement of the act; and acts whose fourth member is a motion require a motion followed by the statement of the act, repeated three times.
- 11. The *Pāṇḍulohitakavastu* (*The Chapter on a Group of Troublesome Monks*) details the five types of disciplinary acts that may be imposed on intransigent monastics, such as censure, chastening, expulsion, reconciliation, and suspension. Its name derives from the site of a dispute in which quarrelsome monks refused to admit to their guilt.[n.21]
- 12. The *Pudgalavastu* (*The Chapter on Types of Persons*) details appropriate and inappropriate times for the confession of breaches in discipline.
- 13. The *Pārivāsikavastu* (*The Chapter on Penitents*) describes how to discipline, through the imposition of probations and penances, a monk who has incurred a saṅgha remnant offense. This chapter also allows for such a monk’s reinstatement as a full member of the community upon successful completion of a probation and penance.
- 14. The *Poṣadhasthāpanavastu* (*The Chapter on the Suspension of the Restoration Rite*) describes the circumstances in which the restoration rite may be suspended and details the restrictions on who is allowed to participate in the restoration.
- 15. The *Śayanāsanavastu* (*The Chapter on Shelter*) discusses the types of shelter suitable for monastics, such as temples, multi-story buildings, verandas, sheds, wooden huts, earthen and rock caves, grass huts, and so on.[n.22]
- 16. The *Adhikaraṇavastu* (*The Chapter on Disputes*) discusses the seven means to resolve disputes that arise from disagreements over the Buddha’s teachings, reproaches regarding another monk’s conduct, offenses, or acts of saṅgha.
- 17. The *Saṅghabhedavastu* (*The Chapter on Schism in the Saṅgha*) narrates at length the Buddha’s youth, awakening, and ministry, as well as the schism prompted by Devadatta.

**i.10** [7c13207b-f756-4d0d-9bb2-9e051d900d25] The above are but summaries of each chapter’s ostensible themes. In several cases, most notably the *Bhaiṣajyavastu* and the *Saṅghabhedavastu*, *avadāna* narratives and important events in the Buddha’s life figure far more prominently than any discussion of communal guidelines on medicine, schisms, or the like. Those interested in detailed summaries of each chapter can find them in Csoma de Körös’s *Analysis of the Dulva*, Banerjee’s *Sarvāstivāda Literature*, and Dutt’s introductions to his *Gilgit Manuscripts*.[n.23] For now, suffice it to say that the *Vinayavastu* has the same eclectic make-up that scholars have come to associate with the Mūlasarvāstivāda Vinaya in general, and that distinguishes it from the other extant monastic codes.

### The Chapter on Going Forth

**i.11** [d38cb3f3-4bce-4c10-aa66-8c311ed41dd1] The first chapter of the *Vinayavastu*, translated here, is “The Chapter on Going Forth.” It describes how the rite of going forth, the formal rejection of household life and entry into the Buddhist order of renunciants, went from a simple and open invitation extended by the Buddha in person to an elaborate rite with admission criteria that could be performed by any monk with sufficient knowledge and reliability.

**i.12** [e3cb0703-9dfa-4714-a3b8-f3daf9c2d9eb] The chapter can be broadly divided into thirds. The first third of the text (“Śāriputra”) tells the story of Śāriputra and Maudgalyāyana’s spiritual search. It provides the historical background for the rise of the Buddhist order against a backdrop of other renunciant orders active in the eastern Gangetic basin in the fifth century *ʙᴄᴇ*. The middle third (“Going Forth” through “Querying Upasena”) describes the three stages the admission rite underwent as the order grew, from the earliest “Come, monk” ordinations, through the Early Rite, and on to the Present Day Rite.[n.24] The last third (“Tīrthikas” through “Persons Whose Hands Have Been Cut Off”) describes the circumstances that led to the adoption of the Present Day Rite’s admission criteria.

**i.13** [a609c536-8312-4884-8fa4-2fa6b37efdcf] Throughout these three sections a number of important themes can be discerned: the opposition between *śramaṇa* ascetics and *brāhmaṇa* householders,[n.25] the existence of a fecund religious scene at the time of the Buddha, the need for official procedures and positions as the Buddhist monastic community grew from an informal group of followers into a spiritual corporation, the importance of a monastic apprenticeship, and the recognition that some people are not suited to life as a Buddhist renunciant.

### Śāriputra and Maudgalyāyana’s Spiritual Search

**i.14** [71608678-550f-4f21-8ba5-dd1c71a26781] “The Chapter on Going Forth” begins in earnest with the story of how Upatiṣya and Kolita came to join the Buddhist order. These two, under the names Śāriputra and Maudgalyāyana, would go on to become the foremost of the Buddha’s disciples. But to begin with they are just young brahmins, well-schooled in Vedic learning and assured of bright futures. In time Upatiṣya proves himself to be a brilliant interpreter of the Vedas, while Kolita, a talented teacher in his own right, is expected to succeed his father as royal priest to the King of Rājagṛha. Though each hears of the other’s reputation from their young brahmin students, they do not meet until the feast of the nāga kings Giri and Valguka, where they recognize one another as kindred spirits. After securing their parents’ consent, they forego their given destinies and set off in search of a renunciant order to join.

**i.15** [1e0e5ee5-c931-4ac2-b078-2ecdbdc02c00] At the time, Rājagṛha and its surroundings are teeming with renunciant orders, and the two spiritual seekers quickly secure audiences with six of the leading tīrthika teachers.[n.26] The pair questions each teacher about his practice and philosophy, and each is found to teach a ruinous path and rejected.[n.27] Eventually Upatiṣya and Kolita come across the teacher Sañjayin who, they are told, has “withdrawn into seclusion.” Duly impressed, they are won over and join his order upon hearing his philosophy—that “the Dharma is truth and nonviolence; the peaceful, ageless, immortal, and unwaning state is Brahman.” Before long, however, Sañjayin passes away and the two move on, bringing the first section to a conclusion.

**i.16** [79b9c72a-90e3-467f-b0d9-373e32aa6e7d] On first encounter this section is disorienting. It begins by meandering through an account of the struggle between the kingdoms of Aṅga and Magadha, with a brief interlude describing the Buddha’s birth, before tracing the rise of two brahmins named Māṭhara and Tiṣya. Only after thirty pages of war and genealogy do we meet the two main protagonists. To appreciate the purpose of this long prologue, one must step back to view the *Vinayavastu* as a whole and understand that interwoven through the text’s seventeen chapters is one of the most extensive biographies of the Buddha available in any language.[n.28] These first episodes, then, are more than mere diversion; they are the first installments of an epic tale that takes shape over the *Vinayavastu*’s 2,500 pages.

**i.17** [c04973dd-434e-4938-92cd-07a297c56267] From a literary perspective, this first chapter exemplifies the *Vinayavastu*’s composite nature,[n.29] where history sits embedded between parable and technical manual. While we know almost nothing about by whom, how, or why this text was compiled in this way, this synthesis is not likely to be ad hoc or random. Rather, diverse elements are drawn in and made to serve a range of purposes. The tale of the six tīrthika teachers, for example, fulfills narrative, partisan, and historical ends. Narratively, it explains how Upatiṣya and Kolita eventually came to the Buddha’s order. In its telling, it emphasizes their exacting standards so that their rejection of each teacher’s philosophy and eventual embrace of the Buddha’s implies the superiority of the Buddhist order.

**i.18** [70600b66-6785-468b-9b85-4013f866056c] Historically speaking, it surveys the spiritual landscape of Greater Magadha at the time of the Buddha. Though the text does not emphasize the connections, scholars have linked several of the tīrthika teachers to the major non-Vedic orders of the day: Jñātiputra is better known as Mahāvīra, leader of the Nirgrantha Jain order and the last Jain Tīrthankara; Gośālīputra was a prominent Ājīvika leader;[n.30] Ajita may have been an important Cārvāka teacher;[n.31] and Pūraṇa has been called the foremost of five hundred Ājīvikas, though the philosophy attributed to him here resembles neither Gośālīputra’s fatalism nor that of the Digambara Jains whom Buddhists sometimes referred to as Ājīvikas.[n.32]

### The Rite of Admission into the Renunciant Order

**i.19** [2dc6bae4-6306-4538-b33b-1926df3c5583] The second third of the text describes the way the admission rite changed as the Buddha’s renunciant order grew. A short interlude under the heading “Querying Upasena” then spells out the terms of a new monk’s apprenticeship to a more senior monk and provides criteria to determine when a monk is sufficiently established in his ordination to live as a teacher and act as a preceptor or instructor himself.

**i.20** [5d755af8-cb2c-4479-a93b-00483403864f] Those familiar with the modern-day ordination rite may be surprised by the original rite’s simplicity. Postulants, personified by Upatiṣya and Kolita in this chapter, would ask the Buddha for permission to join his order. With the words, “Come, monks. Live the holy life,” the Buddha admitted them into his order and ordained them monks. This simple invitation is known as the “ordination by saying, ‘Monk, come.’ ”

**i.21** [fa97d0a3-b6a0-4893-816e-e9534b845168] But as the Buddha’s fame grew, it became less practicable for the Buddha himself to accept and ordain every postulant. While the rite itself was simple enough, anyone wanting to go forth had to see the Buddha in person, which for some meant a long and arduous journey. When the Buddha heard that a postulant coming to see him had died on the way, he permitted the saṅgha to admit new members and ordain them.

**i.22** [0b5e4bc3-a7f9-4b6d-ab4d-c0c266688968] The monks, not knowing how to admit and ordain postulants, asked the Blessed One about it, and he responded by prescribing a short but formalized rite now known as the “Early Rite.” The new rite required postulants to request the saṅgha three times, after which an officiant monk would move that the saṅgha act on the request. By remaining silent, the saṅgha signaled its assent, and the postulant was formally admitted to the order and ordained a monk.

**i.23** [f9695c1a-8fed-43b2-8b9f-0ce47aa9de68] Since the Early Rite permitted monks to accept new members but made no provisions for training them, the new rite solved a logistical problem but did nothing to address an equally, if not more, pressing problem: helping new members establish themselves in a new code of conduct and a new way of life. Consequently, some new monks had no sense of decorum and were poorly behaved. Local brahmins and householders even complained of being harassed by them. The new monks would come to town to beg alms, disheveled and improperly dressed, speaking shrilly in loud voices, behaving wildly, and demanding they be fed.

**i.24** [b9af5289-f09a-424e-baef-19f587105380] When a monk fell ill and died for lack of someone to nurse him, the elder monks felt obliged to take action. Such gross neglect of one’s fellow brahmacārin was too much and the saṅgha asked the Buddha to intervene. After some consideration, the Buddha created the positions of preceptor and instructor and charged the monks in those roles with the responsibility of ordaining and instructing new monks.

**i.25** [0884a2f5-97fe-4f9f-bcf3-d0094caa9f8a] But again the monks found themselves in a quandary, not knowing how to admit and ordain postulants, and so again they asked the Buddha. This time, the Buddha prescribed a longer and more formal rite of admission and ordination, with stricter acceptance criteria and a novel division of the community into lay vow holders, novices, and monks. This rite pertains to the present day and is known in the tradition as the “Present Day Rite.”

**i.26** [cce623a0-100b-408f-93fd-b1dfd66ab208] The Present Day Rite codified a hierarchy in the Buddhist renunciant order, through which a postulant gains admission into the order, is inducted into the novitiate, and is ordained a monk. An outline of the ritual found in the text is given in the appendix, “An Outline of the Ordination Rite.”

### Admission Criteria

**i.27** [cc514dbf-5a77-4757-ac1d-7edc743ce4ef] The final third of the text goes back in time to examine the circumstances that prompted the introduction of a screening process for postulants. The exclusionary criteria, deemed “impediments to ordination,” are all explained by origin stories (Tib. *gleng gzhi*, Skt. *nidāna*), as exemplified by the chapter “Creatures.”
     
**i.28** [5f310db0-ca5c-4520-8845-0d735dc711fb] This chapter, by far the longest in the section, tells the story of Saṅgharakṣita, ostensibly to explain why creatures—specifically nāgas that can assume human form—are not allowed to join the Buddhist renunciant order. Several lesser origin stories, explaining, for instance, what a monk administrator can be expected to account for and why a monk should not teach without first being asked to do so, are enfolded into the greater story of Saṅgharakṣita and the nāga monk.

**i.29** [de5ecf0e-47a0-4b3f-9fb2-331aa00c7f7d] This section also contains several *avadāna*, most notably in the story of how a shape-shifting nāga gained the karma to become a monk. *Avadāna* are didactic stories (or “karmic histories”) that explain a given circumstance in light of the past act that brought it about.[n.33] Other examples of *avadāna* from this section include what happens when monks fight over food, deface saṅgha property, and withhold food and drink from other monks.

**i.30** [cbe62db3-4218-40cb-a2a4-d5eb5065c559] The layering does not end there, either. A Vedic seer’s sarcastic remark about Buddhist monks’ propensity to preach at the slightest provocation becomes the pretext for Saṅgharakṣita’s teaching the *Nagaropama Sūtra*, while Saṅgharakṣita’s efforts to establish the Buddha’s teachings in the land of nāgas becomes a chance to discuss the Sūtra Piṭaka’s “Four Divisions of the Discourses.”[n.34]

**i.31** [6afde71e-2ffa-4302-9ff5-3e377a22b174] The intertwining of genres seen in Saṅgharakṣita’s story is probably the best example in the present chapter of the Mūlasarvāstivādin Vinaya’s bricolage composition and the way stories, sūtras, and catalogs of monastic discipline are woven into a narrative meant to both instruct and inspire.

### Academic Work and Prior Translations

**i.32** [d8574c28-6b1f-4d35-addf-126269d21dd7] In 1983, Helmut Eimer published a critical edition of the Tibetan, and a study in German, of “The Chapter on Going Forth” but did not attempt a translation.[n.35]

**i.33** [70ca257e-57ef-4e80-b297-b6a80a52b48a] Soon afterwards, in a series of four articles, Claus Vogel and Klaus Wille published a carefully revised edition of the Sanskrit fragments of the *Pravrajyāvastu* recovered in Gilgit.[n.36] They scrupulously annotated the editorial process to produce an edition that, in contrast to earlier Sanskrit editions, is free of reconstructions and indicates clearly the uncertainties created by damage to, or missing portions of, the original manuscripts. They also incorporated further fragments of the manuscript that had not been definitively identified at the time previous Sanskrit editions were prepared. The fragments fall into two groups: those from the beginning of the chapter (Sanskrit folios 2–12), and those toward the end (folios 43–53). Together these Sanskrit fragments correspond to about one hundred of the 261 pages of the chapter in the Degé Kangyur. To place the fragments in their proper context, Vogel also translated relevant sections of the text, from the Tibetan for the portions corresponding to folios 2–12, and from the Sanskrit for the portions corresponding to folios 43–53.

**i.34** [dd442db2-a350-410a-85e4-379489dfdabe] In the present translation, the exact correlations between the Sanskrit and the Tibetan are noted in the form of folio references to Vogel and Wille’s edition (folio numbers preceded by S) as well as the usual folio references to the Tibetan of the Degé (preceded by F).

**i.35** [ed6147b2-ff53-40c0-b8e8-e7bfad650f29] Andy Rotman has translated from Sanskrit many of the *avadāna* narratives to be found in the *Divyāvadāna*, a collection of such stories compiled in Nepal and dating probably to the seventeenth century. The individual stories in the *Divyāvadāna* very closely match equivalent passages in the *Vinayavastu* or, in some cases, other sections of the Mūlasarvāstivāda Vinaya. In the present first chapter, the only parallels to the *Divyāvadāna* are the narratives of Saṅgharakṣita and the shape-shifting nāga, which can be found translated in Rotman’s second volume.[n.37] There are several other translations of the same passage from the *Divyāvadāna*.[n.38]

### The Language of Renunciation

**i.36** [50108211-b78a-4a1c-9fda-b1be1de0e20a] One of the difficulties in translating vinaya texts lies in finding appropriate English equivalents for the language of Buddhist monasticism. In several instances we have borrowed terms from Christianity such as “ordination” and “monk,” even though they may only bear a superficial similarity to their Buddhist analogs.[n.39] Another difficulty lies in the historical fact that the language of Buddhist renunciation was adapted from a body of terms and ideas common among Greater Magadhan ascetic communities in the sixth and fifth centuries *ʙᴄᴇ*.[n.40] As is to be expected when different religious communities employ the same words, they come to have unique connotations, the most relevant of which we might now consider.

**i.37** [f98a4f42-bc94-46ac-93b5-1f738492bafe] First and foremost is the term *pravrajyā*, which in its widest application referred to the act of “going forth,” that is, renouncing the settled life of a householder to live as a wandering ascetic. In pre-Buddhist India, the act of going forth often took a ritual form and was made dramatically visible “by shaving off the hair and beard and laying aside the layman’s dress, to cover oneself with rags, with bark or hemp, or to wander in the nude.”[n.41] In the present translation, we render *pravrajyā* (Tib. *rab tu ’byung ba*) as “to go forth” (or, in a small number of cases, “to join the renunciant order”) while one who goes forth (Tib. *rab byung*) is a “renunciant.”

**i.38** [d7a286f1-bf21-4d72-9779-e69fdb0aee5f] In the *Pravrajyāvastu*, we meet several Vedic and non-Vedic ascetics who have undertaken *pravrajyā*. Some, such as Gośālīputra and the Lokāyata ascetic Dīrghanakha, are described as “wandering mendicants” or *parivrājaka*,[n.42] but those who join the Buddha’s order are described as *śramaṇa*, translated here as “ascetic.”[n.43] The term *śramaṇa*, from the verbal root *śram* meaning “to toil,” was used to describe non-Vedic ascetics, especially Buddhist and Jain ones.[n.44] In our text, it is applied repeatedly to both the Buddha and his followers, as when an older man posing as a monk challenges the authenticity of the Buddha’s ordained status by asking, “Who is the *śramaṇa* Gautama’s preceptor?” and in the phrase “the *śramaṇa* sons of the Śākya.”

**i.39** [e1824aba-90ed-4907-af61-db1344028f73] The Buddha’s followers accepted this as an appropriate designation, as when Śāriputra says to Buddharakṣita, “It is those who issue from people like you that become my *śramaṇa* attendants.” As the Buddha himself also frequently referred to his community as *śramaṇa*, it is not surprising that the term chosen to describe “novice” *śramaṇa* was *śrāmaṇera* , the diminutive form of *śramaṇa*.

**i.40** [a5103004-c64e-481a-991c-a3d675e8a657] Ascetic sons of the Śākya who ordained were called *bhikṣu*. This term, too, was used outside the Buddhist tradition. Gautama, the brahmin author of the *Gautama Dharmasūtra*, gives *bhikṣu*, meaning “mendicant,” as the third of four lifestyles open to followers of the Vedas.[n.45] In this context, a mendicant was either an ascetic who relied on alms (partly or fully provided by relatives) or a hermit who had severed all ties with his former worldly life.

**i.41** [e5b1ff81-17b4-41ba-b979-9d2e00a61e4d] Another phrase that points to a shared language among ascetics is the term *brahmacaryā*, rendered here as “to live the holy life.” This phrase appears repeatedly in this chapter in stock passages, most significantly in the Buddha’s invitation, “Come, monk. Live the holy life,” and in the remark made by those who have attained arhatship: “My births have come to an end, I have lived the holy life, I have done what needed doing, I will know no lives after this one.”

**i.42** [f6c6a935-d447-410e-bb9c-f377f4e92e3d] The phrase also figures prominently in Śāriputra and Maudgalyāyana’s questions for the six tīrthika teachers: “What is the result of living the holy life? What are its benefits?” Although the exact meaning of the phrase is never spelled out, the commentator Kalyāṇamitra glosses it as a life of “hardships” or “austerities.”[n.46] Kalyāṇamitra’s interpretation is probably best understood as an explanation of Śāriputra and Maudgalyāyana’s assumptions about what it meant to “live the holy life.” For, as a Jain, Jñātiputra would certainly have equated “the holy life” with austerities, but it is not certain whether any of the other five would have.[n.47] It does, however, seem likely that many of these teachers would have understood “the holy life” to entail celibacy; and that is how the term is now understood in the Buddhist tradition, where a lay vow holder who takes a vow of celibacy is described as a *brahmacārin upāsaka* (Tib. *tshangs spyod dge bsnyen*).

**i.43** [7c946015-71a6-415f-82e9-529f5022a797] Among followers of the Vedas during the Buddha’s lifetime, *brahmacaryā* referred to a student’s apprenticeship to a teacher. It was expected that a student live “a holy life,” which implied celibacy.[n.48]

### The Translation

**i.44** [005913d0-fcf4-4585-a754-2c42da35fd0f] The present translation is based on the Tibetan text in the Degé Kangyur, with reference to the text in other Kangyurs as detailed in the endnotes. Ven. Lhundup Damchö’s draft translation of the extant Sanskrit found in Nalinaksha Dutt’s *Gilgit Manuscripts*, together with Claus Vogel and Klaus Wille’s revised Sanskrit edition and translation, were used as guides to check for variations between the Tibetan and Sanskrit. Although there are numerous differences between the Tibetan and Sanskrit manuscripts, very few of them bear significantly on the overall understanding of the text. We have chosen to note only the most important divergences and, for the rest, would refer readers to Vogel and Wille’s works.

**i.45** [e3d9d941-6360-467f-8ced-b135b0cedf53] A great many of our translation choices are based on glosses given by the late eighth-century master Kalyāṇamitra[n.49] in his *Extensive Commentary on The Chapters of Discipline*.[n.50] On the whole, Kalyāṇamitra’s citations mirror the relevant passages from the root text. However, there is enough variation between the root text and his commentary—direct quotations purportedly from the root text which have no correlate in any of the Tibetan redactions, important passages of the root text not glossed in the commentary, differences in key terms—to suggest Kalyāṇamitra may have been working from a different edition of the *Vinayavastu* than that which was available to the Tibetan translators and their Indian informants.[n.51] And although it does not bear directly on the present work, it should also be noted that the Tibetan translation of Kalyāṇamitra’s commentary appears to be incomplete. Presumably, Kalyāṇamitra commented on all seventeen chapters of the *Vinayavastu*, but the Degé, Coné, and Narthang editions of his commentary all end abruptly after the thirteenth fascicle, four pages into his comments on the *Vinayavastu*’s third chapter, the *Pravāraṇāvastu*.[n.52]

**i.46** [ded6c402-95fc-43e0-aca4-a0091dddcc91] The *Vinayavastu* contains a great deal of repetition. Such repetition ranges in length from short, stock phrases to an entire chapter in which the only change is in the gender of a single character (see “Matricide” and “Patricide”). Aiming to retain the original work’s style and flavor, which may point to its oral origins, in accordance with 84000’s editorial policies we have avoided the temptation to elide these repetitive passages. On the other hand, we have tried in places to help the reader by inserting proper names in places where the original provides only pronouns.

**i.47** [4675a0fb-b0ac-44b3-b5a0-083e2058a2f0] Though technically the present work is the first of the *Vinayavastu*’s seventeen chapters, we have chosen to break the “chapter” into parts based on the list of contents found in the prologue and those parts into chapters based on the indices found at the start of each section.

**i.48** [e221634f-4c9e-4d8b-b69a-b241ec3cbca5] In the chapter on the ordination rite itself, the Tibetan text gives a short heading for each part of the ritual *at the end* of the relevant section. To assist the reader and conform to English typographical norms, we have placed the heading at the start of the relevant section.

**i.49** [f9f7ee5a-54b0-4dce-b240-7f92f23c809e] In closing, we ask forbearance for whatever mistakes and omissions the translation contains.

## The Translation

**The Chapters on Monastic Discipline**

### Prologue to *The Chapters on Monastic Disciplin*e

**p1.1** [fa8e47fd-3748-48a9-bef4-3be917b7fe06] Homage to the Three Jewels.

**p1.2** [fa51d513-cdd5-43ca-bccf-66f631eec49e] Homage to him who severed the bonds,
Destroyed the whole host of tīrthikas,
Vanquished the armies of Māra,
And thus discovered this awakening.

**p1.3** [077ccd4e-19e3-4f8e-9d1e-7a770262d3c7] To begin with, it is hard to renounce a householder’s concerns and go forth.
Having gone forth, it is hard to find happiness in wandering.
It is hard to do well what one pledged to with delight.
It is hard for a skilled wearer of the ochre robes to fail.

**p1.4** [ccc7d61e-c794-4b32-a504-4c7031c04f8d] *The Chapters on Monastic Discipline* *includes* *chapters* *on:*
*Going forth**,* *restoration**,*
*Lifting restrictions**, the rains, leather,*
*Medicine, robes, turning cloth into robes,*
*The monks of* *Kauśāmbī**, formal* *acts* *of saṅgha,*
*A group of troublesome monks, types of persons,*
*Probations**,* *suspension* *of the* *restoration**,*
*Housing,* *disputes, and schisms in the saṅgha.*[n.53]

**The Chapter on Going Forth**

### Prologue to *The Chapter on Going Fort*h

**p2.1** [db59f3cd-4493-4fa5-9b19-8b4177094641] *The whole of The Chapter on Going Forth
Is told in sections on:
Śāriputra, tīrthikas,
The two novices, scaring a crow,
Killing an arhat, and missing hands.*

### Śāriputra

**1.1** [37f04388-95f5-4b88-b779-71cae42e9553] *The Śāriputra section is told over five chapters:
Śāriputra, going forth, refuge, a summary of Upasena’s collection, and a summary of the fives.*

#### Śāriputra

**1.2** [11f247ec-62df-45ae-915b-c59088d7efc0] While the Bodhisattva was dwelling in the Abode of Tuṣita, the King of Aṅga ruled over the lands of Aṅga. Under his rule, the kingdom prospered and thrived, crops were bountiful and the land teemed with animals and people. Meanwhile, King Mahāpadma ruled over the lands of Magadha. Under his rule, the kingdom prospered and thrived, crops were bountiful and the land teemed with animals and people. At times, the King of Aṅga and his armies were dominant. At other times, King Mahāpadma and his armies were dominant.

**1.3** [e39dcbf3-6306-4a06-8e55-58220f8fdf38] At a time when the King of Aṅga and his armies were dominant, he called up the four branches of his armed forces—the elephant corps, the cavalry, the charioteer corps, and the infantry—and laid waste to all of Magadha, save Rājagṛha, before returning.

**1.4** [4f3d434c-0947-48d1-87e1-66385f36a2b7] At a time when King Mahāpadma and his armies were dominant, he too called up the four branches of his armed forces—the elephant corps, the cavalry, the charioteer corps, and the infantry—and laid waste to all of Aṅga, save Campā, before returning.
                                                                               
At yet another time when the King of Aṅga and his armies were dominant, he again called up the four branches of his armed forces—the elephant corps, the cavalry, the charioteer corps, and the infantry—and began again to lay waste to the land of Magadha, prompting the people of Magadha to send a message to King Mahāpadma, saying, “Your Majesty, the King of Aṅga has called up the four branches of his armed forces—the elephant corps, the cavalry, the charioteer corps, and the infantry—and is laying waste to the lands of Magadha.”

**1.5** [ac88ee23-2234-4460-a7b5-62a5f7e66c9c] When King Mahāpadma heard this, he too called up the four branches of his armed forces—the elephant corps, the cavalry, the charioteer corps, and the infantry—and rode out to meet the King of Aṅga in battle.

The King of Aṅga captured King Mahāpadma’s entire elephant corps and proceeded to capture the whole of his cavalry, charioteer corps, and infantry. Defeated and frightened, destroyed and conquered, King Mahāpadma retreated. Entering Rājagṛha, he closed the gates and shut himself up within the walls of his fortress.

**1.6** [3053ca7f-9314-44b3-b2af-b5afbc13f695] The King of Aṅga sent an envoy to King Mahāpadma with the message, “It would be good were you to come out. If you do not surrender, and instead take flight into the sky above, I will fell you with a volley of arrows. Tunnel beneath the earth and I will yank you up as if with a hook. Flee to the mountaintops, and even there you shall find no escape.”

**1.7** [fd50af0d-3f87-49ba-8cec-e1576861a158] King Mahāpadma was unsettled by the message he heard.[n.54] Head in hands, he sat and sat, absorbed in thought.[n.55] Then he said to his ministers, “Gentlemen, this King of Aṅga is belligerent, ruthless, and his military might is great. If he gives an order, how can we not obey?”

**1.8** [022ccdeb-345c-44e3-841b-ef868b29d77b] They spoke in verse:
“When land and life are threatened,
Seek always to protect life.
When the wise look at both, they see
Land, but not life, can be found again.”

**1.9** [f09f544c-1fce-4ddf-816d-dbd61f1825da] They then implored him, “Your Majesty, any way you look at it, you must go out!”

King Mahāpadma hung his sword from his neck in surrender and went out, where the King of Aṅga imposed an annual tribute and tax upon him.

**1.10** [d96c0bdf-4d1e-4f43-b2f0-e8d7c9337451] While the blessed Bodhisattva was dwelling in the Abode of Tuṣita, he saw five sights[n.56] and thrice gave notice to the six classes of gods who revel in the desire realm. Assuming an elephant’s appearance, he entered his mother’s womb as the earth shook and this world and all others too were bathed in a vast light more luminous than the glow of the gods of the Thirty-Three. So great was this miraculous manifestation, it was as if the sun and moon shone in the gulf between worlds.[n.57] So great was its strength that darkness everywhere, even the pitch-black darkness of dark places dark from never knowing the light of the sun and moon, was filled with a vast light. Beings born in those places had never even seen so far as their outstretched hands, yet by this light these beings saw one another and exclaimed, “You there! There are others who have been born here! There are others who have been born here!”

**1.11** [969e5dd8-627c-450d-8fa7-57d083a7d7ec] At the same time as the blessed Bodhisattva was born, sons were also born to four great kings in four great city-states. In Rājagṛha the son of King Mahāpadma was born. In Śrāvastī the son of King Arāḍa Brahmadatta was born. In Ujjayinī the son of King Anantanemi was born. In Kauśāmbī the son of King Śatānīka was born.

**1.12** [ecd95b72-ee90-4c8f-9224-a4092af0f1f3] When the blessed Bodhisattva was born, the entire universe was bathed in a vast light more luminous than the glow of the gods of the Thirty-Three. So great was this miraculous manifestation, it was as if the sun and moon shone in the gulf between worlds. So great was its strength that darkness everywhere, even the pitch-black darkness of dark places dark from never knowing the light of the sun and moon, was filled with a vast light. Beings born in those places had never even seen so far as their outstretched hands, yet by this light these beings saw one another and exclaimed, “You there! There are others who have been born here! There are others who have been born here!”

**1.13** [29750908-f0c6-4478-834a-ef1289352d3b] King Mahāpadma thought, “When my son was born, the world was lit as if by the gold of the rising sun. And as he is the son of Queen Bimbī (Goldie), I shall name this prince Bimbisāra (Essence of Gold).” And so the boy was named Bimbisāra.

King Arāḍa Brahmadatta thought, “When my son was born, the world was lit as if by the light of lights, so I shall name this prince Prasenajit (Supreme Light).” And so the boy was named Prasenajit.

King Śatānīka thought, “When my son was born, the world was lit as if by the rising sun, so I shall name this prince Udayana (Rising).” And so the boy was named Udayana.

King Anantanemi thought, “When my son was born, the world was lit by a brilliant light, so I shall name this prince Pradyota (Brilliant Light).” And so the boy was named Pradyota.

**1.14** [e27b8224-5172-48fd-a046-c69f13d3130f] And so each king attributed the light to the birth of his own son. Though each attributed it to his own son, it was not so. For all that occurred, occurred because of the Bodhisattva.

**1.15** [cf8ac80b-5e93-4f4e-a2fc-48112b4d1328] On the very same day that Prince Bimbisāra was born, five hundred sons of five hundred ministers were also born and were given names appropriate to their patrilineage. [S.2.a]

**1.16** [2396c76b-17fe-4125-9de5-b64e14254d2d] Prince Bimbisāra was entrusted to eight nursemaids:[n.58] two to cuddle him, two to breastfeed him, two to change his diapers, and two to play with him.[n.59] Fortified with milk, curd, butter, ghee, cream, and other nourishing foods, he grew quickly, shooting up like a lotus in a pond. When he was old enough, he was introduced to letters, number names, calculation, counting by hand, expenditures, revenues, and deposits.[n.60] After he finished letters, he became skilled in exegesis, recitation, knowledge, proper conduct,[n.61] and the way to assess gems, sites, fabrics, woods, elephants, horses, women, and men.

**1.17** [d189ca09-6136-4254-8aaf-f10ded0bdded] He trained in and mastered the different fields of arts and skills of anointed kṣatriya kings, or a ruler of the realm endowed with the might and vigor to conquer the wide face of the earth, such as riding on the neck of an elephant, riding horseback, charioteering, swordsmanship, archery, advancing, yielding, wielding a hook, throwing a lasso, casting a spear, and how to hold a weapon, march, tie a topknot,[n.62] slash, quarter, pierce, and strike in five ways—striking from a distance, striking a target using acoustic location, striking a fatal blow, striking without hesitation, and striking forcefully.

These arts and skills were also mastered by the five hundred sons of the five hundred ministers.

**1.18** [41eb5d4a-4a81-4deb-a4c2-9b902f69e404] Bimbisāra’s father enrolled him in the eighteen guilds, due to which he was named and became known as Bimbisāra of the Guilds.[n.63]

**1.19** [eab34f16-ae80-42c9-b850-170f4b8a1266] Later Prince Bimbisāra set out astride an elephant where he saw the King of Aṅga’s officers collecting tributes and taxes, prompting him to inquire of his men, “Gentlemen, for whom are these tributes and taxes being collected?”

“Your Majesty! For the King of Aṅga.”

**1.20** [b526d99e-a36c-4350-b879-0feda9c58137] “What? Will we be offered tribute?”

“No, Your Majesty, we are the ones to offer the tribute.”

“Gentlemen, summon those officers.”

**1.21** [5afb85d9-840a-439a-89d6-adf57bc4818a] When the officers were summoned, he said, “Gentlemen, the King of Aṅga is crowned and an anointed kṣatriya king. If I too am crowned and an anointed a kṣatriya king, why is it you are collecting tributes and taxes here? I forbid you to collect tributes and taxes from this day forth.”

**1.22** [d4910fc6-7e8f-435c-8c75-8aebc2026ee6] “The prince fails to appreciate the situation,” they thought. “Let us go submit the matter to King Mahāpadma.”

**1.23** [b829f634-3d1b-46a0-ac9b-77da11be01c4] They went to King Mahāpadma and said, “Your Majesty, when we officers of the King of Aṅga were collecting tributes and taxes, Prince Bimbisāra stopped us from doing so. Shall we collect them or not?”

“Gentlemen, the prince doesn’t understand the situation. Continue to collect tributes and taxes as you have done before.”

**1.24** [db1837fd-a790-4e57-973d-20ad4a11037e] They had begun their collection again when Prince Bimbisāra spotted them on their way back and said, “Gentlemen, have I not already prohibited you from collecting tributes and taxes? Why are you collecting them again? You are to desist. Fail to desist and I shall close the borders.”

**1.25** [32f7fe67-4c7e-4021-b65d-d2c8fc5cc304] Frightened, they thought, “The prince is dangerous and ruthless. In time he may pose a serious risk to us. We must go warn the King of Aṅga.”

**1.26** [e0a5ea21-45f9-4c31-85ec-92bbdb44f137] They went before the King of Aṅga and said, “Your Majesty, as officers of the court, we were collecting tributes and taxes on your behalf when King Mahāpadma’s son, Prince Bimbisāra, stopped us. If Your Majesty [S.2.b] ignores the prince’s actions, he may, in time, pose a serious risk to us.”

**1.27** [a022a186-53d5-4840-878e-53ef44a650ab] Then they spoke in verse:
“When a tree is small,
Fingernails may fell it.
Yet when the tree is large,
Even a hundred axes may fail.”

**1.28** [2cc463af-dbb4-434c-a068-19679e63bffc] The King of Aṅga sent a letter to King Mahāpadma: “Send Prince Bimbisāra with his sword hung from his neck—or prepare your pyre and shroud, for I myself will come!”

**1.29** [67098123-b10b-4882-9e6b-f183c33d9b74] King Mahāpadma heard this letter read and was troubled. Head in hands, he sat and sat, absorbed in thought. Then he summoned Prince Bimbisāra and said, “Son, why did you stop the King of Aṅga’s officers from collecting tributes and taxes? They have sent me a letter expressing their anger.”

**1.30** [61e90241-65f5-49b1-b9ee-91d91d01f594] “Your Majesty, why do we pay tribute and taxes to him?”

“Son, we are tributaries.”

**1.31** [5fe80c56-ce6f-4caf-8dd0-22cfbb98ae97] “If the King of Aṅga is an anointed a kṣatriya king and we too are anointed kṣatriya kings, why do we offer tribute and taxes to him? Give me an army of just four divisions, Your Majesty, and I will meet the King of Aṅga in battle.”

**1.32** [12a8c380-863c-492e-a523-7efe5b367a8d] King Mahāpadma then sent a message to the King of Aṅga, saying, “You had best hope all the power, forces, will, and authority you possess do not fail you!”

The King of Aṅga found this message intolerable and commanded his ministers, “Gentlemen, lay waste to those lands! Call up the four branches of the armed forces.”

**1.33** [d2a0b71a-7c0c-4634-8362-988bf4a50325] Having called up the four branches of the armed forces—the elephant corps, the cavalry, the charioteer corps, and the infantry—they began to lay waste to the land of Magadha. The people of Magadha sent a message to King Mahāpadma, saying, “Your Majesty, the King of Aṅga has called up the four branches of his armed forces—the elephant corps, the cavalry, the charioteer corps, and the infantry—and is laying waste to the lands of Magadha.”

**1.34** [063a6f24-71bc-48ed-8e98-674acc4f03b9] King Mahāpadma was troubled by this news and, head in hands, sat and sat, absorbed in thought. He summoned Prince Bimbisāra and gave him charge over the four branches of the armed forces. Prince Bimbisāra gathered the five hundred ministers’ sons and said, “Gentlemen, what if I were to meet the King of Aṅga in battle? What would you do?”

**1.35** [67a6b920-b014-41ac-b4ae-a3671056fa8d] “Prince, your struggle shall be our struggle!” they responded.

**1.36** [724adbed-d81a-4fd7-87b3-74752168a776] Then they said in verse:
“In whose house dwells glory,
It is he we should protect.
If he falls, then all fall,
As spokes at a hub’s collapse.”

**1.37** [b6dfab25-c6f7-4bfe-9e56-dc05beda50fa] Prince Bimbisāra said, “Now you must do all you can to protect me.”

“Whatever Your Majesty’s plight may be, that too shall be ours. Wherever Your Majesty’s foot may fall, there shall we bow our heads.”

**1.38** [45f861d7-c1b5-4fde-aaa9-f1157af8a1c0] The four branches of the armed forces were then called up and they set out from Rājagṛha. When King Mahāpadma, who sat shut up in his upper citadel surrounded by his council, saw them depart, he asked his ministers, “Gentlemen, whose army is this?”

**1.39** [e6b2db1c-b9fe-4912-892e-54c4b85ff574] “Your Majesty, it is Prince Bimbisāra’s.”

“Gentlemen! It is awesome to behold!”

Hence, the prince was named and became known as Bimbisāra of the Army. Some knew him as Bimbisāra of the Guilds while some knew him as Bimbisāra of the Army.

**1.40** [87ca7cdc-00c0-4e9f-8361-615b755213a3] Prince Bimbisāra said to the five hundred sons of the ministers, “Gentlemen, this King of Aṅga is belligerent, ruthless, and his military might is great so we cannot meet him in battle. Therefore, we will sneak in, overrun his exposed camp, and kill him while their guard is down and their armor off.”

**1.41** [363f3cce-a4fb-4717-a6bf-6e7047128474] They overran the King of Aṅga’s exposed camp while their guard was down and their armor off, sneaking up and killing him. The four branches of the King of Aṅga’s armed forces scattered to the four directions. Prince Bimbisāra sent mounted emissaries in the four directions with the message, [S.3.a] “Gentlemen, you are anointed kṣatriya kings, and I too am an anointed kṣatriya king, so return! Gentlemen, I will support you!”

**1.42** [3e3c12c6-a745-4228-9c59-f416c8622632] He whom the King of Aṅga left to defend the city of Campā heard how the King of Aṅga had been killed, prompting him to close the gates and take cover within the walls of the fortress. When at last Prince Bimbisāra reached Campā, the prince fixed the King of Aṅga’s head onto a long pole and displayed it, saying, “It is I who has brought your lord to this state. Come out immediately and I shall look favorably upon you. Fail to appear and you too will soon find yourself in this state.”

**1.43** [8075b632-0423-441b-87d5-81d65d26d16e] It distressed the steward of Campā to hear this, and he thought of this verse:
“When land and life are threatened,
Seek always to protect life.
When the wise look at both, they see
Land, but not life, can be found again.”

**1.44** [8bccb370-fcba-4bac-85bd-eb2620d5b243] With that thought he hung his sword from his neck in surrender and came out.

With the King of Aṅga slain, Campā fell into Prince Bimbisāra’s hands, at which point he sent a message to King Mahāpadma, saying, “Your Majesty, I have slain the King of Aṅga and Campā is now in my hands. Your Majesty, tell me what else needs to be done and I shall see to it.”

**1.45** [03b12c77-04e5-4999-a564-0d98f8d09954] Pleased, King Mahāpadma sent Prince Bimbisāra a parasol, a turban, and a coronet with the message, “Son, you must take the reins of power there. I, for my part, will assume the reins of power here.”

**1.46** [d4af220c-416b-453a-a0f7-5783cf268848] And so Prince Bimbisāra assumed the reins of power. Under him, the kingdom prospered and thrived, crops were bountiful and the land teemed with animals and people.

**1.47** [7a0ee602-2c64-4b6f-9a00-2aaf04abf9f3] Once King Mahāpadma’s time had come, the ministers of Rājagṛha sent a message to King Bimbisāra, saying, “Your Majesty, your father’s time has come.” In a great coronation ceremony, the ministers of Rājagṛha and Magadha granted him sovereignty over the lands of Aṅga and Magadha.

**1.48** [d4837947-58c7-4add-b6fd-55b06793f4c1] Under King Bimbisāra’s rule, the kingdoms of Aṅga and Magadha prospered and thrived, crops were bountiful and the land teemed with animals and people. He completely pacified conflict, aggressors, and enemies from without as well as disturbances from within. He rid the land of brigands, thieves, famine, and illness, and brought a wealth of rice, sugar cane, cattle, and buffalo; thus the just Dharma king established a just kingdom.

**1.49** [a0b3859c-3568-4a31-b4db-464a528d4efc] There was a young brahmin who, desiring and in search of esoteric instruction, left the Middle Country and went to the South, where there was a brahmin to whom the Vedas and the limbs of the Vedas had been entrusted, who had been a teacher to brahmins living in a country to the south.[n.64]

**1.50** [b7d73940-949c-4f44-9447-82114686176b] The young brahmin went to see this teacher of brahmins. Serene, the young brahmin bowed his head calmly and sat off to one side. The brahmin teacher warmly greeted him with words of welcome, and asked, “Young brahmin, where have you come from and what do you desire?”

**1.51** [183e8461-7451-468b-9397-de92373f6120] “I hail from the Middle Country and I seek to serve at the feet of a preceptor.”

“Why?”

“So that I may study the Vedas.”

**1.52** [a8a36d07-fee5-4ced-8a86-7133260762d0] “Excellent, my son. You should do just that, for that is a brahmin’s duty.”

And so, the young brahmin began to study the Vedas with the teacher of brahmins.

**1.53** [fe51ee56-6090-48d3-9102-e545f2ae343e] The brahmins’ students were in the habit, when not occupied with their studies, of going to the riverbank to bathe, visiting the city, or collecting wood for use in fire pūjas.

**1.54** [b65cbec8-2486-4425-ab37-006cc8374b0d] Once, when not occupied with their studies, they went to collect wood for fire pūjas. On the way they had the following conversation. “Sons of Kutsa, sons of Vātsa, sons of Śāṇḍili, sons of Bhāradvāja, sons of the Five, sons of the Further Five.[n.65] To begin with, let us share where we come from, from which land we hail.”

**1.55** [7e724c4b-05a5-4e99-a475-7faf3da89ef4] “I am from the East,” one young brahmin responded.

“I am from the South,” said another.

**1.56** [a8c50734-5143-4831-9106-0395cf56f03b] “I am from the West.”

“I am from the North.”

**1.57** [068b2533-3661-47b1-8c54-3c222f0179ee] The young brahmin then said, “I am from the Middle Country.”

To him they said, [S.3.b] “Sir! We have seen and heard of all those other countries, but have neither seen nor heard of the Middle Country.”

**1.58** [2df89adb-4650-42f6-8b91-357658b88fc8] And then they added this verse:
“In the East they are wise,
In the South they are cunning,
In the West they stir division,
In the North they speak roughly.”

**1.59** [27bdf7a8-5275-4744-8bee-6a43a48140a8] “Young brahmin,” they asked, “what is the Middle Country like?”

“Gentlemen, the Middle Country is the best of all lands, abounding in rice, sugar cane, cattle, and buffalo, thronging with hundreds of honest women and filled with upstanding men, devoid of foreign savages, and guided by learned men. The river Gaṅgā, bountiful, meritorious, auspicious, and clean, flows through this famed land, irrigating both shores. At one point, where sages are known to gather, the river flows through eighteen bends. There, sages seek to bodily rise to the heavens through their practice of austerities.”[n.66]

**1.60** [78b8f224-67c1-40c7-aec3-979b236eb0c2] “Young brahmin, having met you, we have another question. Do you have men counted as learned in the Middle Country?”

“Gentlemen, from the first did I not say, ‘Gentlemen, the Middle Country is filled with upstanding men, devoid of foreign savages, and guided by learned men’?”

**1.61** [74535c93-5834-47c2-bc31-a28da3f8707b] “Young brahmin, you did say that. Young brahmin, are there any in the Middle Country like our preceptor, a bull among teachers?”

“Gentlemen, in the Middle Country, the teachers are such that our teacher could not even look them in the face, so eloquently do they speak, so wise are they.”

**1.62** [f2da2acf-5993-4c9e-867a-1a69ac65943d] On hearing the young brahmin speak so highly of the Middle Country, they were moved by the desire to visit it. The young brahmins then went off to collect wood for use in fire pūjas. Bearing their loads of wood, they came to the house in which the teacher of brahmins lived. On arriving, they set their loads of wood off to one side, went to him, and said, “Preceptor, please listen. The young brahmin from the Middle Country speaks so highly of it that we are moved by the desire to visit.”

**1.63** [339f540d-8f8b-4f07-9212-1b2da8d7e5f0] The brahmin said, “Boys, would you visit every place of which you hear? Since you seem to derive so much pleasure from hearing of other countries, I would suggest you not visit those places you hear about.”

**1.64** [c8f43297-4cf5-4d7a-b7e2-c6d8e5dc1796] “Preceptor, according to this young brahmin, in the Middle Country the teachers are such that you, our teacher, could not even look them in the face, so eloquently do they speak, so wise are they.”

**1.65** [16a4092d-dc7d-4171-81a6-2ed342aff410] “My sons, do I say I am the one and only teacher on this earth, that there are no other teachers? After all, since the earth contains many gems, its surface is covered with one beauty after another.”

**1.66** [7676e0a1-ba7b-4823-a93d-cedce4eb4683] “We will see that country yet, Preceptor, if only for a short while. We will bathe on the banks of the river, we will serve the bull among teachers, we will defeat opponents, we will make a name for ourselves and find our fortune, too. We will go to the Middle Country.”

**1.67** [19ad0c7e-32a7-4ecc-82cf-9c06de0b410d] As the brahmin was attached to his students and his circle of students was small, he said to the young brahmins, “In that case, my sons, let us gather our hides, bast robes, staffs, water jugs, ladles, and bowls and go to the Middle Country.”[n.67]

**1.68** [e401df08-a04c-432b-af1d-ba4b32766056] Having collected their things, the brahmin set off with the young brahmins for the Middle Country. Along the way, he defeated an opponent in debate, and then bound him to his chariot. He poured ashes from a pot on another’s head. Another steered clear of him like a crow does an archery range. Another received him with parasols, victory banners, and standards. Another made a pledge to become his student. As he went, he vanquished one opponent after another in villages, cities, towns, marketplaces, and hamlets until he reached Rājagṛha. [S.4.a]

**1.69** [6017cfe4-742d-45e8-bbab-5c6a93f388bc] The brahmin thought, “Why bother pulling off the branches, petals, and leaves while leaving the root? Since all worthy opponents and anyone counted as learned will be close to the king, it is the king I shall see.”

**1.70** [f54fd7af-9e6f-4578-bd6b-a2561b8581f0] With that, the brahmin went to see King Bimbisāra. On arriving, he wished King Bimbisāra success and long life, took a place off to one side, and addressed him: “Your Majesty, from my guru I have received a few teachings. And so I seek to settle a matter in debate with an opponent in Your Majesty’s presence.”

**1.71** [2ef68fd5-ff7a-4910-8187-afc2d9b675f4] The king asked his ministers, “Gentlemen, are there any opponents in my kingdom capable of settling a matter in debate with this brahmin?”

**1.72** [ba909e46-9bb1-481c-a528-69610de2ccb7] “Your Majesty, in the village of Nālada there is a brahmin known as Māṭhara who has been entrusted with the Vedas and the limbs of the Vedas. With blazing intelligence, this capable man illuminates his own assertions and smashes those of others. He has put together a work known as *Māṭhara’s Treatise*.”

**1.73** [0d8ff7da-f1f5-4935-9491-69a64eceee75] “Summon Master Māṭhara.”

“As you wish, Your Majesty.”

**1.74** [e99146b0-195e-4c85-a222-985d7b4ddc4a] Māṭhara received the summons and went to see King Bimbisāra. On arrival, he wished King Bimbisāra success and long life then took a place off to one side.

The ministers said, “This is the preceptor, Your Majesty.”

**1.75** [22eeb524-de07-48cb-ae21-5461d27a394a] The king greeted him with words of welcome and asked, “Preceptor, can you settle a matter in debate in my presence with this brahmin?”

“I, as a capable man, shall do as the king pleases,” replied Māṭhara.

**1.76** [480d4e43-16f6-46f9-8ae8-f80f7271b737] The king ordered the ministers, “Gentlemen, prepare the debate arena and assign the disputants their roles.”

**1.77** [1a55dc9d-89e4-487c-8a69-7a28e8724a5c] The ministers prepared the debate arena and assigned the disputants their roles. The ministers then prostrated at the king’s feet and asked, “Your Majesty, who would you have defend a position first?”

“This brahmin is a visitor so have him defend a position first.”

**1.78** [62535582-4343-41fe-addb-c71d7b276efd] Having been assigned to defend a position first, the brahmin proceeded to recite five hundred lines. Māṭhara repeated them and then said, “This position of yours is devoid of logic. It is inconsistent and incoherent.” The brahmin remained silent as Māṭhara pointed out the position’s flaws.

**1.79** [461f6dab-e61d-49ab-aed5-c105d57bd9e8] That the brahmin had no confidence to respond was damning and among the reasons he was vanquished. The king asked the ministers, “Gentlemen, who won?”

“Māṭhara, Your Majesty.”

**1.80** [fc6f874c-df87-49da-b860-0524cc64175d] This pleased the king, who straightened up, extended his right arm, and declared, “It is a fine discovery for me to find this bull among teachers in my kingdom!”

**1.81** [8e50cc1f-470d-403b-8dc3-a8f5d4333724] He saluted Māṭhara and asked, “Preceptor, where do you live?”

“Your Majesty, in Nālada.”

“Go, and let that village be your victor’s prize.”[n.68]

**1.82** [ef490531-773f-4130-b150-19e155b82f65] Māṭhara was thrilled, delighted, and overjoyed. Surrounded by learned men, he returned to his village. And since the world desires success and distrusts failure, several brahmins pressed their daughters on him in marriage. Māṭhara then took a wife of equal caste and together they played with, took pleasure in, and amused one another. The wife with whom he had played, taken pleasure, and amused himself gave birth to a son with an extraordinarily long torso. Three weeks or twenty-one days after the birth, relatives came and gathered to celebrate his birth in grand style, during which time they chose a name for the boy. The relatives said, “Since this boy has an extraordinarily long torso, he should be named Koṣṭhila (Long Torso).”

**1.83** [4a87b8a6-5946-4b0a-87c0-71397b616d33] The young brahmin was entrusted to eight nursemaids: two to cuddle him, two to breastfeed him, two to change his diapers, and two to play with him.[n.69] Fortified with milk, curd, butter, ghee, cream, and other nourishing foods, he grew quickly, shooting up like a lotus in a pond. When he was old enough, he was introduced to letters, number names, calculation, counting by hand, how to exclude, to add, and to leave,[n.70] and to parse until he had mastered reciting. Then, he was instructed in the ways of brahmins: their conduct, ritual purity, and observances; the handling of ashes, the handling of ritual vases, and the handling of sites; hand gestures, turbans, offering praise, and salutations; the *Ṛgveda*, the *Yajurveda*, the *Sāmaveda*, and the *Atharvaveda*; and a brahmin’s six duties—making fire sacrifices, officiating over fire sacrifices, studying, teaching, giving, and receiving. The Vedas the limbs of the Vedas were entrusted to him, and with his blazing intelligence he could illuminate his own assertions and vanquish those of others.

**1.84** [eac13698-41e3-4fce-a20b-67d5f0cfe77e] The wife with whom Māṭhara had played, taken pleasure, and amused himself again gave birth, this time to a girl with eyes like a śārī bird. Three weeks or twenty-one days after the birth, relatives came and gathered to celebrate her birth in grand style, during which time they chose a name for the girl. The relatives said, “Since this girl has eyes like a śārī, this girl should be given the name Śārikā.” [S.4.b] The girl Śārikā was nurtured and grew. Her father taught her how to combine letters into words so she became proficient in reciting.

**1.85** [f11046be-bbfb-4bb5-bb62-386e1a98c465] Later, when the young brahmin Koṣṭhila was debating Śārikā, Śārikā vanquished him and their father said to Koṣṭhila, “Son, if you are a male, how has a female vanquished you? Once I’m gone, the spoils I’ve won in debate will be taken away.”

At that the young brahmin Koṣṭhila, desiring and in search of esoteric instruction, set off from the Middle Country for the South.

**1.86** [23263652-a0dd-469e-9284-f8488690775d] There, in a country not his own, lived a brahmin named Tiṣya who was learned in Lokāyata philosophy,[n.71] a teacher of brahmins to whom the Vedas and the limbs of the Vedas were entrusted.

**1.87** [bdd81c08-6a6b-4fb5-b991-7224dfef0250] Koṣṭhila went to see the brahmin Tiṣya. Serene, the young brahmin Koṣṭhila bowed at Tiṣya’s feet and sat off to one side.

**1.88** [a85dbf7d-51fd-44bc-bf65-5a8419aee2b3] Tiṣya warmly greeted Koṣṭhila with words of welcome, asking, “Young brahmin, where have you come from and what do you desire?”

“I hail from the Middle Country and I seek to serve at the feet of the preceptor.”

**1.89** [db3be4b4-dcef-48ef-a618-d78211a7c99b] “Why?”

“So that I may uphold the Lokāyata philosophy.”

**1.90** [43888069-0b0d-40b1-97f4-4b7482bac1d0] “Excellent, my son. You should do just that, for that is a brahmin’s duty.”

And so, the young brahmin Koṣṭhila began to study Lokāyata philosophy in the presence of the brahmin Tiṣya. The brahmins’ students were in the habit, when not occupied with their studies, of going to the riverbank to bathe, visiting the city, or collecting wood for use in fire pūjas.[n.72]

**1.91** [abe682a5-c9d5-4317-91e7-9d58e11917b3] Once, when not occupied with their studies, they went to collect wood for fire pūjas. On the way they had the following conversation. “Sons of Kutsa, sons of Vātsa, sons of Śāṇḍili, sons of Bhāradvāja, sons of the Five, sons of the Further Five.[n.73] To begin with, let us share where we come from, from which land we hail.”

**1.92** [b8733939-ee6e-4994-bdd7-6ac16d814ce8] “I am from the East,” one young brahmin responded.

“I am from the South,” said another.

**1.93** [24efc414-2575-45a3-b0d4-9acf169c5a01] “I am from the West.”

“I am from the North.”

**1.94** [de5d09f9-7d78-4ec5-914b-4e2eebabb113] The young brahmin then said, “I am from the Middle Country.”

To him they said, “Sir! We have seen and heard of all those other countries, but have neither seen nor heard of the Middle Country.”

**1.95** [9c5487e8-d5ef-40da-abe8-0204f12f311d] And then they added this verse:
“In the East they are wise,
In the South they are cunning,
In the West they stir division,
In the North they speak roughly.”

**1.96** [8aa8a26b-5227-46b5-b310-dbb405e01a41] “Young brahmin,” they asked, “what is the Middle Country like?”

“Gentlemen, the Middle Country is the best of all lands, abounding in rice, sugar cane, cattle, and buffalo, thronging with hundreds of honest women and filled with upstanding men, devoid of foreign savages, and guided by learned men. The river Gaṅgā, bountiful, meritorious, auspicious, and clean, flows through this famed land, irrigating both shores. At one point, where sages are known to gather, the river flows through eighteen bends. There, sages seek to bodily rise to the heavens through their practice of austerities.”[n.74]

**1.97** [e76c048e-4222-4258-b9bb-ac6db12f8fa9] “Young brahmin, having met you, we have another question. Do you have men counted as learned in the Middle Country?”
                             
“Gentlemen, from the first did I not say, ‘Gentlemen, the Middle Country is filled with upstanding men, devoid of foreign savages, and guided by learned men’?”

**1.98** [e81a8daf-269e-477d-9033-f983d7819baf] “Young brahmin, you did say that. Young brahmin, are there any in the Middle Country like our preceptor, a bull among teachers?”

“Gentlemen, in the Middle Country, the teachers are such that our teacher could not even look them in the face, so eloquently do they speak, so wise are they.”

**1.99** [b494a540-1f76-4257-bed0-1c17fb5726de] On hearing the young brahmin speak so highly of the Middle Country, they were moved by the desire to visit it. The young brahmins then went off to collect wood for use in fire pūjas. Bearing their loads of wood, they came to the house in which the teacher of brahmins lived. On arriving, they set their loads of wood off to one side, went to him, and said, “Preceptor, please listen. The young brahmin from the Middle Country speaks so highly of it that we are moved by the desire to visit.”

**1.100** [54886007-44a5-4637-a7fb-0851a50ba402] The brahmin Tiṣya said, “Boys, would you visit every place of which you hear? Since you seem to derive so much pleasure from hearing of other countries, I would suggest you not visit those places you hear about.”

**1.101** [4dab8ce5-f836-4321-8565-d740ebd2df44] “Preceptor, according to this young brahmin, in the Middle Country the teachers are such that you, our teacher, could not even look them in the face, so eloquently do they speak, so wise are they.”

**1.102** [674b78a3-cbfa-4f6b-8075-fecf369ce1e6] “My sons, do I say I am the one and only teacher on this earth, that there are no other teachers? After all, since the earth contains many gems, its surface is covered with one beauty after another.”

**1.103** [6a91ba8e-88a2-42cd-bf11-26b385c2d6c5] “We will see that country yet, Preceptor, if only for a short while. We will bathe on the banks of the river, we will serve the bull among teachers, we will defeat opponents, and we will make a name for ourselves and find our fortune, too. We will go to the Middle Country.”

**1.104** [1a062ddb-0ce6-4d02-832d-cf8a4a4fc791] As the brahmin was attached to his students and his circle of students was small, he said to the young brahmins, “In that case, my sons, let us gather our hides, bast robes, staffs, water jugs, ladles, and bowls and go to the Middle Country.”[n.75]

**1.105** [01b2df42-baa4-4ebb-abe1-f6e1cbd77f25] Having collected their things, the brahmin set off with the young brahmins for the Middle Country. Along the way, he defeated an opponent in debate, and then bound him to his chariot. He poured ashes from a pot on another’s head. Another steered clear of him like a crow does an archery range. Another received him with parasols, victory banners, and standards. Another made a pledge to become his student. As he went, he vanquished one opponent after another in villages, cities, towns, marketplaces, and hamlets until he reached Rājagṛha.

**1.106** [e168b0c3-7aaa-419b-990a-2caf04dc072a] The brahmin Tiṣya thought, “Why bother pulling off the branches, petals, and leaves while leaving the root? Since all worthy opponents and anyone counted as learned will be close to the king, it is the king I shall see.” [S.5.a.6]

**1.107** [b8284fc2-400b-47a1-b439-f3a8013c9957] In time the brahmin Tiṣya went to see King Bimbisāra. On arriving, he wished the king success and long life, took a place off to one side, and addressed him: “Your Majesty, from my guru I have received a few teachings. And so I seek to settle a matter in debate with an opponent in Your Majesty’s presence.”

**1.108** [54de6087-448c-47fc-9ccb-145bc20abf18] The king asked the ministers, “Gentlemen, where is Preceptor Māṭhara?”

“In Nālada, Your Majesty.”

**1.109** [4853ade0-f323-4f9f-a165-112d3c528cde] “Summon Preceptor Māṭhara.”

“As you wish, Your Majesty.”

**1.110** [657f4575-beb1-4c5e-9151-bc286ee03e70] On receiving the summons, Māṭhara went to see King Bimbisāra. On arrival, he wished the king success and long life then took a place off to one side.

The ministers said, “This is the preceptor, Your Majesty.”

**1.111** [ae3aba38-cc5e-4c5d-9798-e127cf90c95a] The king greeted him with words of welcome and asked, “Preceptor, can you settle a matter in debate in my presence with this brahmin Tiṣya?”

“I, as a capable man, shall do as the king pleases,” replied Māṭhara.

**1.112** [4a80d817-2e56-41f7-9052-2af5320c584b] The king ordered the ministers, “Gentlemen, prepare the debate arena and assign the disputants their roles.”

The ministers prepared the debate arena and assigned the disputants their roles. The ministers then prostrated at the king’s feet and asked, “Your Majesty, who would you have defend a position first?”

“The brahmin Tiṣya is a visitor so have him defend a position first.”

**1.113** [df35a35a-877c-4468-aec3-be70fd6e6a8d] “Your Majesty,” said he brahmin Tiṣya, “as the brahmin Māṭhara is the elder, I ask that you have him defend a position first.”

The brahmin Māṭhara thought, “This brahmin Tiṣya is clearly acquainted with new treatises so I cannot debate him on them. I shall focus on an old text.” And with that he recited five hundred lines.

**1.114** [4de8bdf5-3529-496d-8d99-45af5b5f9e8a] The brahmin Tiṣya repeated them and [S.5.b] then declared, “This position of yours is devoid of logic. It is inconsistent and incoherent.” The other brahmin remained silent as Tiṣya pointed out the text’s flaws.

**1.115** [317c0cc0-e7dc-4acd-9855-aa1e542f5113] That Māṭhara had no confidence to respond[n.76] was damning and among the reasons he was vanquished. The king asked the ministers, “Gentlemen, who won?”

“The brahmin Tiṣya, Your Majesty.”

“Gentlemen, give the brahmin Tiṣya a victor’s prize.”

**1.116** [46a51737-0a48-4ec2-97ed-0a9f9d28099d] “Your Majesty,” they replied, “if you give a prize to everyone who wins a debate, before long your lands of Aṅga and Magadha will themselves be victors’ prizes. Therefore make the village of Nālada the standard victor’s prize. Take it from the brahmin Māṭhara and give it to this brahmin. And if any other should best Tiṣya, then award it to the victor.”

## Notes for this part

**n.1** For a summary in English of the First and Second Councils and the subsequent schism in the saṅgha as recounted in *The Chapters on Monastic Discipline*, see Rockhill (1907, 148–80). For modern scholarship on the councils and the compiling of the Buddhist canon, see Prebish (1974) and Skilling (2009).

**n.2** See Nattier and Prebish (1977) on the rise of the different schools, with references to both traditional sources and modern scholarship.

**n.3** On the history, dating, and geographical distribution of the Mūlasarvāstivādins and their relation to other schools (especially the Sarvāstivādins), see Frauwallner (1956), Nattier and Prebish (1977), Enomoto (1994), Rosenfeld (2006), Salomon (2006), and Clarke (2004a and forthcoming). The six complete extant codes are the Sarvāstivādin’s *Ten Recitations* in Chinese with fragmentary Sanskrit; the Mūlasarvāstivādin’s *Collection of Four Scriptures* in Tibetan and partial Sanskrit and Chinese; the Theravādin’s canonical *Suttavibhaṅga*, *Khandhaka*, and *Appendices* (*Parivāra*) and paracanonical *Pātimokkha* and *Kammavācanā* in Pali; the Dharmaguptaka’s *Four Part Vinaya* in Chinese and partial Sanskrit; the Mahīśāsaka’s *Five Part Vinaya* in Chinese; and the Mahāsāṃghika’s *Mahāsāṃghika Vinaya* in Chinese. See Clarke (2004a, 77–78) and Prebish (2003).

**n.4** The *Vinayavastu* (Toh 1), the *Prātimokṣasūtra* (Toh 2), the *Vinayavibhaṅga* (Toh 3), the *Bhikṣuṇī Prātimokṣasūtra* (Toh 4), the *Bhikṣuṇī Vinayavibhaṅga* (Toh 5), the *Kṣudrakavastu* (Toh 6), and two versions of the *Uttaragrantha*—the incomplete *’dul ba gzhung bla ma* (Toh 7) and the complete *’dul ba gzhung dam pa* (Toh 7a). For more on the *Uttaragrantha* (*’dul ba gzhung dam pa* and *’dul ba gzhung bla ma*), see Kishino (2007, 1221, and 2013) and Clarke (2012).

**n.5** The Mahāsāṃghika Vinaya differs significantly in its structure from the other extant vinayas. See Frauwallner (1956) and Clarke (2004a).

**n.6** See Finnegan (2009, 10–28), for an overview of the history, language, and role of narrative in the Mūlasarvāstivāda Vinaya. For readers of German, see Panglung (1981). In English, see also Schopen (2000, 94–99) and, for reference to the inclusion of narrative and sūtra in the Pali vinaya, see von Hinüber (1996).

**n.7** See Heirman (2008) and Kishino (2013) for Yijing and his translations into Chinese.

**n.8** See Rotman (2008, 15–30) for a discussion of the *Divyāvadāna* and the Mūlasarvāstivāda Vinaya, and Rotman (2008) and (2017) for English translations of portions of the text.

**n.9** For a history of the excavations, see Jettmar (1981, 1–18) and von Hinüber (2014).

**n.10** From the vinayapiṭaka, fragments of the *Prātimokṣasūtra* and *Karmavācana* were also recovered. See Clarke (2014) for an introduction to the Vinaya manuscripts in Sanskrit found at Gilgit, along with a bibliographical survey and concordances with the Tibetan and Chinese translations; and von Hinüber (2014).

**n.11** For a book length presentation of the *Khandhakas*, see Ṭhānissaro Bhikkhu (2001).

**n.12** See Prebish (1994, 22–31) for a summary of each khandaka.

**n.13** “The Skandhaka represents to the saṅgha what the Sūtravibhaṅga represents to the individual monk or nun” (Prebish, 1994, 22).

**n.14** For a study and edition of this chapter in German, see Eimer (1983).

**n.15** For a study, critical edition, and translation of this chapter into German, see Hu-von Hinüber (1994).

**n.16** For a study, critical edition, and translation of this chapter into German, see Chung (1998).

**n.17** For a study and translation of this chapter into Japanese, see Shono (2007 and 2010).

**n.18** For a study and translation of this chapter into Japanese, see Yao (2013).

**n.19** For a translation of portions of this chapter into English, see Wu (2014). For a study and translation of the entire chapter into French, see Sobhita (1967).

**n.20** For an older study and translation of this chapter into English, see Chang (1957) and for a more recent introduction to this chapter in English, see Matsumura (1996). For a lexical study of its terms, see Matsumura (2007).

**n.21** For a study, edition, and translation of this chapter into German, see Yamagiwa (2001).

**n.22** For a study and translation of the first half of this chapter into English, see Schopen (2000).

**n.23** Csoma de Körös (1836); Banerjee (1957, 101–89); Dutt (1939–59).

**n.24** The rites for accepting women into the Buddhist order and inducting them into the novitiate are patterned on the formulas given in the present text, which is explicitly addressed to male candidates. In the Mūlasarvāstivāda Vinaya, the procedures for the ordination of nuns are found in the *Kṣudrakavastu*. See Jyväsjärvi (2011, 513–19) for a translation of Guṇaprabha’s explanation of how to adapt the rites described in the present text for use in admitting and ordaining women into the Buddhist renunciant order. For a summary of these procedures see Tsedroen and Anālayo (2011, esp. 757–66).

**n.25** The opposition between *śramaṇa* ascetics and *brāhmaṇa* householders is common in Buddhist literature but also well recognized in Vedic culture; the second-century *ʙᴄᴇ* grammarian Patañjali chose the phrase *śramaṇabrāhmaṇa* to illustrate the use of oppositional compounds in Sanskrit (Bailey and Mabbett, 2003, 112–13). See also Jaini (1970).

**n.26** Though they are referred to collectively as “six tīrthika teachers,” it is not clear what the designation *tīrthya* (as it appears in the *Gilgit Manuscripts*) or its mainstream Sanskrit equivalent *tīrthika* actually mean. Though the term is used pejoratively in much Buddhist literature, Schopen believes Edgerton was almost certainly right in saying it was originally a neutral term referring to an adherent or founder of any religion (Schopen, 2000, n. 1.18).

**n.27** The philosophies of the six tīrthika teachers are also related in the *Śrāmaṇyaphala Sūtra*, though the account there differs considerably in both its philosophical details and its attribution of ideas from the account given in the present chapter. Claus Vogel (1970) has published a translation and study of the account from the present chapter, while Graeme MacQueen (1978) has published a translation and study of seven surviving editions of the *Śrāmaṇyaphala Sūtra*, four in Chinese and one each in Pali, Sanskrit, and Tibetan.

**n.28** The main body of the biography is contained in the seventeenth and final chapter, the *Saṅghabhedavastu*. For more on Tibetan biographies that draw on the *Vinayavastu*, such as Situ Paṇchen Chökyi Jungné’s biography of the Buddha (*bdag cag gi ston pa rnam ’dren shA kya’i dbang po’i mdzad pa mdo tsam du legs par bshad pa*), see Lin (2011).

**n.29** Finnegan (2009, 16).

**n.30** Jain scriptures claim Gośālīputra was a pupil of the Mahāvīra who later broke with him to become a prominent Ājīvika teacher; see Basham (1981) and Bronkhorst (2003, 155–57). For more on the Ājīvikas, see Bronkhorst (2003).

**n.31** Jaini (1970, 60).

**n.32** Bronkhorst (2007, 47) and Bronkhorst (2012, 826).

**n.33** See Strong (1989); see also Tatelman (2000, 4–10) and Rotman (2008, 19–22) for more on the term *avadāna* in the Mūlasarvāstivādin Vinaya.

**n.34** See glossary entry “Āgama.”

**n.35** Eimer (1983).

**n.36** Vogel and Wille (1984, 1992, 1996a, 1996b). Previous editions of the Sanskrit manuscripts were produced by Dutt (1950) and Bagchi (1970).

**n.37** Rotman (2017, 135–166). Rotman’s chapter 23 begins at 4.172 in the present translation, but breaks to include, as chapter 24, the shape-shifting nāga passage before returning to the rest of the Saṅgharakṣita story as chapter 25.

**n.38** Burnouf (1844, 313–335) and (2010, 310-326); Hiraoka (2007 vol. 2, 1–50); and, for the preamble 4.110 to 4.157, Ware (1938).

**n.39** Consider our use of the word “ordination,” for instance. In Catholicism, one “professes” to become a monk and is “ordained” to become a priest. While a monk may become a priest, the two are distinct vocations, the latter being a clerical office with specific rights and responsibilities not shared by unordained monks. Since the Buddhist tradition does not distinguish between monastic and clerical offices, it is misleading and perhaps even incorrect to translate the Tibetan *bsnyen par rdzogs pa* (Skt. *upasaṃpadā*) as “ordination.” However, as we have not yet come upon a satisfactory translation for this term, we have decided to follow established precedent. We are indebted to Wulstan Fletcher for his advice on this term.

**n.40** In his work, Bronkhorst speaks of Greater Magadha, an area he defines as the Ganges Valley east of the Gaṅgā and Yamunā confluence (Bronkhorst, 2007, 2–3). Over several books, he marshals evidence for its distinctive culture, different from the Vedic society of Kuru-Pañcāla to the west. One of the main features of this Greater Magadhan culture is the preeminence of ascetic (or *śramaṇa*) orders like the Jains and Ājīvikas concerned with liberation from saṃsāra, which stand in contrast to the householder brahmins whose fire sacrifices are aimed at securing greater prosperity within *saṃsāra.* See especially Bronkhorst (2007, 2011). See also part one of Samuel (2008).

**n.41** Kloppenborg (1983, 159).

**n.42** In the *Āpastamba Dharmasūtra* (ca. fourth or fifth century *ʙᴄᴇ*), *parivrājaka* is one of four lifestyles (Skt. *āśrama*) available to someone who has spent time as an apprentice or a disciple to a religious teacher (Bronkhorst, 1998, 5). See also Dutt (1924, 30–56).
                 
**n.43** Though the Buddha famously rejected mortification as a path to liberation, “ascetic” seems the best translation for *śramaṇa*. “Ascetic” not only reflects the Sanskrit sense of hardship and toil, it is derived from the Greek word for “exercise” (*askein*), whence the Greek word for “monk” or “hermit” (*askētēs*), which well reflects the Tibetan *dge sbyong*.

**n.44** Bronkhorst (1998, 66).

**n.45** Olivelle (1993, 211).

**n.46** Tib. *dka’ thub*, Skt. *tapaḥ*. Kalyāṇamitra folio 196.b.4.

**n.47** See Bronkhorst (2003) for a discussion of whether Ājīvikas, like Gośālīputra, practiced asceticism.

**n.48** Olivelle (1993, 78–80).

**n.49** There is some uncertainty in the Tibetan tradition regarding how the author’s name should be rendered in Sanskrit, whether Kalyāṇamitra or Śubhamitra. Tāranātha speaks of the Vinaya master *dge legs bshes gnyen,* a contemporary of Haribhadra (late eighth century *ᴄᴇ*), but fails to offer a Sanskrit equivalent for his name (Tāranātha, 2007, 203). Khetsun Zangpo appears to be speaking of the same master when he says the *mdo sde ’dzin pa Shu bha mi tra* (the sūtra master Śubhamitra) was one of several adherents of the Vijñapti philosophy who contributed to the spread of sūtra and vinaya in the ninth century *ᴄᴇ*, shortly after Kṛṣṇācārya’s time (Khetsun, 1971, 567). If Khetsun Zangpo is correct in his characterization, it would suggest the *mdo sde* in the epithet *mdo sde ’dzin pa* refers to the sūtrapiṭaka and not Sautrāntika tenets, as some have suggested. Six of Kalyāṇamitra’s (or Śubhamitra’s) works on vinaya are included in the Tengyur: the *Vinayavastuṭīkā* (*’dul ba gzhi rgya cher ’grel pa*), the *Vinayāgamottaraviśeṣāgamapraśnavṛtti* (*’dul ba lung bla ma’i bye brag lung zhu ba’i ’grel pa*), the *Pratimokṣavṛttipadapremotpādikā* (*so sor thar pa’i ’grel tshig dga’ ba bskyed pa*), the *Śrāmaṇeraśikṣāpadasūtra* (*dge tshul gyi bslab pa’i gzhi’i mdo*), the *Vinayapraśnakārikā* (*’dul ba dri ba’i tshig le’ur byas pa*), and the *Vinayapraśnaṭīkā* (*’dul ba dri ba rgya cher ’grel pa*) (Prebish, 1994, 105–12).

**n.50** Tib. *’dul ba gzhi rgya cher ’grel ba*, Skt. *Vinayavastuṭīkā*. According to Anukul Chandra Banerjee’s *Sarvāvastivāda Literature*, Kalyāṇamitra gives this text the title *lung gzhi’i ’grel pa* or *Āgamavastuvṛtti* in the colophon (Martin, 2011: *Śubhamitra). None of the Degé, Choné, Kangxi, or Narthang editions of this commentary include a colophon; all of them end abruptly after thirteen fascicles. In the commentary itself, however, Kalyāṇamitra refers to his work numerous times as the *’dul ba gzhi rgya cher ’grel ba* and identifies himself as the *mdo sde ’dzin pa dge legs bshes gnyen* (“the sūtra master Kalyāṇamitra”) at the end of his remarks on the second chapter. The lack of a colophon prevents us from identifying the Tibetan translators who executed the translation and the Indian paṇḍitas who oversaw it.

**n.51** Such variance, common when texts are transmitted in manuscript form, becomes less common with the adoption of block printing. Recent work by scholars such as Shayne Clarke, Chistopher Emms, and Haiyan Hu-von Hinüber also points to the existence of multiple Mūlasarvāstivādin transmissions, though the nature and extent of their differences is not yet clear. That said, the Tibetan translations of Kalyāṇamitra’s commentary and the *Chapter on Going Forth* show remarkable agreement, as do the Sanskrit *Vinayavastu* manuscripts uncovered in Gilgit and the Tibetan translation preserved in the Kangyur.

**n.52** The *Vinayavastu* itself takes up nearly 2,500 pages over four volumes but, since the extant Tibetan translations of Kalyāṇamitra’s *Vinayavastuṭīkā* are incomplete, it is not clear how long his commentary was in the Sanskrit original. The *Vinayavastuṭīkā* begins with a detailed, word-by-word commentary on the first chapter that is as long as the chapter itself, 261 pages. By contrast, the commentary on the *Vinayavastu*’s 180-page second chapter takes only 32 pages. Despite its brevity, Kalyāṇamitra’s commentary to the second chapter is consistent with the material, the structure and terms of which are more straightforward and less diverse than the first chapter. Kalyāṇamitra may have treated the other fifteen chapters as extensively as he did the first chapter or as cursorily as he did the second; given the available material, it is impossible to say more.

**n.53** A summary of each of these chapters is given in the introduction.

**n.54** Following YKN: *blags* (“heard,” “listened”) instead of D: *bklags* (“read”) (Pedurma, 722).

**n.55** Following YJKNC: *khongs su chud* (“absorbed in thought”) instead of D: *khong du chud* (“comprehended”) (Pedurma, 722).

**n.56** The Buddha saw an opportunity to be reborn in the right family, in the right land, at the right time, with the right patrilineage, and to the right woman (Kalyāṇamitra, folios 183.a.7–183.b.1).

**n.57** The “gulf between worlds” refers to the cold hells said to exist between the four continents of ancient Indian cosmology (Kalyāṇamitra, folio 183.b.5–6).

**n.58** The Sanskrit fragments of the *Pravrajyāvastu* recovered from Gilgit begin here. The first complete sentence in Sanskrit begins on the front or recto side of the second folio [S.2.a] (Vogel and Wille, 1992, 71).

**n.59** Following S: *rtse ’grogs*, and HKC (Pedurma, 723): *rtsed grogs* (playmates), instead of D: *rtsen grogs*.

**n.60** The exact meanings of the last three items in this list are obscure and do not appear in the Sanskrit [S.2.a.2] (Vogel and Wille, 1992, 71). A similar list does however appear in the *Divyāvadāna*’s “Story of Koṭikarṇa,” where Rotman translates these three as “debts, deposits, and trusts” (Rotman, 2008, 42). Kalyāṇamitra explains that *dbyung ba* “refers to the ‘yield’ of materials such as bamboo and so forth” (Kalyāṇamitra, folio 184.b.3). In deference to these two sources, we have decided to translate *dbyung ba, gzhug pa, gzhag pa* here as “expenditures, revenues, and deposits,” terms which are fundamental to finance, a subject likely to figure in a king’s education. The same trope is encountered later in the text 1.143, where Śāriputra’s training in reciting the Vedas is described. In that case, we have chosen to follow Geshé Rinchen Ngödrup’s suggestion that these three skills refer to “the way words in Sanskrit are formed or constructed from verbal roots and parsed grammatically.” In that case, we have translated the three as “to exclude, to add, and to leave.”

**n.61** Following YJKNCH: *spyod pa* (“conduct”) instead of D: *skyod pa* (“movement”) (Pedurma, 723).

**n.62** According to Geshé Rinchen Ngödrup, this refers to the turbans warriors would wear into battle.

**n.63** The eighteen guilds were merchants, potters, garland makers, alcohol sellers, cowherds, barbers, millers, smiths, carpenters, fortune-tellers, weavers, leatherworkers, fishermen, dyers, bamboo-weavers, butchers, hunters, and ox-cart makers (Kalyāṇamitra, folio 185.b.4–6). Guilds were an important factor in urban life, “both in organizing production and in shaping public opinion… Customary usage of the guild (*śreṇi-dharma*) had the force of law. That the guild also intervened in the private lives of its members is also clear” (Thapar, 1990, 109–10).

**n.64** The four Vedas are the *Ṛgveda*, which contains sacred incantations or mantras; the *Sāmaveda*, which rearranges the *Ṛgveda*’s verses into chants or songs; the *Yajurveda*, which supplements the *Sāmaveda*’s chants with prose for ritual use; and the *Atharvaveda*, which has incantations used for more mundane ends (Doniger, 2009, 123-124). The branches of Vedic learning are treatises on precepts, rituals, grammar, prosody, etymology, and astrology (Kalyāṇamitra, folio 186.b.4–5).

**n.65** The first four are Vedic sages, ancestors of different brahmin gotras (lineages). The last two may be references to the Pañca Gauḍa and Pañca Drāviḍa, the two main geographical groupings of brahmins, respectively to the north and south of the Vindhya hills, each of which comprises five subgroups.

**n.66** On the goal of bodily ascent to heaven, in White (1996) see chapter three, “Embodied Ascent, Meditation & Yogic Suicide.”

**n.67** The implements they carry distinguish them as brahmin. The water jugs and ladles they bring would have been used for pūja while the bast robes they wore were made of *vālkam*/*valkala* or bark. “*Valkala* was also manufactured from the fiber of the bark of the trees and was usually worn by the saints. Another name for this was *Druma Charma*. *Valkala* cloth was forbidden to the Buddhist monks,” (Jain, 2003, 199). By the fourth century of the common era, the term *vālkam* was used to designate a certain class of textile that included, in addition to cloth made from tree bark, materials such as *kṣauma*, or linen (Kumar, 2008, 60).

**n.68** In this case, the victor’s prize was akin to an endowment, or a land grant (Skt. *brahmadeya*) that entitled the recipient to keep the taxes collected from that village. In Chakravarti (1987), see chapter three, “The Gahapati”.

**n.69** Following S: *rtse ’grogs*, and YHKN (Pedurma, 725): *rtse grogs* (playmates) instead of D: *rtsen grogs*.

**n.70** For these last three items, see n.60.

**n.71** A materialist philosophy inspired by the Cārvaka (Tib. *rgyang ’phen pa*). It is called “This Worldly” (Tib. *’jig rten pa*, Skt. *lokāyata*) because of its rejection of rebirth and an afterlife. For more on Lokāyata philosophy see Chattopadhaya (1959).

**n.72** The three folio sides 10.b to 11.b of the text contain a verbatim repetition of the passage from 7.a to 8.b, i.e. 1.53 through 1.69 above, beginning, “The brahmins’ students were in the habit…” and ending, “Since all worthy opponents and anyone counted as learned will be close to the king, it is the king I shall see.” The only difference is that in this later passage the “teacher of brahmins” who leads his students to Magadha and the Middle Country is not Māthara but Tiṣya, who—unlike Māthara in the earlier passage—is named twice. The passage in the Sanskrit runs from S.4.b.3 to S.5.a.5 (Vogel and Wille, 1992, 77).

**n.73** See n.65.

**n.74** See n.66.

**n.75** See n.67.

**n.76** Following YJKNCH: *lan* (“respond,” “answer”) instead of D: *len* (“take”) (Pedurma, 726).

Continued in part 2: https://84000.co/translation/toh1-1/part-2.md
